Categories
Brandon Blog Post

BANKRUPTCY AND BUSINESS FAILURE: WHY THE STATISTICS UNDOUBTEDLY DO NOT TELL THE FULL STORY


bankruptcy and business

Bankruptcy and Business: Introduction

As a licensed insolvency trustee, (previously referred to as a trustee in bankruptcy), my role involves assisting individuals and businesses in managing the complexities associated with entrepreneurship. The conclusion of a business often occurs without fanfare; it is not typically marked by formal announcements or celebratory farewells but rather unfolds quietly amidst the ongoing activity of the market. Despite rising bankruptcy and business failure through the recorded insolvency numbers, many businesses close without it showing up in the insolvency statistics, revealing a deeper truth about economic resilience.

For every corporate insolvency file that I administer, be it the legal process of a bankruptcy protection financial restructuring or a bankruptcy liquidation, there have been many more inquiries from entrepreneurs where the best advice I can give is rather than spending money on corporate bankruptcy, just shut down the business yourself.

In this Brandon’s Blog, which is aimed at Canadian entrepreneurs and their professional advisors, be they financial advisors, lawyers or accountants, I explore the complexities of bankruptcy and business failures, where one fact stands out: the numbers can be deceiving. The current rise in reported business insolvencies has raised eyebrows. But what’s behind these figures? Many businesses close their doors without formally declaring bankruptcy.

Bankruptcy and Business: Types of Business Structures Affected by Bankruptcy

It is essential to understand the different types of business structures that can be affected by or are eligible for bankruptcy. In this section, I’ll explore the impact of bankruptcy on sole proprietorships, partnerships, and incorporated companies.

Sole Proprietorships

A sole proprietorship is a business owned and operated by one individual personally. In the event of bankruptcy, the sole proprietor’s personal assets, including their home, savings, and other personal property, can be used to pay off business debts. This is because, from a legal perspective, the business and the individual are considered one and the same.

Partnerships

A partnership is a business owned and operated by two or more individuals. In the event of one or more partners filing for personal bankruptcy, the partnership’s assets are typically divided among the partners, and each partner is responsible for paying off their share of the debts. However, if one partner files for bankruptcy protection, then the partnership is automatically dissolved. If one partner is unable to pay their share, the other partners are responsible for paying off the remaining business debts.

Incorporated Companies

An incorporated company, also known as a corporation, is a separate legal entity from its shareholders. In the event of bankruptcy, as the corporation is a separate entity, the corporation’s assets are typically liquidated to pay off its debts, and the shareholders are not personally responsible for paying off the debts. However, if the corporation is insolvent, the shareholders may still be at risk of losing their investment.

Key Takeaways

  • Sole proprietorships: The business and the individual are considered one and the same, and personal assets can be used to pay off business debts.
  • Partnerships: Partners are responsible for paying off their share of the debts, or alternatively, each partner is responsible for paying off the entire amount of all debts. If one partner is unable to pay, and especially if one or more partners file for personal bankruptcy, the other partners are responsible for paying off the remaining business debts.
  • Incorporated companies: The corporation’s assets are typically liquidated to pay off its debts, and shareholders are not personally responsible for paying off the debts, but may still be at risk of losing their investment.

Why Understanding Business Structure is Important

Understanding the type of business structure you have is essential in the event of insolvency, as it influences the appropriate debt relief solution that can be developed and executed. The relationship between bankruptcy and your business structure will affect how your assets are managed and how your debts are settled. For instance, if you operate as a sole proprietorship, you may be personally liable for the repayment of business debts. In contrast, if your business is incorporated, your personal assets are typically safeguarded from creditors.

Bankruptcy can impact any business structure; sole proprietorships, partnerships, and corporations. It is important to comprehend the specific business structure you operate under and the implications a bankruptcy protection filing may have on both you and your business. For Canadian entrepreneurs facing challenges with business debt, it is advisable to consult a licensed insolvency trustee to explore available options and make informed decisions regarding your financial situation.

Although parts of the balance of this article will focus on the corporate business structure, most will also be applicable to Canadian business regardless of the business structure.

bankruptcy and business
bankruptcy and business

Understanding Bankruptcy and Business in Canada: A Guide for Businesses

As a Canadian entrepreneur, it is important to recognize that operating a business involves various risks and challenges. Even with diligent management, financial difficulties may arise that jeopardize the viability of your company. In these circumstances, it is essential to be well-informed about the options at your disposal. One widely recognized and effective solution in such situations is corporate bankruptcy.

What is Corporate Bankruptcy in Canada?

Corporate bankruptcy, arising from a corporate insolvency, occurs when a business is unable to pay its overwhelming debts as they become due – that is the definition of an insolvent company. This can happen due to a variety of reasons, including poor cash flow management, increased competition, unexpected expenses, or even a downturn in the economy. When a business becomes insolvent, it may be forced to cease operations, leading to financial losses for its creditors, employees, and shareholders.

Types of Bankruptcy For Corporations in Canada

There are two main types of corporate bankruptcy in Canada: proposal and bankruptcy.

  • Proposal: A corporate proposal is an alternative to bankruptcy. It is a formal payment plan under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) BIA that allows a business a period of time to settle its debts with its creditors. The proposal is presented to the creditors, who then vote on whether to accept it. If accepted, the proposal then goes to court for approval. When the court approves the proposal, it then is binding on the debtor business and the creditors.

Once the proposal becomes binding, the business can restructure its debt and continue operating by making the monthly payments to the Trustee that it promised to make for the benefit of its creditors. This is otherwise known as a corporate restructuring plan.

  • Bankruptcy: Bankruptcy is also a formal process under the BIA where the business assets are liquidated by selling off its assets. The Trustee then uses the net proceeds of sale to pay for the cost of the corporate bankruptcy process and then to distribute what remains to the unsecured creditors on a pro rata basis according to their claims.

Benefits of Corporate Bankruptcy in Canada

While bankruptcy protection may seem like a last resort, it can actually be a beneficial option for businesses facing financial difficulties. Some of the benefits of corporate bankruptcy in Canada include:

  • Protection from Creditors: Bankruptcy provides a stay of proceedings, which means that creditors cannot take or continue legal action against the business or its assets.
  • Reorganization: Bankruptcy allows businesses to restructure their debt and reorganize their operations to become more sustainable.
  • Fresh Start: Bankruptcy can provide a fresh start for businesses, allowing them to emerge from insolvency and start anew.

When to Consider Corporate Bankruptcy in Canada

If your business is experiencing financial difficulties, it’s essential to seek professional advice from a licensed insolvency trustee. Here are some signs that may indicate it’s time to consider corporate bankruptcy:

  • Cash Flow Problems: Cash flow problems can indicate underlying financial issues within a business. If a company is consistently struggling to pay its bills on time, it is essential to investigate the root causes of this cash flow challenge, as it may reflect broader financial health concerns.
  • High Debt Levels: When a business is burdened with significant debt and faces challenges in meeting its repayment obligations, considering bankruptcy may be a viable option to explore.
  • Loss of Key Customers or Suppliers: Loss of key customers or suppliers can indicate underlying issues within a business that require attention. It is important to analyze the reasons behind this loss, as it may reflect broader challenges affecting the organization’s performance and stability. Addressing these issues promptly can help mitigate potential negative impacts on operations and profitability.

Corporate bankruptcy in Canada is a multifaceted process that can present challenges for businesses in financial distress. However, it can serve as an effective mechanism for companies to address their financial challenges and restructure. By familiarizing themselves with the available options and consulting with qualified professionals, businesses can effectively navigate the bankruptcy process, potentially emerging in a more resilient and sustainable position. Entrepreneurs in Canada facing significant business debt are encouraged to reach out to a licensed insolvency trustee to explore their available options.

Bankruptcy and Business: The Overlooked Landscape of Business Closures

Understanding Bankruptcy and Business Insolvency Filing vs. Closure

Have you ever wondered the difference between a business going bankrupt and closing its doors? It’s important. Business insolvency is the financial condition that the business cannot pay all of its debts as they come due. Business bankruptcy is a legal process where a business files for bankruptcy in order to deal with the distribution of its assets among its creditors in a fair and orderly fashion, as far as the money can go. On the other hand, closure can happen for many reasons, like poor management or market changes. Bankruptcy and business failure many times go hand in hand, but just as often, they don’t.

Reasons For Bankruptcy and Business Failure

Understanding the Common Causes

As a licensed insolvency trustee, I’ve seen firsthand the devastating impact of business bankruptcy on entrepreneurs, employees, and the economy as a whole. While no business is immune to financial difficulties, understanding the common reasons for business bankruptcy can help entrepreneurs take proactive steps to mitigate risks and avoid insolvency.

In this section, we’ll explore the three main categories of reasons for business bankruptcy: Financial Challenges, Operational Issues, and External Factors.

Financial Challenges

Financial challenges are often the most obvious reason for business bankruptcy. Some common financial challenges that can lead to insolvency include:

  • Cash flow management issues: Inability to manage cash flow can lead to delayed payments, missed deadlines, and ultimately, insolvency.
  • High debt levels: Carrying too much debt can put a significant strain on a business’s finances, making it difficult to meet financial obligations.
  • Inadequate funding: Insufficient startup capital or ongoing funding can hinder a business’s ability to grow and operate successfully.
  • Poor budgeting: Failing to create a realistic budget or failing to stick to it can lead to financial difficulties.

Operational Issues

Operational issues can also contribute to business bankruptcy. Some common operational issues that can lead to insolvency include:

  • Inefficient operations: Poorly managed operations can lead to wasted resources, increased costs, and decreased productivity.
  • Lack of scalability: Failing to adapt to growth or changes in the market can lead to operational inefficiencies and financial difficulties.
  • Poor management: Ineffective leadership or management can lead to poor decision-making, which can ultimately result in insolvency.
  • Failure to innovate: Failing to innovate or adapt to changes in the market can lead to stagnation and financial difficulties.

External Factors

External factors can also play a significant role in business bankruptcy. Some common external factors that can lead to insolvency include:

  • Economic downturns: Economic recessions or downturns can lead to reduced consumer spending, decreased demand, and financial difficulties.
  • Competition: Increased competition can lead to reduced market share, decreased revenue, and financial difficulties.
  • Regulatory changes: Changes in regulations or laws can lead to increased costs, decreased revenue, and financial difficulties.
  • Natural disasters: Natural disasters or other external events can lead to significant financial losses and insolvency.

By understanding the common reasons for business bankruptcy, entrepreneurs can take proactive steps to mitigate risks and avoid insolvency. This includes creating a solid business plan, managing cash flow effectively, and staying adaptable to changes in the market. As a licensed insolvency trustee, I’ve seen firsthand the devastating impact of business bankruptcy on entrepreneurs and the economy. By being aware of the common causes of business bankruptcy, entrepreneurs can take steps to avoid insolvency and achieve long-term success.

