Categories
Brandon Blog Post

BANKRUPTCY OF THE COMPANY: OUR ENTREPRENEUR’S COMPREHENSIVE GUIDE TO REBUILDING AFTER BANKRUPTCY

Bankruptcy of the Company: Introduction

Imagine being at the helm of a thriving business, only to watch the bankruptcy of the company. As an insolvency professional, a Canadian licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a trustee in bankruptcy), I have witnessed the rollercoaster of emotions that come with financial failure, often paired with the entrepreneur’s sense of guilt and loss that can feel insurmountable.

Recovering from the bankruptcy of the company is challenging but possible. By understanding the impacts, assessing finances, creating a strong recovery plan, and rebuilding credit and reputation, business owners can rise again with resilience and prepare for future growth.

This is not the end. It’s a transformative stage that opens doors to rethinking, reconstructing, and revitalizing your future. Let’s explore the roadmap to recovery together, filled with actionable advice and insightful anecdotes.

Bankruptcy of the Company: Understanding Business Bankruptcy

Canadian law offers two primary types of bankruptcy for addressing the insolvent company corporate bankruptcy process:

Liquidation

Liquidation is the process of closing a business and selling its assets to generate funds. The proceeds from these sales are then used to pay off creditors. While it represents the conclusion of the company’s operations, understanding this process can help you navigate the winding down of a business effectively.

Reorganization

This initiative aims to thoughtfully reshape the company’s financial and operational structures, ensuring its ongoing success and stability. Reorganization presents a valuable opportunity for businesses facing financial difficulties, allowing them to effectively address and potentially overcome their economic challenges. Typically, this process is carried out through a commercial proposal under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act. For larger corporations with debts of at least $5 million, reorganization can take place under the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act.

Let’s take a closer look at each of these options to better understand how they can help.

Liquidation under bankruptcy of the company

Liquidation is the process of winding up a company that can no longer meet its financial obligations. It follows a structured corporate bankruptcy process outlined in the BIA, which bears similarities to Chapter 7 of the US Bankruptcy Code. Corporate bankruptcy is also called commercial bankruptcy.

Here’s a step-by-step breakdown of liquidation:

  • The decision to file:
  • The board of directors makes the difficult decision to file for bankruptcy and appoint a person to sign the official bankruptcy documents.
  • Assignment in Bankruptcy: A director, or the sole director, signs the required bankruptcy documents to make the company’s assignment into bankruptcy.
  • Appointment of the Licensed Insolvency Trustee: An insolvency trustee is appointed to oversee the process.
  • Asset Transfer: All corporate assets are transferred to the Licensed Insolvency Trustee, which then manages and sells them.
  • Distribution to Creditors: Proceeds from asset sales, after the cost of the corp bankruptcy proceedings, are distributed to creditors based on a predetermined legal priority.
  • Secured creditors, such as lenders with liens on company assets, generally have priority over unsecured creditors.
  • The company ceases to operate: Once assets are distributed, although the bankrupt corporation is not legally dissolved, it no longer operates.

Depending on whether the company is federally or provincially incorporated, eventually, the appropriate government authority will cancel the company’s charter due to the bankruptcy of the company.

Liquidation can be a complex process, but it offers a clear and organized approach to closing a company that is experiencing significant financial challenges. This process ensures that assets are distributed fairly among creditors, helping to bring some resolution to a difficult situation. If you find yourself in this position, rest assured that there are steps in place to manage the process as smoothly as possible.

“The closure of a business doesn’t just impact balance sheets, it impacts lives.”

A picture of a jigsaw puzzle with some pieces missing and a picture of a businessman over the puzzle to reporesent the bankruptcy of his company and his putting the pieces back together to start over.
bankruptcy of the company

Reasons for Bankruptcy of the Company

Financial Challenges

  • Cash Flow Management: Many companies struggle to manage their cash flow effectively, leading to a buildup of debt and ultimately, the bankruptcy of the company. This can be due to a variety of factors, including poor budgeting, delayed payments from customers, or over-reliance on credit.
  • High Debt Levels: Companies that take on too much debt can quickly become overwhelmed by their financial obligations. This can be particularly true for companies that have taken on debt to finance expansion or acquisitions.
  • Inefficient Use of Assets: Companies that fail to optimize their use of assets, such as inventory or equipment, can struggle to generate sufficient revenue to meet their financial obligations.
  • Poor Financial Planning: Companies that fail to plan for the future or make poor financial decisions can quickly find themselves in a difficult financial situation.

Operational Issues

  • Inefficient Operations: Companies that fail to streamline their operations or make inefficient use of resources can struggle to remain competitive and profitable.
  • Lack of Scalability: Companies that may not be fully attuned to shifts in the market or industry can find it difficult to scale their operations effectively. By staying adaptable and responsive to changes, businesses can better meet growing demand and seize new growth opportunities.
  • Poor Management: Companies that are poorly managed or lack effective leadership can struggle to make sound business decisions and ultimately, may force the bankruptcy of the company.
  • Failure to Innovate: Companies that fail to innovate or adapt to changes in the market can quickly become obsolete and struggle to remain competitive.

External Factors

  • Economic Downturn: Companies that operate in industries that are heavily reliant on consumer spending or are sensitive to economic fluctuations can be particularly vulnerable to bankruptcy during economic downturns.
  • Regulatory Changes: Companies facing evolving regulations or laws may find it challenging to adapt. However, with the right strategies and support, they can navigate these changes effectively and avoid potential difficulties. It’s important to stay informed and seek assistance to thrive in a dynamic regulatory environment.
  • Competition: Companies that operate in highly competitive industries can struggle to remain profitable and may force the bankruptcy of the company if they are unable to differentiate themselves or compete effectively.
  • Natural Disasters: Companies that are affected by natural disasters, such as hurricanes or wildfires, can struggle to recover and may ultimately be forced into bankruptcy.

Understanding the Ripple Effects of Bankruptcy

The bankruptcy of the company can turn your business life upside down. But understanding its effects can help you navigate this rough terrain. What are the immediate and long-term consequences?

Understanding The Immediate Effects on Your Credit Score

It’s important to know that your business’s credit score is separate from your credit score. The company is considered a distinct legal entity, meaning that, generally, its financial activities do not directly impact your credit score. However, as an entrepreneur, if you’ve personally guaranteed any bank loans or lines of credit for your business, this could affect you personally. If the company is unable to repay those loans, the bank will look to you to cover any outstanding amounts.

Additionally, as a director of the company, you hold responsibility for any unremitted employee source deductions and unremitted HST owed to the Canada Revenue Agency. Being aware of these obligations can help you manage your financial responsibilities more effectively and protect your credit standing. If you have questions or need further clarification, don’t hesitate to reach out for assistance.

So although the bankruptcy of the company does not directly affect your personal credit score, depending on what your financial position is now and how it is affected by the bankruptcy of the company, it could very well have a negative impact on your credit score.

The bankruptcy of the company gets reported to the two Canadian credit bureaus, TransUnion and Equifax. Depending on how your financial situation is affected by the bankruptcy of the company, your credit score may then suffer. It usually suffers in two ways:

  • Loss of borrowing capacity: You might find it challenging to get credit lines or loans.
  • Higher interest rates: If you do get offers, they may come with steep rates.

Loss of Trust Among Stakeholders

Trust is hard to regain once lost. After filing for corporate bankruptcy, if you wish to start up a new business, suppliers may hesitate to extend credit, leaving you in a bind. Customers might question your reliability, and partnerships can falter.

Legal Limitations Post-Bankruptcy

Additionally, there are legal limitations that follow the bankruptcy of the company. If you are applying for a job or credit for a new business, there could be a question to answer like “Have you ever been a director of a company that filed for bankruptcy”. Your answer could include restrictions on the types of businesses you can operate or positions you can hold.

Understanding these ripple effects is crucial. As financial advisor Jamie Carter wisely said,

“Bankruptcy can be a valuable lesson if you are willing to learn from it and adapt.”

Remember, the impacts extend beyond finances to reputational damage and legal constraints. You can emerge stronger if you take the time to understand these dynamics.

A picture of a jigsaw puzzle with some pieces missing and a picture of a businessman over the puzzle to reporesent the bankruptcy of his company and his putting the pieces back together to start over.
bankruptcy of the company

Reflecting on Financial Health Post-Bankruptcy

Understanding Your Financial Landscape

Recovering from the bankruptcy of the company can feel overwhelming. But remember, it all starts with understanding your financial situation. You can’t chart a path forward if you don’t know where you stand. So, how do you begin?

1. Gather Your Financial Documents

  • Start by collecting all of your financial statements and paperwork.
  • Make sure to include documents that reflect your current cash flow, outstanding debts, and assets.
  • Having this information organized will give you a clear understanding of your current financial position, making it easier to assess your situation effectively.

2. Create a List of Assets and Debts

Take the time to write down what you own and what you owe. Having a clear picture of your financial reality is crucial.

  • Total Debts: $200,000
  • Remaining Assets: $50,000

This exercise can feel daunting. But it’s necessary for redefining your reality. Consider this: how can you build a new foundation without understanding the ground underneath? Remember that you may have given personal guarantees to a lender to the company.

3. Set Realistic Financial Goals

Having a goal gives you direction. Break your recovery journey into achievable steps:

  1. Short-term goals: Focus on income generation, budget management and expense reduction.
  2. Long-term goals: Aim for debt reduction and credit score improvement.

Your goals should be tangible and reflect your new financial reality. It’s about letting clarity drive your recovery.

Using Financial Statements as a Roadmap

Your financial statements will serve as a roadmap throughout your recovery journey. They provide essential guidance when making decisions. For example, if you see a consistent cash flow issue, it might be time to revisit your business strategy.

Visualizing Your Financial Position

Understanding your debts versus assets is vital. The chart below visualizes your financial health:

Financial Element

Amount ($)

Total Debts

$200,000

Remaining Assets

$50,000

Preparation involves a meticulous assessment of your financial landscape. It’s about clarity, honesty, and setting yourself up for real change.

Crafting a Proactive Recovery Blueprint

Recovery is not merely about surviving; it’s about thriving. You can turn challenges into opportunities with the right proactive plan. Let’s break down some essential steps.

1. Establishing a Comprehensive Budget

Creating a detailed budget is crucial. It serves as your roadmap. Think of it as a financial GPS that helps guide your decisions.

  • Forecasting Cash Flows: This allows you to anticipate income and expenses. By understanding your cash flow, you can eliminate any surprises. Wouldn’t it be great to know your financial future better?
  • Identifying Fixed and Variable Costs: Understanding the difference between fixed and variable costs is essential for effective planning. Fixed costs, such as rent and salaries, remain constant regardless of production levels, while variable costs fluctuate based on your business activity.
  • By recognizing these distinctions, you can make more informed decisions and enhance your financial strategy.

2. Exploring Cost-Cutting Avenues

The goal here is to reduce costs without sacrificing quality. It’s a delicate balance.

  • Assess your needs and look for ways to get better deals.
  • Cut unnecessary expenditures.

How much could you save by embracing smarter practices?

3. Implementing Financial Management Systems

Robust financial management systems help ensure future stability. They make monitoring and adjusting your budget easier. They are available to everyone at a reasonable cost.

  • Adopt accounting software: This can automate processes and save time.
  • Conduct regular financial reviews: Staying updated allows for timely adjustments.

“Failing to prepare is preparing to fail.” – John C. Maxwell

These strategies don’t guarantee instant success, but they set a solid foundation for recovery. It’s about making informed decisions today to secure a better tomorrow.

A picture of a jigsaw puzzle with some pieces missing and a picture of a businessman over the puzzle to reporesent the bankruptcy of his company and his putting the pieces back together to start over.
bankruptcy of the company

Rebuilding Business Credit: It’s a Marathon, Not a Sprint

Getting into a new business requires building your business credit and access to financing after hardship is a journey. It’s a marathon, not a sprint. Why rush? Quick fixes can lead to long-term pain. Instead, focus on long-term strategies. Patience is your best friend here.

1. Opening New Credit Lines Responsibly

Start slow. Open new credit lines when you can manage them. This is your stepping stone. Think of it like planting seeds. You need to nurture them to grow. Responsible borrowing can improve your credit utilization ratio. This, in turn, boosts your credit score.

  • Choose accounts that report to credit bureaus.
  • Start with secured credit cards or smaller loans.

2. Using Secured Credit Cards

Secured credit cards are excellent tools for growth. They require a deposit, but they report your payments to credit bureaus. This means you’re building a positive credit history, one payment at a time. It’s about creating a solid foundation for your credit profile.

3. The Importance of Timely Payments

Let’s take a moment to discuss the significance of making payments on time. Your financial reputation is important, and timely payments play a crucial role in demonstrating your responsibility and stability. Think of it as essential for maintaining a healthy credit score – just like breathing is for your well-being.

If you happen to miss a payment, it can negatively impact your score, so it’s important to stay consistent. By prioritizing timely payments, you’re setting yourself up for financial success!

“Rebuilding credit will require discipline and strategy but can lead to an empowered financial future if handled well.”

4. Learning from Others

Many businesses have successfully navigated this path. Their stories are inspiring. They show that it’s possible to come back stronger. Embrace the lessons from those who have rebuilt their credit. Their experiences can guide you.

Remember, this isn’t just about fixing credit. It’s about creating a healthier future for your business. Stay focused on these long-term strategies to ensure lasting impact and success.

Repairing Your Company’s Image: The Reputation Rehabilitation

Repairing Trust through Transparent Communication

After a reputation setback, you might wonder how to regain trust. The answer lies in transparent communication. Regularly update your stakeholders about your journey. Share not just successes but also hurdles. This honesty shows integrity.

Consider this: Wouldn’t it be easier to trust someone who is open about their difficulties? When your audience perceives you as authentic and genuine, it becomes much simpler to reconnect with them.

Leveraging Digital Platforms for Positive Narratives

In today’s connected world, digital platforms play a crucial role. Use social media and your company website to share uplifting stories. Highlight how you’re improving and what your team is excited about.

  • Share success stories from employees or customers.
  • Post updates on community involvement and corporate social responsibility initiatives.
  • Engage with your audience through polls or Q&A sessions.

“Your brand is a story unfolding across all customer touchpoints.” – Jonah Sachs

As this suggests, every interaction is an opportunity to shape your narrative.

Documenting Changes to Restore Confidence

Last but not least, it’s vital to document and showcase changes. This can be anything from new management practices to enhanced product quality. Displaying tangible improvements can effectively demonstrate your commitment to recovery.

Regular updates not only remind stakeholders of your progress but also instill confidence. Keep in mind, that restoring your reputation is a journey, not a sprint.

So, how ready are you to engage fully in your reputation rehabilitation? Embracing these strategies can set your business on the right path.

A picture of a jigsaw puzzle with some pieces missing and a picture of a businessman over the puzzle to reporesent the bankruptcy of his company and his putting the pieces back together to start over.
bankruptcy of the company

Innovating Your Way Back to Success: Growth Beyond Recovery

With a foundation grounded in recovery, you’re now in a position to think bigger. The journey ahead is about more than just bouncing back; it’s about redefining your business potential. Let’s explore some key strategies you can adopt.

1. Identifying New Markets and Opportunities for Diversification

After any setback, understanding where to pivot is essential. Ask yourself: Are there untapped markets waiting for your offerings? Consider the possibilities:

  • Geographic expansion: Could your product resonate in a different region?
  • New demographics: What about targeting younger or older audiences?
  • Product diversification: Have you considered exploring complementary products or services that could enhance your offerings? This could be a great way to provide more value to your customers!

2. Investing in Tech and Innovative Practices

In today’s fast-paced environment, standing still is not an option. Innovation is power. Investing in technology can provide you with a competitive edge. For instance:

  • Automation: Streamline processes to save time and costs.
  • Data analytics: Leverage data to make informed decisions.
  • Digital marketing: Boost your online presence to engage and attract new customers effectively.

3. Building Alliances and Partnerships

Alone, you might find challenges hard to overcome. But together? You can achieve new heights. Consider forming strategic alliances. It could mean collaborating with other businesses to:

  • Share resources, which can lower costs.
  • Access new audiences through shared marketing efforts.
  • Mutual growth leads to stronger foundations for both parties.

“In today’s interconnected world, collaboration is the new competition.”

The Importance of Innovation

Absolutely! It’s important to recognize that innovation goes beyond just technology – it’s fundamentally about our mindset. By adopting an innovative approach during recovery phases, we can create opportunities for sustainable growth. Embracing this perspective can truly make a difference!

As you explore these avenues for growth, keep a sharp focus on your core mission and values. This will reignite your passion and drive for business.

Measuring Progress and Celebrating Wins Along Your Journey

Recovery is a journey filled with small victories. To make your path clear and effective, you need to start by establishing Key Performance Indicators (KPIs). These are measurable values that demonstrate how effectively you’re achieving your recovery goals. Think of them as signposts that guide you along the way.

Establishing KPIs to Monitor Your Recovery Journey

Choose KPIs that resonate with your specific recovery objectives. Here are a few ideas:

  • Credit score improvements
  • Reduction in outstanding debts
  • Revenue growth
  • Customer retention rates

Why is it important to track these KPIs? Regular updates and adjustments to your recovery strategy are essential. When you notice patterns in your progress, you can adapt your plan accordingly. Are you hitting targets? Celebrate that achievement! Are numbers not improving? Analyze what might need to change.

Acknowledging Small Milestones

It’s crucial to acknowledge and celebrate small milestones. Each small win is a step forward. Taking a moment to recognize these successes not only boosts morale but also motivates you to keep pushing onward. Think about what you have accomplished—each step is proof of your progress.

Incorporating these practices—setting KPIs, adjusting strategies as necessary, and celebrating your successes—can transform your recovery journey. By implementing effective tracking and celebrating your achievements, you can maintain a positive outlook and remain committed to your goals.

“Documenting progress not only keeps you accountable but also energizes your journey forward.”

Remember, recovery from the bankruptcy of the company is not just about bouncing back. It’s about moving forward stronger and more resilient than before. Embrace the journey, celebrate each victory, and you’ll find the path to success becomes much clearer. Keep pushing your limits, and don’t shy away from recognizing the efforts that take you further along your journey.

A picture of a jigsaw puzzle with some pieces missing and a picture of a businessman over the puzzle to reporesent the bankruptcy of his company and his putting the pieces back together to start over.
bankruptcy of the company

Bankruptcy of the Company FAQ

1. What happens when my company goes bankrupt?

In Canada, the bankruptcy of the company can be taken down one of two main paths: liquidation and reorganization.

  • Liquidation involves closing the business, selling its assets, and using the proceeds to pay off creditors. It signifies the end of the company’s operations.
  • Reorganization, typically through a proposal under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, aims to restructure the company’s finances and operations to enable its continued existence.

The specific process and outcome will depend on the chosen path and the company’s individual circumstances.

2. How does company bankruptcy affect my personal credit score?

Generally, the bankruptcy of the company doesn’t directly impact your personal credit score. Companies are considered separate legal entities. However, there are exceptions:

  • Personal Guarantees: If you personally guaranteed any of the company’s debts, you become liable for those debts if the company can’t pay. This can negatively affect your credit score.
  • Director Liabilities: As a director, you are responsible for unremitted employee source deductions and HST owed to the CRA. Failure to remit these could impact your creditworthiness.

While the bankruptcy of the company isn’t a direct hit, the resulting financial strain from personal guarantees or liabilities can indirectly affect your creditworthiness.

3. What are the immediate consequences of bankruptcy beyond finances?

The impact of the bankruptcy of the company extends beyond just the financial aspect. You might experience:

  • Loss of Trust: Stakeholders like suppliers, customers, and potential partners might hesitate to work with you due to the bankruptcy of the company.
  • Reputational Damage: The bankruptcy of the company becomes a public record, potentially affecting your future business prospects.
  • Legal Limitations: You might face restrictions on the types of businesses you can operate or positions you can hold.

These consequences highlight that bankruptcy’s impact can be far-reaching and affect your ability to rebuild.

4. How can I understand my financial situation after company bankruptcy?

Start by:

  1. Gathering Financial Documents: Collect all personal and business financial statements, including cash flow statements, debt records, and asset documentation.
  2. Listing Assets and Debts: Create a comprehensive list of what you own and what you owe, including any personal guarantees for company debts.
  3. Setting Realistic Goals: Define achievable short-term goals (income generation, budgeting) and long-term goals (debt reduction, credit score improvement).

