Tag: trustee in bankruptcy

THE CANADIAN BANKRUPTCY AND INSOLVENCY ACT EASY BEGINNER’S GUIDE

Post author By Brandon Smith
Post date September 23, 2021

We hope that you and your family are safe, healthy and secure during this COVID-19 pandemic.

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

What is in the Canadian Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act?

Canada’s bankruptcy and insolvency laws are governed by two major pieces of federal legislation: the Canadian Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act and the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act. Additionally, provincial legislation intersects with the Canadian Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act. During bankruptcy, a debtor can keep certain types of property based on provincial legislation. Details may differ amongst each Canadian province. Provincial governments and territories have their own laws regarding property exemptions, court orders, and debt collection.

The Canadian Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (often referred to as the “BIA” or the “Bankruptcy Act“) is a federal government statute that sets out the rules and procedures governing insolvency proceedings in Canada. These rules and procedures will apply to all corporations, individuals and partnerships that are parties to an insolvency filing. The whole point of bankruptcy legislation is to allow the honest but unfortunate debtor to shed themselves of their debts and to allow for the sale of assets or reorganization and refinancing of insolvent persons so that there is also fairness for the different claims of creditors.

Under the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA), financially troubled corporations are given the opportunity to restructure their affairs in order to avoid bankruptcy. A corporation must have debts of at least $5 million to qualify for the CCAA.

The Canadian insolvency landscape is a complex one, with many different insolvency proceedings being used to deal with many different types of debtors. In this Brandon Blog, I provide an easy beginner’s guide of the Canadian Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, as a primer into Canadian insolvency legislation and the administration of estates.

This Brandon Blog is not about the nuts and bolts of filing for bankruptcy. Other blogs I have written cover that topic and more. You can use the search function above to search for those Brandon Blog topics.

What is the purpose of the Canadian Bankruptcy & Insolvency Act?

Everyone knows you should do your best to stay out of too much debt, but for many people, it’s an impossible feat. When you’re over your head in debt, you’re having to keep up just to pay the interest on your debt. When you are spending more than you are making, you can’t pay your bills on time, or your assets when liquidated are worth less than your total liabilities, you are insolvent. Insolvency is the main test to see if you, or insolvent companies, qualify to start a bankruptcy process or a formal restructuring process, either under the Canadian Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act or the CCAA.

The Bankruptcy Act was designed to help Canadians who find themselves in financial difficulty. It is the main piece of Canadian insolvency legislation that governs bankruptcy proceedings, receivership and personal and corporate restructuring proceedings through consumer proposals and commercial proposals. Commercial proposals are also available for those people with consumer debt levels greater than the amount allowed to qualify for a consumer proposal. All Canadian bankruptcies, proposals and receiverships are governed by the Act. It contains bankruptcy laws, rules and guidelines for all stakeholders: the Superintendent of Bankruptcy (which is part of Industry Canada) the Licensed Insolvency Trustee, the debtor, and the creditors.

What options are available under the Canadian Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act?

The Canadian Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act provides a number of ways to deal with a financially troubled company or person. Most involve a court-supervised process. The options for a person or business in financial trouble and not able to right themself or itself are:

Consumer proposal

It is an offer to your creditors to repay a portion of your unsecured debt obligations in exchange for their elimination (with certain limited exceptions as laid out in the Bankruptcy Act). You can qualify if you owe $250,000 or less, excluding any debts registered against your home, such as mortgage debt or secured home equity line of credit debt.

A person proposes a plan to make monthly payments to the Licensed Trustee acting as the consumer proposal Administrator. The total amount offered to your unsecured creditors must be agreed upon by them. Within 60 months, you must pay off the entire amount accepted. Creditors typically accept a total payment of 25% or less of your total unsecured debt. Individual situations vary, however.

A successfully completed consumer proposal allows the insolvent person to eliminate their debts and avoid an assignment into bankruptcy.

Commercial proposal

Commercial proposals are also known as Division I proposals. The reason for this is because it is provided under Canadian Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, Part III, Division 1 (consumer proposals are found under Part III Division II). An insolvent corporation or person can use it for restructuring proceedings. When a consumer’s debt exceeds the limits of a consumer proposal, a “commercial proposal” would be filed. If a definitive commercial proposal cannot be immediately prepared but the debtor needs to file in order to invoke the stay of proceedings (discussed in the next section), they can get the immediate protection they need by first filing a Notice of Intention To Make A Proposal.

A commercial proposal works in a very similar way to a consumer proposal, except for some differences as follows:

- A commercial proposal may have various classes of creditors. A consumer proposal normally does not.
- Unlike for a person, there is no streamlined reorganization process for companies. Therefore, even if its debt is $250,000 or less, a company cannot file a consumer proposal.
- A meeting of creditors must be held as part of a commercial proposal. If the Official Receiver (being a representative of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy), doesn’t wish to chair the meeting, it can be delegated to the Trustee. A creditor who has filed a valid proof of claim has voting rights. They have the right to vote ahead of the creditors’ meeting by using a voting letter or in person. An official meeting of creditors is only held in a consumer proposal if 25% of the proven creditors’ claims request one.
- In a consumer proposal, if a meeting is not requested, the consumer proposal is deemed approved and there are no voting rights to be concerned about. If a meeting is requested, then the creditors who attend the meeting can vote by ordinary resolution for the acceptance of the consumer proposal. In a commercial proposal, it is a two-pronged test: 3/4 of the $ value voting AND a majority in the number of those voting.
- If the commercial proposal is voted down, the person or company is immediately deemed to have filed an assignment in bankruptcy. There is no such automatic bankruptcy if a consumer proposal is not accepted.

As soon as the commercial proposal is accepted by the creditors and approved by the court, the debtor starts making the payments promised in the proposal to the Insolvency Trustee. Once full payment has been made, the trustee in bankruptcy will issue to the person or company their Certificate of Full Performance. At this point, all provable claims, regardless of whether they filed a proof of claim or not.

As part of a successful restructuring process, the Trustee will run a claims process, vet every proof of claim to ensure that they are valid and that only an allowable claim is considered for distribution purposes. The Trustee will then comprise a scheme of distribution in order to distribute the funds promised to the creditors in the commercial proposal.

Restructuring under either the Canadian Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act or CCAA becomes possible for companies with debts greater than $5 million.

Receivers and Secured Creditors

Receiverships are remedies for lenders who have loaned money out and taken security over the debtor’s assets. It is most common in Canada for financial institutions to be lenders to Canadian businesses. As long as their loan documents, including the security agreement, allow for it in writing, a secured creditor may appoint a receiver when a debtor defaults on secured debt. Secured creditors and receivers are subject to certain requirements under the Canadian Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act.

Receivership relies both on provincial laws and federal legislation. The Bankruptcy Act specifies several main requirements for receivership, including:

- It is not permissible to enforce a security interest on the business assets of an insolvent person unless the secured creditor has given 10 days prior notice in the prescribed form and manner.
- Only a Licensed Insolvency Trustees (formerly called Trustees in Bankruptcy) can act as a receiver.

The secured creditor can appoint the receiver privately or with court approval.

A private receiver’s primary responsibility is to the secured creditor who appointed it. A court-appointed receiver is an officer of the court who protects the interests of all creditors of the debtor company.

Private receivers usually have from the security documents the power to run the debtor’s business and sell the debtor’s assets through auctions, tenders or private sales.

A court appointment is also preferred over a private appointment when there are significant claims against the debtor or its property as well as litigation or a threat of litigation. It is according to the provincial rules of court and s. 243 of the BIA (National Receiver) that a court may appoint a receiver.

The receivership order normally stays proceedings (discussed below in the next section) against the receiver, the debtor, and its property. In terms of its purpose, it gives the receiver authority to manage the assets of the debtor, to borrow money against the assets to repay a loan, to sell the assets of the debtor with the approval of the court, and to commence and defend litigation on behalf of the debtor. A privately-appointed receiver does not enjoy a stay of proceedings.

Bankruptcy

If a personal or commercial restructuring is not possible, then the insolvent person or company has no choice but to file for bankruptcy. The first step in dealing with insolvency is to consult an insolvency trustee. You can learn about the bankruptcy administration process and your legal rights from Trustees in Bankruptcy so you can make an informed decision. A candid discussion about how much you earn, what assets you own, and what types of debts you have can help you decide if bankruptcy is the best choice for you.

Here is what the Canadian bankruptcy procedure is all about. After the bankruptcy assignment has been completed, the Trustee submits it to the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy Canada. All legal obligations will be handled by the Trustee once the assignment has been filed. Your creditors will no longer receive payments directly from you.

The Trustee administers your bankruptcy. No more lawsuits or wage garnishments for you. Depending on your province’s law, some of your assets will certainly be exempt. The bankruptcy vests your non-exempt assets in the Trustee. The Trustee will sell them. According to the Canadian Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, the proceeds will be for the benefit of the bankrupt estate and there could be a scheme of distribution among your preferred creditors and ordinary unsecured creditors.

In the administration of bankruptcy, the Trustee will send your creditors a notice of bankruptcy. You must attend a creditors’ meeting if one is called. Additionally, you will need to attend two counselling sessions. Canadian insolvency legislation in Canada includes rehabilitation programs to help individuals regain financial stability.

Finally, you may need to make payments toward your debt. “Surplus income payments” ensure that people who declare bankruptcy and have sufficient income contribute to paying back a portion of their debt. Your debts will eventually be discharged, relieving you from the obligation of repaying most of the debt you had on the day you filed for bankruptcy.

Despite the fact that most debts can be discharged, some cannot, namely:

alimony and child support;
court fines and penalties;
debts related to fraud; and some
student loans.

You will suffer credit damage for several years after filing for bankruptcy. After your debt is discharged, you can start rebuilding your credit. Although it’s not ideal, it will lift the burden from your shoulders and solve the debt problems you couldn’t resolve on your own.

Canadian Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act: Can bankruptcy protect you from creditors?

In addition to bankruptcy, any filing listed above under the Canadian Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act will protect you from creditors. In fairness to all stakeholders, the filing calls for a “time out” after which no claims for money, lawsuits, or collection efforts are permitted. In legal jargon, we call this a stay of proceedings.

By virtue of the individual’s bankruptcy or insolvency, you may not terminate, amend, or accelerated pay, or claim the term of any agreement. When an insolvent person files a notice of intention or a proposal, a similar provision is made.

Just like in bankruptcy, if you file a notice of intention or a Division I proposal or Division II proposal, all proceedings automatically stay and no creditor is entitled to take any action against the debtor or to pursue any execution or other proceeding for the recovery of a claim provable.

Commercial proposals are normally worded so that Directors of insolvent companies who have filed notices of intention or proposals enjoy similar protection.

A word on cross-border insolvencies

Many of the large CCAA reorganization filings in recent times have been cross-border insolvencies. Canadian courts prefer that cross-border insolvencies proceed as a single process with one jurisdiction acting as the primary entity. The Canadian court examines whether the Canadian case should be considered the main proceeding in order to determine whether it is significant and connected to Canada.

The other jurisdiction (most often the U.S.) usually recognizes the Canadian court’s authority when the court believes the insolvency action should be handled, for the most part, in Canada. Likewise, the opposite is also true.

Canadian Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act: Personal bankruptcy

Canadian Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act summary

I hope you found this Canadian Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act Brandon Blog informative. With too high household debt levels and not enough wealth, you are insolvent. You can choose from several insolvency processes to get the debt relief that you need and deserve. It may not be necessary for you to file for bankruptcy.