Statistical Insights

Recent statistics highlight an important trend that merits our attention. Following the 2008 financial crisis, we saw a notable rise in business closures, with many not opting to file for bankruptcy. This is quite surprising, isn’t it?

In the first quarter of this year, Canada experienced 2,003 insolvencies, which included 1,599 bankruptcies and 404 proposals. This marks an 87 percent increase compared to the same quarter last year and represents the highest number of insolvencies in the first three months since early 2008.

Additionally, Statistics Canada provides insights into active businesses by tracking their monthly payroll filings with the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA). Due to a slight delay in data reporting and analysis, the latest figures are from January, showing there were 936,327 active businesses in Canada. However, there were also 43,121 closures, being companies that reported employees to the CRA in December 2023 but did not in January 2024.

“The real tragedy of business closures hides in the shadows of insolvency statistics.”

In light of all this, understanding that a business can disappear without ever declaring bankruptcy is crucial. It paints a clearer picture of our economy. Whether due to management issues or other challenges affecting the viability and solvency of the business, this is a landscape that deserves attention. What are your thoughts on this?

bankruptcy and business
bankruptcy and business

Bankruptcy and Business: The Hidden Truth Behind Business Closures

Understanding the Landscape of Business Failures

Did you know that the actual number of business closures is likely much higher than what insolvency figures reveal? It’s a shocking reality. Business insolvencies are soaring to heights we haven’t seen since the financial crisis of 2008. But here’s the catch: these numbers only represent a fraction of the businesses that are truly shutting down each year.

Why Do Businesses Fail?

Let’s dig into some reasons why businesses fail:

  • Lack of Cash Flow: Many businesses struggle with cash management. Without enough cash coming in, they can’t pay bills.
  • Poor Decision-Making: Sometimes, choosing the wrong direction can lead to disaster. It’s like sailing without a compass.
  • Competition: It’s a wild world out there. If you can’t keep up with your competitors, you may find yourself left behind.

The Significance of Measuring Failures

When you think about it, why are these insolvency numbers so important? They give us a glimpse into the broader economic conditions. However, they don’t paint the full picture. Countless businesses fold without ever going through the insolvency process. This raises the question: how can we better support these struggling businesses?

What Can Be Done?

We need to think creatively. Here are some strategies to consider:

  1. Strong Cash Flow Management: Maintaining robust financial practices can prevent major setbacks.
  2. Seek Guidance: Consulting with business mentors can provide invaluable insights.
  3. Flexibility is Key: Being adaptable to changing market demands can keep a business afloat.

A detailed examination of these factors reveals that each statistic embodies a narrative. Gaining insight into these dynamics enhances our understanding of the current business environment and facilitates the development of more effective solutions.

Bankruptcy and Business: Understanding Business Failures vs. Insolvency Rates

The current trend of rising bankruptcy and business failures can be alarming. We’re seeing numbers that remind us of the financial crisis back in 2008. But here’s the kicker: the official insolvency figures don’t tell the whole story. They only reflect a fraction of the businesses that close each year. So, what’s going on?

The Hidden Truth Behind Business Closures

When a business shuts down, sometimes bankruptcy and business do not go together. The business is insolvent, but as I stated in the introduction to this bankruptcy and business Brandon’s Blog, sometimes the wisest choice for owners is simply to close their doors rather than declare bankruptcy. Of course, in doing so, the business must treat its employees fairly in making sure that all wages and vacation pay are paid up in full, the books and records should be finalized, any leased equipment or consignment goods returned to their owners and all final government returns are filed.

A voluntary business closure raises a few questions:

  • Are entrepreneurs running away from the stigma of bankruptcy and business failure?
  • Do businesses fear the legal complexities of bankruptcy?

The Reality of Business Closures

Many businesses succumb to market pressures, competition, or changing consumer preferences. So even if a business doesn’t file for bankruptcy, it’s still part of a broader trend of bankruptcy and business failure.

Here are some factors contributing to these closures:

  1. Economic downturns: A slowdown can hit sales hard.
  2. Shifts in consumer behaviour: Staying relevant is crucial.
  3. Operational inefficiencies: Sometimes, a business just can’t keep up.

The data presented reflects not merely statistics, but real stories of individuals whose dreams and aspirations have faced significant challenges. Recognizing this broader context is crucial for comprehending the current realities of the business landscape.

bankruptcy and business
bankruptcy and business

Bankruptcy and Business: Understanding Business Failures Beyond Insolvency Numbers

Every year, countless businesses close their doors. But did you know most failures don’t make it to the insolvency list? It’s a striking fact. There’s a lot more happening beneath the surface.

The Real Picture of Business Failures

Business insolvencies are currently rising, reaching levels reminiscent of the 2008 financial crisis. However, these numbers only tell part of the story.

  • Insolvency counts are just the tip of the iceberg. Many businesses close without ever filing for bankruptcy.
  • They might choose to liquidate assets instead, avoiding formal insolvency procedures.
  • Some simply shutter their operation quietly, leaving no trail that stats can follow.

Why Do They Close?

Now, let’s dig deeper. Why do businesses close? Here are a few key reasons:

  1. Market changes: Trends shift rapidly. A product that sells today may be yesterday’s news tomorrow.
  2. Lack of funds: Often, owners run out of cash. It’s not always about being in debt.
  3. Poor planning: Without a solid business plan, success becomes a game of chance.

It’s critical to understand these points. When we consider the broader picture, it becomes clear that the narrative of bankruptcy and business failure encompasses much more than insolvency figures. So, when you hear those numbers, remember: behind every statistic, there’s a unique story. It’s worth exploring.

Bankruptcy and Business Behind the Scenes: A Personal Journey with Business Failure

Let me describe to you, with no names of course, about an entrepreneur who recently consulted with me. He truly believed in his retail business. It was welcoming, colourful, and brimming with potential. He had dreams of providing the best customer service in town. But, not long after the grand opening, he saw that it wasn’t working out. The foot traffic was lower than he anticipated, and the expenses kept piling up. He had to close the doors within a year of opening. It felt like a hard punch to his gut.

Lessons Learned

From this experience, he learned a few invaluable lessons:

  • Resilience is Key: Every setback can teach us something. We just need to be open to those lessons.
  • Adaptability Matters: The ability to pivot quickly can save a business. If he had been more flexible and had some staying power, perhaps he could have found a way to make it work.
  • Not All Bankruptcy and Business Failures Reflect Capability: Just because a venture doesn’t succeed it doesn’t mean that the person is not capable as an entrepreneur.

The Emotional Toll

Closing his store was not just a business decision; it hit him hard on a personal level. There’s a saying:

“Failure isn’t the opposite of success; it’s part of success.”

This resonated with him throughout the process. He felt a profound sense of loss—not just for his dream, but for his team and the community, albeit small, that had begun to form around his business. It’s important to recognize that every business closure affects many lives.

He will cherish the memories, good and bad. We often think of success as the ultimate goal. However, failures

can be just as important. After all, they prepare us for the next big opportunity.

Bankruptcy and Business: The Economic Ripple Effect of Silent Failures

Have you ever stopped to think about the impact of a business closing its doors quietly? It’s alarming. Each silent closure sends ripples through our communities. But how exactly does this happen?

Understanding the Broader Economy

When a business goes unnoticed, its effects are profound. For small towns and cities, local businesses are often the lifeblood of the economy. They provide jobs and foster a sense of community. But when they fail, a series of consequences unfold.

  • Potential job losses: Every unnoticed closure often results in job losses. It’s estimated that thousands of jobs are impacted as small businesses close each year.
  • Supply chain impacts: Smaller firms are interwoven into larger supply chains. When they disappear, disruptions occur, affecting many others reliant on their goods or services.

A Community Heartbreak

The silence surrounding these closures can be deafening.

“Every business closure is a community heartbreak.”

This isn’t just a catchy phrase; it’s the reality for many.

Large corporations may withstand economic struggles, but small businesses often can’t. Imagine a local diner you frequently visit, or a beloved independent bookstore. If these establishments close, the repercussions extend beyond just lost revenue. They can alter job security and change local culture.

We often overlook just how many jobs depend on these small firms. Have you considered what happens to job seekers when they vanish?

bankruptcy and business
bankruptcy and business

Bankruptcy and Business: Preventing the Silent Nightmare of Business Closure

We all know that running a business can feel like navigating through a storm. Sometimes, even the most resilient enterprises can face economic downturns that threaten their very existence. So, how do we ensure survivability? Here are some strategies to consider:

1. Embrace Innovation

  • Adapt to Market Trends: Staying ahead means constantly evaluating what’s working and what’s not. Are your customers shifting their preferences? Innovate to meet their needs.
  • Leverage Technology: Digital tools can streamline operations and reach wider markets. Tools like social media and e-commerce platforms can significantly boost visibility.

2. Cultivate Adaptability

We must understand that adaptability is key. If we don’t learn and pivot, we risk stagnation. Have you ever noticed how quickly the business landscape shifts? Continuous learning is not just a phrase; it’s a necessity. Training programs and workshops can enhance our expertise.

3. Build Community Support

One of the most effective strategies is building a strong support system. Entrepreneurs often feel isolated—this needn’t be the case. Engaging in community networks or mentorship programs can provide valuable guidance.

Imagine a gardener tending to a plant. It needs nurturing, sunlight, and sometimes a bit of pruning. Similarly, businesses thrive in supportive environments where they can learn and adapt. We need to reinforce this sense of community, where sharing experiences can lead to encouragement and growth.

Finally, I want to acknowledge that the journey is indeed tough. Yet, it is essential to focus on personal resilience. Everyone faces challenges. But through understanding and support, we can not only overcome but also flourish!

I urge you to seek out success stories, too. Businesses that have pivoted successfully often serve as a beacon of hope. They illuminate paths we never considered. By sharing our experiences and challenges, we help each other to thrive.

Bankruptcy and Business: Shining a Light on Shadows

As we’ve explored the complexities of business failures, one fact stands out: the numbers can be deceiving. The current rise in business insolvencies has raised eyebrows. But what’s behind these figures? Many businesses close their doors without formally declaring bankruptcy. This distinction is critical for understanding the health of our economy. Not all failures are recorded in official statistics. Every year, countless ventures close down quietly, leaving little trace. Each shuttered business represents dreams, investments, and hard work.

As we wrap up our discussion, it’s clear that *business failures* are more common than we often admit. Many business owners might feel isolated, and that’s understandable. But recognizing the reality of these failures is essential. It reminds us that every entrepreneur’s journey is difficult yet filled with opportunities to learn and grow.