This process helps you understand your current financial position and create a roadmap for recovery.

5. How do I rebuild business credit after bankruptcy?

Rebuilding business credit takes time and strategic effort. Focus on:

  1. Responsible New Credit Lines: Start small with secured credit cards or loans that report to credit bureaus, gradually building a positive credit history.
  2. Timely Payments: Consistently making payments on time demonstrates financial responsibility and is crucial for improving your credit score.
  3. Learning from Others: Seek advice and inspiration from other businesses that successfully rebuilt their credit after bankruptcy.

Remember, patience and responsible financial management are key to rebuilding business credit.

6. How can I repair my company’s reputation after bankruptcy?

Focus on:

  1. Transparent Communication: Openly communicate with stakeholders about the bankruptcy of the company, your recovery plan, and progress made. This honesty builds trust.
  2. Leveraging Digital Platforms: Utilize your website and social media to share positive stories, highlight improvements, and engage with your audience.
  3. Documenting Changes: Showcase tangible improvements in your operations, management practices, and product quality to demonstrate your commitment to recovery.

By actively managing the narrative and showcasing positive change, you can gradually rebuild trust and restore your company’s reputation.

7. What are some strategies for growth after recovering from bankruptcy?

Consider these strategies:

  1. Identifying New Markets: Explore untapped markets by expanding geographically, targeting new demographics, or diversifying your product/service offerings.
  2. Investing in Innovation: Embrace technology and innovative practices through automation, data analytics, and digital marketing to gain a competitive edge.
  3. Building Partnerships: Form strategic alliances with other businesses to share resources, access new audiences, and achieve mutual growth.

Growth after the bankruptcy of the company involves strategic planning and proactive efforts to explore new opportunities and redefine your business potential.

8. How do I measure my progress and stay motivated during recovery?

Utilize these methods:

  1. Establish KPIs: Define key performance indicators (KPIs) that align with your recovery goals, such as credit score improvement, debt reduction, revenue growth, etc.
  2. Track and Adjust: Regularly monitor your KPIs and adjust your recovery strategy as needed, celebrating successes and addressing areas requiring improvement.
  3. Acknowledge Milestones: Celebrate even small wins and acknowledge your progress to maintain motivation and a positive outlook throughout the recovery journey.

By actively tracking your progress and celebrating achievements, you can stay focused and committed to rebuilding your business stronger than before.

Bankruptcy of the Company: Conclusion

I hope you enjoyed this bankruptcy of the company Brandon’s Blog. Do you or your company have too much debt? Are you or your company in need of financial restructuring due to distressed real estate or other reasons? The financial restructuring process is complex. The Ira Smith Team understands how to do a complex restructuring. However, more importantly, we understand the needs of the entrepreneur or someone with too much personal debt.

You are worried because you are facing significant financial challenges. It is not your fault that you are in this situation. You have been only shown the old ways that do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team uses new modern ways to get you out of your debt troubles while avoiding the bankruptcy process. We can get you debt relief freedom using processes that are a bankruptcy alternative.

The stress placed upon you is huge. We understand your pain points. We look at your entire situation and devise a strategy that is as unique as you and your problems; financial and emotional. The way we take the load off of your shoulders and devise a plan, we know that we can help you.

We know that people facing financial problems need a realistic lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” approach with the Ira Smith Team.

That is why we can develop a restructuring process as unique as the financial problems and pain you are facing. If any of this sounds familiar to you and you are serious about finding a solution, contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. team today.

Call us now for a free consultation. We will get you or your company back on the road to healthy stress-free operations and recover from the pain points in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

The information provided in this Brandon’s Blog is intended for educational purposes only. It is not intended to constitute legal, financial, or professional advice. Readers are encouraged to seek professional advice regarding their specific situations. The content of this Brandon’s Blog should not be relied upon as a substitute for professional guidance or consultation. The author, Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. as well as any contributors to this Brandon’s Blog, do not assume any liability for any loss or damage resulting from reliance on the information provided herein.

A picture of a jigsaw puzzle with some pieces missing and a picture of a businessman over the puzzle to reporesent the bankruptcy of his company and his putting the pieces back together to start over.
bankruptcy of the company
Categories
Brandon Blog Post

NAVIGATING CORP BANKRUPTCY IN CANADA: OUR COMPREHENSIVE GUIDE FOR BUSINESS OWNERS

Corp Bankruptcy Introduction

Running a business can be tough. Sometimes, despite your best efforts, your company may face overwhelming financial difficulties. When business debts pile up and staying afloat seems impossible, it might be time to consider corp bankruptcy proceedings. This can be stressful and complex, but understanding your options is crucial for making the best decisions for your company and yourself.

This guide aims to demystify Canada’s different types of company insolvency proceedings. We’ll break down the intricacies of bankruptcy, Division I proposals, and receivership, providing clarity on their implications for debt resolution and your business’s future.

Understanding What Is Corp Bankruptcy

In Canada, corp bankruptcy, also known as commercial bankruptcy or business bankruptcy, is a legal process that allows the incorporated legal entity unable to pay their debts to seek relief by filing bankruptcy. It provides a framework for either liquidating the company and distributing assets to creditors or reorganizing the business to become financially stable again.

Corp bankruptcy is fundamentally different from personal bankruptcy, which pertains to individuals, including sole proprietorships and partnerships. While personal bankruptcy is designed to assist individuals in obtaining a fresh start by addressing their personal assets, corporate bankruptcy seeks to facilitate either an orderly dissolution of the company or its restructuring.

A businessman on a sinking ship in turbulent waters representing a corporation heading to bankruptcy with a helicopter above throwing a restructuring lifeline.
corp bankruptcy

Navigating this process necessitates specialized knowledge. A Licensed Insolvency Trustee, who is a federally licensed professional, plays an essential role in guiding you through the proceedings. They ensure compliance with the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA) and other relevant regulations while effectively managing a variety of financial matters.

Types of Corp Bankruptcy Proceedings in Canada

Canadian law offers two primary avenues for addressing the corp bankruptcy process:

Liquidation

This involves closing down the business, selling its assets, and using the proceeds to pay creditors. It’s a final step, signifying the end of the company’s operations.

Reorganization

The objective of this initiative is to strategically restructure the company’s financial and operational frameworks, thereby ensuring its continued viability. Reorganization serves as a critical opportunity for businesses facing financial challenges, enabling them to navigate and potentially surmount their economic obstacles.

Let’s explore each type in greater detail.

Liquidation under Corp Bankruptcy

Liquidation is the process of winding up a company that can no longer meet its financial obligations. It follows a structured corporate bankruptcy process outlined in the BIA, which bears similarities to Chapter 7 of the US Bankruptcy Code.

Here’s a step-by-step breakdown of liquidation:

  • Decision to File:
  • The board of directors makes the difficult decision to file for bankruptcy
  • . Assignment in Bankruptcy: A director, or the sole director, signs the required bankruptcy documents to make the company’s assignment into bankruptcy
  • Appointment of the Licensed Insolvency Trustee: An insolvency trustee is appointed to oversee the process.
  • Asset Transfer: All company assets are transferred to the Licensed Insolvency Trustee, which then manages and sells them. Distribution to Creditors: Proceeds from asset sales, after the cost of the corp bankruptcy proceedings, are distributed to creditors based on a predetermined legal priority.
  • Secured creditors, such as lenders with liens on company assets, generally have priority over unsecured creditors.
  • The company ceases to operate: Once assets are distributed, although the bankrupt corporation is not legally dissolved, it no longer operates.

Depending on whether the company is federally or provincially incorporated, eventually, the appropriate government authority will cancel the company’s charter.

Liquidation can be a challenging process, but it provides a structured way to wind down a company facing insurmountable financial difficulties and allows for a fair distribution of assets to creditors.

“The closure of a business doesn’t just impact balance sheets, it impacts lives.”

Reorganization: A Path to Recovery

Reorganization, often known as “bankruptcy protection,” provides struggling but viable businesses an opportunity to restructure their debts and operations, helping them avoid shutting down completely.

In Canada, there are two main legal options for corporate reorganization:

  1. Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA): This federal law is designed for larger corporations with debts over $5 million. The CCAA process is supervised by the court to ensure fairness and transparency.
  2. Division I Proposal under the BIA: This option is geared towards smaller businesses that don’t meet the debt threshold required for the CCAA.

Both of these processes are similar to Chapter 11 reorganizations in the US Bankruptcy Code, offering a structured way for companies to get back on their feet.

The reorganization process generally follows these steps:

  1. Filing for Protection: The company initiates the bankruptcy process by filing under the CCAA with the court or the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA) with the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy. A Licensed Insolvency Trustee is assigned to oversee the process, acting as either the Monitor for CCAA cases or the Proposal Trustee for Division I Proposals under the BIA.
  2. Stay of Proceedings: Once the filing is done, the court grants a stay of proceedings. This means creditors are temporarily barred from starting or continuing any legal actions against the company while it works on its reorganization.
  3. Plan Development: The company then creates a plan of arrangement (for CCAA) or a proposal (for BIA) that details how it plans to restructure its debts and operations.
  4. Creditor Approval: The proposed plan is presented to the creditors, who must approve it. A two-thirds majority vote is needed for the plan to pass.
  5. Court Approval: Finally, the court reviews the plan and must give its approval before the company can move forward with the implementation. This step is especially important for filings under the CCAA.

“Understanding your options is essential for financial clarity and future success.”

Division I Proposals vs. Bankruptcy: Understanding Key Legislation and the Nuances

Although both Division I proposals and bankruptcy fall under the umbrella of corp bankruptcy proceedings, they offer distinct approaches to dealing with financial distress.

Here’s a closer look at the key differences:

Feature

Division I Proposal

Bankruptcy

Eligibility

Smaller corporations (debt typically below $5

Any insolvent

Any insolvent corporation

Court involvement

Less involved; primarily oversees the approval process

Potentially more involved in settling disputes

Flexibility

More flexible; allows for tailored debt restructuring plans

Less flexible; focuses on asset liquidation and distribution

Timeframe

Shorter timeframe for filing a plan

No specific timeframe

Outcome if rejected

Automatic bankruptcy

N/A

Cost

Can be more costly due to the need to restructure operations and negotiate with creditors

Cost depends on complexity and types of assets to be sold

A businessman on a sinking ship in turbulent waters representing a corporation heading to bankruptcy with a helicopter above throwing a restructuring lifeline.
corp bankruptcy

Choosing the right path depends on your company’s specific circumstances, the severity of its financial troubles, and the potential for recovery.

Receivership: When Secured Creditors Take Action

Receivership is a legal process that empowers a receiver, which in Canada can only be a licensed insolvency practitioner, to take control of a company’s assets when it defaults on secured loans.

There are two types of receivership:

  • Private Receivership: The secured creditor appoints a receiver based on the terms of the security agreement, through an appointment letter.
  • Court-Appointed Receivership: The court appoints a receiver upon application, usually by a secured creditor.

The receiver has the authority to:

  1. Take possession of corporate assets.
  2. Manage the assets, potentially running the business temporarily.
  3. Sell assets to recover the secured creditors’ debts, in order of priority.

The primary responsibility of a privately appointed receiver is to the appointing creditor. In contrast, a court-appointed receiver has a duty to all stakeholders and may be subject to court-imposed restrictions.

Receivership can be a powerful tool for secured creditors seeking to recover their funds, but it often results in the liquidation of the company. It may also occur concurrently with corp bankruptcy proceedings, especially when secured creditors hold significant claims against the company.

Corp Bankruptcy: Weighing the Pros and Cons

Each corp bankruptcy proceeding presents unique advantages and disadvantages. Let’s examine these for each option:

Advantages and Disadvantages of Liquidation

Advantages

Disadvantages

Provides a legal framework for businesses unable to pay their debts.

Results in the closure of the business.

Offers an orderly process for winding down the business.

This may lead to action taken due to personal liability for directors for specific debts.

Facilitates the fair distribution of assets to creditors based on their legal priority.

Can be a time-consuming and expensive process.

Can negatively impact the reputation of the directors.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Reorganization

Advantages

Disadvantages

Offers a chance to save the business and preserve jobs.

May not be successful, leading to eventual liquidation.

Provides an opportunity to improve profitability and efficiency.

Can negatively impact employee morale and customer confidence during the restructuring process.

Allows for the modernization of strategies and financial arrangements.

Requires a significant time investment and may cause cash flow challenges.

Can be conducted informally or formally through the BIA or CCAA.

“Reorganization aims to breathe new life into a struggling company.”

Advantages and Disadvantages of Receivership

Advantages

Disadvantages

Offers a direct and efficient method for secured creditors to recover their funds.

Focuses primarily on protecting the interests of the secured creditor, potentially neglecting the interests of other stakeholders.

May facilitate the sale of the business as a going concern, preserving jobs.

The receiver may face conflicts of interest between their duty to the appointing creditor and their duty to the company.

A businessman on a sinking ship in turbulent waters representing a corporation heading to bankruptcy with a helicopter above throwing a restructuring lifeline.
corp bankruptcy

Corporate Recovery and Restructuring: Exploring Alternatives to Corp Bankruptcy in Canada With Other Potential Recovery Options

Before resorting to corp bankruptcy proceedings, it’s essential to explore alternative solutions that might help your company recover without resorting to formal legal processes.

Here are five alternatives to consider:

Cost-Cutting and Budgeting

Implement tighter spending controls and create a realistic cash flow budget. Identifying and eliminating unnecessary expenses can free up funds to address debt obligations.

Debt Refinancing

Consider looking into refinancing options to combine your current debts into a more manageable repayment plan. This could include discussing with your lenders to secure lower interest rates or longer repayment terms.

Shareholder Investment

Consider seeking additional investment from existing shareholders. This infusion of capital can bolster the company’s financial stability and allow it to meet its obligations.

Informal Debt Settlement

Engage in direct negotiations with creditors to reach an informal debt settlement agreement. This might involve proposing a reduced payment amount or a revised payment schedule.

Asset Sales

Evaluate the possibility of selling non-core assets to raise capital. This can provide immediate cash flow to address pressing debt payments and improve the company’s overall financial health.

Informal workouts, negotiated directly with creditors, often provide a more cost-effective and faster solution than formal corp bankruptcy proceedings. However, they require cooperation and flexibility from all parties involved.

If these alternatives prove insufficient, and the company has the potential for long-term viability, restructuring through the CCAA or a Division I proposal under the BIA becomes a viable option. However, if the company is deemed not viable, receivership may be the most appropriate course of action, especially for secured creditors.

Corp bankruptcy FAQs

  1. What is the difference between “insolvency” and “bankruptcy” in Canada?

While the terms are often used interchangeably, they have distinct meanings under Canadian law. Insolvency is a financial state where a debtor is unable to pay their debts as they become due. This could be due to various reasons like business downturns or personal financial mismanagement.

Bankruptcy, on the other hand, is a legal process initiated when an insolvent person’s assets are transferred to a Licensed Insolvency Trustee. The insolvency trustee then distributes these assets to creditors based on a priority order set by the BIA.

In simpler terms, insolvency is the financial condition, while bankruptcy is the legal process to address it.

  1. What are the primary laws governing insolvency and bankruptcy laws in Canada?

Canada’s insolvency framework primarily comprises two federal statutes: The BIA: This Act applies to both personal and corporate bankruptcies. It outlines the procedures for filing for bankruptcy, governs insolvency trustee licensing, and dictates the distribution of a bankrupt entity’s assets among creditors. The CCAA: This Act provides a framework for restructuring insolvent companies with debts exceeding $5 million. It allows for the creation of a Plan of Arrangement to compromise with creditors or facilitate the sale of the business under court supervision.

  1. What does the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy (OSB) do?

The OSB is the federal agency that oversees bankruptcy processes in Canada. Its main responsibilities include:

  • Overseeing cases under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA) and the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA).
  • Making sure that the laws set out in the BIA and CCAA are followed.
  • Regulating Licensed Insolvency Trustees.
  • Keeping a public record of filings related to the BIA and CCAA.

4. What happens to a company’s operations when it files for bankruptcy?

Typically, day-to-day business operations cease upon filing for bankruptcy. A LIT takes control of the company’s assets, liquidates them, and distributes the proceeds to creditors based on the BIA’s priority rules.

Shareholders generally lose their investments, and directors may face personal liability for certain debts, depending on specific circumstances and provincial laws.

  1. How does the Canadian insolvency system prioritize creditors?

The BIA establishes a specific order of priority for creditor claims:

  • Deemed trusts: Amounts like unremitted source deductions from employees and unremitted HST are held in trust for the Crown and are paid first.
  • Unpaid suppliers: Suppliers can reclaim unpaid goods delivered within a specific timeframe before bankruptcy.
  • Super-priorities: These include unpaid wages, pension contributions, and costs for environmental cleanup.
  • Secured claims: Creditors with security over specific assets are paid from the proceeds of those assets.
  • Preferred claims: Certain unsecured claims under section 136(1) of the BIA, such as administrative costs of the bankruptcy, are prioritized.
  • Ordinary unsecured claims: All other claims are paid proportionally from the remaining funds.
  1. Can a company avoid bankruptcy in Canada?

Yes, alternatives to bankruptcy debt relief options are:

  • Proposal to Creditors (BIA): A company may propose a plan to restructure its debts and negotiate compromises with creditors. If this proposal is accepted by both the creditors and the court, the company can successfully avert bankruptcy.
  • Restructuring under the CCAA: Corporations with debts exceeding $5 million may seek court protection under the CCAA to undertake a restructuring of their operations and financial obligations.
  • Informal Arrangements: Companies have the option to engage in direct negotiations with creditors to establish informal agreements, which may include debt restructuring or payment deferrals.
  1. What is receivership, and how does it relate to bankruptcy?

Receivership is a legal process where a secured creditor appoints a receiver to take control of a debtor’s assets, typically to enforce a security interest. This appointment can be made privately by the creditor or through a court order.

While receivership can happen at the same time as bankruptcy, it mainly aims to protect the interests of the secured creditor. The receiver may sell off assets to pay back the secured debt, whereas a trustee in bankruptcy oversees the distribution of assets to all creditors following the priorities set out in the BIA.

  1. How can a foreign company with operations in Canada be affected by Canadian insolvency laws?

If a foreign company has assets or carries on business in Canada, it falls under the jurisdiction of Canadian insolvency laws like the BIA and CCAA. It can be subject to bankruptcy proceedings or restructuring efforts in Canada.

The BIA also has provisions for recognizing and cooperating with foreign insolvency proceedings, allowing for coordination between Canadian courts and foreign jurisdictions in cross-border insolvency cases.

Conclusion: Seeking Expert Guidance for Corp Bankruptcy

Navigating the complexities of corp bankruptcy in Canada demands a thorough understanding of the legal frameworks and available options. Bankruptcy, Division I proposals, and receivership each offer distinct paths with varying implications for debt resolution, business operations, and stakeholder interests.

Remember, seeking professional advice is paramount. A LIT and a qualified lawyer specializing in insolvency can provide expert guidance, ensuring you make informed decisions and protect your rights throughout the process. Early intervention and expert assistance can significantly improve the chances of a successful outcome, whether that means restructuring your company or navigating a controlled and dignified wind-down.

I hope you enjoyed this corp bankruptcy Brandon’s Blog. Do you or your company have too much debt? Are you or your company in need of financial restructuring due to distressed real estate or other reasons? The financial restructuring process is complex. The Ira Smith Team understands how to do a complex restructuring. However, more importantly, we understand the needs of the entrepreneur or someone with too much personal debt.

You are worried because you are facing significant financial challenges. It is not your fault that you are in this situation. You have been only shown the old ways that do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team uses new modern ways to get you out of your debt troubles while avoiding the bankruptcy process. We can get you debt relief freedom using processes that are a bankruptcy alternative.

The stress placed upon you is huge. We understand your pain points. We look at your entire situation and devise a strategy that is as unique as you and your problems; financial and emotional. The way we take the load off of your shoulders and devise a plan, we know that we can help you.

We know that people facing financial problems need a realistic lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” approach with the Ira Smith Team.

That is why we can develop a restructuring process as unique as the financial problems and pain you are facing. If any of this sounds familiar to you and you are serious about finding a solution, contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. team today.