If you or your business are dealing with substantial debt challenges, you need debt help, and you assume bankruptcy is the only option, call me.

If you’re thinking about bankruptcy, you’re probably in a situation where you’re overwhelmed, frightened, and feel like you’re alone. That’s natural and it is not your fault.

It’s good that you’ve come to this site, where you’ll find answers to your questions, sort through your options, and discover that you can get help. You’re not alone, and the professionals at Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. are committed to helping you find a debt solution that’s best for you.

It is not your fault that you remain in this way. You have actually been only shown the old ways to try to deal with financial issues. These old ways do not work anymore.

The Ira Smith Team utilizes new modern-day ways to get you out of your debt difficulties with debt relief options as an alternative to bankruptcy. We can get you the relief you need and so deserve. Our professional advice will create for you a personalized debt-free plan for you or your company during our no-cost initial consultation.

You are under a lot of pressure. Our team knows how you feel. You and your financial and emotional problems will be the focus of a new approach designed specifically for you. With our help, you will be able to blow away the dark cloud over your head. We will design a debt settlement strategy for you. We know that we can help you now.

We understand that people with credit cards maxed out and businesses facing financial issues need a realistic lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” method with the Ira Smith Team. Not everyone has to file bankruptcy in Canada. The majority of our clients never do as we know the alternatives to bankruptcy. We help many people and companies stay clear of filing an assignment in bankruptcy.

Because of this, we can develop a new method for paying down your debt that will be built specifically for you. It will be as unique as the economic problems and discomfort you are experiencing. If any one of these seems familiar to you and you are serious about getting the solution you need to become debt-free, contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. group today.

Call us now for a no-cost consultation.

canadian bankruptcy and insolvency act

We hope that you and your family are safe, healthy and secure during this COVID-19 pandemic.

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

Tags administration of bankruptcy, allowable claims, assignment into bankruptcy, bankruptcy estate, bankruptcy laws, bankruptcy legislation, bankruptcy procedure, bankruptcy proceedings, bankruptcy process, bankruptcy vests, canadian bankruptcy and insolvency act, canadian courts, Canadian insolvency legislation, claims of creditors, claims process, classes of creditors, commercial proposals, commercial restructuring, consumer debt levels, consumer proposals, corporate restructuring proceedings, cross-border insolvencies, debt obligations, debtor company, federal legislation, financial difficulty, insolvency proceedings, insolvent companies, insolvent corporation, Ira Smith Trustee, legal rights, licensed insolvency trustees, notice of inention, official receiver, preferred creditors, proof of claim, provable claims, restructuring proceedings, restructuring process, scheme of distribution, secured creditor, successful restructurings, trustee in bankruptcy, trustees in bankruptcy, types of debts, unfortunate debtor, unsecured creditors, voting rights

Brandon Blog Post

LICENSED INSOLVENCY TRUSTEE VAUGHAN: THE COMPLETE GUIDE FOR YOUR HAPPY DEBT FREE L1FE

Post author By Brandon Smith
Post date August 11, 2021

We hope that you and your family are safe, healthy and secure during this COVID-19 pandemic.

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting. Through the use of video meetings, we can help you even if you do not live close to our office in the Jane Street Hwy. 7 area. It is just like we are coming to you!

The bankruptcy trustee in Vaughan: We transformed into a licensed insolvency trustee Vaughan

The bankruptcy trustee in Vaughan went through a metamorphosis similar to a caterpillar becoming a butterfly. The term “bankruptcy trustee” turned into a “licensed insolvency trustee“. The licensed insolvency trustee designation was mandated to all licensed trustees by the Industry Canada Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy (OSB). The OSB licenses and supervises the activities of all licensed insolvency trustees across Canada. This includes us as a licensed insolvency trustee Vaughan, Ontario.

The purpose of this Brandon blog is to offer an overview of our role in the Greater Toronto Area with our licensed insolvency trustee Vaughan insolvency trustee firm head office.

Role of a Licensed Insolvency Trustee Vaughan (formerly called Trustee in Bankruptcy Vaughan)

A licensed insolvency trustee Vaughan can fulfill various roles. It all starts with providing a no-cost consultation for a person or company that finds themselves in a troubling financial situation that worries them about their prospects for a bright financial future.

Due to the various roles, a licensed insolvency trustee Vaughan can play, we are also known as “receivers”, “trustee in bankruptcy” or “financial restructuring professionals”. We are appointed when a company or person is financially distressed and either has no other options to get out of financial difficulty and is unable to pay its bills. A licensed insolvency trustee is the only party licensed by the Government of Canada to perform a federal government-approved debt settlement plan, being a consumer proposal consolidation.

As a licensed insolvency trustee Vaughan firm, there are different roles we can play.

Find the right option with the help of a Licensed Insolvency Trustee Vaughan

Personal situation insolvency

For individuals who are insolvent, we can provide and act in the following:

A no-cost initial consultation to provide advice about debt relief.
Credit counselling. to help with your household budget and determine if you really need one of the available debt relief options.
Consumer Proposal – Toronto and GTA – Act as Consumer Proposal Administrator to conduct a Consumer Proposal Process for people who owe $250,000 or less in unsecured debts (not including any debts registered against their home) who wish to eliminate their debt and wish an alternative to bankruptcy so that they can avoid filing bankruptcy. This is a government-approved interest-free debt settlement plan that can be paid over as much as five years.
Division I Proposal – Toronto and GTA – This process is not quite as streamlined as a consumer proposal, but it is for people who wish to eliminate their debt while avoiding personal bankruptcy.
These 2 proposal remedies are the only accredited government debt relief programs in Canada.
Personal bankruptcy – Toronto and GTA – As a licensed insolvency trustee Vaughan, we can of course assist anyone who wishes filing for bankruptcy. In your no-cost consultation with us, we first get to know you and your financial situation in order to determine if you qualify for one of the bankruptcy alternatives. If not, we will discuss the entire bankruptcy process with you, including the cost of bankruptcy. If you wish to proceed, we will accept your assignment in bankruptcy.

All collection activities against you cease when you make an assignment in bankruptcy, or file a debt settlement restructuring proposal. Legal action against you may include wage garnishment, collection calls, or a legal action against you. You get legal protection as a result of the stay of proceedings afforded by an insolvency filing.

The two most common types of debt we encounter in our personal insolvency practice are credit card debt and income tax debt. We have successfully handled for clients serious negotiations with Canada Revenue Agency in order to achieve debt settlement for people with a financial history of income tax debt.

Corporate insolvency

For companies, and especially entrepreneurial family businesses that are insolvent, we can provide and act in the following:

A no-cost initial consultation to provide advice about debt restructuring options.
Restructuring & Turnarounds.
Business analysis, business review and monitoring.
Receivership – Toronto and GTA – Only a licensed insolvency trustee can act as a receiver on behalf of a secured creditor. As a licensed insolvency trustee Vaughan, we act as a privately-appointed receiver on behalf of a secured creditor. We also act as a court-appointed receiver upon the application to a court by a secured creditor or other stakeholders.
Winding-Up and Liquidator – Toronto and GTA – For solvent companies that wish to wind up operations through a legal process, we act as either privately appointed or court-appointed Liquidator.
licensed insolvency trustee vaughan

Selecting The Right Licensed Insolvency Trustee in Vaughan

Experience and professionalism

You might not find the expertise to solve your financial difficulties with someone just around the corner. You can start your search for the right Trustee by visiting the website of the Canadian Association of Insolvency and Restructuring Professionals. Both Ira Smith and Brandon Smith are members of the Canadian Insolvency and Restructuring Professional Association. It shows an individual’s commitment to staying up to date with all the latest industry advancements by belonging to this organization. Check the website of the OSB to ensure that the Trustees you are considering are not suspended or under file management by the regulator.

Interacting with them on many levels is essential

As a beginning, they must be able to quickly understand your needs and desires, as well as provide you with a realistic plan that can be followed. If you have issues or concerns, they also need to be available to you. Look for their interest in you. How enthusiastic are they about their industry? Do you really feel their compassion for you? Do you feel you are going to get along on an inter-personal basis with this person?

That’s exactly how you measure enthusiasm. The most effective solutions and suggestions will be offered by a knowledgeable insolvency trustee. You may not find this type of person within walking distance of your home or workplace.

Licensed insolvency trustee Vaughan: Are you able to agree on the same concepts?

It is not a totally free service to engage a professional trustee. The complexity of your situation could affect the bankruptcy cost. Your trust in a bankruptcy trustee is diminished if you feel they view you as just another dollar sign. Look for those who seem to have similar values to you. It may not be the closest to your home to find such a licensed insolvency trustee.

Websites for licensed insolvency trustee Vaughan

Searching for “bankruptcy trustee near me” or “licensed insolvency trustee Vaughan” on a search engine today will bring up various websites to visit. How does the website make you feel? What bankruptcy FAQs do they provide? Can you see pictures of the people you would deal with? From their blog, do they demonstrate that they have a deep knowledge base?

You can meet with more than one Trustee

Unless you sit across the table from him or her, you won’t know which one is the right fit for you. Comparing two bankruptcy trustees is a good idea. You want to be able to compare two or more for your own validation purposes. The one you feel best about is the one to go with. Trust your gut!

3 Best Licensed Insolvency Trustees in Vaughan, ON

Throughout the years my firm has been inspected for 50 points, including reviews, ratings, reputation, history, complaints, satisfaction, trust, cost, and general excellence. The results have allowed us to rank consistently among the top 3 Best Licensed Insolvency Trustees in Vaughan, ON.

Licensed insolvency trustee Vaughan summary

I hope that you found this licensed insolvency trustee Vaughan Brandon Blog helpful in describing our role as debt professionals and my thoughts on how to go about choosing the one you think is the best fit for anyone in a financial crisis. Problems will arise when you are cash-starved and in debt. There are several insolvency processes available to a person or company with too much debt.

If you are concerned because you or your business are dealing with substantial debt challenges, you need debt help and you assume bankruptcy is your only option, call me.

It is not your fault that you remain in this way. You have actually been only shown the old ways to try to deal with financial issues. These old ways do not work anymore.

The Ira Smith Team utilizes new modern-day ways to get you out of your debt difficulties with debt relief options as alternatives to bankruptcy. We can get you the relief you need and so deserve. Our professional advice will create for you a personalized debt-free plan for you or your company during our no-cost initial consultation.

The tension put upon you is big. We know your discomfort factors. We will check out your entire situation and design a new approach that is as unique as you and your problems; financial and emotional. We will take the weight off of your shoulders and blow away the dark cloud hanging over you. We will design a debt settlement strategy for you. We know that we can help you now.

We understand that people with credit cards maxed out and businesses facing financial issues need a realistic lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” method with the Ira Smith Team. Not everyone has to file bankruptcy in Canada. The majority of our clients never do as we know the alternatives to bankruptcy. We help many people and companies stay clear of filing an assignment in bankruptcy.

That is why we can establish a new restructuring procedure for paying down debt that will be built just for you. It will be as one-of-a-kind as the economic issues and discomfort you are encountering. If any one of these seems familiar to you and you are serious about getting the solution you need to become debt-free, contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. group today.

Call us now for a no-cost consultation.

We hope that you and your family are safe, healthy and secure during this COVID-19 pandemic.