Here are some key points we’ve explored:

  1. The numerous factors that contribute to business closures.
  2. The impact of community support on a business’s survival.
  3. How understanding failures can lead to future successes.

    bankruptcy and business
    bankruptcy and business

Bankruptcy and Business in Canada: FAQ

1. What is the difference between a business closing and a business going bankrupt?

Business closure and bankruptcy are distinct concepts in the realm of business operations.

Business closure refers to the termination of a business’s operations for various reasons. These reasons may include factors such as ineffective management, shifts in market conditions, or a deliberate choice by the owner to cease operations.

On the other hand, business bankruptcy is a legal process defined by the BIA in Canada. This occurs when a business officially declares its inability to meet its financial obligations. The bankruptcy process typically involves either restructuring debts through a formal proposal or liquidating business assets to repay creditors.

It is important to note that while bankruptcy often results in the closure of a business, not all closures are accompanied by bankruptcy proceedings. A business can close without filing for bankruptcy, opting instead to liquidate its assets and settle any outstanding debts on its own.

2. What are the main types of corporate bankruptcy in Canada?

Canada provides two main avenues for corporations encountering bankruptcy:

  • Proposal: This option involves submitting a formal payment plan to creditors for their approval. If the proposal is accepted and subsequently sanctioned by the court, the business can restructure its debts, continue its operations, and repay creditors over an extended period.
  • Bankruptcy: In this scenario, the corporation liquidates its assets to settle debts with creditors. The proceeds from the asset sales are allocated to creditors, starting with secured creditors, followed by a proportional distribution of any remaining funds to unsecured creditors.

3. What are some common reasons for business failure?

Business failure can result from various issues that can be categorized into three main areas:

Financial Challenges:

  • Poor cash flow management
  • High levels of debt
  • Insufficient funding
  • Ineffective budgeting practices

Operational Issues:

  • Inefficient operational processes
  • Inability to scale operations
  • Subpar management practices
  • Lack of innovation

External Factors:

  • Economic downturns
  • Heightened competition
  • Changes in regulations
  • Natural disasters

4. Why is the number of business closures likely higher than official insolvency statistics suggest?

Many businesses choose to close their doors without formally filing for bankruptcy. This could be due to several reasons:

  • Avoiding the stigma of bankruptcy: Some entrepreneurs may perceive bankruptcy as a personal failure and opt for a quiet closure.
  • Complexity and cost of bankruptcy proceedings: The legal processes involved in bankruptcy can be daunting and expensive, deterring some businesses.
  • Strategic decision to liquidate independently: Owners may decide to manage the closure process themselves, selling assets to settle debts outside of formal insolvency proceedings.

5. What are the economic consequences of unrecorded business closures?

Unrecorded closures have a significant impact on the economy:

  • Job losses: Closures, whether reported or not, often lead to job losses, impacting individuals, families, and communities.
  • Supply chain disruptions: Small businesses are often integral to larger supply chains. Their closures can disrupt these networks, impacting other businesses reliant on their goods or services.
  • Reduced economic activity: Closures reduce overall economic activity in communities, impacting local spending, tax revenue, and overall economic health.

6. What are some strategies to help businesses avoid closure?

  • Embrace innovation: Adapting to market trends, leveraging technology, and developing new products or services can help businesses remain competitive.
  • Cultivate adaptability: Continuous learning, training, and willingness to adjust strategies can improve resilience in the face of change.
  • Build community support: Engaging with local networks, seeking mentorship, and fostering collaboration can provide valuable resources and guidance.
  • Prioritize financial management: Strong cash flow management, responsible budgeting, and careful debt management are crucial for business stability.

7. How can we better understand the true landscape of business closures?

  • Improved data collection: Implementing better tracking mechanisms to capture closures beyond formal insolvency filings could provide a more accurate picture of business failure rates.
  • Research and analysis: Studying the reasons behind unrecorded closures can offer insights into common challenges and potential solutions.
  • Open dialogue and awareness: Encouraging entrepreneurs to share their experiences, both successes and failures, can normalize conversations about business closure and facilitate learning.

8. What is the key takeaway from understanding the difference between business closures and bankruptcy?

Recognizing that business closures are more prevalent than official insolvency statistics indicate is crucial. It highlights the challenges faced by entrepreneurs and emphasizes the need for support systems, innovation, adaptability, and sound financial management to foster business success and resilience. Acknowledging the silent failures allows for a more accurate understanding of the economic landscape and can help policymakers and support organizations develop strategies to address these challenges and better support businesses.

Bankruptcy and Business: Conclusion

So, why is it important to acknowledge these failures? It’s simple. They are not just numbers on a report; they are the culmination of hard work, dreams, and sometimes missteps. When a business fails, it can feel like a dark cloud, but it can also be the start of something new.

I hope you enjoyed this bankruptcy and business Brandon’s Blog. Do you or your company have too much debt? Are you or your company in need of financial restructuring due to distressed real estate or other reasons? The financial restructuring process is complex. The Ira Smith Team understands how to do a complex restructuring. However, more importantly, we understand the needs of the entrepreneur or someone with too much personal debt.

You are worried because you are facing significant financial challenges. It is not your fault that you are in this situation. You have been only shown the old ways that do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team uses new modern ways to get you out of your debt troubles while avoiding the bankruptcy process. We can get you debt relief freedom using processes that are a bankruptcy alternative.

The stress placed upon you is huge. We understand your pain points. We look at your entire situation and devise a strategy that is as unique as you and your problems; financial and emotional. The way we take the load off of your shoulders and devise a plan, we know that we can help you.

We know that people facing financial problems need a realistic lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” approach with the Ira Smith Team.

That is why we can develop a restructuring process as unique as the financial problems and pain you are facing. If any of this sounds familiar to you and you are serious about finding a solution, contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. team today.

Call us now for a free consultation. We will get you or your company back on the road to healthy stress-free operations and recover from the pain points in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

The information provided in this Brandon’s Blog is intended for educational purposes only. It is not intended to constitute legal, financial, or professional advice. Readers are encouraged to seek professional advice regarding their specific situations. The content of this Brandon’s Blog should not be relied upon as a substitute for professional guidance or consultation. The author, Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. as well as any contributors to this Brandon’s Blog, do not assume any liability for any loss or damage resulting from reliance on the information provided herein.

bankruptcy and business
bankruptcy and business
Categories
Brandon Blog Post

WHAT DOES BANKRUPTCY PROTECTION MEAN? THE ABSOLUTELY IMPORTANT THINGS YOU NEED TO KNOW


what does bankruptcy protection mean

What does bankruptcy protection mean? Canada’s Bankruptcy & Insolvency Act

What does bankruptcy protection mean? Bankruptcy protection is a legal status granted to individuals or businesses under Canada’s Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA). This protection shields debtors from creditor actions while working towards a fresh financial start, whether through bankruptcy or a consumer proposal.

Common questions are:

  • How does bankruptcy protect my assets?
  • What is the difference between a Consumer Proposal and bankruptcy?
  • How does bankruptcy protect my income?
  • Can I file for bankruptcy if I have no assets or income?
  • What happens to my debts after bankruptcy?
  • Do I need a bankruptcy lawyer to file for bankruptcy?

In this Brandon’s Blog, I demystify the concept of bankruptcy protection, shedding light on its significance and the various forms it can take. I answer these and other questions to explain “What Does Bankruptcy Protection Mean?“.

The legal framework of bankruptcy protection is rooted in the BIA in Canada. This act provides a structured process for individuals and business debtors facing overwhelming debt to seek relief and a fresh financial start.

Here’s a breakdown of the key elements:

Automatic Stay: Upon filing for bankruptcy or a Consumer Proposal, an automatic stay comes into effect. This legal measure serves as a shield against creditor actions. It immediately halts all collection attempts, including legal actions, wage garnishments, and asset seizures.

Exempt Assets: Contrary to the misconception that bankruptcy leads to complete asset forfeiture, provincial laws designate certain assets as exempt. These assets, encompassing essential items like household goods, a vehicle, limited home equity, tools of the trade, and certain RRSPs, are protected during bankruptcy proceedings. The specific value allowances for these exemptions vary by province.

Asset Protection Mechanisms: Even if an individual possesses assets exceeding the prescribed exemption limits, there are options to retain them. The repurchase of a person’s equity in the assets allows individuals, such as a family member, to keep an asset by paying the non-exempt portion of its value into the bankruptcy estate.

Alternatives to Bankruptcy: Consumer Proposals offer an alternative path to bankruptcy while still protecting through an automatic stay. In a Consumer Proposal, individuals negotiate a reduced debt repayment plan with their creditors, preserving their assets.

Income Protection: Bankruptcy filings protect income from creditors, effectively preventing wage garnishments and bank account freezes. This protection extends to most creditors, including the Canada Revenue Agency, with exceptions like ongoing child or spousal support payments. During bankruptcy, earned income goes directly to the individual. Depending on the income level, a person may need to pay over a portion using monthly payments for the benefit of the creditors.

It’s worth mentioning that bankruptcy protection laws can be quite complicated. It’s a good idea to consult with qualified professionals, like a licensed insolvency trustee (formerly known as a bankruptcy trustee or a trustee in bankruptcy), who can offer tailored advice and assist you in understanding the process.

what does bankruptcy protection mean
what does bankruptcy protection mean

What Does Bankruptcy Protection Mean? Types of Bankruptcy Protection

The BIA is a federal law that covers bankruptcy protection. Provincial laws determine which assets you can keep when filing for bankruptcy. Here are the main types of bankruptcy protection in Canada:

Canadian Liquidation Bankruptcy (known in the United States as a Chapter 7 bankruptcy)

This is a legal process available to both companies and individuals. The company or the person declares themselves unable to repay your debts when filing an assignment in bankruptcy. This results in a stay of proceedings that prevents creditors from taking action against you or your property. A licensed insolvency trustee will be appointed to manage your bankruptcy.

The bankrupt person or company may be required to surrender some assets to the Trustee, who will then sell them and distribute the funds to your creditors. However, for individuals, certain assets are protected under provincial law. For a first-time bankrupt person with no surplus income, you will be discharged from bankruptcy, usually within nine months, after which your debts will be wiped out, with limited exceptions.

Consumer Proposal (known in the United States as a Chapter 13 bankruptcy)

A consumer proposal is a financial restructuring bankruptcy alternative for people who owe $250,000 or less, other than for any debts registered against your principal residence. In a consumer proposal, you offer your creditors a partial repayment of your debt through a licensed insolvency trustee. If your creditors accept the proposal, your debts are consolidated into one settlement, and you make payments over some time, typically up to five years. Your assets are not affected by a consumer proposal, and you are protected from creditor actions while the proposal is in effect.