Call us now for a free consultation. We will get you or your company back on the road to healthy stress-free operations and recover from the pain points in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

The information provided in this Brandon’s Blog is intended for educational purposes only. It is not intended to constitute legal, financial, or professional advice. Readers are encouraged to seek professional advice regarding their specific situations. The content of this Brandon’s Blog should not be relied upon as a substitute for professional guidance or consultation. The author, Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. as well as any contributors to this Brandon’s Blog, do not assume any liability for any loss or damage resulting from reliance on the information provided herein.

A businessman on a sinking ship in turbulent waters representing a corporation heading to bankruptcy with a helicopter above throwing a restructuring lifeline.
corp bankruptcy
Categories
Brandon Blog Post

BANKRUPTCY AND BUSINESS FAILURE: WHY THE STATISTICS UNDOUBTEDLY DO NOT TELL THE FULL STORY


bankruptcy and business

Bankruptcy and Business: Introduction

As a licensed insolvency trustee, (previously referred to as a trustee in bankruptcy), my role involves assisting individuals and businesses in managing the complexities associated with entrepreneurship. The conclusion of a business often occurs without fanfare; it is not typically marked by formal announcements or celebratory farewells but rather unfolds quietly amidst the ongoing activity of the market. Despite rising bankruptcy and business failure through the recorded insolvency numbers, many businesses close without it showing up in the insolvency statistics, revealing a deeper truth about economic resilience.

For every corporate insolvency file that I administer, be it the legal process of a bankruptcy protection financial restructuring or a bankruptcy liquidation, there have been many more inquiries from entrepreneurs where the best advice I can give is rather than spending money on corporate bankruptcy, just shut down the business yourself.

In this Brandon’s Blog, which is aimed at Canadian entrepreneurs and their professional advisors, be they financial advisors, lawyers or accountants, I explore the complexities of bankruptcy and business failures, where one fact stands out: the numbers can be deceiving. The current rise in reported business insolvencies has raised eyebrows. But what’s behind these figures? Many businesses close their doors without formally declaring bankruptcy.

Bankruptcy and Business: Types of Business Structures Affected by Bankruptcy

It is essential to understand the different types of business structures that can be affected by or are eligible for bankruptcy. In this section, I’ll explore the impact of bankruptcy on sole proprietorships, partnerships, and incorporated companies.

Sole Proprietorships

A sole proprietorship is a business owned and operated by one individual personally. In the event of bankruptcy, the sole proprietor’s personal assets, including their home, savings, and other personal property, can be used to pay off business debts. This is because, from a legal perspective, the business and the individual are considered one and the same.

Partnerships

A partnership is a business owned and operated by two or more individuals. In the event of one or more partners filing for personal bankruptcy, the partnership’s assets are typically divided among the partners, and each partner is responsible for paying off their share of the debts. However, if one partner files for bankruptcy protection, then the partnership is automatically dissolved. If one partner is unable to pay their share, the other partners are responsible for paying off the remaining business debts.

Incorporated Companies

An incorporated company, also known as a corporation, is a separate legal entity from its shareholders. In the event of bankruptcy, as the corporation is a separate entity, the corporation’s assets are typically liquidated to pay off its debts, and the shareholders are not personally responsible for paying off the debts. However, if the corporation is insolvent, the shareholders may still be at risk of losing their investment.

Key Takeaways

  • Sole proprietorships: The business and the individual are considered one and the same, and personal assets can be used to pay off business debts.
  • Partnerships: Partners are responsible for paying off their share of the debts, or alternatively, each partner is responsible for paying off the entire amount of all debts. If one partner is unable to pay, and especially if one or more partners file for personal bankruptcy, the other partners are responsible for paying off the remaining business debts.
  • Incorporated companies: The corporation’s assets are typically liquidated to pay off its debts, and shareholders are not personally responsible for paying off the debts, but may still be at risk of losing their investment.

Why Understanding Business Structure is Important

Understanding the type of business structure you have is essential in the event of insolvency, as it influences the appropriate debt relief solution that can be developed and executed. The relationship between bankruptcy and your business structure will affect how your assets are managed and how your debts are settled. For instance, if you operate as a sole proprietorship, you may be personally liable for the repayment of business debts. In contrast, if your business is incorporated, your personal assets are typically safeguarded from creditors.

Bankruptcy can impact any business structure; sole proprietorships, partnerships, and corporations. It is important to comprehend the specific business structure you operate under and the implications a bankruptcy protection filing may have on both you and your business. For Canadian entrepreneurs facing challenges with business debt, it is advisable to consult a licensed insolvency trustee to explore available options and make informed decisions regarding your financial situation.

Although parts of the balance of this article will focus on the corporate business structure, most will also be applicable to Canadian business regardless of the business structure.

bankruptcy and business
bankruptcy and business

Understanding Bankruptcy and Business in Canada: A Guide for Businesses

As a Canadian entrepreneur, it is important to recognize that operating a business involves various risks and challenges. Even with diligent management, financial difficulties may arise that jeopardize the viability of your company. In these circumstances, it is essential to be well-informed about the options at your disposal. One widely recognized and effective solution in such situations is corporate bankruptcy.

What is Corporate Bankruptcy in Canada?

Corporate bankruptcy, arising from a corporate insolvency, occurs when a business is unable to pay its overwhelming debts as they become due – that is the definition of an insolvent company. This can happen due to a variety of reasons, including poor cash flow management, increased competition, unexpected expenses, or even a downturn in the economy. When a business becomes insolvent, it may be forced to cease operations, leading to financial losses for its creditors, employees, and shareholders.

Types of Bankruptcy For Corporations in Canada

There are two main types of corporate bankruptcy in Canada: proposal and bankruptcy.

  • Proposal: A corporate proposal is an alternative to bankruptcy. It is a formal payment plan under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) BIA that allows a business a period of time to settle its debts with its creditors. The proposal is presented to the creditors, who then vote on whether to accept it. If accepted, the proposal then goes to court for approval. When the court approves the proposal, it then is binding on the debtor business and the creditors.

Once the proposal becomes binding, the business can restructure its debt and continue operating by making the monthly payments to the Trustee that it promised to make for the benefit of its creditors. This is otherwise known as a corporate restructuring plan.

  • Bankruptcy: Bankruptcy is also a formal process under the BIA where the business assets are liquidated by selling off its assets. The Trustee then uses the net proceeds of sale to pay for the cost of the corporate bankruptcy process and then to distribute what remains to the unsecured creditors on a pro rata basis according to their claims.

Benefits of Corporate Bankruptcy in Canada

While bankruptcy protection may seem like a last resort, it can actually be a beneficial option for businesses facing financial difficulties. Some of the benefits of corporate bankruptcy in Canada include:

  • Protection from Creditors: Bankruptcy provides a stay of proceedings, which means that creditors cannot take or continue legal action against the business or its assets.
  • Reorganization: Bankruptcy allows businesses to restructure their debt and reorganize their operations to become more sustainable.
  • Fresh Start: Bankruptcy can provide a fresh start for businesses, allowing them to emerge from insolvency and start anew.

When to Consider Corporate Bankruptcy in Canada

If your business is experiencing financial difficulties, it’s essential to seek professional advice from a licensed insolvency trustee. Here are some signs that may indicate it’s time to consider corporate bankruptcy:

  • Cash Flow Problems: Cash flow problems can indicate underlying financial issues within a business. If a company is consistently struggling to pay its bills on time, it is essential to investigate the root causes of this cash flow challenge, as it may reflect broader financial health concerns.
  • High Debt Levels: When a business is burdened with significant debt and faces challenges in meeting its repayment obligations, considering bankruptcy may be a viable option to explore.
  • Loss of Key Customers or Suppliers: Loss of key customers or suppliers can indicate underlying issues within a business that require attention. It is important to analyze the reasons behind this loss, as it may reflect broader challenges affecting the organization’s performance and stability. Addressing these issues promptly can help mitigate potential negative impacts on operations and profitability.

Corporate bankruptcy in Canada is a multifaceted process that can present challenges for businesses in financial distress. However, it can serve as an effective mechanism for companies to address their financial challenges and restructure. By familiarizing themselves with the available options and consulting with qualified professionals, businesses can effectively navigate the bankruptcy process, potentially emerging in a more resilient and sustainable position. Entrepreneurs in Canada facing significant business debt are encouraged to reach out to a licensed insolvency trustee to explore their available options.

Bankruptcy and Business: The Overlooked Landscape of Business Closures

Understanding Bankruptcy and Business Insolvency Filing vs. Closure

Have you ever wondered the difference between a business going bankrupt and closing its doors? It’s important. Business insolvency is the financial condition that the business cannot pay all of its debts as they come due. Business bankruptcy is a legal process where a business files for bankruptcy in order to deal with the distribution of its assets among its creditors in a fair and orderly fashion, as far as the money can go. On the other hand, closure can happen for many reasons, like poor management or market changes. Bankruptcy and business failure many times go hand in hand, but just as often, they don’t.

Reasons For Bankruptcy and Business Failure

Understanding the Common Causes

As a licensed insolvency trustee, I’ve seen firsthand the devastating impact of business bankruptcy on entrepreneurs, employees, and the economy as a whole. While no business is immune to financial difficulties, understanding the common reasons for business bankruptcy can help entrepreneurs take proactive steps to mitigate risks and avoid insolvency.

In this section, we’ll explore the three main categories of reasons for business bankruptcy: Financial Challenges, Operational Issues, and External Factors.

Financial Challenges

Financial challenges are often the most obvious reason for business bankruptcy. Some common financial challenges that can lead to insolvency include:

  • Cash flow management issues: Inability to manage cash flow can lead to delayed payments, missed deadlines, and ultimately, insolvency.
  • High debt levels: Carrying too much debt can put a significant strain on a business’s finances, making it difficult to meet financial obligations.
  • Inadequate funding: Insufficient startup capital or ongoing funding can hinder a business’s ability to grow and operate successfully.
  • Poor budgeting: Failing to create a realistic budget or failing to stick to it can lead to financial difficulties.

Operational Issues

Operational issues can also contribute to business bankruptcy. Some common operational issues that can lead to insolvency include:

  • Inefficient operations: Poorly managed operations can lead to wasted resources, increased costs, and decreased productivity.
  • Lack of scalability: Failing to adapt to growth or changes in the market can lead to operational inefficiencies and financial difficulties.
  • Poor management: Ineffective leadership or management can lead to poor decision-making, which can ultimately result in insolvency.
  • Failure to innovate: Failing to innovate or adapt to changes in the market can lead to stagnation and financial difficulties.

External Factors

External factors can also play a significant role in business bankruptcy. Some common external factors that can lead to insolvency include:

  • Economic downturns: Economic recessions or downturns can lead to reduced consumer spending, decreased demand, and financial difficulties.
  • Competition: Increased competition can lead to reduced market share, decreased revenue, and financial difficulties.
  • Regulatory changes: Changes in regulations or laws can lead to increased costs, decreased revenue, and financial difficulties.
  • Natural disasters: Natural disasters or other external events can lead to significant financial losses and insolvency.

By understanding the common reasons for business bankruptcy, entrepreneurs can take proactive steps to mitigate risks and avoid insolvency. This includes creating a solid business plan, managing cash flow effectively, and staying adaptable to changes in the market. As a licensed insolvency trustee, I’ve seen firsthand the devastating impact of business bankruptcy on entrepreneurs and the economy. By being aware of the common causes of business bankruptcy, entrepreneurs can take steps to avoid insolvency and achieve long-term success.

Statistical Insights

Recent statistics highlight an important trend that merits our attention. Following the 2008 financial crisis, we saw a notable rise in business closures, with many not opting to file for bankruptcy. This is quite surprising, isn’t it?

In the first quarter of this year, Canada experienced 2,003 insolvencies, which included 1,599 bankruptcies and 404 proposals. This marks an 87 percent increase compared to the same quarter last year and represents the highest number of insolvencies in the first three months since early 2008.

Additionally, Statistics Canada provides insights into active businesses by tracking their monthly payroll filings with the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA). Due to a slight delay in data reporting and analysis, the latest figures are from January, showing there were 936,327 active businesses in Canada. However, there were also 43,121 closures, being companies that reported employees to the CRA in December 2023 but did not in January 2024.

“The real tragedy of business closures hides in the shadows of insolvency statistics.”

In light of all this, understanding that a business can disappear without ever declaring bankruptcy is crucial. It paints a clearer picture of our economy. Whether due to management issues or other challenges affecting the viability and solvency of the business, this is a landscape that deserves attention. What are your thoughts on this?

bankruptcy and business
bankruptcy and business

Bankruptcy and Business: The Hidden Truth Behind Business Closures

Understanding the Landscape of Business Failures

Did you know that the actual number of business closures is likely much higher than what insolvency figures reveal? It’s a shocking reality. Business insolvencies are soaring to heights we haven’t seen since the financial crisis of 2008. But here’s the catch: these numbers only represent a fraction of the businesses that are truly shutting down each year.

Why Do Businesses Fail?

Let’s dig into some reasons why businesses fail:

  • Lack of Cash Flow: Many businesses struggle with cash management. Without enough cash coming in, they can’t pay bills.
  • Poor Decision-Making: Sometimes, choosing the wrong direction can lead to disaster. It’s like sailing without a compass.
  • Competition: It’s a wild world out there. If you can’t keep up with your competitors, you may find yourself left behind.

The Significance of Measuring Failures

When you think about it, why are these insolvency numbers so important? They give us a glimpse into the broader economic conditions. However, they don’t paint the full picture. Countless businesses fold without ever going through the insolvency process. This raises the question: how can we better support these struggling businesses?

What Can Be Done?

We need to think creatively. Here are some strategies to consider:

  1. Strong Cash Flow Management: Maintaining robust financial practices can prevent major setbacks.
  2. Seek Guidance: Consulting with business mentors can provide invaluable insights.
  3. Flexibility is Key: Being adaptable to changing market demands can keep a business afloat.

A detailed examination of these factors reveals that each statistic embodies a narrative. Gaining insight into these dynamics enhances our understanding of the current business environment and facilitates the development of more effective solutions.

Bankruptcy and Business: Understanding Business Failures vs. Insolvency Rates

The current trend of rising bankruptcy and business failures can be alarming. We’re seeing numbers that remind us of the financial crisis back in 2008. But here’s the kicker: the official insolvency figures don’t tell the whole story. They only reflect a fraction of the businesses that close each year. So, what’s going on?

The Hidden Truth Behind Business Closures

When a business shuts down, sometimes bankruptcy and business do not go together. The business is insolvent, but as I stated in the introduction to this bankruptcy and business Brandon’s Blog, sometimes the wisest choice for owners is simply to close their doors rather than declare bankruptcy. Of course, in doing so, the business must treat its employees fairly in making sure that all wages and vacation pay are paid up in full, the books and records should be finalized, any leased equipment or consignment goods returned to their owners and all final government returns are filed.

A voluntary business closure raises a few questions:

  • Are entrepreneurs running away from the stigma of bankruptcy and business failure?
  • Do businesses fear the legal complexities of bankruptcy?

The Reality of Business Closures

Many businesses succumb to market pressures, competition, or changing consumer preferences. So even if a business doesn’t file for bankruptcy, it’s still part of a broader trend of bankruptcy and business failure.

Here are some factors contributing to these closures:

  1. Economic downturns: A slowdown can hit sales hard.
  2. Shifts in consumer behaviour: Staying relevant is crucial.
  3. Operational inefficiencies: Sometimes, a business just can’t keep up.

The data presented reflects not merely statistics, but real stories of individuals whose dreams and aspirations have faced significant challenges. Recognizing this broader context is crucial for comprehending the current realities of the business landscape.

bankruptcy and business
bankruptcy and business

Bankruptcy and Business: Understanding Business Failures Beyond Insolvency Numbers

Every year, countless businesses close their doors. But did you know most failures don’t make it to the insolvency list? It’s a striking fact. There’s a lot more happening beneath the surface.

The Real Picture of Business Failures

Business insolvencies are currently rising, reaching levels reminiscent of the 2008 financial crisis. However, these numbers only tell part of the story.

  • Insolvency counts are just the tip of the iceberg. Many businesses close without ever filing for bankruptcy.
  • They might choose to liquidate assets instead, avoiding formal insolvency procedures.
  • Some simply shutter their operation quietly, leaving no trail that stats can follow.

Why Do They Close?

Now, let’s dig deeper. Why do businesses close? Here are a few key reasons:

  1. Market changes: Trends shift rapidly. A product that sells today may be yesterday’s news tomorrow.
  2. Lack of funds: Often, owners run out of cash. It’s not always about being in debt.
  3. Poor planning: Without a solid business plan, success becomes a game of chance.

It’s critical to understand these points. When we consider the broader picture, it becomes clear that the narrative of bankruptcy and business failure encompasses much more than insolvency figures. So, when you hear those numbers, remember: behind every statistic, there’s a unique story. It’s worth exploring.

Bankruptcy and Business Behind the Scenes: A Personal Journey with Business Failure

Let me describe to you, with no names of course, about an entrepreneur who recently consulted with me. He truly believed in his retail business. It was welcoming, colourful, and brimming with potential. He had dreams of providing the best customer service in town. But, not long after the grand opening, he saw that it wasn’t working out. The foot traffic was lower than he anticipated, and the expenses kept piling up. He had to close the doors within a year of opening. It felt like a hard punch to his gut.

Lessons Learned

From this experience, he learned a few invaluable lessons:

  • Resilience is Key: Every setback can teach us something. We just need to be open to those lessons.
  • Adaptability Matters: The ability to pivot quickly can save a business. If he had been more flexible and had some staying power, perhaps he could have found a way to make it work.
  • Not All Bankruptcy and Business Failures Reflect Capability: Just because a venture doesn’t succeed it doesn’t mean that the person is not capable as an entrepreneur.

The Emotional Toll

Closing his store was not just a business decision; it hit him hard on a personal level. There’s a saying:

“Failure isn’t the opposite of success; it’s part of success.”

This resonated with him throughout the process. He felt a profound sense of loss—not just for his dream, but for his team and the community, albeit small, that had begun to form around his business. It’s important to recognize that every business closure affects many lives.

He will cherish the memories, good and bad. We often think of success as the ultimate goal. However, failures

can be just as important. After all, they prepare us for the next big opportunity.

Bankruptcy and Business: The Economic Ripple Effect of Silent Failures

Have you ever stopped to think about the impact of a business closing its doors quietly? It’s alarming. Each silent closure sends ripples through our communities. But how exactly does this happen?

Understanding the Broader Economy

When a business goes unnoticed, its effects are profound. For small towns and cities, local businesses are often the lifeblood of the economy. They provide jobs and foster a sense of community. But when they fail, a series of consequences unfold.

  • Potential job losses: Every unnoticed closure often results in job losses. It’s estimated that thousands of jobs are impacted as small businesses close each year.
  • Supply chain impacts: Smaller firms are interwoven into larger supply chains. When they disappear, disruptions occur, affecting many others reliant on their goods or services.

A Community Heartbreak

The silence surrounding these closures can be deafening.

“Every business closure is a community heartbreak.”

This isn’t just a catchy phrase; it’s the reality for many.

Large corporations may withstand economic struggles, but small businesses often can’t. Imagine a local diner you frequently visit, or a beloved independent bookstore. If these establishments close, the repercussions extend beyond just lost revenue. They can alter job security and change local culture.

We often overlook just how many jobs depend on these small firms. Have you considered what happens to job seekers when they vanish?

bankruptcy and business
bankruptcy and business

Bankruptcy and Business: Preventing the Silent Nightmare of Business Closure

We all know that running a business can feel like navigating through a storm. Sometimes, even the most resilient enterprises can face economic downturns that threaten their very existence. So, how do we ensure survivability? Here are some strategies to consider:

1. Embrace Innovation

  • Adapt to Market Trends: Staying ahead means constantly evaluating what’s working and what’s not. Are your customers shifting their preferences? Innovate to meet their needs.
  • Leverage Technology: Digital tools can streamline operations and reach wider markets. Tools like social media and e-commerce platforms can significantly boost visibility.

2. Cultivate Adaptability

We must understand that adaptability is key. If we don’t learn and pivot, we risk stagnation. Have you ever noticed how quickly the business landscape shifts? Continuous learning is not just a phrase; it’s a necessity. Training programs and workshops can enhance our expertise.