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

Tags 3 Best Licensed Insolvency Trustees in Vaughan, accredited government debt relief, advice about debt relief, alternative to bankruptcy, assignment in bankruptcy, bankruptcy alternatives, bankruptcy process, bankruptcy trustee, bankruptcy trustee in vaughan, collection calls, Consumer Proposal, consumer proposal administrator, consumer proposal consolidation, consumer proposal process, corporate insolvency, cost of bankruptcy, credit card debt, credit counselling, debt relief options, debt restructuring options, Division I Proposal, federal government-approved debt settlement plan, filing for bankruptcy, financial difficulty, financial future, financial situation, financially distressed, Find the right option with the help of a Licensed Insolvency Trustee Vaughan, government-approved interest-free debt settlement plan, household budget, income tax debt, Industry Canada, insolvency filing, insolvency trustee firm, insolvent, Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc., jane street, legal action, legal process, licensed insolvency trustee, licensed insolvency trustee Vaughan, licensed insolvency trustees, licensed trustees, liquidator, no-cost consultation, no-cost initial consultation, Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy, ON, OSB, personal bankruptcy, personal situation, receivers, receivership, Role of a Licensed Insolvency Trustee Vaughan (formerly called Trustee in Bankruptcy Vaughan), Selecting The Right Licensed Insolvency Trustee in Vaughan, trustee in bankruptcy, unsecured debts, wage garnishment, Winding-Up

Brandon Blog Post

WHAT DOES THE BANKRUPTCY TRUSTEE INVESTIGATE? SIMPLE RULES EXPLAINED BY A TORONTO TRUSTEE

Post author By Brandon Smith
Post date July 14, 2021

We hope that you and your family are safe, healthy and secure during this COVID-19 pandemic.

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

What does the bankruptcy trustee investigate – What is a bankruptcy trustee?

The new name for a bankruptcy trustee is a licensed insolvency trustee. I will use the terms interchangeably in this Brandon Blog. In this blog, I discuss what does the bankruptcy trustee investigate? But first, I want to go through a few basics.

The process of a bankruptcy trustee’s role in the Canadian insolvency system is a delicate one. The licensed insolvency trustee starts out by reviewing the debtor’s financial information and advises the debtor on whether a restructuring is possible to avoid bankruptcy or if filing for bankruptcy is their only realistic option.

The Trustee’s job is to help a debtor restructure his or her financial affairs and to do that, he or she must know what the debtor’s assets and liabilities are, the bigger picture of the debtor’s life and what transactions the debtor may have recently entered into. It is not just what he or she claims his or her debts are.

The Trustee collects all this information in order to advise the debtor on whether a bankruptcy protection financial restructuring filing is possible or if bankruptcy is their best option and why. The debtor then must choose what sort of insolvency process they wish to enter. Once filed, the Trustee also acts for the creditors and is required to perform an investigation.

Today I discuss what does the bankruptcy trustee investigate? Anyone contemplating a bankruptcy filing should know what they are in for before it is too late.

What does the bankruptcy trustee investigate – Tell your bankruptcy trustee everything

I thought of writing this blog topic because just yesterday, a lawyer friend called up with a question. The lawyer is a family law lawyer, representing a spouse who completed a consumer proposal. The lawyer, on behalf of his client, is making a claim as having a trust claim over his spouse’s home.

The judge asked if the client declared this claim as a potential asset in his sworn statement of affairs in the consumer proposal bankruptcy paperwork? The answer is no. Now the judge says, correctly, that the client had a duty to disclose that information at the time. The judge is correct. The judge then went on to ask how he can rely on the credibility of the client’s assertions now? What a jackpot they are now in!

That is why I say tell your bankruptcy trustee everything. If there is full disclosure in the initial interview before the period of time the bankruptcy process begins, I can then consider any troublesome issues and advise on the best course of action. Then you don’t need to worry about what does the bankruptcy trustee investigate. Nobody wants to have a nasty surprise like my lawyer friend’s client.

What does the bankruptcy trustee investigate? What if I fail to remember to divulge something?

It is fairly possible that you will accidentally neglect to divulge something in your bankruptcy documents or inform your Trustee about it. You do not want anyone thinking you are conducting the concealment of assets.

What does the bankruptcy trustee investigate? What can I do?

As quickly as you learn of your error, call your trustee right away and correct this mistake. You want to make sure the Trustee understands it was a simple error and not a case of you making a false claim.

What does the bankruptcy trustee investigate? What if I have outstanding tax returns?

If as an example, you forget to inform your insolvency trustee that you have unfiled tax returns, CRA can oppose your discharge and request that all outstanding returns be filed before you get to a discharge hearing. This will extend the time you remain in bankruptcy and puts your discharge into a court hearing.

It may turn out that the amount owing from those unfiled returns is not that large, and if you had filed the returns before going bankrupt and declared that additional liability, there would not have been a problem at all. Your Trustee actually should have caught that before you filed and got you to bring your tax filings current.

What does the bankruptcy trustee investigate? What happens If I overreported income?

Reporting earnings greater than you actually earn might set off a surplus income payment requirement that is either higher than it should be or where there would not have been one at all if you had properly reported your monthly income. Make sure you have documents to back up everything you are advising your trustee about so that such an error is not made.

The same holds true for underreporting. You may have a surplus income obligation that will not be caught and finding out at the end will hold up your discharge. Again, your Trustee should have asked for backup during your initial meeting and should have caught your error before filing for bankruptcy.

What does the bankruptcy trustee investigate? Suppose I am not divulging certain information?

If you fail to divulge particular information about your assets or give information that at some point complicates your insolvency, it is certain that this will complicate your discharge at the very least. It may also open you up to having committed a bankruptcy offence which will create worse penalties and headaches for you.

Recall that I mentioned at the beginning of this Brandon Blog that the reason I wrote on this topic today was because of a phone call received from a divorce lawyer friend of ours. The lack of disclosure was not caught in the consumer proposal administration. However, it may totally ruin the client’s chances for any meaningful recovery in his family law proceedings.

If the client had divulged the asset, which at the time was contingent, to the bankruptcy trustee acting as an administrator in the consumer proposal, the Trustee could have worked that into a successful outcome for the client AND the client would not now have his legal problems which could very well cost him big time!

What does the bankruptcy trustee investigate? – Collection of information by bankruptcy trustee also allowed under PIPEDA

A person filed a complaint after a bank, where she as well as her husband had gotten a mortgage from, revealed her personal information, especially regarding her financial situation, to the Trustee of the Bankrupt Estate of her spouse. There was no disagreement that this disclosure happened without the complainant’s understanding or permission.

However, the federal government ruled that it was allowable under the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act (PIPEDA) given that the financial institution was required to provide the information under another law, namely, the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA).

PIPEDA paragraph 7(3)(b) specifies that a party may disclose personal information without the knowledge or consent of that party if the disclosure is for the purpose of collecting on a financial obligation owed by the person to that party.

Paragraph 7(3)(i) of PIPEDA specifies that an organization might disclose personal information without the knowledge or permission of the person if the disclosure is required by law. Trustees are licensed by the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy (Canada) (OSB) under the BIA and also are held to requirements of practices or solutions established by the BIA.

The designated Trustee for her hubby’s insolvent estate wrote to the financial institution, requesting the complete financial institution file connected to the mortgage on the residence jointly had by the complainant wife and the bankrupt husband be disclosed, according to the provisions of S. 164(2) of the BIA.

The bank stated that it revealed the wife’s personal details without her understanding or permission, based on the PIPEDA sections I referenced above. The complainant thought that the Trustee did not have the right to access her individual info from the financial institution without her understanding or consent. The Privacy Commission ruled against her.

As long as the Trustee is asking for information from a 3rd party that will assist in the bankruptcy administration, that 3rd party can provide the information without worrying about what does the bankruptcy trustee investigate or a PIPEDA violation.

On the flip side, for every insolvency administration we perform, as part of the initial sign-up documents, we provide a PIPEDA disclosure statement to the debtor or designated officer of the company. Our PIPEDA disclosure says that in performing our duties we collect and store personal information which we may have to divulge to 3rd parties in performing our duties under the BIA, to the court or in assisting the debtor in reaching arrangements with their creditors.

What does the bankruptcy trustee investigate? – Can I sell my stuff before filing bankruptcy?

Bankruptcy is a fair and well-balanced treatment that considers the interests of all stakeholders. I always tell potential clients that any sale or transfer of property has to be done as if your creditors are evaluating your every move while you do it.

In Ontario, the Execution Act provides for certain personal exemptions, which also apply to anyone who does a bankruptcy filing in Ontario, up to a stated value. The exempt property consists of:

household furnishings and appliances – $14,180;
tools and other personal property used to earn an income:
- in the case of a debtor engaged solely in the tillage of the soil or farming, $31,379 for livestock, fowl, bees, books, tools and implements and other chattels ordinarily used by the debtor in the debtor’s occupation, or
- in any other case, $14,405;
motor vehicle – $7,117; and
principal residence – $10,783.

You might be liquidating assets that you don’t need to because they would be exempt. If you are thinking about liquidating nonexempt property to make financial settlements with certain of your creditors, this will be problematic. You could end up preferring some over others which will cause both you and them problems in your bankruptcy.

This is another factor to think about. My best advice is that you raise these issues with a Trustee before you do anything if you are contemplating bankruptcy. The Trustee will explain to you the ramifications of what you are thinking of doing so that you will have the smoothest time possible in your bankruptcy estate. The Trustee will also explain what does the bankruptcy trustee investigate so you will be informed.

What does the bankruptcy trustee investigate and look for in bank statements?

The personal bankruptcy trustee uses bank statements and other documents to discover errors or irregularities in your pre-filing personal bankruptcy paperwork. To start, you’ll list your creditors and the amounts you owe each of them; your assets, their values, and whether you can keep any of them as exempt property; your earnings for the last 12 months; as well your regular monthly expenditures. Not only will you disclose your income in several spots in the bankruptcy documents, but you’ll also give confirmation in the form of paycheque stubs and income tax returns, as well

The Trustee then goes over these anomalies with you to permit you to give better paperwork in support of your list of assets and liabilities. You’ll likewise have to send duplicates of your bank statements and also other documents that the Trustee asks for after you file for bankruptcy. Your licensed insolvency trustee makes use of the bank statements to validate your reported info.

If for some reason your historical financial institution deposits are dramatically different than your claimed earnings, you’ll need to be prepared to describe the disparity. If you approximated your bank accounts having a total of $100, yet it was, in fact, your deposit accounts had $1,500 on the day you filed, it will be nonexempt, and the Trustee will take it.

If you paid any type of huge expenses or transferred a large sum or an asset to someone right before you filed personal bankruptcy, the Trustee will have an obligation to report those transactions to your creditors, the OSB and the court and bring that cash back right into the personal bankruptcy estate for all creditors to share. If the cash is not recoverable from a third party, the Trustee will oppose your discharge and will look for payment of a minimum of that cash from YOU as a condition of your bankruptcy discharge.

If nevertheless, the Trustee thinks that you either lied or deliberately omitted details, the Trustee has to report that. The Trustee will certainly oppose your discharge and you will have a substantial issue on your hands needing you to retain a personal bankruptcy attorney.

What does the bankruptcy trustee investigate? All of that.

Red flags the bankruptcy trustee looks for at the meeting of creditors

Communicating with creditors and the meeting of creditors are very useful tools for the trustee in bankruptcy. The creditors have a much longer relationship with the bankrupt than the Trustee. They may very well have information that would be helpful to the Trustee in gaining a better understanding of the assets and liabilities of the bankrupt and of the bankrupt’s financial affairs not clear from the financial documents already reviewed by the Trustee.