Commercial Proposal (known in the United States as a Chapter 11 bankruptcy)

Companies, or people who owe more than $250,000, can get bankruptcy protection, restructure their finances and avoid bankruptcy through the commercial proposal section of the BIA.

Restructuring under the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act (this is the closest we have to a US Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection filing)

Companies that owe $5 million or more, can gain bankruptcy protection and restructure their operations and finances using federal legislation called the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act.

All of the above bankruptcy protection alternatives require a licensed insolvency trustee to administer the process.

What Does Bankruptcy Protection Mean? Key Concepts of Bankruptcy Protection

Automatic Stay

What is a stay of proceedings and how does it work? A stay of proceedings is a legal measure triggered by filing for bankruptcy or a Consumer Proposal for financial restructuring. It immediately halts all creditor actions against you, including collection calls, legal proceedings, and asset seizures. This provides relief from creditor harassment and safeguards your assets and income while navigating the process.

Debt Restructuring through bankruptcy or consumer proposal

Two primary methods for debt restructuring in Canada are bankruptcy and consumer proposals. People understand how consumer proposals are for debt restructuring because that is exactly what it does. But how can personal bankruptcy be a debt restructuring tool?

Both options provide legal protection from creditors and offer a path toward financial stability.

Bankruptcy process

Filing for bankruptcy initiates a legal process and invokes the stay of proceedings. That halts all creditor actions, including collection calls, lawsuits, and wage garnishments. This protection extends to most creditors, including government agencies like the Canada Revenue Agency, with a few exceptions, like family support payments.

A common misconception is that bankruptcy leads to the loss of all assets. However, there are provincial laws in Canada that intersect with federal bankruptcy laws. One such provincial statute is the Ontario Execution Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. E.24, which designates certain assets as “exempt”. These exempt assets, based on liquidation value, not original cost, are protected during bankruptcy and can include:

  • Household furnishings and appliances – $13,150
  • Equity in a vehicle – $6,600
  • Home equity up to $10,000
  • RRSPs, other than for contributions made in the 12 months before filing bankruptcy
  • Medical aids and devices that are required to assist with a disability or a medical or dental condition
  • Cash surrender value of life insurance policies where a spouse or family member is an irrevocable designated beneficiary

Even if an asset exceeds the exemption limit, options exist to retain it. These options include repurchasing the asset by paying the non-exempt value into the bankruptcy estate or including that value in calculating what you need to pay for a successful consumer proposal instead.

To file for bankruptcy, you need to owe at least $1,000. You need debts to file; it doesn’t require any assets or income to be eligible! Individuals with minimal or no assets can still file for bankruptcy and benefit from its protections.

Consumer Proposal

A consumer proposal is a formal arrangement between a debtor and their creditors, arranged through a licensed insolvency trustee. This option helps debtors combine their debts and propose to repay creditors a portion of what they owe, typically between 20% and 50% of the total debt.

Consumer proposals offer several advantages:○

  • You do not lose your assets, making it suitable for those with significant non-exempt assets.
  • Interest charges stop accruing.
  • Creditors are legally prevented from starting or pursuing further collection actions due to the “stay of proceedings”.
  • Although a consumer proposal isn’t technically bankruptcy, it provides similar legal protections and debt relief benefits.

Both bankruptcy and consumer proposals are complex legal processes. Consulting with a licensed insolvency trustee, the only professional authorized to administer these proceedings is crucial to determine the most suitable option for individual circumstances. We can assess your financial situation, explain the implications of each choice, and guide you through the process.

what does bankruptcy protection mean
what does bankruptcy protection mean

What Does Bankruptcy Protection Mean? Rights and Responsibilities of Debtors

Rights of Debtors:

  • Stay of Proceedings
  • Asset Protection
  • Options For Non-Exempt Assets
  • Income Protection: Bankruptcy shields debtors’ income from most creditors, protecting them from wage garnishments and bank account seizures. This includes protection from the CRA. There are some specific cases where income protection is not available, such as ongoing child or spousal support payments.
  • Eligibility Regardless of Assets or Income
  • Consumer Proposals as an Alternative: Consumer proposals provide a bankruptcy alternative, allowing debtors to consolidate debts and negotiate a reduced repayment plan with their creditors10. While offering similar creditor protection through a stay of proceedings, consumer proposals do not impact assets, making them attractive for individuals with significant non-exempt equity.

Responsibilities of Debtors:

While the sources primarily focus on the rights and protections offered by bankruptcy and consumer proposals, there are certain inherent responsibilities:

  • Full Disclosure: Debtors are obligated to provide accurate and complete financial information to their licensed insolvency trustee, including all assets, debts, income, and expenses.
  • Cooperation: Debtors must cooperate with their Trustee throughout the bankruptcy or proposal process, attending meetings, providing requested documentation, and adhering to the terms of their agreement.
  • Compliance with Legal Requirements: Debtors must fulfill the specific legal requirements of their chosen debt relief solution, which may include attending financial counselling sessions or making agreed-upon payments.

Choosing the Right Path

Deciding between bankruptcy and a consumer proposal requires careful consideration with the guidance of a licensed insolvency trustee. The Trustee’s expertise helps determine the most suitable option based on individual circumstances, ensuring debtors understand their rights and obligations.

What Does Bankruptcy Protection Mean? The Role of Bankruptcy Courts

In Canada, bankruptcy courts play a crucial role in the administration of bankruptcy and insolvency proceedings. Here are some key responsibilities of bankruptcy courts in Canada:

  • Hearing Bankruptcy Applications: Bankruptcy courts hear petitions filed by individuals or businesses seeking to be declared bankrupt be it personal or business bankruptcy. The court determines whether the applicant is eligible to be declared bankrupt and whether the petition is valid.
  • Approving Reorganization Plans: In cases where a company is seeking to restructure its debt through BIA or CCAA reorganization plans, the bankruptcy court must approve the plan. The court ensures that the plan is fair and reasonable and that it provides for the payment of creditors in a timely manner.
  • Approving Asset Sales: Bankruptcy courts have the authority to approve asset sales conducted by the Trustee. This ensures that the sales are conducted fairly and reasonably and that the assets are sold for a fair price under the circumstances.
  • Hearing Creditors Appealing the Trustee’s Disallowance of Their Claim: Bankruptcy courts hear appeals of claim disallowances against the bankrupt’s estate. The court determines if the Trustee’s decision on the validity and priority of each claim is correct or not if appealed.
  • Approving Settlements: Bankruptcy courts can approve settlements between the Trustee and creditors, ensuring that the settlement is fair and reasonable.
  • Overseeing the Administration of the Bankrupt’s Estate: Bankruptcy courts monitor the administration of the bankrupt’s estate, ensuring that the Trustee is performing their duties following the BIA and that the estate is being managed fairly and reasonably.
  • Making Rulings on Disputes: Bankruptcy courts make rulings on disputes that arise during the bankruptcy process, such as disputes between the Trustee and creditors, or between creditors themselves.
  • Providing Guidance: Bankruptcy courts can guide the Trustee, creditors, and other stakeholders on the interpretation and application of the BIA and other relevant laws in response to such a motion.
  • Bankrupt’s opposed discharges: The Court hears all opposed applications for discharge of the bankrupt person and rules on what kind of discharge the person is entitled to.

    what does bankruptcy protection mean
    what does bankruptcy protection mean

What Does Bankruptcy Protection Mean? The Role of the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy Canada

The Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy Canada (OSB) is a federal agency that manages bankruptcy and insolvency proceedings across the country. The OSB is essential for enforcing the BIA and making sure the insolvency system runs smoothly and fairly. Here are some of the main responsibilities of the OSB:

  • Regulation and Oversight: The OSB regulates and oversees the activities of trustees, receivers, and other insolvency professionals to ensure that they comply with the BIA and other relevant laws.
  • Licensing and Registration: The OSB licenses and registers trustees, receivers, and other insolvency professionals, ensuring that they meet the necessary qualifications and standards.
  • Monitoring and Investigation: The OSB monitors and investigates complaints and concerns related to the administration of bankruptcy and insolvency proceedings, including allegations of misconduct or fraud.
  • Enforcement: The OSB enforces the BIA and other relevant laws, including issuing warnings, fines, and penalties to individuals and companies that violate the law.
  • Guidance and Education: The OSB provides guidance and education to stakeholders, including trustees, creditors, and debtors, on the BIA and other relevant laws and regulations.
  • Research and Analysis: The OSB conducts research and analysis on insolvency trends, statistics, and best practices, which help inform policy decisions and improve the effectiveness of the insolvency system.
  • Policy Development: The OSB develops and recommends policies to the Minister of Justice and Attorney General of Canada, which helps shape the direction of the insolvency system.
  • Public Education: The OSB provides public education and awareness campaigns to inform Canadians about the insolvency system, the consequences of bankruptcy, and the importance of financial literacy.
  • Collaboration with Other Agencies: The OSB works closely with other government agencies, such as the CRA and the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC), to ensure a coordinated approach to insolvency and debt management.
  • Reporting and Accountability: The OSB is responsible to Parliament and reports directly to the Minister of Justice and Attorney General of Canada. This structure ensures transparency and accountability in its operations and decisions.

In summary, the OSB is essential for maintaining the integrity and efficiency of Canada’s insolvency system and safeguarding the rights of creditors, debtors, and other parties involved.

What Does Bankruptcy Protection Mean? Impacts of Bankruptcy Protection

Financial Relief for Debtors

Bankruptcy provides an opportunity for debt relief. While it does not require the debtor to have any assets, it might involve surrendering non-exempt assets to the bankruptcy estate. However, debtors can explore options like a family member repurchasing assets by paying the non-exempt value or filing a Consumer Proposal, which allows for debt consolidation and partial repayment to creditors without surrendering assets.

Bankruptcy allows individuals and businesses struggling with debt to restructure or eliminate their debts and rebuild a stable financial future. After the personal bankruptcy process, debtors receive a discharge, typically within nine months for a first-time bankrupt person, marking the end of their bankruptcy and the elimination of eligible debts. In corporate bankruptcies, there is not a discharge process.

Effects on Credit Scores

Filing for bankruptcy becomes a matter of public record and is reported to credit bureaus. This information remains on your credit report for a significant period, typically six to seven years in Canada, though this can vary based on provincial laws and the type of bankruptcy protection filed. This negative mark on your credit history will likely result in a significant drop in your credit score.

Lenders use credit scores to assess the risk associated with lending money. A low credit score resulting from bankruptcy makes it difficult to obtain new credit, such as loans, credit cards, or mortgages. Even if you do qualify for credit, you may face less favourable terms, including higher interest rates and lower credit limits.