3. Build Community Support

One of the most effective strategies is building a strong support system. Entrepreneurs often feel isolated—this needn’t be the case. Engaging in community networks or mentorship programs can provide valuable guidance.

Imagine a gardener tending to a plant. It needs nurturing, sunlight, and sometimes a bit of pruning. Similarly, businesses thrive in supportive environments where they can learn and adapt. We need to reinforce this sense of community, where sharing experiences can lead to encouragement and growth.

Finally, I want to acknowledge that the journey is indeed tough. Yet, it is essential to focus on personal resilience. Everyone faces challenges. But through understanding and support, we can not only overcome but also flourish!

I urge you to seek out success stories, too. Businesses that have pivoted successfully often serve as a beacon of hope. They illuminate paths we never considered. By sharing our experiences and challenges, we help each other to thrive.

Bankruptcy and Business: Shining a Light on Shadows

As we’ve explored the complexities of business failures, one fact stands out: the numbers can be deceiving. The current rise in business insolvencies has raised eyebrows. But what’s behind these figures? Many businesses close their doors without formally declaring bankruptcy. This distinction is critical for understanding the health of our economy. Not all failures are recorded in official statistics. Every year, countless ventures close down quietly, leaving little trace. Each shuttered business represents dreams, investments, and hard work.

As we wrap up our discussion, it’s clear that *business failures* are more common than we often admit. Many business owners might feel isolated, and that’s understandable. But recognizing the reality of these failures is essential. It reminds us that every entrepreneur’s journey is difficult yet filled with opportunities to learn and grow.

Here are some key points we’ve explored:

  1. The numerous factors that contribute to business closures.
  2. The impact of community support on a business’s survival.
  3. How understanding failures can lead to future successes.

    bankruptcy and business
    bankruptcy and business

Bankruptcy and Business in Canada: FAQ

1. What is the difference between a business closing and a business going bankrupt?

Business closure and bankruptcy are distinct concepts in the realm of business operations.

Business closure refers to the termination of a business’s operations for various reasons. These reasons may include factors such as ineffective management, shifts in market conditions, or a deliberate choice by the owner to cease operations.

On the other hand, business bankruptcy is a legal process defined by the BIA in Canada. This occurs when a business officially declares its inability to meet its financial obligations. The bankruptcy process typically involves either restructuring debts through a formal proposal or liquidating business assets to repay creditors.

It is important to note that while bankruptcy often results in the closure of a business, not all closures are accompanied by bankruptcy proceedings. A business can close without filing for bankruptcy, opting instead to liquidate its assets and settle any outstanding debts on its own.

2. What are the main types of corporate bankruptcy in Canada?

Canada provides two main avenues for corporations encountering bankruptcy:

  • Proposal: This option involves submitting a formal payment plan to creditors for their approval. If the proposal is accepted and subsequently sanctioned by the court, the business can restructure its debts, continue its operations, and repay creditors over an extended period.
  • Bankruptcy: In this scenario, the corporation liquidates its assets to settle debts with creditors. The proceeds from the asset sales are allocated to creditors, starting with secured creditors, followed by a proportional distribution of any remaining funds to unsecured creditors.

3. What are some common reasons for business failure?

Business failure can result from various issues that can be categorized into three main areas:

Financial Challenges:

  • Poor cash flow management
  • High levels of debt
  • Insufficient funding
  • Ineffective budgeting practices

Operational Issues:

  • Inefficient operational processes
  • Inability to scale operations
  • Subpar management practices
  • Lack of innovation

External Factors:

  • Economic downturns
  • Heightened competition
  • Changes in regulations
  • Natural disasters

4. Why is the number of business closures likely higher than official insolvency statistics suggest?

Many businesses choose to close their doors without formally filing for bankruptcy. This could be due to several reasons:

  • Avoiding the stigma of bankruptcy: Some entrepreneurs may perceive bankruptcy as a personal failure and opt for a quiet closure.
  • Complexity and cost of bankruptcy proceedings: The legal processes involved in bankruptcy can be daunting and expensive, deterring some businesses.
  • Strategic decision to liquidate independently: Owners may decide to manage the closure process themselves, selling assets to settle debts outside of formal insolvency proceedings.

5. What are the economic consequences of unrecorded business closures?

Unrecorded closures have a significant impact on the economy:

  • Job losses: Closures, whether reported or not, often lead to job losses, impacting individuals, families, and communities.
  • Supply chain disruptions: Small businesses are often integral to larger supply chains. Their closures can disrupt these networks, impacting other businesses reliant on their goods or services.
  • Reduced economic activity: Closures reduce overall economic activity in communities, impacting local spending, tax revenue, and overall economic health.

6. What are some strategies to help businesses avoid closure?

  • Embrace innovation: Adapting to market trends, leveraging technology, and developing new products or services can help businesses remain competitive.
  • Cultivate adaptability: Continuous learning, training, and willingness to adjust strategies can improve resilience in the face of change.
  • Build community support: Engaging with local networks, seeking mentorship, and fostering collaboration can provide valuable resources and guidance.
  • Prioritize financial management: Strong cash flow management, responsible budgeting, and careful debt management are crucial for business stability.

7. How can we better understand the true landscape of business closures?

  • Improved data collection: Implementing better tracking mechanisms to capture closures beyond formal insolvency filings could provide a more accurate picture of business failure rates.
  • Research and analysis: Studying the reasons behind unrecorded closures can offer insights into common challenges and potential solutions.
  • Open dialogue and awareness: Encouraging entrepreneurs to share their experiences, both successes and failures, can normalize conversations about business closure and facilitate learning.

8. What is the key takeaway from understanding the difference between business closures and bankruptcy?

Recognizing that business closures are more prevalent than official insolvency statistics indicate is crucial. It highlights the challenges faced by entrepreneurs and emphasizes the need for support systems, innovation, adaptability, and sound financial management to foster business success and resilience. Acknowledging the silent failures allows for a more accurate understanding of the economic landscape and can help policymakers and support organizations develop strategies to address these challenges and better support businesses.

Bankruptcy and Business: Conclusion

So, why is it important to acknowledge these failures? It’s simple. They are not just numbers on a report; they are the culmination of hard work, dreams, and sometimes missteps. When a business fails, it can feel like a dark cloud, but it can also be the start of something new.

I hope you enjoyed this bankruptcy and business Brandon’s Blog. Do you or your company have too much debt? Are you or your company in need of financial restructuring due to distressed real estate or other reasons? The financial restructuring process is complex. The Ira Smith Team understands how to do a complex restructuring. However, more importantly, we understand the needs of the entrepreneur or someone with too much personal debt.

You are worried because you are facing significant financial challenges. It is not your fault that you are in this situation. You have been only shown the old ways that do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team uses new modern ways to get you out of your debt troubles while avoiding the bankruptcy process. We can get you debt relief freedom using processes that are a bankruptcy alternative.

The stress placed upon you is huge. We understand your pain points. We look at your entire situation and devise a strategy that is as unique as you and your problems; financial and emotional. The way we take the load off of your shoulders and devise a plan, we know that we can help you.

We know that people facing financial problems need a realistic lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” approach with the Ira Smith Team.

That is why we can develop a restructuring process as unique as the financial problems and pain you are facing. If any of this sounds familiar to you and you are serious about finding a solution, contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. team today.

Call us now for a free consultation. We will get you or your company back on the road to healthy stress-free operations and recover from the pain points in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

The information provided in this Brandon’s Blog is intended for educational purposes only. It is not intended to constitute legal, financial, or professional advice. Readers are encouraged to seek professional advice regarding their specific situations. The content of this Brandon’s Blog should not be relied upon as a substitute for professional guidance or consultation. The author, Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. as well as any contributors to this Brandon’s Blog, do not assume any liability for any loss or damage resulting from reliance on the information provided herein.

bankruptcy and business
bankruptcy and business
Categories
Brandon Blog Post

THE BANK RUPTCY RECOVERY PLAN: A COMPREHENSIVE ROADMAP TO FINANCIAL STABILITY

Bank ruptcy: Introduction

I know it looks weird, but I have noticed through our software that people wanting to find out more about the Canadian bankruptcy process are searching for the two-syllable phrase “bank ruptcy“. I started to investigate this phenomenon. It turns out that individuals may often search for the term “bankruptcy” by entering “bank ruptcy” due to a phenomenon known as “typo-based search behaviour.” This behaviour occurs when users inadvertently type a word incorrectly while still approaching the correct spelling closely enough that their search engine or browser can suggest the accurate term.

In this instance, individuals may intend to find information about “bankruptcy” but mistakenly type “bank ruptcy.” The search engine or browser, recognizing the intent, may then offer “bankruptcy” as a suggested correction, which users can select to access the desired information.

Moreover, some users may be utilizing mobile devices or keyboards with non-standard layouts, which can contribute to typographical errors or misspellings. In such instances, search engines or browsers often retain the capability to discern the user’s intent behind the query and provide relevant search results.

It is also important to acknowledge that search engines, such as Google, are designed to improve user experience by interpreting and correcting common typing errors, thereby facilitating more effective information retrieval without necessarily teaching the person the correct spelling.

Bank ruptcy: What is Bankruptcy and Where Did the Word Originate?

The term “bankruptcy” has its origins in ancient civilizations, notably in Greece and Rome, where debtors had avenues for seeking relief from their creditors through various forms of debt forgiveness or restructuring. However, the modern legal framework and procedures associated with bankruptcy are a more recent development, emerging in Europe during the 16th century.

The word bank ruptcy is likely derived from the Italian two-word phrase “banca rupta,” which translates to “broken bench” or “broken table.” In this context, “banca” refers to a “bench” or “table,” while “rupta” means “broken.” This term was historically employed in medieval Italy to describe a merchant or trader who was unable to meet their financial obligations. Business was conducted at the benches or tables of the various merchants. Consequently, their “bench” or “table,” representing their business, was broken and rendered inoperative if they ran out of money.

In the 14th century, the Old French term “banqueroute” evolved from the phrase “banquer ost,” which followed the Italian meaning and further contributed to the development of the modern word and concept of bankruptcy as we understand it today.

The term evolved to include the concept of a legal process by which a person or business could be declared insolvent and their assets liquidated to pay off creditors. Being insolvent is the financial condition that can lead to the legal bankruptcy process to allow the honest but unfortunate debtor to have financial recovery.

bank ruptcy canada
bank ruptcy

Bank ruptcy: Are you ready to take control of your financial life and gain peace of mind?

Are you facing overwhelming debt and experiencing persistent financial stress and uncertainty? Do you aspire to liberate yourself from the burdens of debt and emerge more resilient and financially savvy? If so, you are not alone.

Millions of individuals worldwide are navigating similar challenges, and it is common to feel isolated in your struggle with debt issues. However, there is a solution. By identifying the underlying causes of debt and formulating a tailored recovery plan, you can take significant steps toward financial stability.

If you are prepared to regain control of your finances, overcome debt, and lay the groundwork for a more secure future, you have come to the right place. Let us embark on this journey to financial freedom from debt together.

Bank ruptcy: Reasons for Filing for Bankruptcy

Common financial difficulties

Consumers

Many Canadians who are considering a consumer proposal or personal bank ruptcy filing face similar financial challenges, including:

  1. High-interest debt.
  2. Job loss or reduced income.
  3. Unexpected expenses.
  4. Divorce or separation.
  5. High credit card debt.
  6. Student loan debt.
  7. Mortgage debt.
  8. Tax debt.
  9. Overextension of credit.
  10. Lack of budgeting and financial planning.
  11. Financial stress and anxiety.

It’s essential for individuals experiencing financial difficulties to seek professional help, such as credit counselling or speaking to a licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a bankruptcy trustee), to address their debt and develop a plan for financial recovery.

Businesses

Common financial difficulties Canadian businesses who need to file either a financial restructuring proposal or bank ruptcy often exhibit common danger signals such as:

  1. Cash flow problems.
  2. High debt levels.
  3. Declining sales or revenue.
  4. Increased competition.
  5. Regulatory changes.
  6. Supply chain disruptions.
  7. Economic downturns.
  8. Over-expansion.
  9. Poor financial planning.
  10. High operating costs.
  11. Lack of diversification.
  12. Insufficient working capital.
  13. Seasonal fluctuations.
  14. Lack of access to capital.
  15. Poor management decisions.
  16. Industry-specific challenges.
  17. Cybersecurity breaches.
  18. Environmental liabilities.
  19. Lack of succession planning.

If a business faces financial struggles, it’s important to, it’s important to consult a licensed insolvency trustee. They can advise on turnaround strategies and help create a recovery plan to tackle these challenges effectively.

Impact of debt on individuals and businesses

Debt can significantly influence both individuals and businesses in various ways. For individuals, the burden of overwhelming debts may result in considerable financial stress, which can manifest as anxiety and, in severe cases, depression. When debt becomes unmanageable, it can hinder one’s ability to meet daily expenses, potentially leading to missed monthly payments, impaired credit scores, and a pervasive sense of despair.

Additionally, consumer debts can restrict an individual’s financial flexibility, making it challenging to make substantial purchases, assume new financial responsibilities, or pursue long-term financial aspirations. Moreover, the strain of financial difficulties can impact personal relationships, as stress related to finances often leads to conflicts and tension among family and friends.

Similarly, for businesses, the implications of debt issues can be equally challenging. Elevated outstanding debt levels can create cash flow issues, complicating a company’s ability to fulfill its financial commitments, including employee salaries, supplier payments, and tax obligations.

Furthermore, substantial debt can curtail a business’s capacity to invest in new opportunities, foster innovation, or expand operations, ultimately hindering growth and sustainability. Understanding debt’s effects is crucial for individuals and businesses to navigate financial challenges effectively and maintain long-term stability.

Bank ruptcy: The Bankruptcy Process in Canada

Obtaining a Free Debt Assessment

If you’re having difficulty keeping up with your debt payments and feeling stressed about your financial situation, you might want to seek help from a licensed insolvency trustee. These professionals are qualified to guide you through the often complicated process of managing debt. One of the key services they provide is a free debt assessment.

This assessment involves a thorough look at your finances, including your income, expenses, assets, and debts. The trustee will work with you to pinpoint the main issues contributing to your debt and help create a personalized plan to get you back on your feet.

The best part is that a free debt assessment from a licensed insolvency trustee is completely free, with no obligation to proceed with any debt relief options. This means that you can get a clear understanding of your financial situation and explore your options without incurring any costs or risks.

During the assessment, the trustee will also be able to advise you on the best course of action to take, whether that’s a debt consolidation loan, a debt management plan, or even bank ruptcy. By taking advantage of a free debt assessment from a licensed insolvency trustee, you can gain the clarity and confidence you need to take control of your finances and start building a brighter financial future.

Necessary Forms to Declare Bankruptcy

The bankruptcy procedure in Canada is a complex and intimidating process, but it’s essential to understand the necessary forms and procedures to navigate it successfully. In Canada, the necessary bankruptcy paperwork is to declare bank ruptcy is prepared by a licensed insolvency trustee, who will guide you through the process and ensure that all required documents are completed accurately and on time.

More than that, the insolvency trustee must be able to explain your options to you and help you feel comfortable that the option you choose, is the best one for your circumstances. The information that the insolvency trustee uses to prepare the forms comes from the initial intake form the licensed trustee provides to you. From that form, the Trustee can then prepare the required documents.

The main documents required to file either a consumer proposal or for bank ruptcy are:

  1. Either the consumer proposal or the assignment in bankruptcy.
  2. The statement of affairs outlines the assets and liabilities of the debtor and includes other important information for both unsecured creditors and the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy Canada to consider.
  3. The debtor’s statement of monthly income and expenses.
  4. The notice to the debtor outlining their responsibilities in the insolvency process chosen, be it a consumer proposal or bankruptcy.

Your licensed insolvency trustee will provide you with these forms and guide you through the process of completing them accurately and submitting them to the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy Canada. By completing these forms and following the necessary procedures, you can ensure that your bankruptcy is processed efficiently and effectively and that you can start rebuilding your financial future.

Role of Licensed Insolvency Trustees

Licensed Insolvency Trustees are essential participants in the Canadian debt relief landscape. These professionals possess specialized expertise in the field of insolvency, and their work is regulated by the Canadian government, which oversees the entire insolvency process and bankruptcy laws in the country. As the only individuals authorized by the federal government, insolvency trustees play a critical role in assisting both individuals and businesses as they navigate the often complex procedures associated with debt relief, including bankruptcy, consumer proposals, and financial restructuring.

Insolvency trustees serve as neutral third parties, allowing them to offer objective advice and support to those experiencing financial challenges. They collaborate closely with creditors to negotiate settlements and develop payment plans, and they can facilitate debt restructuring efforts that lead to a more sustainable financial future.

Engaging the services of a licensed insolvency trustee can provide individuals and businesses with valuable reassurance, as they can trust in the expertise and guidance of these qualified professionals during their journey toward financial recovery.

bank ruptcy canada
bank ruptcy

Advantages of Filing for Bank ruptcy in Canada

Filing for a consumer proposal, corporate restructuring or bank ruptcy for individuals or corporate bankruptcy in Canada can provide several advantages, including:

  1. Debt Relief: It provides a fresh start by discharging most of your debts, allowing you to start over financially.
  2. Protection from Creditors: An insolvency process provides automatic protection from creditors, which means they cannot pursue you for payment or take legal action against you.
  3. Stop Wage Garnishments: A consumer proposal or bankruptcy can stop wage garnishments, which is a legal process when judgment creditors take a portion of your paycheque to pay off debts.
  4. Stop Collection Calls and legal proceedings: Upon filing, you can stop collection calls and letters from creditors by referring them to your insolvency trustee. This gives you peace of mind and reduces stress.
  5. Impact on Credit Score: It is true that an insolvency process initially worsens a person’s credit score. However, it allows you to use certain techniques that we teach you to rebuild credit and over time improve your credit rating.
  6. Protection of Assets: A consumer proposal can protect all of your assets. Bankruptcy protects your exempt property. In many cases, it stops your home or car from being seized by creditors.
  7. Simplified Financial Life: The insolvency process simplifies your financial life by eliminating debt and providing a clear plan for moving forward.
  8. Professional Guidance: Insolvency trustees provide guidance and support throughout the process.
  9. Discharge of Debts: Over time, the insolvency process allows you to discharge most debts, including credit card debt, loans, and other unsecured debts.
  10. Fresh Start Perspective: Bankruptcy, a consumer proposal and financial restructuring all provide a fresh start, allowing you to start over and make a new beginning.
  11. Reduced Stress: A successful insolvency process reduces stress and anxiety caused by debt, allowing you to focus on rebuilding your life.
  12. Protection from Tax Debt: It protects you from tax debt which can be a significant burden for many individuals.

It’s important to note that bankruptcy is a serious legal process and should only be considered as a last resort. There are various debt relief options as alternatives to bankruptcy for you to consider before resorting to bankruptcy. It’s essential to consult with a Licensed Insolvency Trustee to determine which of the many options is best for your specific situation.

Bank ruptcy: Resources for Bank ruptcy Information

There are several resources available for bankruptcy information in Canada, including:

  1. Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy Canada: The Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy Canada is the federal agency responsible for overseeing the bankruptcy and insolvency system in Canada. Their website provides information on bankruptcy, consumer proposals, and other debt-relief options.
  2. Licensed insolvency trustees: They and their websites can They and their websites can provide guidance and advice on bankruptcy and other debt-relief options.
  3. Credit Counselling Services: Legitimate non-profit c services, such as the Credit Counselling Society, provide free or low-cost advice and guidance on managing debt and avoiding bankruptcy. Financial institutions: Many banks and credit unions provide resources and information about bankruptcy and debt relief options.
  4. Government Websites: The Government of Canada’s website provides information on bankruptcy, including a guide to bankruptcy and a list of licensed insolvency trustees.

    bank ruptcy canada
    bank ruptcy

Bank ruptcy Conclusion: Moving Forward After Bank ruptcy

Here is what I tell everyone about moving forward after bank ruptcy to have a successful and stress-free life:

  1. Take responsibility: Acknowledge that you made mistakes and take responsibility for your financial decisions. This will help you to learn from your mistakes and positively move forward.
  2. Continue budgeting: Part of the personal insolvency process involves financial counselling and proper budgeting. A budget shows you what you earn each month and therefore how much you have, after tax, to spend. Allocating your earnings over your essential needs first and sticking to that plan will keep you out of debt trouble in the future.
  3. Establish an emergency fund: It is important to try to save part of your monthly income to create an emergency fund that can pay for unforeseen expenses. This will help you reduce the need for debt when unexpected financial demands arise.
  4. Focus on rebuilding credit: Rebuilding credit takes time, but it’s essential to start building a positive credit history. Make on-time payments, keep credit utilization low, and monitor your credit report regularly.
  5. Support: Finally, It’s important to reach out for support from friends, family, or even a financial advisor. Having a solid support system can keep you motivated and focused on your goals.