At the First Meeting of Creditors in bankruptcy or the Meeting of Creditors in a Division I Proposal (or if required in a consumer proposal), the Trustee and creditor representatives can ask the debtor questions about their financial affairs. This is especially so for any type of discrepancies raised by your filing documents or financial records that indicates that you may be misstating assets or worse, the concealment of assets.

In any financial restructuring, including corporate reorganization plans, the value of the debtor’s nonexempt property really matters mainly because of the rule that entitles unsecured creditors to get a better outcome from such a repayment plan than would be the case in the debtor’s bankruptcy.

If your earnings don’t match your reported numbers, or if you improperly report side hustle business revenues, you can anticipate some sharp concerns and also possibly trouble getting your restructuring authorized or your discharge from bankruptcy.

What does the bankruptcy trustee investigate – When the bankruptcy trustee suspects fraud?

When allegations of bankruptcy fraud enter into bankruptcy administration, the next step normally includes obtaining information via an examination under oath. The BIA enables either the Trustee or the OSB to examine a bankrupt under oath. The BIA additionally permits the Trustee to put questions under oath to anyone that might have information, knowledge or documents concerning the affairs of the bankrupt. One of the key functions of the bankruptcy trustee is to protect the interests of unsecured creditors and to do so at every stage of the bankruptcy process.

As soon as the Trustee has gathered sufficient proof to support a case, the Trustee has 2 options, depending on the circumstances. If it is criminal activities or bankruptcy offences that the bankrupt person or the Directors of the bankrupt company have done, the Trustee can ask the OSB to review the proof. If they concur with the Trustee’s analysis, they can then call in the RCMP to check out.

If the RCMP has adequate evidence of a crime having been committed, or of bankruptcy offences, they will have the Crown lay bankruptcy fraud charges and then there will be a criminal trial. The result can be a fine, jail time or both. This will also give cause for the Trustee to have no choice but to oppose the person’s bankruptcy discharge.

If it is only about the recovery of money for creditors, the Trustee, if it has sufficient evidence and also funds, can launch a legal action against the appropriate party. The point of this kind of adversary case is to obtain cash for creditors (rather than prosecuting a criminal offence).

Such a proceeding resembles legal actions in various other courts yet generally, the matter in a bankruptcy administration will be heard in a shorter period of time in bankruptcy court than proceedings in various other courts. The obvious goal is for the Trustee to enter into settlement agreements with the offending parties. The goal of settlement agreements is to get cash for the creditors.

What does the bankruptcy trustee investigate summary

I hope that you found what does the bankruptcy trustee investigate Brandon Blog interesting and that you now have a better appreciation for the investigation aspect of an insolvency proceeding. Problems will arise when you are cash-starved and in debt. There are several insolvency processes available to a person or company with too much debt.

If you are concerned because you or your business are dealing with substantial debt challenges, you need debt help and you assume bankruptcy is your only option, call me.

It is not your fault that you remain in this way. You have actually been only shown the old ways to try to deal with financial issues. These old ways do not work anymore.

We understand that people and businesses facing financial issues need a realistic lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” method with the Ira Smith Team. Not everyone has to file bankruptcy in Canada. The majority of our clients never do as we know the alternatives to bankruptcy. We help many people and companies stay clear of filing an assignment in bankruptcy.

Call us now for a no-cost bankruptcy consultation.

We hope that you and your family are safe, healthy and secure during this COVID-19 pandemic.

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

Tags allegations of bankruptcy fraud, Bankruptcy, bankruptcy fraud, bankruptcy offence, bankruptcy protection, bankruptcy trustee, BIA, collection of information by bankruptcy trustee also allowed under PIPEDA, concealment of assets, Consumer Proposal, financial restructuring, financial situation, First Meeting of Creditors, I am not divulging certain information, insolvency, Ira Smith Trustee, jail time, licensed insolvency trustee, meeting of creditors, nonexempt property, Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy Canada, personal bankruptcy, PIPEDA, questions under oath, red flags the bankruptcy trustee looks for at the meeting of creditors, repayment plan, tell your bankruptcy trustee everything, trustee, trustee in bankruptcy, unsecured creditors, what does the bankruptcy trustee investigate, what does the bankruptcy trustee investigate and look for in bank statements, what happens If I overreported income, what if I fail to remember to divulge something, what if I have outstanding tax returns, what is a bankruptcy trustee, when the bankruptcy trustee suspects fraud

Brandon Blog Post

TRUSTEE IN BANKRUPTCY: CERTAIN ACTIONS AGAINST TRUSTEE CAN BE UNLEASHED WITHOUT FIRST REQUIRING COURT PERMISSION

Post author By Brandon Smith
Post date June 21, 2021

We hope that you and your family are safe, healthy and secure during this COVID-19 pandemic.

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

If you would prefer to listen to the audio version of this Brandon Blog, please scroll to the very bottom and click play on the podcast.

Trustee in Bankruptcy: No action against Trustees without leave of court

Canadian insolvency laws say that there cannot be any legal action against trustees in bankruptcy (now called a licensed insolvency trustee) without the prior leave of the court. The leave application, more often than not, would be brought before a Bankruptcy Judge. However, as you will see below, any Judge of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice could hear such an application involving a trustee in bankruptcy.

Section 215 of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA) protects the Canadian bankruptcy laws for all officials in the bankruptcy process, including the bankruptcy trustee:

“215 Except by leave of the court, no action lies against the Superintendent, an official receiver, an interim receiver or a trustee with respect to any report made under, or any action taken pursuant to, this Act.”

In my January 9, 2019, Brandon Blog, PRIVACY BREACH LAWSUIT AGAINST LICENSED INSOLVENCY TRUSTEE FAILS, I described one attempt that failed to obtain leave of the court to begin litigation against a trustee in bankruptcy.

Our bankruptcy and insolvency courts believe that the test to determine whether a court should use its discretion to give leave for litigation to be commenced against either a trustee in bankruptcy or a court-appointed receiver was not a tough test. The protection is only to ensure that the receiver or trustee in bankruptcy is protected against senseless or burdensome actions that have no basis.

In this Brandon Blog, I describe a recent Ontario court decision that further clarifies a basis for when the court will exercise its discretion and allow litigation against a licensed trustee in bankruptcy. As the Motions Judge used the old terminology, I will stick with it in this blog.

Action against the trustee in bankruptcy background

The Motion Judge‘s Endorsement was released on May 31, 2021. The Endorsement was from a motion by the plaintiff for a determination as to whether or not leave of the court under S.215 of the BIA was required. The plaintiff’s position was that it was not, but if it was, such leave should be granted. The defendant trustee in bankruptcy’s position was that leave was required and should not be granted.

The plaintiff, Mr. Flight, ended up filing bankruptcy proceedings 4 times over a 13 year period of time! He filed the same type of bankruptcy over and over again! He claims his financial situation is the fault of the defendant trustee in bankruptcy. He used the same trustee in bankruptcy for all of his bankruptcies! It is not clear in this motion how the trustee is responsible for his having to file personal bankruptcy all those times.

Mr. Flight brings on litigation against the trustee in bankruptcy claiming negligence, fraud, breach of fiduciary duty, unjust enrichment and conversion. The complainant claims the accused failed to identify and take suitable action relating to a fraud perpetrated by the bookkeeper for Mr. Flight’s sole proprietorship business.

The plaintiff’s amended claim seeks a declaration the defendant engaged in misfeasance, negligence, fraud and breach of fiduciary duty in his personal capacity, and that the defendant was unjustly enriched.

The plaintiff’s claim against the trustee in bankruptcy

The main subject matter of the claim alleges the bookkeeper’s theft caused the plaintiff’s repeated bankruptcies and that the defendant trustee in bankruptcy ought to have detected this fraud in the administration of the four bankruptcies.

The plaintiff maintains that the trustee in bankruptcy then failed to take any meaningful action to address the alleged fraud and its impact on the fourth bankruptcy after its discovery. In particular, the plaintiff claims the trustee failed to diligently commence an action against the former bookkeeper, failed to investigate the fraud, failed to adjust the plaintiff’s surplus income, failed to recommend debt relief options or financial options, and certainly no other possible insolvency process such as a consumer proposal alternative to bankruptcy and failed to have the plaintiff promptly discharged from his fourth bankruptcy.

The defendant’s alleged “grand failure to act” caused Mr. Flight damages of $10 million from loss of business, loss of profit, loss of income and pain and suffering.

The court’s analysis

As I mentioned above, the threshold issue under Canadian insolvency legislation is whether the plaintiff required leave to commence this action. If it is determined that leave is required, the analysis then moves to whether the claim meets the test for leave.

The Motion Judge stated that there is authority to support the plaintiff’s position that the insolvency laws state that leave is not required where the trustee in bankruptcy is being sued in its personal capacity.

More particularly, the Supreme Court of Canada held that the leave provision under the BIA is not to be interpreted as though it applied to any action arising out of the administration of the estate. That is not the way section 215 is worded. To allege that the trustee in bankruptcy made an act of omission is a claim that is not concerning a report made under or any action taken according to the BIA.

Trustee in bankruptcy: The court’s decision

The plaintiff alleges causes of action against the trustee in bankruptcy in his personal capacity in their amended statement of claim and affidavit materials for negligence, fraud, breach of fiduciary duty, unjust enrichment and conversion starting with the confidential consultation and with each bankruptcy assignment. The Motion Judge concluded that the plaintiff does not require leave under s. 215 of the BIA to commence this action. Based on this conclusion, the Motion Judge did not need to consider anything further.

You will observe as I previously stated, none of the court’s evaluation had anything to do with whether the claims had a possibility of success in its litigation legal process. The Motion Judge, who was not a Bankruptcy Judge but rather a Motion Judge felt the accusations were such that they were not purposeless or burdensome actions that have no basis.

As the main action will now proceed, I will follow the case to find out the exact details and the various bankruptcy claims that Mr. Flight is making regarding the conduct of trustees involved. As the case is reported, I will report to you.

Finding a good, Licensed Insolvency Trustee (Trustee In Bankruptcy) Near You

I hope that you found this trustee in bankruptcy Brandon Blog interesting. If you are concerned because you or your business are dealing with substantial debt challenges and you assume bankruptcy is your only option, call me.

It is not your fault that you remain in this way. You have actually been only shown the old ways to try to deal with financial issues. These old ways do not work anymore.

Call us now for a no-cost bankruptcy consultation.

We hope that you and your family are safe, healthy and secure during this COVID-19 pandemic.

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

Brandon Blog Post

EQUALIZATION PAYMENT DIVORCE ONTARIO: THE BASIC RULE FOR MARITAL PROPERTY AND BANKRUPTCY

Post author By Brandon Smith
Post date April 26, 2021

We hope that you and your family are safe, healthy and secure during this coronavirus pandemic.

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

If you would prefer to listen to the audio version of this Brandon Blog, please scroll to the very bottom of the page and click on the podcast.

Bankruptcy and divorce: Equalization payment introduction

The pandemic has taken a toll on couples both financially and psychologically, which has actually triggered many to consider going for separation and maybe even filing for bankruptcy. This is not to say that every bankruptcy causes a subsequent divorce, or that every separation will certainly necessitate the declaring of bankruptcy.