While not directly related to credit scores, bankruptcy can impact other aspects of your financial life. For instance, some employers and landlords may consider credit history when making hiring or rental decisions.

what does bankruptcy protection mean
what does bankruptcy protection mean

What Does Bankruptcy Protection Mean FAQ

Here is our what does bankruptcy protection mean FAQ:

  1. What does “Bankruptcy Protection” mean? Bankruptcy protection refers to the legal safeguards provided to individuals or companies when they file for bankruptcy. It essentially halts all debt collection activities, legal actions, and wage garnishments by creditors. This protection is activated through an “automatic stay” upon filing for bankruptcy.
  2. What does Bankruptcy Protection protect? Bankruptcy protection is designed to help you keep your assets safe from creditors. It provides a legal way to either reorganize your finances or sell off assets in an orderly fashion under court oversight. Many people think that filing for bankruptcy means you have to give up everything, but that’s not the case. Some laws allow you to keep important items such as your home, car, and personal possessions.
  3. How does the automatic stay work? The automatic stay is a court order that takes effect immediately upon filing for bankruptcy. It acts as a legal shield, prohibiting creditors from taking any further action to collect debts incurred before the bankruptcy filing. This includes stopping lawsuits, wage garnishments, bank account freezes, and even harassing phone calls.
  4. Does filing for bankruptcy mean I will lose all my assets? Not necessarily. While bankruptcy may involve liquidating some assets to repay creditors, the bankruptcy code provides exemptions that allow you to keep certain assets deemed necessary for your livelihood. These exemptions vary by state but generally include a homestead exemption for your primary residence, a vehicle exemption, and exemptions for personal property like clothing, furniture, and tools needed for your profession.
  5. How does bankruptcy protection help me keep my assets? Bankruptcy protection helps preserve your assets in two primary ways:
  6. Automatic Stay: It prevents creditors from seizing your assets while you reorganize your finances or create a repayment plan. Exemptions: These legal provisions shield specific assets from liquidation, ensuring you retain essential possessions.
  7. What is the difference between Bankruptcy and a Consumer Proposal? Bankruptcy means selling off non-exempt assets to repay creditors. It’s generally an option for individuals or businesses that are struggling with low income and limited assets. On the other hand, a consumer proposal is a way for individuals with a steady income to suggest a repayment plan to their creditors that lasts up to five years. This option lets you keep your assets while getting rid of your debt.
  8. How can I learn more about bankruptcy protection and whether it’s right for me? If you’re looking to learn more about bankruptcy protection and whether it’s the right choice for you, it’s important to talk to a licensed insolvency trustee. They can provide insights tailored to your financial situation, explain the various bankruptcy options available, clarify how it might affect your assets, and help you navigate the legal steps involved.
  9. What are some misconceptions about bankruptcy? You will lose everything: While some assets may be liquidated, exemptions exist to protect essential belongings. It will ruin your credit forever: While bankruptcy negatively impacts credit scores, it is possible to rebuild credit over time with responsible financial management. It is a mark of shame: Bankruptcy is a legal process designed to provide individuals and businesses with a fresh financial start.

What Does Bankruptcy Protection Mean Conclusion

Navigating the world of bankruptcy protection can feel daunting, but fear not! It’s a valuable safety net designed to help both individuals and businesses get back on their feet during tough financial times. Think of it as a wonderful opportunity to reorganize debts and embrace a fresh start.

By familiarizing yourself with the different types of bankruptcy, understanding the implications of filing, and discovering how it may affect your credit score, you’ll be well-equipped to make smart choices for your financial future. While bankruptcy isn’t the perfect fit for everyone, it can truly be a lifesaver for those in need of a financial reboot. So take a deep breath and explore your options—you’ve got this!

I hope you enjoyed this what does bankruptcy protection mean Brandon’s Blog. Do you or your company have too much debt? Are you or your company in need of financial restructuring due to distressed real estate or other reasons? The financial restructuring process is complex. The Ira Smith Team understands how to do a complex restructuring. However, more importantly, we understand the needs of the entrepreneur or someone with too much personal debt.

You are worried because you are facing significant financial challenges. It is not your fault that you are in this situation. You have been only shown the old ways that do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team uses new modern ways to get you out of your debt troubles while avoiding the bankruptcy process. We can get you debt relief freedom using processes that are a bankruptcy alternative.

The stress placed upon you is huge. We understand your pain points. We look at your entire situation and devise a strategy that is as unique as you and your problems; financial and emotional. The way we take the load off of your shoulders and devise a plan, we know that we can help you.

We know that people facing financial problems need a realistic lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” approach with the Ira Smith Team.

That is why we can develop a restructuring process as unique as the financial problems and pain you are facing. If any of this sounds familiar to you and you are serious about finding a solution, contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. team today.

Call us now for a free consultation. We will get you or your company back on the road to healthy stress-free operations and recover from the pain points in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

The information provided in this Brandon’s Blog is intended for educational purposes only. It is not intended to constitute legal, financial, or professional advice. Readers are encouraged to seek professional advice regarding their specific situations. The content of this Brandon’s Blog should not be relied upon as a substitute for professional guidance or consultation. The author, Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. as well as any contributors to this Brandon’s Blog, do not assume any liability for any loss or damage resulting from reliance on the information provided herein.

what does bankruptcy protection mean
what does bankruptcy protection mean
Categories
Brandon Blog Post

THE COMPLETE CORPORATE BANKRUPTCY IN CANADA GUIDE: WHAT EVERY BUSINESS OWNER NEEDS TO KNOW

Corporate bankruptcy in Canada: Introduction

Are you a business owner with company financial difficulties and apprehensive about the possibility of corporate bankruptcy and is it something that you will have to seriously consider? Corporate bankruptcy in Canada process can be complex and overwhelming, but understanding it is necessary for making authoritative decisions about your business.

In this Brandon’s Blog, I will analyze the ins and outs of corporate bankruptcy in Canada, including the different types, the steps in filing for corporate bankruptcy, the impact on creditors and shareholders, and alternatives to consider. By the end of this Brandon’s Blog, you will have a better understanding of corporate bankruptcy in Canada and be able to understand how to make the best decision for your business.

Explanation of what corporate bankruptcy in Canada is

The corporate bankruptcy process in Canada – otherwise known as commercial bankruptcy or incorporate business bankruptcy – is a legal means by which an incorporated business that is unable to pay its debts can be liquidated, and its liabilities discharged. This process allows the business to liquidate its assets and redistribute the value among its creditors. The process is intended to give an honest, but unfortunate corporate debtor a discharge from most debts while ending the business of that corporation.

It is important to note that corporate bankruptcy is different from personal bankruptcy which is a legal process through which an insolvent individual can substantially reduce debt and hopefully restructure. Unlike an individual who files for personal bankruptcy, it is not intended that the bankrupt corporation will come out of bankruptcy through a discharge process.

If single individuals are operating businesses and are considering business bankruptcy, then we are talking about the bankruptcies of sole proprietorships. If more than one person is operating a business partnership, then we need to think of the issues in a partnership bankruptcy. Either way, we have insolvent persons, which means personal bankruptcy, which is not the subject of this Brandon’s Blog.

It’s important to note that the process of corporate bankruptcy in Canada is complex and can only be handled by a licensed insolvency trustee. The Trustee will help you understand the process and the options available to your corporation and then prepare the documents required to submit the bankruptcy filing.

In Canada, if a corporation is bankrupt, it is subject to both the federal Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (“BIA”) and relevant provincial regulations. The BIA outlines the procedure for managing a corporate bankruptcy, while provincial law governs other aspects of the business such as labour laws.

business bankruptcy in canada
corporate bankruptcy in canada

A brief overview of how the process of corporate bankruptcy in Canada begins

Navigating corporate bankruptcy in Canada can be complicated, as there are numerous steps that need to be taken. To begin, it is important to consult with a licensed insolvency trustee to review the financial details of the company, including income, profits, liabilities, and any personal guarantees. From there, the next step is to determine the misogynist options.

The board of directors needs to hold a meeting, in order to pass a resolution permitting the corporation to file for bankruptcy. This process is initiated by a director, or the single director, who will then execute the necessary bankruptcy paperwork.

Types of corporate bankruptcy in Canada

There are two types of corporate bankruptcy in Canada: liquidations and reorganizations. Although a reorganization is not an actual bankruptcy, the phrase “bankruptcy protection” is used to describe a formal reorganization. So for the purposes of this Brandon’s Blog, we will consider both as types of bamkruptcy.

The type of corporate bankruptcy in Canada proceedings can often provide a good indication as to whether the unsecured creditors will get all, a portion, or none of what they are owed.

business bankruptcy in canada
corporate bankruptcy in canada

An overview of the 2 types of bankruptcy proceedings available to Canadian businesses

Liquidation

The process of corporate bankruptcy involves a business ceasing operations as it is unable to fulfill its financial obligations and the demand for its goods and services has become obsolete. This form of corporate bankruptcy is commonly referred to as liquidation.

Canadian bankruptcy proceedings must adhere to Canadian bankruptcy law under the BIA. This law contains similar liquidations to Chapter 7 of the U.S. Bankruptcy Code. Commencing the process of bankruptcy liquidation in Canada is the initial step.

It all starts with the board of directors of the corporation getting together and deciding to file for bankruptcy. One of the directors, or a single director, will then have to sign the official documents for the bankruptcy process.

Once the liquidation process has been initiated, the corporation’s assets, subject to the rights of any creditor having security over all or some of the assets, are taken over by the Trustee. The Trustee will sell the corporate assets and the proceeds will be distributed among the creditors according to the priority established by law. The corporation will then be laid to rest, as it will no longer operate as a legal entity.

Reorganization

Corporate reorganization is one of the alternatives to bankruptcy. It is a process in which a process for a company that is facing financial difficulties is able to restructure its outstanding debt and its operations in order to improve its financial situation. In Canada, the primary statutes for corporate reorganization are the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA) and the BIA. These laws are similar reorganizations under Chapter 11 of the U.S. Bankruptcy Code.

The CCAA provides a thoroughfare of debt reorganization for corporations on a larger scale, as the amount owed by the company must exceed $5 million. Through this federal legislation, the debtor corporation can still operate while reaching an approved plan of arrangement with its creditors.

For corporations that do not reach this $5 million threshold, the Division I Proposal under the BIA can be utilized. The BIA provides for the restructuring of insolvent corporations and individuals.

The CCAA is a federal statute that allows for the sale of an insolvent business, with a reach that transcends the wideness of the whole Canadian nation and even extends beyond its borders.

The process of corporate reorganization under either the CCAA or BIA begins with the corporation filing for protection under the appropriate Act. In the case of the CCAA, the filing is with the court. Under the BIA, the filing is with the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy Canada.

The debtor will then be safeguarded with all its possessions. Then, the corporation will be allotted a specified value of time – typically 30 to 45 days – to present a plan of arrangement. This plan must be approved by the creditors and the court in order to move forward. When the plan of arrangement is given the thumbs up, it can be set into motion.