I hope you enjoyed this bank ruptcy Brandon’s Blog. Do you or your company have too much debt? Are you or your company in need of financial restructuring? The financial restructuring process is complex. The Ira Smith Team understands how to do a complex restructuring. However, more importantly, we understand the needs of the entrepreneur or someone with too much personal debt.

You are worried because you are facing significant financial challenges. It is not your fault that you are in this situation. You have been only shown the old ways that do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team uses new modern ways to get you out of your debt troubles while avoiding bank ruptcy. We can get you debt relief freedom.

The stress placed upon you is huge. We understand your pain points. We look at your entire situation and devise a strategy that is as unique as you and your problems; financial and emotional. The way we take the load off of your shoulders and devise a plan, we know that we can help you.

We know that people facing financial problems need a realistic lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” approach with the Ira Smith Team.

That is why we can develop a restructuring process as unique as the financial problems and pain you are facing. If any of this sounds familiar to you and you are serious about finding a solution, contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. team today.

Call us now for a free consultation. We will get you or your company back on the road to healthy stress-free operations and recover from the pain points in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

The information provided in this Brandon’s Blog is intended for educational purposes only. It is not intended to constitute legal, financial, or professional advice. Readers are encouraged to seek professional advice regarding their specific situations. The content of this Brandon’s Blog should not be relied upon as a substitute for professional guidance or consultation. The author, Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. as well as any contributors to this Brandon’s Blog, do not assume any liability for any loss or damage resulting from reliance on the information provided herein.

bank ruptcy canada
bank ruptcy
Categories
Brandon Blog Post

NAVIGATING BUSINESS INSOLVENCY IN CANADA: A LAWYER AND ACCOUNTANT’S COMPREHENSIVE GUIDE TO MASTERING INSOLVENCY LAW

Introduction to Business Insolvency

Welcome to our Brandon’s Blog where we will explore the intricate world of insolvency and its profound impact on businesses in Canada from my perspective as a professional in the field. In this exploration of business insolvency, we will uncover the implications that insolvency brings for creditors, shareholders, their lawyers and accountants, and employees alike.

Understanding the complexities of financial distress is crucial for businesses to navigate through turbulent times successfully. Join me as we discuss effective strategies and best practices to mitigate the challenges of insolvency, ensuring a smoother transition toward financial stability.

Definition of Business Insolvency

Business insolvency in the Canadian context refers to the financial state of a business where it is unable to pay its debts as they become due. It is a financial condition, not a legal one. Do not confuse the business or company with the financial condition of being an insolvent person with the legal condition of being involved in bankruptcy proceedings. Corporate insolvency is not corporate bankruptcy.

Corporate insolvency results in the business being unable to pay its debts when due which may make it impossible for the business to continue its operations. Insolvent companies may very well end up in the legal state of bankruptcy or as an alternative to bankruptcy, in insolvency restructuring proceedings.

Business insolvency can force the business to choose one of the insolvency options for businesses, including bankruptcy filings or proposals for restructuring and repayment plans under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA).

In Canada, the number of business insolvencies has been on the decline for many years, but the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic has seen a reversal of this trend. Business insolvency filings are on the rise again. However, there are many small businesses where a business bankruptcy process does not make any sense as there are either no or few assets to offset the large company debts. We get calls daily from entrepreneurs of such companies where we tell them it is in their best interests to merely close the business doors rather than spend money to put their company into bankruptcy.a picture of an overwhelmed man to represent the owner of an insolvent company turning into a picture of a calm and happy business owner representing a solvent and profitable company with people walking up a staircase representing company profitability and growth

Causes and Warning Signs of Business Insolvency

Economic Downturn and Market Volatility

One of the primary contributors to business insolvency in Canada is the unpredictable nature of economic fluctuations and market volatility. As businesses strive to adapt to shifting market trends and consumer demands, they are often met with unforeseen challenges that can strain financial resources. Economic downturns, changes in consumer behaviour, and global market dynamics all play a pivotal role in determining the financial health of businesses across various sectors.

Cash Flow Problems: Overleveraging and Excessive Debt Burden

Another significant factor that can precipitate business insolvency is overleveraging and an excessive debt burden. While leveraging can be a strategic tool for growth and expansion, it becomes problematic when businesses accumulate debt beyond their capacity to repay. High levels of debt, coupled with declining revenues or profitability, can create a precarious financial situation, ultimately leading to insolvency if left unaddressed.

Poor Financial Planning and Management

Effective financial management and planning are essential components of sustainable business operations. However, inadequate financial oversight and poor planning can leave businesses vulnerable to insolvency. From misaligned budgeting strategies to ineffective cash flow management, deficiencies in financial management practices can exacerbate existing challenges and hasten the onset of insolvency.

Navigating the complex regulatory landscape in Canada can pose significant challenges for businesses, especially concerning compliance and legal matters. Failure to adhere to regulatory requirements, such as tax obligations or industry-specific regulations, can result in legal disputes, penalties, and fines, placing additional strain on financial resources. Moreover, litigation and legal challenges can further impede business operations and contribute to business insolvency.

Technological Disruption and Industry Shifts

The rapid pace of technological innovation and industry shifts can disrupt traditional business models and market dynamics, presenting both opportunities and challenges for businesses in Canada. Failure to embrace technological advancements or adapt to changing industry trends can render businesses obsolete or inefficient, leading to a decline in competitiveness and financial viability. As such, businesses must remain agile and proactive in leveraging technology to stay ahead of the curve and mitigate the risk of insolvency.

External Shocks and Unforeseen Events

External shocks and unforeseen events, such as natural disasters, geopolitical instability, or pandemics, can have profound implications for business continuity and financial stability. The unprecedented disruptions caused by such events can severely impact supply chains, disrupt operations, and erode consumer confidence, thereby jeopardizing the financial health of businesses. While certain external shocks may be beyond the control of businesses, proactive risk management and contingency planning are essential to mitigate their adverse effects.

Remember, proactive planning, decisive action, and collaboration with knowledgeable professionals are the cornerstones of navigating business insolvency effectively.

Business Insolvency: Overview of Insolvency Law in Canada

In Canada, insolvency law plays a vital role in guiding businesses through financially distressed situations. As a professional knowledgeable in this field, I will delve into the types of insolvency proceedings and the key legislation and regulations that govern insolvency processes.

  • Types of Insolvency Proceedings: In Canada, businesses can navigate various types of insolvency proceedings:
    • bankruptcy;
    • proposal;
    • corporate restructuring;
    • receivership.

Bankruptcy involves the liquidation of assets to repay creditors, while a proposal allows for negotiating repayment plans to avoid bankruptcy. For larger corporations, corporate restructuring under different legislation than a proposal (discussed next) is available. Finally, when a secured creditor enforces its security to liquidate the business assets, that is receivership.

Understanding the nuances between these proceedings is essential for businesses facing financial challenges. All of these proceedings are described in detail in my previous blogs in the Lawyer and Accountant Series over the last few weeks.

  • Key Legislation and Regulations: The BIA applies to all business bankruptcy, proposal and receivership proceedings in Canada. The Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA) applies to corporations that owe more than $5 million to creditors who wish to avail themselves of Canadian bankruptcy protection to restructure their operations and finances.

These are the pivotal legislation for an insolvent person, be they a consumer, individual, proprietorship, partnership or corporation. They govern personal insolvency and business insolvency in Canada. The BIA will govern any personal bankruptcy or corporate bankruptcy.

Understanding these aspects of insolvency law is imperative for businesses as they navigate through financial difficulties. By recognizing the procedures and regulations outlined in the key legislation, businesses can protect their interests and work towards a successful resolution of insolvency issues.

As we continue to unravel the intricate landscape of insolvency law in Canada, I will now explore the specific roles of lawyers and accountants in business insolvency, shedding light on their invaluable contributions to navigating insolvency proceedings effectively.a picture of an overwhelmed man to represent the owner of an insolvent company turning into a picture of a calm and happy business owner representing a solvent and profitable company with people walking up a staircase representing company profitability and growth

Role of a Lawyer in Business Insolvency

Lawyers play a critical role in guiding businesses through the challenging landscape of insolvency. There are many complexities and responsibilities involved in representing clients during financial distress. Let’s explore the legal responsibilities and duties, as well as effective strategies for representing clients in insolvency proceedings.

A lawyer’s primary responsibility is to ensure that their clients navigate the legal proceedings smoothly, legally and ethically. Upholding the highest standards of professionalism and compliance with relevant laws is paramount in protecting the interests of all involved parties. From providing sound legal advice to negotiating on behalf of clients, every action must align with the legal framework outlined in insolvency law.

In insolvency proceedings, it’s essential to draft and review legal documents meticulously, such as restructuring plans and agreements, to safeguard the rights of creditors, shareholders, and employees. Transparency and adherence to the law are non-negotiable aspects that guide a lawyer’s responsibilities in representing clients effectively.

Strategies for Representing Clients

When representing clients in business insolvency cases, adopting a strategic approach is key to achieving successful outcomes. Clear communication with clients to understand their objectives and concerns forms the foundation of developing a tailored strategy. By conducting in-depth research, analyzing financial documents, and collaborating with other professionals like accountants and insolvency practitioners, lawyers can offer comprehensive legal services.

Each client’s situation is unique, requiring a personalized strategy that addresses their specific needs and goals. Through a combination of legal expertise, practical considerations, and proactive communication, lawyers strive to navigate the complexities of insolvency proceedings effectively. By working collaboratively with clients and other professionals, especially the insolvency professionals, they can secure the best possible resolutions for their clients’ insolvency challenges.

Role of an Accountant in Business Insolvency

Accountants also play a critical role in the realm of business insolvency. The CPA understands the importance of financial analysis and compliance with accounting standards in navigating through the complexities of insolvency. Let’s explore how accountants play a pivotal role in helping businesses facing financial distress.

Financial Analysis and Reporting

Financial analysis and reporting are fundamental aspects of dealing with business insolvency. The accountant’s role involves carefully assessing the financial health of a company experiencing insolvency issues. By analyzing crucial financial statements, cash flow projections, and other relevant data, CPAs can provide insights that help the business understand its current financial situation.

Through their expertise in financial analysis, CPAs identify key areas of concern and create accurate reports that are essential for stakeholders, including creditors, shareholders, and employees, to make informed decisions. Effective financial analysis enables businesses to develop strategies for managing financial distress, paving the way for a smoother resolution of insolvency issues.

Compliance with Accounting Standards

Compliance with accounting standards is a cornerstone for businesses navigating insolvency in Canada. The CPA will ensure that the financial statements are prepared in adherence to the relevant accounting principles and regulations. This commitment to compliance promotes transparency and upholds the integrity of financial reporting.

By maintaining strict compliance with accounting standards, businesses demonstrate their dedication to ethical practices and financial accuracy. This, in turn, fosters trust among creditors, shareholders, and other stakeholders during times of financial distress. Upholding accounting standards is crucial for businesses to mitigate legal and financial risks, emphasizing the need for meticulous attention to regulatory requirements.

CPAs recognize the significance of financial analysis and compliance with accounting standards in guiding businesses through the insolvency process. By providing invaluable financial expertise ensuring adherence to regulatory guidelines, and working with other professionals, especially the insolvency professionals, the external CPA supports businesses in making well-informed decisions and navigating the complexities of business insolvency successfully.

This is how both non-insolvency lawyers and accountants can still play a meaningful role in business insolvency, especially in a business restructuring process. A successful outcome of the business restructuring is the best way for the existing lawyer and accountant to maintain both the client but also a close meaningful business relationship for the long term.a picture of an overwhelmed man to represent the owner of an insolvent company turning into a picture of a calm and happy business owner representing a solvent and profitable company with people walking up a staircase representing company profitability and growth

Impact of Business Insolvency

Job Losses and Unemployment

The impact of Canadian business insolvency on job losses and unemployment can be significant. When a business becomes insolvent, it may be forced to lay off employees or shut down entirely, leading to job losses. This can result in a higher unemployment rate as workers find themselves without a job and struggle to secure new employment.

The COVID-19 pandemic has exacerbated these challenges, with many entrepreneurial businesses in Canada continuing to face financial difficulties and the continued risk of closure. Such businesses are still struggling to return to normal revenues, carry unpaid debt taken on during the pandemic, and face rising costs and a shortage of labour.

Targeted measures and support for small businesses are crucial to prevent closures and job losses. By assisting, such as financial aid, access to resources, and support for restructuring, the impact of business insolvency on job losses and unemployment can be mitigated. Additionally, policies like the recent amendments to prioritize creditor claims related to defined-benefit pension plans can help protect employees’ financial security in the event of insolvency.

Effects on Suppliers and Creditors

The effects of Canadian business insolvency on suppliers and creditors can be significant. When a business becomes insolvent, suppliers may face challenges in receiving payment for goods or services provided to the business. This can result in financial difficulties for the suppliers themselves, especially if they rely heavily on the insolvent business as a major customer.

Creditors, including financial institutions and other lenders, may also experience losses when a business files for bankruptcy or proposes a restructuring plan. In most cases, creditors will not receive the full amount owed to them, or they may have to wait a significant amount of time to receive any repayment.

Overall, Canadian business insolvency can have a ripple effect on suppliers and creditors, leading to financial challenges and losses for those involved in the business’s operations. Suppliers and creditors need to assess their credit risks before extending credit and take appropriate measures to protect their interests in the event of a business insolvency.

Potential Closure or Sale of the Business

In Canadian business insolvency, the potential closure or sale of the business can have significant implications for the business owner, employees, creditors, and the economy as a whole. If an entrepreneurial business is unable to meet its financial obligations and is forced to close its doors, it can result in job losses, financial losses for creditors, and a decrease in economic activity in the local community.

For the business owner, the closure or sale of the business can mean the end of their entrepreneurial venture, financial loss, and potential personal liability for both Director liabilities as well as any corporate debt personally guaranteed by the entrepreneur. Such liabilities can have a significant impact on their financial well-being and prospects.

For employees, the closure of a business can result in job loss, uncertainty, and financial hardship. They may struggle to find new employment, especially if the closure is due to broader economic challenges in the industry or region.

For creditors, the closure of a business can mean they probably will not recover the full amount owed to them. They may have to write off the debt as a loss, which can impact their financial stability and ability to extend credit to other businesses.

In terms of the economy, the closure or sale of a business can contribute to a decrease in economic activity, reduced consumer confidence, and a negative impact on the overall business environment. It can also lead to a loss of tax revenue for the government, further impacting public services and infrastructure.

Overall, the potential closure or sale of a business in a Canadian business insolvency is a complex and challenging situation that requires careful consideration of the implications for all stakeholders involved. It underscores the importance of effective financial management, planning, and risk mitigation strategies for entrepreneurial businesses to avoid insolvency and closure in the first place.

Reputation Damage

Reputation damage arising from a Canadian business insolvency can have long-lasting effects on a company. When a business becomes insolvent, it is unable to fulfill its financial obligations, leading to creditors and suppliers losing trust in the company. This can result in difficulty in securing credit, partnerships, and contracts in the future.

Moreover, news of a business insolvency can spread quickly, damaging the company’s reputation among customers and stakeholders. Customers may lose faith in the company’s ability to deliver products or services, leading to a loss of business and revenue. Employees may also become concerned about job security and employee wages. Morale suffers and the most qualified employees can find new jobs quickly. All of this leads to morale suffering which makes the business insolvency closer to a self-fulfilling prophecy.

Reputation damage from a business insolvency can be difficult to overcome. Rebuilding trust with creditors, suppliers, customers, and employees may take time and effort. Companies trying to implement a restructuring insolvency plan need to implement strong communication strategies to address concerns and demonstrate a commitment to financial stability and responsibility.

Overall, reputation damage arising from Canadian business insolvency can have significant consequences for a company’s long-term success and viability. Businesses need to address insolvency issues promptly and transparently to mitigate potential reputational harm.

Initiating the Insolvency Process

In Canada, the process of initiating insolvency proceedings is a critical step for businesses facing financial distress. There are two kinds of processes; 1. voluntary and 2. involuntary.

The voluntary process normally begins with the insolvent business formally declaring insolvency by filing for bankruptcy protection under either the BIA or CCAA to begin the restructuring process. Alternatively, the insolvent business can file corporate bankruptcy if liquidation is the only answer for a business that is no longer viable.

The involuntary process would normally begin with either a secured creditor privately appointing or making an application to the Court for the appointment of a receiver. Alternatively, one or more unsecured creditors owed in total at least $1,000 can launch a Bankruptcy Application against the insolvent company.

Seeking professional guidance from experts like insolvency lawyers and licensed insolvency trustees is essential to navigate this complex process effectively. Businesses can begin addressing their financial challenges by initiating insolvency proceedings and working toward a resolution.

Managing Stakeholder Relationships

Managing stakeholder relationships is paramount during times of business insolvency in Canada. Creditors, shareholders, and employees all have vested interests in the outcome of insolvency proceedings. Effective communication and transparency are essential to build trust and mitigate potential conflicts. By keeping stakeholders informed, addressing their concerns, and involving them in decision-making processes, businesses can navigate insolvency proceedings with clarity and confidence.

Business insolvency is a complex issue that requires careful navigation. By understanding the implications for all stakeholders and seeking professional advice, businesses can better prepare for financial challenges.a picture of an overwhelmed man to represent the owner of an insolvent company turning into a picture of a calm and happy business owner representing a solvent and profitable company with people walking up a staircase representing company profitability and growth

There are two main avenues for addressing legal issues within insolvency cases: 1. Negotiation and Mediation Techniques, as well as 2. Litigation and Court Proceedings. I will now delve into the strategies and approaches essential for navigating through challenging financial times successfully.

Negotiation and Mediation Techniques

When faced with legal issues within insolvency cases, negotiation and mediation techniques can be powerful tools for finding amicable solutions. Insolvency trustees find that engaging in constructive dialogue with stakeholders can often lead to mutually beneficial outcomes. By exploring innovative and collaborative approaches, businesses can avoid unnecessary conflicts and costly legal battles.

  1. Effective negotiation involves understanding the concerns and needs of all parties involved.
  2. Mediation offers a platform for open communication, ensuring that diverse perspectives are heard and respected.
  3. Skilled mediators facilitate the process, guiding toward agreements that protect the interests of creditors, shareholders, and employees.

By adopting a strategic and empathetic approach to negotiation and mediation, businesses can navigate the complexities of insolvency issues with resilience and integrity. The ability to find common ground and explore creative solutions is essential in any business restructuring.

Litigation and Court Proceedings

While negotiation and mediation are preferred methods for resolving legal issues within the insolvency case, there are instances where litigation and court proceedings become inevitable. This is more so within a liquidating bankruptcy proceedings rather than in a business reorganization. Licensed insolvency trustees understand the importance of legal recourse in protecting the rights and interests of all stakeholders involved.

  1. Litigation provides a formal platform for resolving disputes and making legally binding decisions.
  2. Court proceedings ensure that insolvency matters are adjudicated fairly and by the law.
  3. Legal experts specializing in insolvency law offer invaluable guidance throughout the litigation process.

By preparing meticulously and engaging competent legal representation, businesses can navigate the complexities of court proceedings with confidence. While litigation may signify a more adversarial approach, it can also lead to definitive resolutions that provide clarity and direction in times of financial turmoil.

4 Common Business Insolvency FAQs

  1. What is the difference between company insolvency and personal bankruptcy?

Company insolvency refers to a company that is unable to pay its bills and debts owed, while personal bankruptcy is a legal process for individuals who cannot pay their bills to eliminate debt.

  1. When should a company consider filing for bankruptcy?

A company should consider filing for bankruptcy or bankruptcy protection to restructure when they are facing overwhelming financial difficulties, such as a loss of income, high levels of debt, inadequate cash flow, and reliance on personal credit to meet obligations. This only makes sense if action is taken relatively early in the insolvency when there are still assets that can be used in perhaps a different corporate form to continue to run the viable part of the insolvent business.