In my Brandon Blog dated March 2, 2020, titled “DIVORCE DEBT: NOT ALL EQUALIZATION ISSUES ARE EQUAL IN BANKRUPTCY” I described a decision of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice (Commercial List) where the court decided that the claim for an equalization payment is “personal as between the spouses” and cannot be started by the licensed insolvency trustee. However, if the claim was already started by the spouse prior to his or her bankruptcy assignment, then it is a claim for property that the Trustee can continue to advance.

I thought that was the end of the matter, but apparently not. The bankruptcy trustee, who could have left well enough alone, did not. The trustee in bankruptcy appealed the court’s decision to the Court of Appeal for Ontario. Recently, the three-judge panel released their decision of the appeal that was heard last November.

In this Brandon Blog, I discuss this recent Court of Appeal for Ontario decision dealing with an equalization payment, marital property, divorce and bankruptcy in Ontario.

Bankruptcy and property: Insolvency 101 on what happens to property in a personal bankruptcy

It is a fact that when someone files for personal bankruptcy, the bankruptcy provisions states that all of their property vests in the licensed insolvency trustee administering the file. There is a discrete list of assets set by every province in Canada that is exempt from seizure and therefore cannot be sold by the Trustee. Technically, the licensed insolvency trustee gives back to the bankrupt that property. In practical terms, the Trustee never seizes it. But whenever the topic of bankruptcy under federal bankruptcy laws gets mixed in with the Ontario Family Law Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. F.3 (“FLA”), the discussion on matters about bankruptcy always starts to get murky.

A claim for an equalization payment by one spouse against the other in Ontario family law proceedings meets the definition of property. So if the spouse entitled to the equalization payment files an assignment in bankruptcy, that entitlement is their property which now vests in their licensed insolvency trustee. When collected upon, it is available to the bankruptcy estate and its creditors. However, what if that spouse has yet to make the equalization payment claim and goes bankrupt? Does the Trustee have the right to assert that claim?

What are equalization payments in divorce?

In Canada, each province sets their own family law statutes. When it comes to family property and divorce, there are two different possibilities in Canada. The province can elect for those divorcing spouses to have to split their property equally. This would make them a division of property province under family law.

Alternatively, rather than looking for a division of assets, the province can mandate that each spouse calculate their respective net family property. Then the spouse with the higher net family property value has to either pay money or transfer property to the other spouse so that they end up being equal. Hence the money that would be paid over from one spouse to another is called the equalization payment. This is what happens in Ontario. Ontario is not a property division province but rather is an equalization jurisdiction.

The application for equalization and the equalization payment is totally separate from the claim for and determination of spousal support and child support to the other. The equalization claim falls into the category of non-support-related spousal claims.

Rusinek & Associates v. Arachchilage & Baliah, 2020 ONSC 1090 (CanLII)

In my March 2020 blog referred to above, I described this Ontario family law case combined with the insolvency situation of bankruptcy. You can certainly read it if you want all the details. However, the bottom line of that decision is that under the FLA, the post-separation equalization claim is “personal as between the spouses”.

This means that if a spouse who subsequently becomes bankrupt had not yet made that claim, his or her Trustee cannot start the claim for the determination of equalization on the basis that the claim is a property that vests in the Trustee. However, if the claim had already been made and the equalization process litigation has already begun, and then that spouse becomes bankrupt, the Trustee does take over the right to advance that litigation against the non-bankrupt spouse for the equalization payment which stands in lieu of property rights. Whatever payment comes from it goes to the Trustee for the general benefit of the creditors.

Bankruptcy and equalization payments: Court of Appeal for Ontario says the timing of the bankruptcy matters

From what I have told you so far, you can see that the timing of the person’s voluntary assignment into bankruptcy or the Bankruptcy Order being made (from the filing of a Bankruptcy Application) does matter. For the trustee in bankruptcy to be able to assert that equalization payment claim, the bankrupt spouse had to have already made that claim prior to becoming bankrupt.

The Court of Appeal for Ontario considered the Trustee’s appeal of this lower court decision. It considered the laws around bankruptcy and the FLA and dismissed the appeal. I will now tell you why.

The Court of Appeal stated that a spouse’s claim for equalization becomes property of the bankrupt if that same spouse then declares bankruptcy. The action vests in the trustee in bankruptcy and the Trustee has control over the claim together with the right to get any unpaid equalization payment.

There is no restriction in the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA), under the FLA or in the common law, preventing the trustee in bankruptcy from going after it after the now-bankrupt spouse had already started that part of the Family Law litigation.

[NOTE: This bracketed portion is not part of the case heard by the Appeal Court, but this is the appropriate place to share this information with you. I think it is obvious that the bankrupt spouse would not start the equalization claim litigation while being an undischarged bankrupt. Otherwise, the Trustee would be entitled to the proceeds.

Also, presumably, the bankrupt spouse might do better if the non-bankrupt spouse only paid support instead of both support and equalization. I would advise the bankrupt’s family law lawyer to not make an equalization claim, and in return, negotiate for a larger support claim, in lieu of both.

A Trustee cannot directly attach to a support claim. The Trustee would just have to assess that information, along with whatever other income the bankrupt spouse has, to determine if there is any surplus income obligation.]

The Court then went through a thoughtful analysis of whether the entitlement to equalization can be initiated by the licensed insolvency trustee. The Court of Appeal concluded that because the action for equalization is “personal as between the spouses”, only spouses can bring claims for equalization. The Trustee cannot.

It is for these reasons that the Court of Appeal for Ontario confirmed the lower court decision, dismissed the Trustee’s appeal and awarded costs of $10,000 against the Trustee in favour of the non-bankrupt spouse respondent.

I will now go on to provide you with some extra information about divorce proceedings and bankruptcy.

How does an unpaid equalization payment intersect with bankruptcy?

In a bankruptcy, if the non-bankrupt spouse still owes the bankrupt spouse an unpaid equalization payment, the bankruptcy plays no part. That spouse still has to make the payment. Only now, it has to be made to the Trustee.

However, if the spouse who files for bankruptcy owes the non-bankrupt spouse an unpaid equalization payment, that liability is caught in the bankruptcy. The non-bankrupt spouse has a provable ordinary unsecured claim in the bankruptcy of the spouse. As stated above, the bankrupt spouse no longer has to make the equalization payment because it is an unsecured debt and will be discharged from that person’s discharge from bankruptcy.

What happens to spousal and child support payments during bankruptcy? Nothing. Any liability for support, either spousal support or child support, is not eliminated by filing bankruptcy. The bankrupt spouse still has to make those payments. Just like any other spouse, if the bankrupt spouse does not make the support payments, the spouse that is entitled to receive support can obtain collection assistance from the Ontario Family Responsibility Office.

What happens to joint debt if you file for bankruptcy?

Joint debt in a divorce is hard enough to sort out. Layer a bankruptcy on top of that and things may become much clearer, but also potentially unfair. When you file for bankruptcy and have joint debt, it is important to know what happens to the debt. The most common type of joint debt couples share is from joint credit cards. Next would be if one spouse co-signed for or otherwise guaranteed the debts of the other spouse. Other common examples are joint mortgages and joint lines of credit.

A creditor can collect the debt from both you and your co-signer, but in your bankruptcy, the law does not protect your non-bankrupt co-signer from your joint debt. If you file for bankruptcy, your creditors can still come after your co-signer for the debt.

If your estranged spouse is considering bankruptcy as a last-ditch effort to eliminate their overwhelming unsecured debt, it could spell trouble for you if they file for bankruptcy. When they file for bankruptcy, they are trying to erase their unsecured debt. Unfortunately, you will be saddled with the sole responsibility to repay those joint debts. You will have to try as best you can to be protected financially through the divorce process.

You need to decide how you will deal with these debts that your spouse won’t have to pay because of their bankruptcy. If you cannot afford to pay them on your own, in addition to your other living expenses, you may have to consider either bankruptcy or a consumer proposal as an option to save you from this catastrophe.

Are the bankruptcy rules fair, especially given the discussion above about the equalization payment? The BIA is the set of regulations and rules that govern a bankruptcy or insolvency in Canada. The BIA governs both people and companies that have come to be incapable to pay their financial debts. It handles the regulations for the time duration both leading up to insolvency and the declaring of bankruptcy.

The policies established by the BIA have a substantial impact on the lives of debtors and creditors. They are extremely crucial for the survival of the business or person. The rules are fair for everyone. But the effect they have on different stakeholders in an insolvency file may not be very fair.

Equalization payment and Ontario divorce and bankruptcy summary

I hope you enjoyed the equalization payment Brandon Blog post. You may be very frustrated and angry over your marital and financial situations. The entrepreneur may be very frustrated that the company can no longer pay all its debts as they come due.

There may be sufficient value to take care of the secured creditor, but nothing for anyone else, including the unsecured creditors. There may be some business units that should not survive, but if cut out, the business will be viable. A receivership might very well accomplish the goals for the entrepreneur also. I have many times structured a receivership process, in order to meet the goals of the entrepreneur, while satisfying the requirements of the secured creditor.

Are you worried because you or your business are dealing with substantial debt challenges and you assume bankruptcy is your only option? Call me. It is not your fault that you remain in this way. You have actually been only shown the old ways to try to deal with financial issues. These old ways do not work anymore.

The Ira Smith Team utilizes new modern-day ways to get you out of your debt difficulties while avoiding bankruptcy. We can get you the relief you need and so deserve.

The tension put upon you is big. We know your discomfort factors. We will check out your entire situation and design a new approach that is as unique as you and your problems; financial and emotional. We will take the weight off of your shoulders and blow away the dark cloud hanging over you. We will design a debt settlement strategy for you. We know that we can help you now.

We understand that people and businesses facing financial issues need a realistic lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” method with the Ira Smith Team. Not everyone has to file bankruptcy in Canada. The majority of our clients never do. We help many people and companies stay clear of bankruptcy.

That is why we can establish a new restructuring procedure for paying down debt that will be built just for you. It will be as one-of-a-kind as the economic issues and discomfort you are encountering. If any one of these seems familiar to you and you are serious about getting the solution you need, contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. group today.

Call us now for a no-cost consultation.

We will get you or your business back up driving to healthy and balanced trouble-free operations and get rid of the discomfort factors in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

We hope that you and your family are safe, healthy and secure during this coronavirus pandemic.

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

equalization payment

Brandon Blog Post

How Much Does A Consumer Proposal Cost: We Show You Our Rules To Make It FREE

Post author By Brandon Smith
Post date April 5, 2021

We hope that you and your family are safe, healthy and secure during this coronavirus pandemic.

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

If you would prefer to listen to the audio version of this Brandon Blog, please scroll to the very bottom and click play on the podcast.

How much does a consumer proposal cost: Only pay a Trustee for consumer proposal services

This Brandon Blog answers the question “how much does a consumer proposal cost?”. There is one thing that I want to get out of the way first, that directly impacts the cost of a consumer proposal. The only party authorized by law to administer a consumer proposal in Canada are licensed insolvency trustees (formerly called bankruptcy trustees).

There are many firms that advertise that they will settle your debts without you having to see a licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a trustee in bankruptcy). They sell you on the sizzle of staying away from a licensed trustee implying that visiting a reputable bankruptcy trustee will immediately mean that bankruptcy will be your only option.

These firms promise a lot but deliver little or nothing. In return, you need to pay the high fees. Then, when they have charged you everything they can, they walk you down the street to a licensed insolvency trustee (Trustee) to administer a consumer proposal for you. So they end up taking you to the exact professional they first told you to avoid when they cannot charge you any more fees. Why can’t they charge you any more fees? Because by then, you have wised up to their game!