So corporate reorganization in Canada is a process in which a company that is viable but is facing financial difficulties is allowed to restructure its business debts and operations in order to modernize its financial situation. The CCAA is mainly used for larger corporations and the BIA for smaller ones. Both legislations provide a process to restructure a company while under the protection of the court and it’s intended to be a way to save a company while protecting the rights of the creditors.

Advantages and disadvantages of corporate bankruptcy in Canada

Liquidation

Advantages of corporate liquidation using corporate bankruptcy in Canada:

  • Allows an incorporated entity that is unable to pay its debts to file for bankruptcy, as per the BIA.
  • Allows for the liquidation of resources and redistribution of that value among creditors, which can provide relief for the corporation and its creditors.

Disadvantages to bankruptcy and corporate liquidation using corporate bankruptcy in Canada:

  • The Canada Business Corporations Act (CBCA) prevents a company in bankruptcy from seeking dissolution under the CBCA.
  • Unfortunately, specific liabilities or obligations of the corporation are passed to its directors. This would put personal assets at risk.
  • The process is time-consuming and may also be expensive.
  • Unfortunately, the director’s reputation may moreover be tarnished in the process.

Reorganization

Advantages of reorganization under corporate bankruptcy in Canada:

  • Can uplift profits and increase efficiency.
  • Can extend the life of the business.
  • Can modernize strategy and financial arrangements.
  • Could be done informally without a court process by agreement between the debtor and its creditors or formally under either a proposal as outlined in part III of the BIA or a plan of arrangement under the CCAA.

Disadvantages of reorganization under corporate bankruptcy in Canada:

  • It may not work.
  • Decreased employee morale and concern among customers.
  • Can be a significant time investment with potential setbacks in cash flow
  • If the financial matters are so dire that a reorganization is not viable, the remaining option is full bankruptcy, which results in the liquidation of resources to pay creditors.

    business bankruptcy in canada
    corporate bankruptcy in canada

Filing a voluntary assignment into bankruptcy for corporate bankruptcy in Canada

Overview of steps involved in filing for Corporate Bankruptcy in Canada

  • Finding a Licensed Insolvency Trustee (formerly called a trustee in bankruptcy) (LIT) and retaining the LIT to make an informed decision about proceeding with bankruptcy.
  • One of the directors (or sole director) will be required to execute corporate bankruptcy papers
    Upon bankruptcy assignment, the LIT will notify business creditors of the bankruptcy proceeding.
  • Hold a meeting of creditors.
  • Conduct a sale of assets.
  • Carry out its other duties in accordance with the BIA.

Note: The above steps are a general outline and the specific process may vary depending on the case. It’s advisable to seek guidance from a licensed insolvency trustee and a legal professional to ensure compliance with the laws and regulations.

Essential paperwork and information

In order to file a voluntary assignment for corporate bankruptcy in Canada, and get to the point of holding the First Meeting of Creditors, the following documentation and information are typically required:

  1. Provide the LIT with the corporate minute book, seal and accounting records.
  2. Fully signed minutes of a validly held meeting of directors resolving that the corporation file an assignment in bankruptcy and appointing either a director or senior management person to be the Designated Officer to sign all bankruptcy documents and attend the First Meeting of Creditors.
  3. A completed Voluntary Assignment of the corporate debtor, prepared by the LIT and signed by the Designated Officer.
  4. The LIT prepared statement of affairs, reviewed, approved and sworn/confirmed by the Designated Officer, which includes information about the debtor’s assets and the names and addresses of all known creditors and the amounts owing to each of them.
  5. The LIT will take the necessary steps to lodge the paperwork with the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy, who in turn will give the Certificate of Bankruptcy – marking the very beginning of bankruptcy proceedings in Canada. The moment the Certificate is issued will be the exact time the corporate bankruptcy in Canada is activated.
  6. The LIT then prepares the statutory notice to creditors which is mailed to all known creditors with a notice of the time and place of the First Meeting of Creditors will be held and also includes a proof of claim form for the creditors to complete fully and file with the LIT.
  7. The LIT will also prepare the bankruptcy notice to be placed in a local newspaper to advertise for creditors to contact the Trustee.
  8. The LIT prepares its Report on Preliminary Administration to provide necessary information to the creditors about the causes of the corporate bankruptcy in Canada, the available assets to be sold, if any and other important information. The LIT’s report is distributed at the First Meeting of Creditors.

In a voluntary assignment, the LIT is picked by the debtor. In an involuntary assignment, the LIt is suggested to and chosen by the court. In issuing the Certificate, the LIT choice is confirmed by the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy. However, it is ultimately up to the creditors attending and voting at the First Meeting of Creditors to either confirm the appointment of the LIT or substitute the LIT with another one (don’t worry about the mechanics for now!). The LIT will be responsible for overseeing the administration of the debtor’s estate and distributing the proceeds to creditors.

It’s important to note that the above list is not exhaustive and additional documentation and information may be required by the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy(OSB) or the appointed Trustee. It’s recommended to seek professional advice from a LIT, a lawyer or both, before filing for a voluntary assignment in bankruptcy.

The OSB plays an important part in the area of insolvency

The OSB is tasked with keeping orderly standards for the supervisory oversight of stakeholders within the insolvency process, creating an accessible archive of public records, compiling and analyzing data, and enforcing the BIA and CCAA regulations. Furthermore, the OSB is devoted to facilitating an effective and efficient insolvency framework in Canada.

The OSB in Canada is responsible for the supervision and regulation of the Canadian insolvency system, and overseeing the administration of all insolvency proceedings described as bankruptcies, commercial reorganizations, Division I commercial proposals, consumer proposals and receiverships.

The effects of corporate bankruptcy in Canada on creditors and stockholders

How corporate bankruptcy affects the distribution of assets among creditors

Divvying up resources among those owed money in a corporate bankruptcy in Canada can be quite intricate and can be affected by various elements, such as the kind of bankruptcy declared and the company’s ownership and organizational setup.

When a company files for bankruptcy, its day-to-day operations will typically come to a halt. All of the corporation’s assets will be sold off and the proceeds will be divided among its creditors. In Canada, this process can have a major impact on how the assets are divided up among those who are owed money.

The BIA requires the LIT to take control of all the unencumbered assets, sell them and assigns orders of importance to the many claims against the debtor. The net sale proceeds are then doled out to creditors depending on the priority of the claims.

In a nutshell, the types of creditors and the order of priority is:

  • Trust claims, including unremitted employee payroll withholdings.
  • Secured lenders.
  • Preference is given to certain kinds of unsecured debt.
  • Ordinary unsecured creditors are last.

In Canada, though the assets of a company are distinct from the owners’ individual wealth, banks will always take security on the company’s assets when loaning funds and anticipate the entrepreneur to provide some kind of collateral. It bears mentioning that this is a standard requirement.

Should the proceeds of the company assets fail to cover the bank debt in the event of a Canadian bankruptcy, the owners will be called upon to make good on their personal liability and may be faced with the liquidation of some or all of their personal belongings to make up the difference.

What sort of ramifications does corporate bankruptcy in Canada have on the equity holders and their privileges?

Generally, when it comes to bankruptcy proceedings, it’s usually shareholders who are left holding the shorter end of the stick. Most often, they don’t get anything back after all other creditors have been taken care of– leaving them with nothing but the realization that their investments have gone down the drain. Furthermore, they forfeit any rights they once held with the company.

If any of the shareholders are also in a director position, then they will have the added worry about whether there are any debts that are also a director liability. Legal advice is always required by directors of an insolvent company. In next week’s Bradon’s Blog, I will talk about recent developents arising from an Ontario court decision about the directing mind of a bankrupt corporation.

The one small solace they may have is that Canada Revenue Agency will acknowledge the corporate bankruptcy in Canada as a legitimate means of allowing shareholders to deduct the value of their shares as a loss on their tax return.

business bankruptcy in canada
corporate bankruptcy in canada

Alternatives to Corporate Bankruptcy in Canada

For a business that is viable yet unable to pay off its debts, there are 5 alternatives to corporate bankruptcy in Canada that must be explored:

  1. Implement tighter controls over spending and create a cash-flow budget to see if costs can be cut or eliminated, freeing up funds to pay off debts.
  2. Refinance existing debt in order to consolidate it into more manageable payments.
  3. The shareholders provide a fresh injection of funds.
  4. Informal out-of-court debt settlement through direct negotiation with creditors.
  5. Selling redundant or no longer-needed assets to raise cash for debt repayment.

Rather than going through the effort of reorganizing debt under the CCAA or BIA, a corporate workout is an amicable arrangement between the company and its creditors that allows them to come to a mutually-satisfactory resolution without resorting to legal proceedings and a reorganization court case. This is seen as an advantageous alternative to a formal filing.

If all other solutions fail to prevent a company in Canada from going bankrupt, then the CCAA or BIA’s restructuring provisions should be carefully considered to potentially save the company, its jobs and business assets.

If the company is not viable or profitable and is in a state of financial distress, then a secured lender can exercise their rights through a receivership process. This could be used in conjunction with a corporate bankruptcy in Canada if the situation calls for that.
The reasons why bankruptcy and receivership may be needed to work in tandem are complex and are best left as a topic for another day.

Corporate bankruptcy in Canada: Conclusion

I hope you enjoyed this corporate bankruptcy in Canada Brandon’s Blog.

Revenue and cash flow shortages are critical issues facing entrepreneurs and their companies and businesses. Are you now worried about just how you or your business are going to survive? Those concerns are obviously on your mind. Coming out of the pandemic, we are now worried about its economic effects of inflation and a potential recession.

The Ira Smith Team understands these concerns. More significantly, we know the requirements of the business owner or the individual that has way too much financial debt. You are trying to manage these difficult financial problems and you are understandably anxious.

It is not your fault you can’t fix this problem on your own. The pandemic has thrown everyone a curveball. We have not been trained to deal with this. You have only been taught the old ways. The old ways do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team makes use of new contemporary ways to get you out of your debt problems while avoiding bankruptcy. We can get you debt relief now.

We have helped many entrepreneurs and their insolvent companies who thought that consulting with a trustee and receiver meant their company would go bankrupt. On the contrary. We helped turn their companies around through financial restructuring.

We look at your whole circumstance and design a strategy that is as distinct as you are. We take the load off of your shoulders as part of the debt settlement strategy we will draft just for you.

We understand that people facing money problems require a lifeline. That is why we can establish a restructuring procedure for you and end the discomfort you feel.