  1. How much debt does a business need to owe to file for bankruptcy in Canada?

In Canada, an insolvent person or insolvent business needs to owe $1,000 or more to unsecured creditors to be eligible to file for bankruptcy.

  1. Can sole proprietorships and partnerships file for business bankruptcy?

Yes, sole proprietorships and partnerships can file for business bankruptcy, and they would need to work with a Licensed Insolvency Trustee to do so. In these forms of business, it is the sole proprietor or partners who would be filing bankruptcy. As this would be a consumer insolvency, the bankruptcy rules dealing with the insolvency of individuals would guide this kind of bankruptcy process.

Business Insolvency Conclusion

Navigating business insolvency in Canada is a multifaceted challenge that requires careful consideration and strategic planning. As a licensed insolvency trustee, I have explored the intricacies of insolvency law and its impact on businesses, creditors, shareholders, and employees. Understanding the complexities of insolvency is pivotal for businesses to weather financial storms successfully for a brighter financial future.

The role of corporate lawyers and accountants in helping to guide businesses through insolvency proceedings is an important one. By recognizing the significance of legal responsibilities, financial analysis, and compliance with accounting standards, businesses, with the help of a Licensed Insolvency Trustee and insolvency legal counsel can tackle insolvency issues with confidence and resilience.

I hope you enjoyed this business insolvency Brandon’s Blog. Individuals and business owners must take proactive measures to address financial difficulties, consumer debt and company debt and promptly seek assistance when necessary. It is crucial to recognize that financial stress is a prevalent concern and seeking help is a demonstration of fortitude, rather than vulnerability. Should you encounter challenges in managing your finances and find yourself burdened by stress, do not delay in pursuing aid.

Revenue and cash flow shortages are critical issues facing people, entrepreneurs and their companies and businesses with debt problems that are in financial distress. Are you now worried about just how you or your business are going to survive? Are you worried about what your fiduciary obligations are and not sure if the decisions you are about to make are the correct ones to avoid personal liability? Those concerns and more associated with your company debt are obviously on your mind.

The Ira Smith Team understands these overwhelming debt financial health concerns. More significantly, we know the requirements of the business owner or the individual who has way too much financial debt. You are trying to manage these difficult financial problems and you are understandably anxious. It is not your fault you can’t fix this problem on your own and it does not mean that you are a bad person. The pandemic has thrown everyone a curveball. We have not been trained to deal with this. You have only been taught the old ways. The old ways do not work anymore.

The Ira Smith Team uses innovative and cutting-edge methodologies, to adeptly navigate you through the intricacies of your financial challenges ensuring a resolution to your debt-related predicaments without resorting to the rigours of the bankruptcy process. We can get you debt relief now! We have helped many entrepreneurs and their insolvent companies who thought that consulting with a Trustee and receiver meant their company would go bankrupt.

On the contrary. We helped turn their companies around through financial restructuring. We look at your whole circumstance and design a strategy that is as distinct as you are. We take the load off of your shoulders as part of the debt settlement strategy we will draft just for you.

The Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. team understands that people facing money problems require a lifeline. That is why we can establish a restructuring procedure for you and end the discomfort you feel. Call us now for a no-cost consultation. We will listen to the unique issues facing you and provide you with practical and actionable ideas you can implement right away to end the pain points in your life, to begin your debt-free life, Starting Over, Starting Now.a picture of an overwhelmed man to represent the owner of an insolvent company turning into a picture of a calm and happy business owner representing a solvent and profitable company with people walking up a staircase representing company profitability and growth

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

CORPORATE BANKRUPTCY FAQ: USE OUR HACK TO SOLVE YOUR CHALLENGING INSOLVENT COMPANY ISSUES

Corporate bankruptcy: An overview

Corporate bankruptcy is a legal process by which businesses can reorganize their financial affairs or liquidate their assets. Although bankruptcy can be complicated and stressful, it can provide businesses with a fresh start.

When it does happen, the corporate bankruptcy process can be complicated. Insolvency can take a toll on your company’s employees, customers, and shareholders. A solid understanding of corporate bankruptcy can help you properly restructure and reorganize your company using an insolvency process without killing your business.

Last week, I gave my best FAQ answers to common questions about personal bankruptcy services. A business partnership or sole proprietorship means that the individual(s) operate the business in their personal name. Answers about business bankruptcies for those forms of business would fall under the personal bankruptcy process that was covered in last week’s personal bankruptcy FAQ blog.

When a corporation conducts business, some of the questions, and answers, are different. In this Brandon’s Blog, I answer the most frequently asked questions about corporate bankruptcy.

Can a business declare corporate bankruptcy?

As stated previously, only a corporation can declare corporate bankruptcy. A corporation is its own legal entity. A “person” is eligible for relief under federal bankruptcy law. A “person” is typically defined in the Canadian bankruptcy legislation to include an individual, part of a partnership, a proprietorship, a company, an unincorporated association, a cooperative society, or a cooperative organization.corporate bankruptcy canada

What are the different types of corporate bankruptcy in Canada?

There are 2 different types of bankruptcy that a company can file for under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act Canada (BIA). They are:

  1. Liquidation: This is when the insolvent company is unable to pay its debts and its business is no longer viable. The only real option for it is to sell off its assets to repay its secured creditors and unsecured creditors as best as possible since it files for bankruptcy in the priority outlined in the BIA.
  2. Restructuring: This is when the company is insolvent and is incapable to repay its debts due to its financial difficulties, yet all or a sufficient portion of the company’s business is still viable. So, the company negotiates brand-new terms with creditors to lower its financial obligations and also might have the ability to sell some assets to settle its financial debts. Restructuring is the most well-known alternative to bankruptcy. Restructuring under insolvency legislation is also described in the media as bankruptcy protection.

What factors lead to corporate bankruptcy proceedings?

A company always shows signs of trouble before it needs to file for corporate bankruptcy. Some of the early danger signals are:

  • continued history of losses;
  • dwindling cash position;
  • the departure of key management or employees;
  • difficulty meeting loan or lease obligations;
  • the breaking of loan covenants; and
  • difficulty meeting payroll.

Corporate bankruptcy: What does it mean for a company when it liquidates?

As stated above, when a company liquidates it means that the company is unable to pay its debts and its business is no longer viable. The only real option for it is to sell off its assets to repay secured creditors and unsecured creditors as best as possible through bankruptcy and then shut down.corporate bankruptcy canada

What happens to debt in corporate bankruptcy?

If the purpose of the corporate bankruptcy is to shut down and have liquidation of business assets, then we first need to see what the net proceeds of sale from those assets are. The BIA describes the order in which funds must be distributed by a licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a bankruptcy trustee) in bankruptcy. The order in which the debts must be repaid, in whole or in part, is called the priority.

The priority of the rights of creditors to be repaid in a corporate bankruptcy is:

  1. Trust and deemed trust claimants – These are parties whose property is being held or is deemed to be held in trust for them by the bankrupt corporation. The most common type of deemed trust claim in a corporate bankruptcy is Canada Revenue Agency for unremitted employee source deductions.
  2. Secured creditors – Creditors who hold valid security over the assets of the company get paid next. There could be more than just one secured creditor. Within the secured creditor group, the order of priority is based on the ranking of the security registration dates.
  3. Preferred creditors – These are unsecured creditors who have been given certain priority in a corporate bankruptcy under federal bankruptcy laws. The most common examples in a corporate bankruptcy would be Trustee fees, the Trustee’s lawyer’s fee, the levy payable to the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy Canada on any distribution made by the Trustee to a creditor and certain salary, wages or commissions due to employees.
  4. Ordinary unsecured creditors – This group comes after the preferred creditors. They are all creditors who have supplied goods or services and do not hold any security and do not fit into the definition of a preferred creditor.

The balance of any unpaid debt ends up getting written off on the books of the creditors because there are no assets left in the company to claim against.

How does a company get into corporate bankruptcy and what happens to the company?

The way a company gets into bankruptcy is the exact same way an individual can. For a liquidation, either the company can file a voluntary assignment into bankruptcy. If it is one or more creditors owed at least $1,000 trying to push the company into bankruptcy, then they would file a Bankruptcy Application with the court requesting the court to make a Bankruptcy Order.corporate bankruptcy canada

Why might a company choose to file for corporate bankruptcy protection and restructure under a BIA proposal?

Corporate bankruptcy protection and restructuring under a BIA proposal can provide a company with financial difficulties a much-needed relief and a chance to return to profitability. When a company files for protection, the BIA proposal offers an orderly and reliable process for restructuring, which can be appealing to businesses that have a good chance of a turnaround.

A corporation that has a viable business and can return to profitability after restructuring, with support from creditors, has all the right ingredients for a successful restructuring. This is why a company might choose to file for corporate bankruptcy protection and restructure under a BIA proposal. The company will survive and jobs will be saved.

Who is responsible for developing the reorganization plan for the company?

Reorganization is the restructuring of a business to gain efficiency, improve workflow, and drive profits. Reorganization plans vary in length and detail and take a certain period of time to properly develop. They generally describe desired outcomes and final goals. Sometimes a company will undergo a complete reorganization, while other plans focus on aspects that require reorganization, such as a business unit or department.

The reorganization plan of a company is essential to ensure its smooth transition. The reorganization plan involves restructuring various departments of the business, reducing operational costs, and streamlining the workflow. Writing a reorganization plan requires a lot of time, effort, and money.

When a business downsizes, it reduces its workforce to a smaller number. Such a reduction can be a painful process that even threatens to collapse the business. The company needs to have a plan in place to accomplish this reorganization while still running the business. When downsizing occurs, businesses require reorganization plans. Involving and informing employees of the process makes them more likely to follow new plans and less resistant to change.

All of the various individual department organization plans and product sales plans need to be combined into an overall business plan. This overall business plan must also include financial information to show how the company, emerging from restructuring, will operate profitably.

Now that the overall plan is set, senior management must work with its outside financial and legal restructuring professionals to establish the restructuring commercial proposal or plan of arrangement to be presented to the creditors to be voted upon. An excellent communication program must be put into place so that creditors can understand the benefits to them of supporting and voting in favour of the restructuring proposal. Normally negotiations with certain creditors or creditor groups must take place in order to come up with a final and successful restructuring plan that will gain both creditor support and pass through the legal proceedings of court approval.corporate bankruptcy canada

What becomes of a corporation after corporate bankruptcy?

Going through corporate bankruptcy means your company’s assets have been sold to pay off some portion of its debts. Bankruptcy also by operation of law terminates all of the employees. So the corporation is left with no assets and no employees. All it has is debt and a deficit equal to the total debt less the amount that is shown on the balance sheet for the company’s preferred and common stock.

Therefore, the corporation, as a legal entity, is then left to just float away into the stratosphere. There are only 2 ways that a company can survive a corporate bankruptcy:

  • from the sale of the corporate assets, pay off 100% of all of its business debt plus interest; or
  • file a BIA proposal, obtain creditor support and court approval and successfully complete it.

The first way will almost never happen. The second way can happen if there is a good reason to try to make sure that the corporation as a legal entity survives. A reason for doing this might be that there is value to the shares. After becoming bankrupt, a successfully completed proposal annuls the bankruptcy. By definition, the proposal will discharge all of the company’s outstanding debt. The company is now debt-free.

The common stock may have value because it is a public company and the shares can be relisted on the stock exchange. Now the corporate shell is attractive to a private company that wishes to go public and can do so by amalgamating with this public shell. Alternatively in a private company, or in a public company, there may be significant tax loss carryforwards available for use if this corporate shell is merged with the right kind of profitable company. the only way to use the tax losses is first by owning all the shares.

This is all possible, but, the normal outcome for a company that has gone through a corporate bankruptcy is just to fade away, never to be heard from again.

When a company declares corporate bankruptcy, what will happen to your stock or bond?

When you invest money in a company by investing your capital, your money is legally represented by the stock or bonds that you purchased. When you see a company declaring bankruptcy, it means the company can no longer afford to pay its debts.

If a company just liquidates its assets during corporate bankruptcy, the existing shares will likely be worth very little or nothing at all. For a private company, a successful corporate restructuring might increase the value of the shares as the company will emerge from its restructuring with much less debt than before.

The value of a company’s shares is most likely to lower if it effectively restructures its financial affairs. It might have to issue brand-new stock to creditors that will not be paid back in full, watering down the value of the business’s shares.

As far as corporate bonds are they secured or unsecured against the company’s assets? If secured, they could be repaid in whole or in part depending on where they stand in the secured assets pecking order. If unsecured, then it just becomes part of the larger unsecured creditor pool. In a corporate bankruptcy that is a liquidation, those bondholders will receive their share of any distribution made by the Trustee to the ordinary unsecured creditors if there is such a distribution made.

Corporate bankruptcy and insolvency at a glance

In conclusion, bankruptcy and insolvency of course go together, although many people prefer to think of bankruptcy as an economic failure while insolvency is more accurately a sign of a business’s financial failings.

In the same way I hoped last week’s personal bankruptcy blog helped your understanding, I hope this Brandon’s Blog on corporate bankruptcy was helpful to you in understanding more about the corporate bankruptcy system in Canada.

If you or your company has too heavy a debt load, we understand how you feel. You’re stressed out and anxious because you can’t fix your or your company’s financial situation on your own. But don’t worry. As a government-licensed insolvency professional firm, we can help you get your personal or corporate finances back on track.

If you’re struggling with money problems, call the Ira Smith Team today. We’ll work with you to develop a personalized plan to get you back on track and stress-free, all while avoiding the bankruptcy process if at all possible.

Call us today and get back on the path to a healthy stress-free life.

CLICK HERE TO GET THE FREE HOW TO CLOSE YOUR BUSINESS WITHOUT BANKRUPTCY OFFER
corporate bankruptcy canada

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

DECLARING BANKRUPTCY: REAL ESTATE COMPANY LOSES CHALLENGE ON CORPORATE BANKRUPTCY APPEAL

Declaring bankruptcy: Business insolvency

When the corporate finances are such that the business has an insufficient cash flow to cover its operating expenses and pay its debts when they come due, these financial difficulties create the financial condition of insolvency for the business. Another indicator of insolvency often exists at the same time: if you were to sell all of the company’s assets, you would not be able to raise enough money to pay off its outstanding debt.

Medcap Real Estate Holdings Inc. (Medcap) is an Ontario corporation that owns certain commercial real estate. Medcap’s principal, through other companies which he owns or controls, operates various fitness facilities.

Several creditors made a bankruptcy application to the Court to wind up Medcap’s business through a corporate bankruptcy. In December 2021, the Judge released his decision to issue a bankruptcy order and place the company in the legal position of bankruptcy. Medcap appealed the decision to the Court of Appeal for Ontario.

In this Brandon’s Blog, I discuss the two ways there are for declaring bankruptcy and highlight the reasoning of the Court of Appeal for Ontario in dismissing this company’s appeal for its corporate bankruptcy.

Declaring bankruptcy: An overview of corporate bankruptcy

In Canada, a company is a separate legal entity from its shareholders or Directors and Officers. So a company can go into corporate bankruptcy, as opposed to a person entering personal bankruptcy, also known as consumer bankruptcy. There are two ways a company (or a person) can go bankrupt.

The first way is that a company (or person) files for bankruptcy by filing an assignment in bankruptcy with a licensed insolvency trustee. This is called a voluntary assignment into bankruptcy. The second way, which is what happened to Medcap, is that they are pushed into bankruptcy.

To push a limited company (person) into bankruptcy, one or more creditors, each owed at least $1,000, make a bankruptcy application to the court. The application will include a sworn affidavit from the people with knowledge of the situation providing evidence as to why the company (the person) is insolvent, what acts of bankruptcy the business (person) committed within 6 months preceding the date of the application and requesting that a bankruptcy order be made against the debtor.

Regardless of the types of bankruptcy proceedings that may be involved, these are the only two ways for companies with crippling debt to become bankrupt. It is either voluntary or an involuntary one.

declaring bankruptcy
declaring bankruptcy

Declaring bankruptcy: Types of Corporate Bankruptcy

A company that ends up declaring bankruptcy may be doing so for a variety of reasons, all of which relate to significant financial losses. In Canada, there are two primary types of bankruptcy filings under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA).

Once the company is insolvent and no longer viable, declaring bankruptcy in order to have liquidation of assets and end the business in that legal entity is the next step. In this situation, there may be certain business debts that are also a personal liability of the corporate Directors. Unremitted source deductions and HST and unpaid wages and vacation pay fall into this category.

Bankruptcy is a tricky topic. Many people tend to fear it, thinking of it as the end of the road. Given my description above of bankruptcy being for liquidating the company assets, that is understandable.

But what about the company that is insolvent but the business is very viable if the bad parts are cut out? In this kind of situation, filing under the BIA using the restructuring provisions of this federal statute, or for larger companies, the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA), is a legal way for the company to restructure its debts to get its finances back in order. In a successful restructuring, the good parts of the business are restructured and preserved, the company’s finances are right-sized and most if not all jobs are saved. This form of declaring bankruptcy is what is referred to in the media as bankruptcy protection.

So in Canada, declaring bankruptcy is one type, but declaring bankruptcy protection is also possible. That is why I suggest in Canada, there are 2 types of business-specific options in corporate bankruptcy filings.

Declaring bankruptcy: Does corporate bankruptcy affect personal assets?

The legal separation of personal and corporate assets is clear. However, a company declaring bankruptcy may have an impact on the personal assets of certain people. There are situations where personal assets may be at risk. If you are concerned about your personal assets, you should consult with a legal professional to assess your individual case.

Before making any business or investment decisions, is when you should get that professional advice. Once a corporate bankruptcy filing has been made, it will be too late to properly plan for that situation. Personal assets could be at risk if it is a bankruptcy liquidation and not a successful restructuring.

Examples of when personal assets may be at risk because of business bankruptcies include:

  • the entrepreneur who had to give a personal guarantee of certain corporate debt financial obligations to the company’s primary secured creditor lender and in a liquidation of the company’s assets, the lender suffers a shortfall;
  • there is not enough money left over from the liquidation after any trust claims and secured creditor claims to pay the outstanding wages and vacation pay so the Directors’ personal assets may be at risk;
  • the liquidation value of the assets is essentially zero so the Directors are called upon by Canada Revenue Agency to repay any unremitted employee source deductions or HST amounts;
  • in bankruptcy liquidation, there is generally nothing available to repay investors or shareholders so the money an individual investor or shareholder loses certainly affects their personal assets and personal property. The stock of companies that liquidated their assets after declaring bankruptcy is worthless; and
  • any creditors that are unincorporated, being either a proprietorship or partnership who lose some or all of the amounts owed to them as ordinary unsecured creditors clearly affect the personal assets of those business owners.

Declaring bankruptcy: The Medcap case

With this discussion of corporations declaring bankruptcy, there are some interesting points to be learned from the Medcap appeal case and the bankruptcy process. The application judge dismissed the bankruptcy applications of all but one of the applicants. He issued the bankruptcy order and appointed the licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a trustee in bankruptcy or bankruptcy trustee) which began Medcap’s administration of bankruptcy.

The Medcap company appealed the bankruptcy order on only one ground; the judge who made the original order failed to exercise his discretion on whether or not to dismiss the application. Medcap did not appeal the application judge’s finding that the prerequisites to the making of a bankruptcy order – a debt owing to an applicant of at least $1,000 and the commission of an act of bankruptcy within six months of the commencement of the application – had been met!

The most interesting part of the Court of Appeal’s decision is the discussion of the two factors that a court could look at where a judge could exercise discretion to justify refusing an otherwise proven bankruptcy application.

declaring bankruptcy
declaring bankruptcy

Declaring bankruptcy: Appealing a bankruptcy order

As mentioned previously, Medcap did not contest the judge’s conclusion that the creditor whose bankruptcy application was allowed had met the requirements under s. 43(1) of the BIA. This is that Medcap owed them a debt exceeding $1,000 and that Medcap committed an act of bankruptcy within 6 months before the filing of that bankruptcy application.

The application judge found that Medcap had failed to pay that creditor’s debt, for which a judgment was issued, despite demands. This is defined as an act of bankruptcy in s. 42(1)(j) of the BIA. In its appeal, the Medcap company argued that, even though the debt and the act of bankruptcy were proven, the application judge made a mistake by not using his discretionary power under s. 43(7) of the BIA to dismiss the application.