So do yourself a favour. The easiest way to know how much does a consumer proposal cost is to make an initial Trustee visit for a no-cost initial consultation to learn all your debt relief options and forget about the non-licensed debt management company.

How much does a consumer proposal cost: Getting rid of debt

When you are buried in debt, things like saving for the future can seem impossible. This is because you are trying to climb up a hill with a heavy backpack on your back, making it hard to take a step forward. You may even be tempted to stop trying when you hear everyone else talking about how they are able to save so much, but you wonder why you can’t.

If you’re looking at a pile of unpaid bills and thinking, “I just can’t afford to make those payments” or “I can’t believe I’m falling so far behind,” you’re not alone. But you’re not hopeless. It is possible to get out from under crushing debt and start getting ahead. The first step is to stop making the situation worse with missed payments and late fees. To do this, you need to make a plan.

Managing your debt is a lot like dieting – it looks easy and straightforward on the commercials, but when you get down to doing it, it’s a whole different story. There are hundreds of books and websites out there, each with different tips and techniques that you can follow to help you get a handle on your debt. Here are a few things to consider:

As I have written in several blogs before, a self-help remedy is always the best. First look at all your monthly income sources and all your expenses for a typical month. Create a budget showing what it all is so that you can figure out how much more you are spending each month than you earn. Now, look critically at all your behaviours during a typical month that leads to that spending. What can you cut out?

Also, look at your total monthly income. Do you have the time for and ability to either get a second part-time job or create a side hustle for yourself in order to earn more income? Based on all this reflection, what is the best budget you can come up with to try to spend no more than you earn, after-tax? This will let you see if you can work yourself out of your financial challenges by having excess money each month to pay off your debts or not.

If yes, terrific. Put your plan into play and pay down your debts. Curb your credit card spending so that you only charge what you can pay off by the due date. If not, then perhaps you need to visit a Trustee.

How much does a consumer proposal cost: Get a personalized debt free plan

When people talk about getting out of debt, it can sometimes be hard to know where to start. If you’re stressed about your financial situation, the last thing you want is to be confused by too many options and not know what to do. Thankfully, there’s a way to get a personalized debt-free plan that will help you figure out what to do and how to get out of debt. We can help you develop a debt relief plan that will put you on the path to a debt-free life.

If you have overdue consumer financial debts, you are receiving telephone calls from financial debt collectors. Although personal bankruptcy gives a fresh start for those that are drowning in debt, in my view, it is the last resort for those that have maxed out their credit cards. If you require an financial clean slate, a consumer proposal is an excellent way to relieve yourself of the stress and anxiety of too much debt. It is the only federal government-approved method for debt settlement.

In an initial no-cost consultation with a Trustee, all possible debt relief options will be discussed. At the end of the consultation, you will have a clear understanding of what personalized debt-free plan is best for you. Let us know dive deeper into how much does a consumer proposal cost.

How much does a consumer proposal cost: A negotiated debt settlement

You can easily look back on some of my earlier blogs to refresh yourself on all the details of what a consumer proposal is and how it works, including my Brandon Blog CONSUMER PROPOSAL FAQ: ANSWERS TO 10 TANTALIZING CONSUMER PROPOSAL QUESTIONS. To save you time, the important points to remember are that in the consumer proposal process:

You can settle your unsecured debts totalling a level of debt of $250,000 or less, not including any mortgages or lines of credit secured by way of a mortgage or other charge against your personal residence.
The settlement of debts will be at a total dollar settlement value much less than the total outstanding debt you owe.
The amount you will have to pay in a consumer proposal is based on what your creditors can expect from your bankruptcy. The bankruptcy statute in Canada states that your offer in the consumer proposal must be better than what your unsecured creditors would receive in your bankruptcy. Although there is no guarantee as to what the final amount will be, as a general rule of thumb, you can consider a consumer proposal totalling 25% of the total amount you owe as a good rule of thumb.
You can take a period of time up to 5 years to make monthly consumer proposal payments to the Trustee, who acts as the Administrator of your proposal, to pay the entire consumer proposal fund. The Trustee then makes the required creditor distributions to your unsecured creditors on a pro-rata basis.
A Trustee is the only debt professional in Canada who is licensed and supervised by the Canadian government, through the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy Canada. A Trustee is the only professional that can offer consumer proposals services.
how much does a consumer proposal cost

The Cost of a Consumer Proposal in Ontario

In Canada, the term consumer proposal refers to a formal, legally binding arrangement between a debtor and creditors, involving a lump sum payment spread over equal monthly payments to the Trustee but taking no more than 60 months.

This money is then used by the Trustee to make the necessary creditor distributions in return for a consumer proposal discharge. The creditors agree to accept a portion of the outstanding debt in full settlement. A consumer proposal is a viable option for those who are having trouble paying their debts because they are disabled, unemployed, or have suffered a loss of income.

How much does a consumer proposal cost is on everyone’s mind when they contemplate filing one. When we think of cost, our minds first go to “how much will the licensed trustee charge me for all this?”. The reality is that the amount the insolvent debtor will have to pay to the Trustee who is called the Administrator in a consumer proposal to create the proposal fund is a direct result of what the unsecured creditors could expect to receive in the debtor’s bankruptcy filing. The statute says that the offer to the unsecured creditors has to be better than what they could expect to receive in the debtor’s bankruptcy.

Let’s look at a real example so I can better illustrate this. Assume we have an insolvent debtor who would be a first-time bankrupt. Assume that their personal situation in their filing for bankruptcy is as follows:

Surplus income payments of NIL.
Assets realization of $20,000 and non-exempt assets therefore not sold by the Trustee.
Total liabilities of $173,000.

So in this bankruptcy process, the total fund that would provide for the payments to creditors would be $20,000 in the bankruptcy. The fee and disbursements allowed for the Trustee in this bankruptcy example are governed by the bankruptcy statute. The fee is therefore called a tariff fee. For purposes of figuring out what kind of consumer proposal would be required, the tariff fee of the Trustee in this bankruptcy is irrelevant.

Assuming the person in this example did not commit any sort of bankruptcy offence, there is nothing more to discuss as to what each creditor could expect out of the bankruptcy. They would receive their pro-rata share of the distribution.

In order for a consumer proposal to be a better alternative for the unsecured creditors, I suggest that a consumer proposal filing offering a total payment of $25,000 payable in regular monthly payments over a maximum five-year period would be appropriate.

This is the cost of this consumer proposal in Ontario, $25,000. As this example shows, how much does a consumer proposal cost has zero relationship to what my Firm would earn as the Administrator.

How much does a consumer proposal cost: Consumer proposal costs in Ontario

As the Administrator of a consumer proposal, I am entitled to a tariff fee stipulated in the Rules to the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada). There are also some administrative expenses and taxes to be paid. What the tariff allows, to be paid from the consumer proposal fund, is as follows:

$750 payable on filing a copy of the consumer proposal with the Official Receiver;
$750 payable on the approval or deemed approval of the consumer proposal by the court;
20% of the money distributed to creditors under the consumer proposal, payable on the distribution of the money;
the costs of counselling at $85 per session, payable after each session, to a maximum of two sessions;
the fee payable to the official receiver in the amount of $100, payable at the time of filing a copy of the consumer proposal;
the fee payable to the registrar in the amount of $50, but only if you have to go to Court; and
all applicable taxes for GST/HST.

The final amount payable not listed above is the levy payable to the federal government calculated at 5% of any distribution made to the creditors. This payment to the government is what pays for the administration of the Canadian bankruptcy system.

So taking the above example of the $25,000 consumer proposal, the consumer proposal calculation assuming everything went smoothly and there was no need to go to Court would go as follows:

Category	$
Payment under proposal	25,000.00
Counselling fees (2 x $85) for Administrator	170.00
The fee paid to the Official Receiver	100.00
Administrator’s fees	1,500.00
HST on above fees ($2,250)	292.50
The amount available for distribution	22,937.50
Administrator fee of 20% of the money distributed to creditors	4,587.50
Applicable HST	596.37
5% Levy payable	887.68
Total amount to be distributed to the unsecured creditors	16,865.95

So in this example, out of the total consumer proposal fund of $25,000:

- The amount paid for the consumer proposal is $25,000.
- This represents 14.5% of the total liabilities.
- The Administrator earned fees (net of HST) totalling $6,257.50.
- The Administrator earned fees are paid for by the unsecured creditors as it is deducted from the amount they would otherwise receive.

Therefore, how much does a consumer proposal cost the insolvent debtor? The cost to the debtor for the Administrator’s services is FREE!
how much does a consumer proposal cost

How much does a consumer proposal cost: Get a personalized debt free plan today

I hope you enjoyed this how much does a consumer proposal cost Brandon Blog post. Are you worried because you or your business are dealing with substantial debt challenges and you assume bankruptcy is your only option? Call me. It is not your fault that you remain in this way. You have actually been only shown the old ways to try to deal with financial issues. These old ways do not work anymore.

The Ira Smith Team utilizes new modern-day ways to get you out of your debt difficulties while avoiding bankruptcy. We can get you the relief you need and so deserve.

The tension put upon you is big. We know your discomfort factors. We will check out your entire situation and design a new approach that is as unique as you and your problems; financial and emotional. We will take the weight off of your shoulders and blow away the dark cloud hanging over you. We will design a debt settlement strategy for you. We know that we can help you now.

We understand that people and businesses facing financial issues need a realistic lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” method with the Ira Smith Team. Not everyone has to file bankruptcy in Canada. The majority of our clients never do. We help many people and companies stay clear of bankruptcy.

That is why we can establish a new restructuring procedure for paying down debt that will be built just for you. It will be as one-of-a-kind as the economic issues and discomfort you are encountering. If any one of these seems familiar to you and you are serious about getting the solution you need, contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. group today.

Call us now for a no-cost consultation.

We will get you or your business back up driving to healthy and balanced trouble-free operations and get rid of the discomfort factors in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

We hope that you and your family are safe, healthy and secure during this coronavirus pandemic.

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

how much does a consumer proposal cost

Tags bankruptcy statute, Consumer Proposal, consumer proposal filing, consumer proposal payments, crushing debt, debt professional, debt relief options, debt settlement, Get a personalized debt free plan, getting rid of debt, how much does a consumer proposal cost, licensed insolvency trustee, monthly income, negotiated debt settlement, only pay a trustee for consumer proposal services, personal bankruptcy, settlement of debts, the cost of a consumer proposal in ontario, trustee in bankruptcy

Brandon Blog Post

FILE BANKRUPTCY IN CANADA ONLINE: OUR COMPLETE GUIDE ON HOW TO FILE BANKRUPTCY ONLINE

Post author By Brandon Smith
Post date December 16, 2020

We hope that you and your family are safe and healthy.

The Ira Smith Trustee Team is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

File bankruptcy in Canada online introduction

People have been asking us recently, “Can I file bankruptcy in Canada online?”. The most honest answer is yes, just not all alone with your computer and internet connection. Doesn’t sound very definitive, does it? That is because you cannot file bankruptcy yourself.

The only one the federal government authorizes in Canada to do bankruptcy filings is a licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a bankruptcy trustee or a trustee in bankruptcy) (Trustee). The process itself requires anyone experiencing financial problems either themselves or with their company, needs to meet with a Trustee for an initial consultation.

However, since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic and the lockdowns that have accompanied it since March 2020, the way a Trustee meets with people considering bankruptcy has changed. It has essentially gone online given the current operating environment. I will explain what I mean and how it might help you with your individual situation.