Call us now for a no-cost consultation. We will listen to the unique issues facing you and provide you with practical and actionable ideas you can implement right away to end the pain points in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

corporate bankruptcy in canada
business bankruptcy in canada

 

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

CORPORATE BANKRUPTCY FAQ: USE OUR HACK TO SOLVE YOUR CHALLENGING INSOLVENT COMPANY ISSUES

Corporate bankruptcy: An overview

Corporate bankruptcy is a legal process by which businesses can reorganize their financial affairs or liquidate their assets. Although bankruptcy can be complicated and stressful, it can provide businesses with a fresh start.

When it does happen, the corporate bankruptcy process can be complicated. Insolvency can take a toll on your company’s employees, customers, and shareholders. A solid understanding of corporate bankruptcy can help you properly restructure and reorganize your company using an insolvency process without killing your business.

Last week, I gave my best FAQ answers to common questions about personal bankruptcy services. A business partnership or sole proprietorship means that the individual(s) operate the business in their personal name. Answers about business bankruptcies for those forms of business would fall under the personal bankruptcy process that was covered in last week’s personal bankruptcy FAQ blog.

When a corporation conducts business, some of the questions, and answers, are different. In this Brandon’s Blog, I answer the most frequently asked questions about corporate bankruptcy.

Can a business declare corporate bankruptcy?

As stated previously, only a corporation can declare corporate bankruptcy. A corporation is its own legal entity. A “person” is eligible for relief under federal bankruptcy law. A “person” is typically defined in the Canadian bankruptcy legislation to include an individual, part of a partnership, a proprietorship, a company, an unincorporated association, a cooperative society, or a cooperative organization.corporate bankruptcy canada

What are the different types of corporate bankruptcy in Canada?

There are 2 different types of bankruptcy that a company can file for under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act Canada (BIA). They are:

  1. Liquidation: This is when the insolvent company is unable to pay its debts and its business is no longer viable. The only real option for it is to sell off its assets to repay its secured creditors and unsecured creditors as best as possible since it files for bankruptcy in the priority outlined in the BIA.
  2. Restructuring: This is when the company is insolvent and is incapable to repay its debts due to its financial difficulties, yet all or a sufficient portion of the company’s business is still viable. So, the company negotiates brand-new terms with creditors to lower its financial obligations and also might have the ability to sell some assets to settle its financial debts. Restructuring is the most well-known alternative to bankruptcy. Restructuring under insolvency legislation is also described in the media as bankruptcy protection.

What factors lead to corporate bankruptcy proceedings?

A company always shows signs of trouble before it needs to file for corporate bankruptcy. Some of the early danger signals are:

  • continued history of losses;
  • dwindling cash position;
  • the departure of key management or employees;
  • difficulty meeting loan or lease obligations;
  • the breaking of loan covenants; and
  • difficulty meeting payroll.

Corporate bankruptcy: What does it mean for a company when it liquidates?

As stated above, when a company liquidates it means that the company is unable to pay its debts and its business is no longer viable. The only real option for it is to sell off its assets to repay secured creditors and unsecured creditors as best as possible through bankruptcy and then shut down.corporate bankruptcy canada

What happens to debt in corporate bankruptcy?

If the purpose of the corporate bankruptcy is to shut down and have liquidation of business assets, then we first need to see what the net proceeds of sale from those assets are. The BIA describes the order in which funds must be distributed by a licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a bankruptcy trustee) in bankruptcy. The order in which the debts must be repaid, in whole or in part, is called the priority.

The priority of the rights of creditors to be repaid in a corporate bankruptcy is:

  1. Trust and deemed trust claimants – These are parties whose property is being held or is deemed to be held in trust for them by the bankrupt corporation. The most common type of deemed trust claim in a corporate bankruptcy is Canada Revenue Agency for unremitted employee source deductions.
  2. Secured creditors – Creditors who hold valid security over the assets of the company get paid next. There could be more than just one secured creditor. Within the secured creditor group, the order of priority is based on the ranking of the security registration dates.
  3. Preferred creditors – These are unsecured creditors who have been given certain priority in a corporate bankruptcy under federal bankruptcy laws. The most common examples in a corporate bankruptcy would be Trustee fees, the Trustee’s lawyer’s fee, the levy payable to the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy Canada on any distribution made by the Trustee to a creditor and certain salary, wages or commissions due to employees.
  4. Ordinary unsecured creditors – This group comes after the preferred creditors. They are all creditors who have supplied goods or services and do not hold any security and do not fit into the definition of a preferred creditor.

The balance of any unpaid debt ends up getting written off on the books of the creditors because there are no assets left in the company to claim against.

How does a company get into corporate bankruptcy and what happens to the company?

The way a company gets into bankruptcy is the exact same way an individual can. For a liquidation, either the company can file a voluntary assignment into bankruptcy. If it is one or more creditors owed at least $1,000 trying to push the company into bankruptcy, then they would file a Bankruptcy Application with the court requesting the court to make a Bankruptcy Order.corporate bankruptcy canada

Why might a company choose to file for corporate bankruptcy protection and restructure under a BIA proposal?

Corporate bankruptcy protection and restructuring under a BIA proposal can provide a company with financial difficulties a much-needed relief and a chance to return to profitability. When a company files for protection, the BIA proposal offers an orderly and reliable process for restructuring, which can be appealing to businesses that have a good chance of a turnaround.

A corporation that has a viable business and can return to profitability after restructuring, with support from creditors, has all the right ingredients for a successful restructuring. This is why a company might choose to file for corporate bankruptcy protection and restructure under a BIA proposal. The company will survive and jobs will be saved.

Who is responsible for developing the reorganization plan for the company?

Reorganization is the restructuring of a business to gain efficiency, improve workflow, and drive profits. Reorganization plans vary in length and detail and take a certain period of time to properly develop. They generally describe desired outcomes and final goals. Sometimes a company will undergo a complete reorganization, while other plans focus on aspects that require reorganization, such as a business unit or department.

The reorganization plan of a company is essential to ensure its smooth transition. The reorganization plan involves restructuring various departments of the business, reducing operational costs, and streamlining the workflow. Writing a reorganization plan requires a lot of time, effort, and money.

When a business downsizes, it reduces its workforce to a smaller number. Such a reduction can be a painful process that even threatens to collapse the business. The company needs to have a plan in place to accomplish this reorganization while still running the business. When downsizing occurs, businesses require reorganization plans. Involving and informing employees of the process makes them more likely to follow new plans and less resistant to change.

All of the various individual department organization plans and product sales plans need to be combined into an overall business plan. This overall business plan must also include financial information to show how the company, emerging from restructuring, will operate profitably.

Now that the overall plan is set, senior management must work with its outside financial and legal restructuring professionals to establish the restructuring commercial proposal or plan of arrangement to be presented to the creditors to be voted upon. An excellent communication program must be put into place so that creditors can understand the benefits to them of supporting and voting in favour of the restructuring proposal. Normally negotiations with certain creditors or creditor groups must take place in order to come up with a final and successful restructuring plan that will gain both creditor support and pass through the legal proceedings of court approval.corporate bankruptcy canada

What becomes of a corporation after corporate bankruptcy?

Going through corporate bankruptcy means your company’s assets have been sold to pay off some portion of its debts. Bankruptcy also by operation of law terminates all of the employees. So the corporation is left with no assets and no employees. All it has is debt and a deficit equal to the total debt less the amount that is shown on the balance sheet for the company’s preferred and common stock.

Therefore, the corporation, as a legal entity, is then left to just float away into the stratosphere. There are only 2 ways that a company can survive a corporate bankruptcy:

  • from the sale of the corporate assets, pay off 100% of all of its business debt plus interest; or
  • file a BIA proposal, obtain creditor support and court approval and successfully complete it.

The first way will almost never happen. The second way can happen if there is a good reason to try to make sure that the corporation as a legal entity survives. A reason for doing this might be that there is value to the shares. After becoming bankrupt, a successfully completed proposal annuls the bankruptcy. By definition, the proposal will discharge all of the company’s outstanding debt. The company is now debt-free.

The common stock may have value because it is a public company and the shares can be relisted on the stock exchange. Now the corporate shell is attractive to a private company that wishes to go public and can do so by amalgamating with this public shell. Alternatively in a private company, or in a public company, there may be significant tax loss carryforwards available for use if this corporate shell is merged with the right kind of profitable company. the only way to use the tax losses is first by owning all the shares.

This is all possible, but, the normal outcome for a company that has gone through a corporate bankruptcy is just to fade away, never to be heard from again.

When a company declares corporate bankruptcy, what will happen to your stock or bond?

When you invest money in a company by investing your capital, your money is legally represented by the stock or bonds that you purchased. When you see a company declaring bankruptcy, it means the company can no longer afford to pay its debts.

If a company just liquidates its assets during corporate bankruptcy, the existing shares will likely be worth very little or nothing at all. For a private company, a successful corporate restructuring might increase the value of the shares as the company will emerge from its restructuring with much less debt than before.

The value of a company’s shares is most likely to lower if it effectively restructures its financial affairs. It might have to issue brand-new stock to creditors that will not be paid back in full, watering down the value of the business’s shares.

As far as corporate bonds are they secured or unsecured against the company’s assets? If secured, they could be repaid in whole or in part depending on where they stand in the secured assets pecking order. If unsecured, then it just becomes part of the larger unsecured creditor pool. In a corporate bankruptcy that is a liquidation, those bondholders will receive their share of any distribution made by the Trustee to the ordinary unsecured creditors if there is such a distribution made.

Corporate bankruptcy and insolvency at a glance

In conclusion, bankruptcy and insolvency of course go together, although many people prefer to think of bankruptcy as an economic failure while insolvency is more accurately a sign of a business’s financial failings.

In the same way I hoped last week’s personal bankruptcy blog helped your understanding, I hope this Brandon’s Blog on corporate bankruptcy was helpful to you in understanding more about the corporate bankruptcy system in Canada.

If you or your company has too heavy a debt load, we understand how you feel. You’re stressed out and anxious because you can’t fix your or your company’s financial situation on your own. But don’t worry. As a government-licensed insolvency professional firm, we can help you get your personal or corporate finances back on track.

If you’re struggling with money problems, call the Ira Smith Team today. We’ll work with you to develop a personalized plan to get you back on track and stress-free, all while avoiding the bankruptcy process if at all possible.

Call us today and get back on the path to a healthy stress-free life.

CLICK HERE TO GET THE FREE HOW TO CLOSE YOUR BUSINESS WITHOUT BANKRUPTCY OFFER
corporate bankruptcy canada

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

DECLARING BANKRUPTCY: REAL ESTATE COMPANY LOSES CHALLENGE ON CORPORATE BANKRUPTCY APPEAL

Declaring bankruptcy: Business insolvency

When the corporate finances are such that the business has an insufficient cash flow to cover its operating expenses and pay its debts when they come due, these financial difficulties create the financial condition of insolvency for the business. Another indicator of insolvency often exists at the same time: if you were to sell all of the company’s assets, you would not be able to raise enough money to pay off its outstanding debt.