Medcap made three arguments to support its appeal: (i) that the trial judge erred in finding that Medcap was unable to pay its debts; (ii) that he erred in finding that the application was brought for an improper motive; and (iii) that he erred in finding that the bankruptcy order would serve no purpose.

Let’s see what the Court of Appeal for Ontario said about this.

Declaring bankruptcy: Unable to pay its debts

This is the first of the three bankruptcy issues that the Court of Appeal looked at. Medcap argued that the application judge dismissed the applications of all applicants but one because there was potential that they were not creditors. Medcap also stated that the application judge had not taken into account that Medcap had reached a settlement with the one creditor whose application was allowed to be heard. Medcap submitted that the application judge erred in not taking this into account as there was no debt owing because of the settlement and the payment of that settlement.

The appellate court found that the lower court judge did not err in rejecting Medcap’s argument. An application for bankruptcy is not solely for the benefit of the applicant creditor, but for the rights of creditors, ALL creditors. Further, the arrangements between the applicant creditor and the debtor will not be able to justify the withdrawal or dismissal of a bankruptcy application, unless the court is satisfied that the debtor is solvent and that other creditors will not be prejudiced by the withdrawal or dismissal.

To be able to pay debts as set out in the BIA, the evidence must be provided for all debts owed, as well as the debtor’s ability to pay them. In other words, the debtor must prove that they are solvent. Medcap did not provide such evidence. Therefore this ground of appeal was dismissed.

Declaring bankruptcy: Bankruptcy application for improper motives

Medcap argued that in cases where a creditor has an ulterior motive for filing a bankruptcy application, this can be sufficient cause for dismissal of the application. The Court of Appeal said that the existence of a motive is a question of fact, and the application judge considered and rejected the suggestion that there was such a motive in this case.

The Court of Appeal found that the application judge was within his rights to reject the argument based on the record. Therefore, the Court of Appeal for Ontario found no justification to interfere and dismissed the appeal on that ground.declaring bankruptcy

Declaring bankruptcy: There is no purpose for this bankruptcy

Medcap argued that the application judge erred in failing to find that no purpose would be served by bankruptcy. He ought to have dismissed the application on the basis that there was nothing to be gained by making a bankruptcy order.

The Court of Appeal emphasized that safeguarding creditors is crucial to insolvency proceedings. A debtor who has (a) committed an act of bankruptcy by not paying debts when they come due, and (b) failed to provide evidence to the court demonstrating the ability to do so, carries the burden of proving that bankruptcy would be pointless. The judge was correct in finding that Medcap had not met that burden.

The three-panel judge went on to say that, in order to demonstrate that there is no purpose for the Medcap bankruptcy, they would need to show that a better result would be achieved for creditors if it were allowed time to restructure under the commercial proposal provisions of the BIA or the provisions of the CCAA.

Medcap did not argue that doing either would have the requisite creditor support but rather suggested that leaving it up to them would be best.

The three appellate court judges hearing this case unanimously rejected Medcap’s appeal, upholding the lower court’s ruling and allowing the bankruptcy process legal proceedings to continue. At this point, the licensed trustee named in the bankruptcy order begins administering the bankruptcy legal process.

Declaring bankruptcy: The final word

What fascinated me most about this case was the nerve of Medcap to argue that the application judge should have declined to make the bankruptcy order, regardless of all the evidence against it.

The Court of Appeal for Ontario soundly rejected the appeal of the bankruptcy order being issued after analyzing the bankruptcy application process in Canada. It concluded that only a real possibility of a successful restructuring under either the BIA or CCAA to avoid bankruptcy liquidation would be a reason to do so.

I hope this Brandon’s Blog on the Medcap case was helpful to you in understanding more about declaring bankruptcy, corporate bankruptcy and how the Ontario court would decide if it was appropriate to issue a bankruptcy order. Hopefully, you have also gained insight into how a corporate bankruptcy decision is made and how a successful corporate bankruptcy protection filing and restructuring can be beneficial.

We understand how you feel. You’re stressed out and anxious because you can’t fix your or your company’s financial situation on your own. But don’t worry. As a government-licensed insolvency professional firm, we can help you get your personal or corporate finances back on track.

If you’re struggling with money problems, call the Ira Smith Team today. We’ll work with you to develop a personalized plan to get you back on track and stress-free, all while avoiding the bankruptcy process if at all possible.

Call us today and get back on the path to a healthy stress-free life.

declaring bankruptcy
declaring bankruptcy
Categories
Brandon Blog Post

SMALL BUSINESS IN CANADA: MUST A STAGGERING 200,000 CANADIAN SMALL BUSINESSES DECLARE BANKRUPTCY DUE TO THE PANDEMIC?

We hope that you and your family are safe, healthy and secure during this coronavirus pandemic.

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

If you would prefer to listen to the audio version of the small business in Canada Brandon Blog, please scroll to the very bottom of the page and click play on the podcast.

small business in canada
small business in canada

Small business in Canada introduction

The Canadian Federation of Independent Business (CFIB) is the country’s champ of small business in Canada. CFIB is Canada’s biggest non-profit organization devoted to producing and sustaining an atmosphere where your small business in Canada can succeed.

CFIB promotes small business in Canada issues with political leaders as well as decision-makers. As a non-partisan company, it influences public policy based upon its members’ views. It tries to ensure that small business owners have an opportunity to impact the regulations and policies that impact Canadian business.

A member survey was performed by CFIB and the results were announced on Thursday, January 21, 2021. The results suggest that greater than 200,000 organizations could shut permanently because of and during the pandemic.

The federation states that it could throw greater than 2.4 million people out of work. The study suggests 1 in 6, or about 181,000 small companies, are currently seriously considering closing down. That’s up from 1 in seven or around 158,000 last summer.

The CFIB is contacting provincial and federal governments to try to help small businesses by presenting secure pathways to re-open and end lockdowns that may kill off these businesses.

The question I wish to explore with you today is if a small business in Canada needs to shut down, does it have to become one of the statistics of Canadian business bankruptcies? Must it file for corporate bankruptcy? For this small business in Canada Brandon Blog, I will assume that the small business is a corporation.

Small business in Canada: When is a corporation bankrupt, or insolvent?

As I have discussed with you in previous blogs, a company is insolvent under the BIA if:

  • it is not able to satisfy its debts as they generally come to be due; or
  • it has ceased paying current debts in the normal course of business as they end up being due; or
  • the company’s property is not enough, at a fair valuation, to permit settlement of all debts (significance that even if all the property was to be sold, the proceeds would not provide sufficient cash to pay all financial obligations which are owed, or will certainly soon end up being due).

A company is bankrupt under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA) if it has made an assignment in bankruptcy, or if a bankruptcy order has actually been made against it. Bankruptcy is a legal process to eliminate debts if the small business in Canada is unable to pay them.

To be bankrupt, in the case of an assignment, the company, and in the case of a court order, the applicant creditor would have engaged the services of a licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a bankruptcy trustee or a trustee in bankruptcy). Licensed insolvency trustees are the only professionals allowed to administer bankruptcies in Canada and are licensed and supervised by the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy (OSB).

Every corporate bankruptcy is what is called an “ordinary administration“. Unlike in personal bankruptcy, there is no streamlined method for corporate bankruptcy. Remember this point as it serves as the basis for answering the question “Must a small business in Canada declare bankruptcy in order to close down due to the pandemic“?

Small business in Canada: Is small business bankruptcy the right choice?

One of the most difficult decisions that an entrepreneur owner of a small business in Canada ever needs to make is whether or not to put his/her business into bankruptcy. Obviously, every entrepreneur goes into business hoping for success, so thinking about bankruptcy isn’t just an economic decision; it is a psychological emotional one too. It’s very crucial to understand the truths regarding local business bankruptcy and also the various other options that may be available to you before you make that decision. This will aid you to avoid making a rash choice that could be the wrong one.

The reality is that, for many companies, there are choices besides small business in Canada bankruptcy. One possible choice is a proposal to creditors. In a proposal, you make a deal to your unsecured creditors to pay off a percentage of what is owed to them and/or stretch out (commonly lower) monthly payments over a longer amount of time. This ensures that creditors receive either some or all of what is owed to them in a way the company can afford. This enables small business in Canada to avoid bankruptcy and remain in operation.

The whole concept of a proposal is that you have a corporate entity that is insolvent, but, the underlying business is viable. If you can cut away the layers of debt, the business could continue to operate and employ people. You may even need to transition the business assets to a new corporation. All of this is possible under a Division I Proposal under the BIA. A proposal under the BIA is the same as the term you hear in the news all the time – bankruptcy protection. The company ultimately comes up with a plan of reorganization to tell its unsecured creditors what the company can do for them because it does not have the necessary money to pay them 100%.

If the business is not that complex and there are only a few creditors, possibly an informal proposal would work. The entrepreneur would discuss his company’s problems with each creditor and make an offer to them that is both appropriate and something the company can pay. If successful, the company can avoid formal restructuring proceedings. If there are too many creditors to do it on an informal basis, or if the restructuring is too complex, the small business can restructure under the BIA.

A proposal can be an excellent option for a small business that has actually encountered recent economic issues while having had success in the past. It can also be useful for a small company that was profitable but is now having a hard time due to the fact that past issues are weighing it down. A proposal is one of the alternatives to bankruptcy that I implement to save a company by allowing it to develop its plan of reorganization to emerge healthy to stay in business and to save jobs.

However, for some organizations, filing for small company bankruptcy is the choice that makes the most sense. A Trustee can help you recognize the alternatives available to ensure that you can decide if a bankruptcy filing is a proper alternative for your small business.

small business in canada
small business in canada

Small business in Canada: Is just closing the door an alternative?

Over the years we have consulted with many entrepreneurs about their small businesses in Toronto or other small business Ontario locations. Many times we end up advising them that it does not make sense to spend the money on any of the various types of bankruptcy proceedings. The size of the company and the nature of its assets makes either a proposal in bankruptcy or any bankruptcy process unnecessary. None of the forms of bankruptcy make sense. Let me explain.

Most small business opportunities in Canada started by entrepreneurs are funded using a variety of methods including:

  • investment by the owners;
  • small business start up grants Canada; and
  • small business loans.

More recently, the small business loan covid 19 Canada ($40000 Canada Emergency Business Account (CEBA) loan which has now been increased to $60,000) has also been used. The combination of owners taking stock in exchange for cash, loaning money to the small business and having a small business bank loan, perhaps even the official government-guaranteed Canada small business loan is pretty standard.

The bank will take security over all of the assets of the small business in Canada. By the time the business needs to shut down, there are not many assets left. Whatever assets there are, they are all fully secured by the bank. If the business is no longer viable, then although it is insolvent, it cannot be restructured as the business itself does not work anymore. If the assets are all fully encumbered, then there is no restructuring that can take place.

So a Division I Proposal under the BIA is not possible. Bankruptcy is a remedy for the unsecured creditors. If there are not many assets left, and what is left is fully secured by the bank, then the bank will suffer a shortfall and there are no assets available for the Trustee to use to make a distribution to the unsecured creditors. So why have any type of bankruptcy or any bankruptcy proceeding? It does not make sense to spend that money.

In this situation, it just makes sense to tell the bank that the business is shutting down, turn the key in the lock to the front door and give the key to the bank.

Small business in Canada: So what happens if I just close the door and lock it?

I call this the self-help remedy. There are too many problems with the business that it is not viable anymore. Perhaps the COVID-19 lockdown is just too tough to recover from and the small business cannot survive. Perhaps the assets are not worth much – think restaurant equipment where the cost of the leasehold improvements may be as much as the cost of the equipment. Because of this, the only choice is to walk away.

As a director of the company, you have a responsibility to make sure that all final government returns are completed and filed. If the company’s books and records are stored on-site. Perhaps the accounting information is stored on a computer hard drive. The directors should make sure that the books and records, be they electronic or physical, are safeguarded by taking them off the business premises.

You may need them not only to prepare final returns but also in case Canada Revenue Agency or any other regulatory authority has any questions or wishes to perform an audit. The directors will also want to make sure that all final employee records are completed and distributed to the former employees.

Next comes the bank. In Canada, the bank loan would have been either fully or partially guaranteed by the entrepreneur. The entrepreneur may have also personally guaranteed the premises lease of the business. The entrepreneur may also have personal liability for director obligations such as unremitted source deductions, unpaid HST and outstanding employee wages and vacation pay.

If the individual does not have sufficient personal assets or other resources to make good on their personal guarantee, then rather than focussing on bankruptcy for the business notwithstanding all the business debts, we need to focus on the person’s situation. Perhaps they will need to look at the various bankruptcy options, be it a consumer proposal, Division I Proposal or as a last resort, bankruptcy.

It will be much more productive for the entrepreneur to retain me to help them with their personal financial problems arising out of the closure of the small business in Canada rather than on the business itself that has little in the way of assets and no viable business left to salvage.

Must 200,000 Canadian small businesses declare bankruptcy due to the pandemic?

So given the above, the answer to the question is no. If the small business in Canada is viable, then perhaps it can be restructured to avoid bankruptcy, maintain operations and save jobs. If it is not viable, then, bankruptcy may be necessary depending on the complexity of the business and the issues facing it.

If it is not complex and there are no free assets, then just closing the doors of that small business in Canada is all that needs to happen. The individual will then have to deal with their personal liabilities arising from that.

Small business in Canada summary

I hope you enjoyed this small business in Canada Brandon Blog post. If you are concerned because you or your business are dealing with substantial debt challenges and you assume bankruptcy is your only option, call me. It is not your fault that you remain in this way. You have actually been only shown the old ways to try to deal with financial issues. These old ways do not work anymore.

The Ira Smith Team utilizes new modern-day ways to get you out of your debt difficulties while avoiding bankruptcy. We can get you the relief you need and so deserve.

The tension put upon you is big. We know your discomfort factors. We will check out your entire situation and design a new approach that is as unique as you and your problems; financial and emotional. We will take the weight off of your shoulders and blow away the dark cloud hanging over you. We will design a debt settlement strategy for you. We know that we can help you now.

We understand that people and businesses facing financial issues need a realistic lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” method with the Ira Smith Team. Not everyone has to file bankruptcy in Canada. The majority of our clients never do. We help many people and companies stay clear of bankruptcy.

That is why we can establish a new restructuring procedure for paying down debt that will be built just for you. It will be as one-of-a-kind as the economic issues and discomfort you are encountering. If any one of this seems familiar to you and you are serious about getting the solution you need, Contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. group today.

Call us now for a no-cost consultation.

We will get you or your business back up driving to healthy and balanced trouble-free operations and get rid of the discomfort factors in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

We hope that you and your family are safe, healthy and secure during this coronavirus pandemic.

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

BANKRUPTCY FRAUD: QUICK GUIDE TO BANKRUPTCY FRAUD AND BANKRUPTCY EXAMINATIONS

We hope that you and your family are safe, healthy and secure during this coronavirus pandemic.

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

If you would prefer to listen to the audio version of this bankruptcy fraud Brandon Blog, please scroll to the very bottom and click play on the podcast.

bankruptcy fraud
bankruptcy fraud

Bankruptcy fraud introduction

Bankruptcy fraud is not something that the vast majority of individual Canadians engage in. Personal insolvency case filers can be for either a consumer proposal, Division I proposal or consumer bankruptcy filings under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA) so that individuals can get the debt relief they need. Entrepreneurs can file a Division I proposal, or for corporate bankruptcy for when their company needs to either restructure or liquidate under the BIA. They can also file a Plan of Arrangement under the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act if their company qualifies under Canada’s insolvency laws.

Most of these individuals are honest and would never even think about bankruptcy fraud. They or their company have actually experienced such substantial financial difficulties leading to their insolvent financial condition, that the only thing they can do to solve the financial problems is to get relief within the Canadian insolvency system. Their problems may result from a job loss, a change in their household situation like divorce, a major disease resulting in loss of income and/or medical bills they cannot pay, bad financial advice, or most recently, the bottom falling out of their lives because of the COVID-19 pandemic.

There are instances, however, where an individual is not a victim and perhaps they are trying to pull off a bankrupt fraud crime. They will use misconduct to create abuse of the system and continue to trade and get credit understanding that they will never be able to pay back the money they are borrowing. There are people who try to use the insolvency system in Canada to get out of problems that they have created themselves through bad faith or fraud. They may even unknowingly cross the line into a white-collar financial crime and bankruptcy fraud.

In this Brandon Blog, I first discuss what bankruptcy fraud is and then comment on a very recent decision of the Supreme Court of British Columbia in Bankruptcy and Insolvency on what level of suspicion is necessary in order for the court to order an examination of the bankrupt or by extension, the designated officer of the bankrupt company.

What is bankruptcy fraud?

When I talk about bankruptcy fraud, it could include criminal fraud under the Criminal Code of Canada, but not necessarily. Bankruptcy fraud is a white-collar criminal activity that can be in several different forms.

The more common fraudulent activity that either is or are indicators of bankruptcy fraud committed under Canadian bankruptcy law (which may be just a bankruptcy offence or can also be a criminal code crime, depending on the circumstances) are:

  • Disposing of or concealing assets prior to or right after the bankruptcy to avoid having to hand them over to the licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a bankruptcy trustee or a trustee in bankruptcy).
  • Records false transactions in a statement of account or hides, destroy or purposely misstates a schedule or other document pertaining to his/her/its assets or affairs.
  • Obtains credit or any other goods or services arising from false depictions;
  • Conceals claims or debt obligations against the debtor;
  • Obtains credit without advising the people he is dealing with that he/she is bankrupt;
  • Refuses to answer fully and honestly to questions posed in an examination taking place under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA).

Anyone who is found guilty of an offence, whether from criminal fraud charges or not and is responsible, on a summary conviction basis, to a dollar fine not exceeding $5,000 or to jail time for a term not going beyond one year or to both, or on conviction on indictment, to a penalty not surpassing $10,000 or to jail time for a term not going beyond three years, or to both. So there are penalties from a bankruptcy offence finding and a bankruptcy fraud conviction.

What are bankruptcy offences and how are they and bankruptcy fraud discovered?

The bankruptcy offences are set out in sections 198-201 of the BIA, Canada’s bankruptcy law. They represent the kinds of activities that form the types of bankruptcy fraud outlined above. There are 3 normal ways that a Trustee can start identifying bankruptcy offences and bankruptcy fraud.

When a consumer proposal, larger corporate or personal restructuring proposal or a bankruptcy is filed, the licensed insolvency trustee is required to review the available books and records. Insolvency trustees must look for transactions that appear questionable.

Insolvency trustees prepare a report for the creditors in which the conduct of the insolvent debtor, including any issues like suspicious transactions, entered into, or suspected bankruptcy fraud, are reported. In a restructuring, the bankruptcy trustee must also advise what effect the transaction has on the creditors and what actions, if any, the licensed insolvency trustee is going to take. That is the first way that bankruptcy fraud and bankruptcy offences can be discovered.

The second way that bankruptcy offences and bankruptcy fraud can be discovered is from information available from creditors. The creditors have been dealing for some time with the individual or company filing for bankruptcy or the restructuring proposal. Creditors may very well have information about the debtor’s affairs that would be very useful. That information might just lead the licensed trustee to discover the offences.

The third way of getting more information about suspected bankruptcy fraud and offences is through conducting examinations.

Examination of the bankrupt or the designated officer of the bankrupt company

In this section, I will use the examination of the bankrupt regarding his or her property and examination of the designated officer concerning the company’s property and affairs, interchangeably.

Section 161(1) of the BIA allows for the examination of the bankrupt by the official receiver. An official receiver is a qualified person in the local office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy Canada. In personal bankruptcy, this examination could be held any time prior to the discharge of the bankrupt.

The official receiver can examine the bankrupt under oath relative to the insolvent’s conduct, the reasons for the bankruptcy and the disposition of the bankrupt’s property. The official receiver can generally ask any questions they wish about the bankrupt’s conduct and affairs.

Section 163(1) of the BIA allows the Trustee, by ordinary resolution passed by the creditors or inspectors, may, without a court order, examine under oath before the registrar of the court or other authorized person:

  • the bankrupt;
  • any person fairly believed to have knowledge of the bankrupt’s affairs; or
  • anyone who is or has been an agent, or a clerk, an officer, management or an employee of the bankrupt.