Can I file bankruptcy in Canada online?

Virtually anything and everything can be done online. The lockdown has increased our use of online purchasing. Whether it is clothes, office supplies, or toilet paper, it can all be ordered online and shipped to our homes. The taxi industry has been under assault for some time now from both Uber and Lyft.

The internet also includes a wealth of knowledge on thousands of different subjects. Financial topics are no exception. I find that anyone contacting me who is struggling with their, or their company’s financial problems, debts and paying their bills, including credit card bills, have already looked online for information and help to try to recover for their financial future.

Although people may not understand everything about insolvency and bankruptcy with all its nuances, which is to be expected, callers are definitely more educated in options for help in dealing with their secured creditors, unsecured creditors and different types of debts – both secured debt and unsecured debt.

So nowadays, everyone expects that you can do everything online, including the ability to file bankruptcy in Canada. This is true for people who think bankruptcy might be a solution for them. They are curious to understand if they can declare bankruptcy online. It is no longer just a bankruptcy in-person system.

file bankruptcy in canada

How the coronavirus pandemic pushed bankruptcy online

The bankruptcy law in Canada is a federal statute. So the Canadian government supervises the administration of the insolvency process in Canada through the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy Canada (OSB). On March 13, 2020, as a result of COVID-19, the OSB provided guidance to Trustees about how elements of the process for filing bankruptcy in Canada have changed. The document issued by the OSB is called Temporary Guidance for LITS During the COVID-19 Pandemic.

In that guidance, the OSB pushed the Canadian insolvency system as close to how can you file bankruptcy online. The only thing you still cannot do is file bankruptcy online yourself.

There was great growing concern in Canada about COVID-19. Insolvency practitioners had to take action to reduce in-person meetings. The OSB supported the Trustee community in these initiatives while keeping the stability of Canada’s insolvency system.

The OSB encouraged Trustees to make use of the considerable flexibilities that exist in the OSB’s Directives when determining which measures may be appropriate, in light of the pandemic.

To allow for the necessary social distancing, while still allowing people to file bankruptcy in Canada, the OSB advised the Trustee community:

Assessment of a person’s or company’s financial situation – Trustees are allowed to make use of techniques besides in-person meetings. The OSB recognized the COVID-19 pandemic as a remarkable circumstance.
- Trustees did not need to get separate approval to conduct assessments making use of techniques aside from in-person. Where a video conference is not feasible, evaluations and discussions about a person’s or company’s debt situation may be carried out through a mix of telephone discussion and email.
- In these assessment meetings, we discuss various debt relief options and alternatives to bankruptcy to avoid bankruptcy. We talk about credit counselling sessions, debt consolidation, debt settlement, various financial management techniques. We even discuss is a debt consolidation loan a realistic prospect?
- Then we move on to the insolvency remedies of a consumer proposal for financial reorganization and debt settlement, corporate financial reorganization, personal bankruptcy or corporate bankruptcy. Whatever is appropriate. Then we give the person our recommendations and help them pick the best solution for them. The aim is always to avoid bankruptcy, wherever possible.
Insolvency financial counselling – Trustees and the accredited credit counsellors in their office are allowed to give financial management counselling via video conferencing. The OSB also allowed for credit counseling over the telephone, when video conferencing is not feasible. That is how I have been doing each credit counselling session and it has been working very well.
Meeting of Creditors – The Chair of the meeting is now allowed to hold creditors’ meetings either by video or conference call. The Chair can count on the representations by those in attendance to confirm their identity. It is mainly the unsecured creditors who are interested in the meeting of creditors.
Oaths and Signatures: Filing for bankruptcy and the bankruptcy process, involves bankruptcy forms. We are now urged to trade bankruptcy paperwork using e-mail. Trustees also explain to anyone filing bankruptcy, be it personal bankruptcy or corporate bankruptcy, using video conferencing.
This also the case for a consumer proposal filing. So even though we are not sitting in the same room as the person, we give the debtor the required support to explain the bankruptcy forms by using Zoom, FaceTime or over the phone.

What I do for taking oaths is that I confirm the person’s name and ask them to hold up their birth certificate or driver’s licence to their webcam or mobile phone. I also watch them sign the official bankruptcy documents. Then, I ask them to scan everything, including the identification they used, email it to me right away and then put the originals in the regular Canada Post mail.

So far, this has worked quite well. It has allowed people to file bankruptcy in Canada even during a pandemic. It has worked so well, we are now helping people and entrepreneurs looking for debt relief options who otherwise could not travel to our office. They would not travel to see us in person because although they are in Ontario, they are not in the Great Toronto Area.

Trustees already use an online bankruptcy filing system

Once the Trustee receives the documents by email from the person, they then turn to the electronic online bankruptcy filing system. It is called the E filing system. The Trustee can upload certain computer files into the E filing system, to tell the OSB all the information it needs to issue the Certificate of Appointment.

It is the same system across the country, regardless of what province you are in when someone wants to file bankruptcy in Canada. When the OSB issues the Certificate, that is the moment when a person or company officially becomes bankrupt and the Trustee is appointed.

This same E filing system is used also for all filings. Things like a consumer proposal, corporate receivership and corporate restructuring filings are also uploaded through the same online portal.

***File bankruptcy in Canada*: The rest of the process is the same as before**

Once the type of online bankruptcy or consumer proposal filing is made to help you with the debt solutions you need, the rest of the process is the same. How bankruptcies work in Canada from this point on is not really different, other than as stated above, the two mandatory counselling sessions are done by either video or telephone meeting. Also, the effect on someone’s credit report is the same.

To find out the information on how the overall process works when you file bankruptcy in Canada, take a look at my Brandon’s Blog – HOW TO FILE FOR BANKRUPTCY IN CANADA: PERSONAL BANKRUPTCY MODUS OPERANDI. That will give you a very good read on the entire process.

File bankruptcy in Canada online: A word of warning

A word of caution for you. Bear in mind at the beginning I told you that only a Trustee is licensed to do any insolvency filing in Canada. You should understand that to file bankruptcy in Canada or file a consumer proposal online in Canada with someone that is not licensed by the federal government as a Trustee isn’t a choice.

You must be aware of fake organizations, firms, or service providers that attempt to trick people right into believing they can do any kind of insolvency filing for you. This includes anyone wanting to file bankruptcy in Canada.

Sadly, there are many debt consultant bankruptcy scam artists that state that they can help you do a debt settlement for you for a fee. DO NOT think of them under any circumstances. All they do is charge you for the first bankruptcy assessment of a person’s financial situation that a Trustee will do for you at no cost.

Then they try to offer you more items that the state will certainly help improve your credit score. This may also include giving you a high-interest rate loan but holding back all the cash to make the monthly payments out of until gone. Then when they cannot sell you any more products, they walk you down the block to file with a Trustee either to do a consumer proposal or to file bankruptcy in Canada.

Do not fall for these scammers that make it seem like they can file bankruptcy in Canada for you.

File bankruptcy in Canada summary

I hope you have enjoyed this file bankruptcy in Canada Brandon’s Blog. Do you or your company have too much debt? Are you or your company in need of financial restructuring? The financial restructuring process is complex. The Ira Smith Team understands how to do a complex restructuring. However, more importantly, we understand the needs of the entrepreneur or the person who has too much personal debt.

You are worried because you are facing significant financial challenges and you think the only thing you can do is file bankruptcy in Canada. It is not your fault that you are in this situation. You have been only shown the old ways that do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team uses new modern ways to get you out of your debt troubles while avoiding bankruptcy. We can get you debt relief freedom.

The stress placed upon you is huge. We understand your pain points. We look at your entire situation and devise a strategy that is as unique as you and your problems; financial and emotional. We know that we can help you the way we take the load off of your shoulders and devise a debt settlement plan.

We know that people facing financial problems need a realistic lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” approach with the Ira Smith Team. Not everyone has to file bankruptcy in Canada. We help many people and companies avoid bankruptcy.

That is why we can develop a restructuring process as unique as the financial problems and pain you are facing. If any of this sounds familiar to you and you are serious about finding a solution, contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. team today.

Call us now for a free consultation.

We will get you or your company back on the road to healthy stress-free operations and recover from the pain points in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

We hope that you and your family are safe and healthy.

The Ira Smith Trustee Team is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

Brandon Blog Post

TRUSTEE BANKRUPTCIES FEES IN A SCARY CORONAVIRUS WORLD

Post author By Brandon Smith
Post date November 23, 2020

The Ira Smith Trustee Team is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting. We hope that you and your family are safe and healthy.

If you would prefer to listen to the audio version of this trustee bankruptcies Brandon’s Blog, please scroll to the bottom and click on the podcast.

Trustee bankruptcies introduction

Are trustee bankruptcies filings high right now?

Every day we read or hear in the media about the life-threatening health challenges faced daily by Canadians. We also hear sad stories about people who have lost their job because of businesses having to close down.

The general public thinks that right now there is a lot of personal bankruptcy and corporate bankruptcy filings. In actual fact, the numbers are low. The 2 main reasons are:

Government support programs have helped support people and businesses. Most of the programs ended effective September 30, 2020.
Creditors are not chasing or harassing borrowers right now. Given that we are about 5 weeks away from Christmas, that will not change until some time in 2021.

I am receiving a lot of inquiries from people and entrepreneurs about their personal and business debt situation. I am doing a lot of initial consultations by telephone or video meeting. That tells me that there should be an increase in insolvency filings in 2021.

It may surprise you to hear that even a licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a bankruptcy trustee or trustee in bankruptcy) business could be having cash-flow problems. A recent court decision out of Ottawa highlights this issue. The purpose of this Brandon’s Blog is to discuss the court case and what it means for a trustee bankruptcies fee collection.

What are the fees of a licensed insolvency trustee?

This question is quite relevant, but the answer depends on what role the licensed insolvency trustee takes on.

A trustee in bankruptcy performs a wide variety of services, such as:

administrator in a consumer proposal;
the monitor under a Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA) corporate restructuring;
licensed insolvency trustee in either a summary administration or ordinary personal bankruptcy;
receiver over a company’s assets, either by private appointment or court appointment;
the licensed insolvency trustee in a corporate restructuring under the proposal provisions of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA);
as the licensed insolvency trustee in a corporate bankruptcy; or
act as a consultant in either a corporate or personal insolvency situation, advising either a creditor or the debtor.

The fee will certainly differ depending on what duty is played. Keep in mind that the costs of trustee bankruptcies are established under the BIA itself for all insolvency administrations under the BIA.

Personal bankruptcy administration where the non-exempt assets are estimated to be worth less than $15,000 is called a summary administration bankruptcy. Rule 128 of the BIA General Rules dictates the cost and disbursements in such trustee bankruptcies. This kind of fee is called a tariff. A tariff also exists in a consumer proposal file.

A bankruptcy is called an “ordinary” bankruptcy when the realizable assets are estimated at $15,000 or greater in personal bankruptcy. Every corporate bankruptcy is an ordinary administration. The BIA also regulates the trustee bankruptcies fee and disbursements.

With this information as background, I will now discuss the recent case out of the court in Ottawa.

**A bankruptcy trustee needs cash flow too**

The case involves a court application by an Ottawa bankruptcy trustee on 3 separate ordinary administration personal bankruptcy files. Normally, when a bankruptcy trustee wishes to get an interim draw towards its fees and disbursements in an ordinary administration, they either get the approval of the creditors at a meeting of creditors or, approval of the inspectors appointed in the bankruptcy administration.