Medcap Real Estate Holdings Inc. (Medcap) is an Ontario corporation that owns certain commercial real estate. Medcap’s principal, through other companies which he owns or controls, operates various fitness facilities.

Several creditors made a bankruptcy application to the Court to wind up Medcap’s business through a corporate bankruptcy. In December 2021, the Judge released his decision to issue a bankruptcy order and place the company in the legal position of bankruptcy. Medcap appealed the decision to the Court of Appeal for Ontario.

In this Brandon’s Blog, I discuss the two ways there are for declaring bankruptcy and highlight the reasoning of the Court of Appeal for Ontario in dismissing this company’s appeal for its corporate bankruptcy.

Declaring bankruptcy: An overview of corporate bankruptcy

In Canada, a company is a separate legal entity from its shareholders or Directors and Officers. So a company can go into corporate bankruptcy, as opposed to a person entering personal bankruptcy, also known as consumer bankruptcy. There are two ways a company (or a person) can go bankrupt.

The first way is that a company (or person) files for bankruptcy by filing an assignment in bankruptcy with a licensed insolvency trustee. This is called a voluntary assignment into bankruptcy. The second way, which is what happened to Medcap, is that they are pushed into bankruptcy.

To push a limited company (person) into bankruptcy, one or more creditors, each owed at least $1,000, make a bankruptcy application to the court. The application will include a sworn affidavit from the people with knowledge of the situation providing evidence as to why the company (the person) is insolvent, what acts of bankruptcy the business (person) committed within 6 months preceding the date of the application and requesting that a bankruptcy order be made against the debtor.

Regardless of the types of bankruptcy proceedings that may be involved, these are the only two ways for companies with crippling debt to become bankrupt. It is either voluntary or an involuntary one.

declaring bankruptcy
declaring bankruptcy

Declaring bankruptcy: Types of Corporate Bankruptcy

A company that ends up declaring bankruptcy may be doing so for a variety of reasons, all of which relate to significant financial losses. In Canada, there are two primary types of bankruptcy filings under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA).

Once the company is insolvent and no longer viable, declaring bankruptcy in order to have liquidation of assets and end the business in that legal entity is the next step. In this situation, there may be certain business debts that are also a personal liability of the corporate Directors. Unremitted source deductions and HST and unpaid wages and vacation pay fall into this category.

Bankruptcy is a tricky topic. Many people tend to fear it, thinking of it as the end of the road. Given my description above of bankruptcy being for liquidating the company assets, that is understandable.

But what about the company that is insolvent but the business is very viable if the bad parts are cut out? In this kind of situation, filing under the BIA using the restructuring provisions of this federal statute, or for larger companies, the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA), is a legal way for the company to restructure its debts to get its finances back in order. In a successful restructuring, the good parts of the business are restructured and preserved, the company’s finances are right-sized and most if not all jobs are saved. This form of declaring bankruptcy is what is referred to in the media as bankruptcy protection.

So in Canada, declaring bankruptcy is one type, but declaring bankruptcy protection is also possible. That is why I suggest in Canada, there are 2 types of business-specific options in corporate bankruptcy filings.

Declaring bankruptcy: Does corporate bankruptcy affect personal assets?

The legal separation of personal and corporate assets is clear. However, a company declaring bankruptcy may have an impact on the personal assets of certain people. There are situations where personal assets may be at risk. If you are concerned about your personal assets, you should consult with a legal professional to assess your individual case.

Before making any business or investment decisions, is when you should get that professional advice. Once a corporate bankruptcy filing has been made, it will be too late to properly plan for that situation. Personal assets could be at risk if it is a bankruptcy liquidation and not a successful restructuring.

Examples of when personal assets may be at risk because of business bankruptcies include:

  • the entrepreneur who had to give a personal guarantee of certain corporate debt financial obligations to the company’s primary secured creditor lender and in a liquidation of the company’s assets, the lender suffers a shortfall;
  • there is not enough money left over from the liquidation after any trust claims and secured creditor claims to pay the outstanding wages and vacation pay so the Directors’ personal assets may be at risk;
  • the liquidation value of the assets is essentially zero so the Directors are called upon by Canada Revenue Agency to repay any unremitted employee source deductions or HST amounts;
  • in bankruptcy liquidation, there is generally nothing available to repay investors or shareholders so the money an individual investor or shareholder loses certainly affects their personal assets and personal property. The stock of companies that liquidated their assets after declaring bankruptcy is worthless; and
  • any creditors that are unincorporated, being either a proprietorship or partnership who lose some or all of the amounts owed to them as ordinary unsecured creditors clearly affect the personal assets of those business owners.

Declaring bankruptcy: The Medcap case

With this discussion of corporations declaring bankruptcy, there are some interesting points to be learned from the Medcap appeal case and the bankruptcy process. The application judge dismissed the bankruptcy applications of all but one of the applicants. He issued the bankruptcy order and appointed the licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a trustee in bankruptcy or bankruptcy trustee) which began Medcap’s administration of bankruptcy.

The Medcap company appealed the bankruptcy order on only one ground; the judge who made the original order failed to exercise his discretion on whether or not to dismiss the application. Medcap did not appeal the application judge’s finding that the prerequisites to the making of a bankruptcy order – a debt owing to an applicant of at least $1,000 and the commission of an act of bankruptcy within six months of the commencement of the application – had been met!

The most interesting part of the Court of Appeal’s decision is the discussion of the two factors that a court could look at where a judge could exercise discretion to justify refusing an otherwise proven bankruptcy application.

declaring bankruptcy
declaring bankruptcy

Declaring bankruptcy: Appealing a bankruptcy order

As mentioned previously, Medcap did not contest the judge’s conclusion that the creditor whose bankruptcy application was allowed had met the requirements under s. 43(1) of the BIA. This is that Medcap owed them a debt exceeding $1,000 and that Medcap committed an act of bankruptcy within 6 months before the filing of that bankruptcy application.

The application judge found that Medcap had failed to pay that creditor’s debt, for which a judgment was issued, despite demands. This is defined as an act of bankruptcy in s. 42(1)(j) of the BIA. In its appeal, the Medcap company argued that, even though the debt and the act of bankruptcy were proven, the application judge made a mistake by not using his discretionary power under s. 43(7) of the BIA to dismiss the application.

Medcap made three arguments to support its appeal: (i) that the trial judge erred in finding that Medcap was unable to pay its debts; (ii) that he erred in finding that the application was brought for an improper motive; and (iii) that he erred in finding that the bankruptcy order would serve no purpose.

Let’s see what the Court of Appeal for Ontario said about this.

Declaring bankruptcy: Unable to pay its debts

This is the first of the three bankruptcy issues that the Court of Appeal looked at. Medcap argued that the application judge dismissed the applications of all applicants but one because there was potential that they were not creditors. Medcap also stated that the application judge had not taken into account that Medcap had reached a settlement with the one creditor whose application was allowed to be heard. Medcap submitted that the application judge erred in not taking this into account as there was no debt owing because of the settlement and the payment of that settlement.

The appellate court found that the lower court judge did not err in rejecting Medcap’s argument. An application for bankruptcy is not solely for the benefit of the applicant creditor, but for the rights of creditors, ALL creditors. Further, the arrangements between the applicant creditor and the debtor will not be able to justify the withdrawal or dismissal of a bankruptcy application, unless the court is satisfied that the debtor is solvent and that other creditors will not be prejudiced by the withdrawal or dismissal.

To be able to pay debts as set out in the BIA, the evidence must be provided for all debts owed, as well as the debtor’s ability to pay them. In other words, the debtor must prove that they are solvent. Medcap did not provide such evidence. Therefore this ground of appeal was dismissed.

Declaring bankruptcy: Bankruptcy application for improper motives

Medcap argued that in cases where a creditor has an ulterior motive for filing a bankruptcy application, this can be sufficient cause for dismissal of the application. The Court of Appeal said that the existence of a motive is a question of fact, and the application judge considered and rejected the suggestion that there was such a motive in this case.

The Court of Appeal found that the application judge was within his rights to reject the argument based on the record. Therefore, the Court of Appeal for Ontario found no justification to interfere and dismissed the appeal on that ground.declaring bankruptcy

Declaring bankruptcy: There is no purpose for this bankruptcy

Medcap argued that the application judge erred in failing to find that no purpose would be served by bankruptcy. He ought to have dismissed the application on the basis that there was nothing to be gained by making a bankruptcy order.

The Court of Appeal emphasized that safeguarding creditors is crucial to insolvency proceedings. A debtor who has (a) committed an act of bankruptcy by not paying debts when they come due, and (b) failed to provide evidence to the court demonstrating the ability to do so, carries the burden of proving that bankruptcy would be pointless. The judge was correct in finding that Medcap had not met that burden.

The three-panel judge went on to say that, in order to demonstrate that there is no purpose for the Medcap bankruptcy, they would need to show that a better result would be achieved for creditors if it were allowed time to restructure under the commercial proposal provisions of the BIA or the provisions of the CCAA.

Medcap did not argue that doing either would have the requisite creditor support but rather suggested that leaving it up to them would be best.

The three appellate court judges hearing this case unanimously rejected Medcap’s appeal, upholding the lower court’s ruling and allowing the bankruptcy process legal proceedings to continue. At this point, the licensed trustee named in the bankruptcy order begins administering the bankruptcy legal process.

Declaring bankruptcy: The final word

What fascinated me most about this case was the nerve of Medcap to argue that the application judge should have declined to make the bankruptcy order, regardless of all the evidence against it.

The Court of Appeal for Ontario soundly rejected the appeal of the bankruptcy order being issued after analyzing the bankruptcy application process in Canada. It concluded that only a real possibility of a successful restructuring under either the BIA or CCAA to avoid bankruptcy liquidation would be a reason to do so.

I hope this Brandon’s Blog on the Medcap case was helpful to you in understanding more about declaring bankruptcy, corporate bankruptcy and how the Ontario court would decide if it was appropriate to issue a bankruptcy order. Hopefully, you have also gained insight into how a corporate bankruptcy decision is made and how a successful corporate bankruptcy protection filing and restructuring can be beneficial.

We understand how you feel. You’re stressed out and anxious because you can’t fix your or your company’s financial situation on your own. But don’t worry. As a government-licensed insolvency professional firm, we can help you get your personal or corporate finances back on track.

If you’re struggling with money problems, call the Ira Smith Team today. We’ll work with you to develop a personalized plan to get you back on track and stress-free, all while avoiding the bankruptcy process if at all possible.

Call us today and get back on the path to a healthy stress-free life.

declaring bankruptcy
declaring bankruptcy
Call a Trustee Now!