Essentially, anyone who has knowledge of the bankrupt’s affairs. This also includes anyone in possession of any books, records or documents regarding the affairs of the bankrupt. Such persons would also have to hand over those documents.

Section 163(2) allows any creditor or another interested person on sufficient cause being revealed (such as the suspicion of bankruptcy fraud) can apply for an order to be made for the examination of the bankrupt, under oath, before the registrar or other accredited person.

So as you can see from this description, the existence of this section of the BIA allowing for the ability to examine a person in connection with a bankruptcy filing is quite generous. The suspicion of the bankrupt trying to commit bankruptcy fraud can lead to a request for an examination of the bankrupt.

So the question becomes, can the examination process be used for a fishing expedition or does the Trustee or creditor need to have some evidence of wrongdoing? Do they need to have more than just a hunch? The BC court decision I am going to now describe seems to answer that question.

Bankruptcy fraud: Examination of the bankrupt court case background

The matter is Hanlon (Re), 2021 BCSC 40. Mr. Hanlon wants his bankruptcy discharge. However, a major creditor of his has reason to suspect that there is more information to be learned about Mr. Hanlon’s conduct, affairs and property. The creditor made an application under section 163(2) of the BIA.

A lady called Ms. Johnson acquired a judgment against Mr. Hanlon after a five-day defamation trial that occurred in August 2018. Ms. Johnson was granted an award of $27,500 against Mr. Hanlon.

On June 14, 2019, Mr. Hanlon filed a proposal under BIA. The proposal was unsuccessful and Mr. Hanlon was deemed to have filed an assignment in bankruptcy. The effect was as if Mr. Hanlon chose himself filing for bankruptcy. At the meeting of creditors, Mr. Hanlon said, which is recorded in the Minutes, that “there was an expectation that any amounts owing to his mother would be deducted from his inheritance.” The lawyer from the law firm representing Ms. Johnson was appointed an Inspector in the bankruptcy administration.

Ms. Johnson opposed the bankrupt’s discharge as she suspects bankruptcy fraud. On February 3, 2020, she filed an amended proof of claim. In it, she made an unsecured claim for $94,443.01, consisting of the original judgment, post-judgment interest, and a claim of $66,788.26 for special costs.

bankruptcy fraud
bankruptcy fraud

Bankruptcy fraud: The position of the bankrupt, creditor and Trustee

The creditor

Ms. Johnson is concerned that the bankrupt is trying to commit bankruptcy fraud. She argues that Mr. Hanlon and his mother should each be subjected to an examination for the purposes of finding more information to ensure that she can canvass concerns connected to:

  • If he is a beneficiary under his mother’s will and the potential of an inheritance being received.
  • Info about the status of his chequing account and credit cards, including his use of his mom’s bank card.
  • Cash and loans Mr. Hanlon might have received from his mom and step-father.
  • Exactly How Mr. Hanlon is paying for expenditures.
  • Particulars any businesses the bankrupt runs, the revenue he gains, and whether he has been purposefully underemployed.

She says that examinations are necessary considering that the evidence produced to date sustains that “something is amiss” and also there is “a disconnect” with his current financial situation.

Ms. Johnson also wants approval to examine his mother about any financial arrangements between them. She also wants to examine the mother about any inheritance that her son is entitled to. Finally, she also wants to see a copy of the will. She suggests that his mother is directly attached to the bankruptcy estate.

The Trustee

The Trustee did not take any position on Ms. Johnson’s application. The Trustee advised the court that:

  • An examination of Mr. Hanlon under oath happened already.
  • Mr. Hanlon has been extremely honest with everything that he has been asked
  • To her knowledge, there are no outstanding requests.
  • It would be an uncommon request to demand the supply of a will from a person who is still living. If Mr. Hanlon’s mom passes away then the Trustee will take all needed actions to investigate the situation and the bankruptcy estate.

Ultimately, the Trustee is of the view that the bankrupt’s discharge hearing should happen as soon as possible. It has already been postponed. The Trustee had no indication that the bankrupt was trying to commit bankruptcy fraud.

The bankrupt

The bankrupt stated that his mom and stepfather are alive and generally in good health. If his mother passes away everything will certainly go to his stepfather. They have been wed for 40 years and their house remains in joint-tenancy. He advised that his mother is currently 85 years of age, she does need the use of a wheelchair and is deaf in both ears. His stepfather is either 72 or 73 years old. He opposes the examination of his mom as being in the nature of a fishing exploration.

He disputed that there is anything amiss about the documents provided and that he has not committed any bankruptcy offence or crime and that he has not entered into any suspicious transaction. He explains that there is a senior’s discount referral on his bank account due to the fact that it is a joint account with his stepfather who is elderly. He described that the only time he has used his mom’s charge card was to pay a process server (in one of his prior paralegal businesses) who called for a credit card over the phone. He rejects ever accessing his mother’s bank account.

He submits that he has supplied a description of his work history, consisting of what companies he was paid by. He also stated that he has provided all items the Trustee has ever asked for. He further submitted that the application should be dismissed as it is without benefit, a fishing expedition, and is being made solely for the purpose of delaying his discharge hearing.

Mr. Hanlon presented himself as an honest but unfortunate person that is not trying to commit bankruptcy fraud.

Bankruptcy fraud: The court decision for the request to examine the bankrupt

The court accepted there were issues raised that need more information. An example of one is that the bankrupt did not list any debts owing to either his mother or stepfather in his sworn Statement of Affairs. He stated at this hearing that he was not conscious that such household debts were to be included in his bankruptcy. The situation of loans from his mother or stepfather and the arrangements need more clarification.

It is not totally clear to what degree there has actually been some intermingling of the bankrupt’s affairs with his mother’s yet the evidence does support that he has utilized her credit card. He claims it was only once however the creditor is entitled to explore this issue. The bankrupt admitted that his mom supplies him with money to pay a specific expense or expenses. He is living with his mother and stepfather in a self-contained bachelor suite and is not paying rent.

The particulars of his revenue and work are also uncertain and there was a discrepancy between the bankrupt’s evidence and one record of employment he received. An examination would shed additional light on this incongruity in addition to the allegation made that he is purposefully underemployed.

The judge was persuaded that sufficient cause has been revealed by Ms. Johnson to support an examination of Mr. Hanlon under s. 163( 2) of the BIA. The judge was also satisfied that such an examination has the possibility of benefitting the general body of creditors and it is not just a fishing expedition. Accordingly, the court ordered that the bankrupt attend an exam at a time and location to be fixed. The assessment will be limited to two hours. The expenses of the exam and getting a transcript will certainly be for Ms. Johnson’s account.

The court decision about the request for documents and to examine the bankrupt’s mother

The court felt that the applicant was looking for too wide an order for the production of documents. The court directed that Ms. Johnson set the particulars of the documents she is looking for using a letter to Mr. Hanlon, with a copy to the Trustee. This letter laying out the particulars of the documents should be supplied at the very least three weeks before the exam takes place. The judge ordered that the bankrupt will deliver the files he has in his possession or control no later than 7 days prior to the day scheduled for his exam.

Concerning his mother’s will, the court was not encouraged that the production of the will to prove that the bankrupt will be getting any type of inheritance was necessary. Even if he is a beneficiary under his mom’s will, she is alive and there was no evidence that he will certainly acquire anything as a beneficiary either now or in the future.

The evidence established that his mother is married with the majority of the value of her assets registered in joint-tenancy with her husband. The evidence also showed that his stepfather is more than 10 years younger than his mother. The court decided that the will should not be produced, but that did not restrict Ms. Johnson from checking out issues associated with any kind of prospective inheritance at the examination.

The judge was not satisfied that his mother ought to be required to participate in interviews. Such an examination would be oppressive because of his mother’s age, being 85 years old, her current health standing, although she did not have any specific illness, as well as the existing COVID-19 pandemic.

The court also took judicial notice of the fact that in the sworn statement of service, the server deposes that when he served the application on the bankrupt’s mother, she did not appear to comprehend that she was being served with legal papers. So any inquiries regarding the use of her credit cards by the bankrupt or how he is paying for his living expenditures can be canvassed at the exam of the bankrupt. Ms. Johnson’s application to examine the mother was denied.

Bankruptcy fraud and examination of the bankrupt: Other matters

The judge was also completely satisfied that an order should be made that any discharge hearing happens after the examination has been completed. In order that there is no delay, the court directed that the examination is to be finished before February 28, 2021. The bankrupt is to cooperate by establishing a day for the exam within this period. The discharge hearing can be set up for a day beginning in March 2021.

It will be up to the presider of the discharge hearing to ultimately decide what consideration ought to be given on any kind of possible inheritance when determining the disposition of the bankrupt’s application for discharge.

Finally, Ms. Johnson was awarded costs against the bankrupt. This cost award is a post-filing debt that will not be released by the bankrupt’s discharge from bankruptcy.

Bankruptcy fraud summary

I hope you enjoyed this bankruptcy fraud Brandon Blog post. If you are concerned because you or your business are dealing with substantial debt challenges and you assume bankruptcy is your only option, call me. It is not your fault that you remain in this way. You have actually been only shown the old ways to try to deal with financial issues. These old ways do not work anymore.

The Ira Smith Team utilizes new modern-day ways to get you out of your debt difficulties while avoiding bankruptcy. We can get you the relief you need and so deserve.

The tension put upon you is big. We know your discomfort factors. We will check out your entire situation and design a new approach that is as unique as you and your problems; financial and emotional. We will take the weight off of your shoulders and blow away the dark cloud hanging over you. We will design a debt settlement strategy for you. We know that we can help you now.

We understand that people and businesses facing financial issues need a realistic lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” method with the Ira Smith Team. Not everyone has to file bankruptcy in Canada. The majority of our clients never do. We help many people and companies stay clear of bankruptcy.

That is why we can establish a new restructuring procedure for paying down debt that will be built just for you. It will be as one-of-a-kind as the economic issues and discomfort you are encountering. If any one of this seems familiar to you and you are serious about getting the solution you need, contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. group today.

Call us now for a no-cost consultation.

We will get you or your business back up driving to healthy and balanced trouble-free operations and get rid of the discomfort factors in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

We hope that you and your family are safe, healthy and secure during this coronavirus pandemic.

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

DECLARING BANKRUPTCY IN CANADA: NEVER WORRY WHAT TO DO AGAIN WITH THESE AWESOME TIPS

declaring bankruptcy in canada
declaring bankruptcy in canada

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

If you would prefer to listen to the audio version of this declaring bankruptcy in Canada Brandon Blog, please scroll to the bottom and click play on the podcast.

Declaring bankruptcy in Canada: Introduction

Declaring bankruptcy in Canada is a legal process through which you may be discharged from your financial obligations (with certain minor exceptions). Its purpose is to permit an honest but unfortunate debtor to obtain a discharge from many financial debts, based on affordable conditions.

The Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy (OSB) is charged with the administration of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA), the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA) and their respective rules. All documents associated with filings under either of those Acts can be found at the OSB’s internet site. The OSB likewise licenses and supervises the actions of licensed insolvency trustees (LITs ). LITs are accredited to:

  • administer the estates of bankrupts;
  • manage alternatives to bankruptcy such as consumer proposals and commercial proposals in order for debtors to get creditor protection and restructure in order to avoid bankruptcy; and
  • serve as a monitor under the CCAA.

When can you declare bankruptcy in Canada?

Any insolvent person in financial difficulty can declare bankruptcy in Canada any time through a bankruptcy assignment after they have seen a licensed insolvency trustee and made suitable arrangements for the Trustee to administer handle the bankruptcy administration. The bankruptcy trustee prepares the necessary documents for the debtor to sign for filing for bankruptcy.

The licensed trustee then files certain legal documents with the OSB. The OSB then issues its Certificate to evidence the bankruptcy of the person or company. The date and time indicated on the Certificate are when a voluntary bankruptcy starts.

If you are not able to get a LIT to accept your data, or if you cannot afford to work with a LIT in order to declare bankruptcy in Canada, the OSB’s Bankruptcy Assistance Program might have the ability to help. This is provided that you are not and have actually not just recently been, involved in commercial activities or you are not in jail.

What happens when you declare bankruptcy in Canada?

There are three different avenues that can have someone declare bankruptcy in Canada:

  1. Voluntary assignment – A financially troubled insolvent person or company can make a voluntary assignment in bankruptcy. This is where they voluntarily make a general assignment in bankruptcy for the general benefit of all of their creditors.
  2. Bankruptcy application – A creditor who is owed at least $1,000 on an unsecured basis submits an application to the court for obtaining a bankruptcy order against the debtor and the debtor’s property.
  3. Deemed bankruptcy – When a debtor who has made the choice to start an insolvency process under the BIA to gain debt relief through trying to restructure their unsecured debt, has fallen short to satisfy the requirements for:
    1. submitting a Division I proposal;
    2. gaining the necessary votes in favour of the proposal from the unsecured creditors; or
    3. obtaining court approval for the proposal.

Under a deemed bankruptcy, the moment the debtor fails in one of these ways, the BIA says that the debtor is deemed to have made an assignment in bankruptcy.

The bankrupt is able to earn a living after filing for bankruptcy. For this objective, the bankrupt can work or run a company, after the bankruptcy event. However, an undischarged bankrupt cannot be a director of a company. Also, upon the onset of the bankruptcy, the debtor must turn over to the licensed insolvency trustee, any shares of companies owned by the bankrupt.

The Trustee will send a notice to your creditors informing them of the bankruptcy. If there needs to be a meeting of creditors, the Trustee will hold it. The Trustee will also provide the bankrupt person with two credit counselling/financial counselling sessions with an individual who is an OSB qualified credit counsellor from the Trustee’s office, as part of the overall bankruptcy administration.

As you can see, not every way of declaring bankruptcy in Canada is totally voluntary.

declaring bankruptcy in canada
declaring bankruptcy in canada

Declaring bankruptcy in Canada: What assets do you lose in bankruptcy?

One of the most important tasks a Trustee has in the entire personal bankruptcy process or corporate bankruptcy process after the debtor chose declaring bankruptcy in Canada is to:

  • take an inventory of the debtor’s assets;
  • make sure they are physically secure and insured;
  • formulate a plan to sell the assets for the most amount possible under the circumstances;
  • review the financial affairs of the bankrupt, including the household income and financial situation of the bankrupt in a personal bankruptcy filing, and prepare a report to the creditors; and
  • then pay a dividend to the creditors.

There are however certain exemptions allowed for people. Few are based on federal law. Most are based on provincial law. So exempt assets may differ from province to province. In Ontario, assets that are exempt, and therefore not subject to seizure by a Trustee, are:

  • The equity in your home of no greater than $10,000.
  • A vehicle with an equity value of no more than $6,000.
  • Garments and medical/dental aids.
  • Household furnishings up to a worth of $13,100.
  • Tools of the trade with a value of no greater than $11,300.
  • Pension plans, RRIF, RRSP (other than any kind of RRSP payments made within 12 months of the date of bankruptcy).
  • Farmers– no greater than $29,100 for animals and also tools & equipment.

Even though someone has decided that filing bankruptcy is the route they must go, there are certain assets they will not have to give up.

Declaring bankruptcy in Canada: Does Bankruptcy clear tax debt in Canada?

The short answer is yes. Income taxes payable calculated on your tax return but not paid is a type of debt that is released when a person gets their bankruptcy discharge. However, you should know that there is a wrinkle for anyone who owes $200,000 or more in income tax debt and if that debt to Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) equals 75% or more of the total unsecured proven claims in the bankruptcy. If that is the case, then that affects the bankrupt’s ability to get a discharge after declaring bankruptcy in Canada.

If it is the person’s first time filing bankruptcy and they do not have to make surplus income payments, then they are still entitled to a discharge after 9 months from the date of bankruptcy. If it is their first time but they do have surplus income payments, then they cannot apply for a discharge until after 21 months.

If this is the person’s second time filing bankruptcy, if they do not have any surplus income payments, then rather than being able to apply for a discharge after 9 months, they must wait 24 months. If they do have surplus income payments, then it is extended to 36 months.

If someone has been bankrupt more than one time before and has at least $200,000 of income tax debt representing 75% or more of the total proven unsecured claims, then regardless of their surplus income payment situation, they must wait 36 months.

Such a bankrupt is called a high tax debtor. A high tax debtor is not entitled to have the Trustee issue an automatic bankruptcy discharge when the time has expired. Rather, there must be a court hearing for the bankrupt’s application for discharge.

CRA will oppose an absolute discharge at least on the basis of the fact that they are a high tax debtor. The Trustee does not have to oppose the discharge on this basis. However, if the bankrupt has failed to live up to any of their duties, including making the required surplus income payment, the Trustee will oppose.

The court will make a conditional order of discharge. At least one of the conditions will be to pay a certain amount to the Trustee for the benefit of the unsecured creditors. The amount depends on the unique circumstances of that bankrupt, but you can assume that the amount will be about 25% of the income tax owing.

So anyone how has income tax debt and is contemplating declaring bankruptcy in Canada, needs to look at their total liabilities carefully. If at all possible, you do not want to be a high tax debtor when declaring bankruptcy in Canada.

Declaring bankruptcy in Canada: What debt does bankruptcy not cover?

Some people think that in a personal bankruptcy filing, the bankruptcy filing itself is what eliminates the person’s debts. That is wrong. At the moment of declaring bankruptcy in Canada, nothing actually happens to your debts. It is the person’s discharge from bankruptcy that “discharges” the person from their debts.

Yet, there is still a category of debts that are not covered and not discharged when a personal bankruptcy discharge occurs. The debts that are not covered or discharged, are outlined in section 178(1) of the BIA. These such debts are:

  • any type of penalty, fine, restitution order or other order comparable in nature to a penalty, fine or restitution order, enforced by a court in regard of an offence, or any kind of debt developing out of a recognizance or bond;
  • any damages award by a court in civil process for:

    ( i) physical injury intentionally caused, or sexual assault, or

    ( ii) wrongful death resulting therefrom;
  • any type of financial debt or responsibility for spousal support or alimentary pension;
  • any kind of financial obligation or liability developing under a judgment establishing an association or about support or maintenance, or under an agreement for maintenance and support of a spouse, former spouse, previous common-law companion or child not living with the bankrupt;
  • any type of financial obligation or liability occurring out of fraudulence, embezzlement, misappropriation or defalcation while acting in a fiduciary capacity or, in the Province of Quebec, as a trustee or administrator of the property of others;
  • any financial debt or liability resulting from getting property or services by false pretenses or fraudulent misrepresentation, apart from a debt or responsibility that arises from an equity claim;
  • liability for the dividend that a creditor would have been qualified to receive on any kind of provable claim not disclosed to the trustee unless the creditor had notification or understanding of the bankruptcy and fell short to take reasonable activity to confirm the claim; or
  • student loans if the bankruptcy filing happened before the person stopped being a full or part-time student or within seven years after the day on which the bankrupt stopped to be a complete- or part-time student

Declaring bankruptcy in Canada summary

I hope you enjoyed this declaring bankruptcy in Canada Brandon Blog post. If you are concerned because you or your business are dealing with substantial debt challenges and you assume bankruptcy is your only option, call me. It is not your fault that you remain in this way. You have actually been only shown the old ways to try to deal with financial issues. These old ways do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team utilizes new modern-day ways to get you out of your debt difficulties while avoiding bankruptcy. We can get you the relief you need and so deserve.

The tension put upon you is big. We know your discomfort factors. We will check out your entire situation and design a new approach that is as unique as you and your problems; financial and emotional. We will take the weight off of your shoulders and blow away the dark cloud hanging over you. We will design a debt settlement strategy for you. We know that we can help you now.

We understand that people and businesses facing financial issues need a realistic lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” method with the Ira Smith Team. Not everyone has to file bankruptcy in Canada. The majority of our clients never do. We help many people and companies stay clear of bankruptcy.

That is why we can establish a new restructuring procedure for paying down debt that will be built just for you. It will be as one-of-a-kind as the economic issues and discomfort you are encountering. If any one of this seems familiar to you and you are serious about getting the solution you need, contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. group today.

Call us now for a no-cost consultation.

We will get you or your business back up driving to healthy and balanced trouble-free operations and get rid of the discomfort factors in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

Call a Trustee Now!