The First Meeting of Creditors has to take place within 21 days of the date of bankruptcy. It is rare to have to call another meeting of creditors. So if the Trustee does not get approval for an interim draw at the outset from the creditors present at the First Meeting, that chance is gone quickly. If no inspectors are appointed, or a long time has passed and the Trustee has trouble finding the inspectors, getting inspector approval may also prove difficult.

But there is one more way for a Trustee to get approval to get an interim draw for its cash flow.

Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy (OSB) Directive no. 27R

The OSB publishes Directives from time to time. Trustees are bound by and obliged to follow all regulations provided by the OSB. This is so there will be consistency in the insolvency process across Canada. Directive 27R is titled “Advance of Trustee’s Remuneration for Bankruptcies Under Ordinary Administration.”. It was issued on February 10, 2010. The purpose of this Directive is to set out the correct procedure the Trustee should comply with when making an interim withdrawal or taking out an advance on remuneration for ordinary trustee bankruptcies.

To withdraw an advance on its compensation, the Trustee needs to obtain consent in the form of:

a resolution of a duly comprised meeting of creditors;
the resolution of a majority of the inspectors at a properly convened meeting of inspectors; or
make an application to the Court for an order approving such interim advance.

This is what this Ottawa Trustee did for 3 of its trustee bankruptcies.

The OSB did not like the court application

The OSB did not like the fact that the Trustee made this application. The OSB actually opposed the application, notwithstanding the Trustee was properly following all the requirements of Directive 27R. The Trustee brought to the court’s attention that it would still take some time to prepare its Final Statement of Receipts and Disbursements, submit it to the OSB to receive their comment letter and then apply to the court for taxation. The process would take many months.

The Trustee also highlighted for the court that these are not normal times. Due to the coronavirus pandemic, government and court staff were not working at their normal pace. The Trustee also pointed out that its own business had to lay off staff and its own cash flow was suffering. Therefore, the Trustee was making an application to the court for approval for an interim draw, as allowed. The Trustee highlighted what has gone on to date in each bankruptcy estate. The Trustee also provided proof of proper service on the OSB of this motion.

The decision does not indicate why the Trustee did not just go for inspector approval. Nevertheless, its position was that it was within its rights to make this application to the court and for the court to approve it.

The OSB’s basis for opposing this motion can be summarized as:

Interim draws approved by a court under Directive 27R are just to be made in special circumstances.
While COVID-19 is an exceptional situation, it is insufficient to call for the orders asked for by the Trustee.
The OSB additionally argues that the motion was not on notice to the creditors in the respective trustee bankruptcies estates concerned, who might actually object to the amount being claimed by the Trustee.
The OSB is worried that, if the motion is granted and the court order made, it could cause more need on the court’s time as more Trustees will seek similar orders in other trustee bankruptcies estates.
Finally, the OSB says that this matter is not urgent and therefore ought to not be dealt with right now. The Trustee should just go for final taxation in the normal course.

The OSB also provided two earlier court decisions where interim draws were not approved in support of its opposition.

The court sees COVID-19 creating urgencies, even for trustee bankruptcies

The court considered the OSB’s submissions and the cases it relied upon. The court distinguished those cases from the current motion for these trustee bankruptcies. Due to COVID-19, the Court found that it is not practical for the Trustee to need to wait on the receipt of the OSB Letter of Comment and then proceed to final taxation.

The court stated these are not normal times. The timelines for any of the steps involved in the final taxation process could be much longer, taking into consideration the stay-at-home orders that have been issued, even including the OSB team.

The judge stated that the court must deal with the situation as it presently exists and as it advances each day, and also make appropriate decisions as necessary. He stated that businesses in all industries have been laying workers off. This includes the insolvency industry. A lot of the businesses that are still operating are doing so with minimized staff. Those businesses are attempting to make the most out of their limited cash flow to sustain operations.

The court stated that it understands that the choice it makes on this motion might bring about an influx of cases for interim draws in trustee bankruptcies. If that becomes the case, the court will deal with it. In addition, the court recognized that, because of coronavirus, interim draws are a practical method of managing the liquidity crunch presently being experienced by Trustees. Even if there had been no coronavirus pandemic, Directive 27R still allows for such an application to the court in the trustee bankruptcies.

The Court was also conscious that accounting firms, and consequently licensed insolvency trustee businesses, have been proclaimed essential services in the Province of Ontario.

**The court’s decision on the trustee bankruptices motion**

As a result of all these findings, the court decided that licensed insolvency trustees must have the tools essential to maintain their operations and to permit people and companies to get access to the Canadian insolvency system. Therefore, the court held that Trustees need to be able to access the funds in their trust accounts that they have actually earned as fees, inclusive of HST.

Taking all this into account, the court exercised its discretion and ordered that the Trustee is approved to withdraw 75% of the fee that has been earned in the three trustee bankruptcies, including HST. The Trustee should then move to final taxation. There are already safeguards built into the final taxation process where creditors in each of the trustee bankruptcies estates can object to the taxation and the total fees if they wish to.

If the total final fees are approved, then the Trustee can withdraw the remaining 25%. If final taxation results in any fees less than the 75% interim draw approved in any of the trustee bankruptcies, then the Trustee will have to repay into the bankruptcy estate the specific amount(s).

The court ordered that any costs incurred on the motion was an overhead cost of the Trustee and was not recoverable from the trustee bankruptcies. Costs were neither sought nor awarded. My understanding is that the OSB is not appealing this decision.

Trustee bankruptcies summary

I hope you have enjoyed this trustee bankruptcies Brandon’s Blog. It is the first decision I am aware of that deals with the reality that like any other entrepreneur, a licensed insolvency trustee is running a business too.

Do you or your company have too much debt? Are you or your company in need of financial restructuring? The financial restructuring process is complex. The Ira Smith Team understands how to do a complex restructuring. However, more importantly, we understand the needs of the entrepreneur or the person who has too much personal debt.

You are worried because you are facing significant financial challenges. It is not your fault that you are in this situation. You have been only shown the old ways that do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team uses new modern ways to get you out of your debt troubles while avoiding bankruptcy. We can get you debt relief freedom.

The stress placed upon you is huge. We understand your pain points. We look at your entire situation and devise a strategy that is as unique as you and your problems; financial and emotional. The way we take the load off of your shoulders and devise a debt settlement plan, we know that we can help you.

We know that people facing financial problems need realistic lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” approach with the Ira Smith Team.

That is why we can develop a restructuring process as unique as the financial problems and pain you are facing. If any of this sounds familiar to you and you are serious in finding a solution, contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. team today.

Call us now for a free consultation.

We will get you or your company back on the road to healthy stress-free operations and recover from the pain points in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

Tags bankruptcy administration, Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, bankruptcy trustee, Consumer Proposal, Corporate Bankruptcy, insolvency, Ira Smith Trustee, licensed insolvency trustee, personal bankruptcy, trustee, trustee bankruptcies, trustee in bankruptcy

Brandon Blog Post

BANKRUPTCY MEANING: OUR POWER LIST OF DUTIES OF THE BANKRUPT AND OTHERS

Post author By Brandon Smith
Post date October 19, 2020

If you would prefer to listen to an audio version of this bankruptcy meaning Brandon’s Blog, please scroll down to the bottom and click on the podcast.

Bankruptcy meaning introduction

I recently read a decision of the Supreme Court of Nova Scotia in Bankruptcy and Insolvency. It was an interesting decision about a bankrupt who essentially absented himself and became AWOL after filing for bankruptcy. I will describe the case below. However, it did get me thinking that perhaps Brandon’s Blog about the duties of the various stakeholders in the bankruptcy process would be of interest. Put another way, if everyone does not do their part, what is the bankruptcy meaning?

The Merriam-Webster dictionary provides a bankruptcy meaning definition as:

“1a: a debtor (such as an individual or an organization) whose property is subject to voluntary or involuntary administration under the bankruptcy laws for the benefit of the debtor’s creditors

b: a person who becomes insolvent

2: a person who is completely lacking in a particular desirable quality or attribute

a moral bankrupt”

In this bankruptcy meaning Brandon’s Blog, I will focus on the first definition, as that is the one I am qualified to answer.

Bankruptcy meaning: The stakeholders

There are various players in the bankruptcy process. The primary ones are:

The person or company, the debtor, who is now bankrupt.
The licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a trustee in bankruptcy) (Trustee) who administers the bankruptcy process.
The creditors who are owed money.
The Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy (Canada) (OSB) who regulates and supervises all administrations under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA) in Canada.

I will leave the duties of the bankrupt until the end. That description in the bankruptcy meaning list will flow nicely into my description of the Nova Scotia bankruptcy court case.

Bankruptcy meaning: Duties of the Trustee

There are of course various statutory steps that a Trustee must take in any bankruptcy administration. It is also obvious that the Trustee must perform those steps properly.

In addition, the OSB has established a Code of Ethics for Trustees. The Code of Ethics for Trustees is an integral part of the BIA General Rules.

The Code establishes a standard for services to be provided by Trustees. It addresses:

the information that Trustees must provide to creditors;
the treatment of funds entrusted to Trustees;
conflicts of interest; and
the sale and purchase of the property of a business or individual who has filed for bankruptcy.

It also contains standards for advertising by Trustees and for maintaining the good reputation of the Trustee community.

Rules 34 through 53 inclusive of the BIA General Rules contain what the bankruptcy meaning of the Code of Ethics for Trustees is. You can read them by clicking on this Code of Ethics for Trustees link.

There are also various Directives issued by the OSB that guide the statutory steps that a Trustee must take. Examples of these Directives are:

Directive No. 1R2 Counselling in Insolvency Matters – This Directive deals with how the Trustee should conduct the required financial counselling sessions.
Directive No. 4R Delegation of Tasks – A Directive about when certain Trustee or administrator tasks can be delegated to others.
Directive No. 5R4 – Estate Funds and Banking – How a Trustee must handle estate trust funds.
Directive No. 6R3 – Assessment of an Individual Debtor – The steps to be taken in assessing the financial situation of the debtor, explaining the various options available and what bankruptcy duties are.
Directive No. 11R – Surplus Income – When assessing the financial situation of the debtor who becomes bankrupt, how to calculate the surplus income payments obligation of the bankrupt person.
Directive No. 17 – Retention of Documents by the Trustee – This one is self-explanatory.

These are but a handful of the Directives issued by the OSB that Trustees must follow.

Bankruptcy meaning: Duties of creditors

In the bankruptcy meaning context, creditors have certain duties which can better be described as rights. Creditors are always invited and welcome to participate in the bankruptcy process. It begins with filing a Form 31 Proof of Claim as evidence of the debt owed to them by the bankrupt.

Once they file their claim in the bankruptcy estate, the creditor now has the status to fully participate in the administration of the bankruptcy estate. The filing of the proof of claim allows the creditor to vote, either in person or by proxy. They now have the authority to participate and vote at the First Meeting of Creditors. They can vote for the appointment of Inspectors.

A creditor may notify the Trustee of any kind of inappropriate activities or transactions on the part of the bankrupt that hurt the interests of the creditors. For instance, a creditor may have knowledge of assets or deals that the bankrupt failed to declare. In many cases, creditors who have dealt with the debtor over many years will have better information than the Trustee initially can gain. A Trustee always welcomes this kind of assistance from creditors. If a creditor thinks there is misconduct or illegal activities on the part of the insolvent the creditor should advise the Trustee and the OSB.

A creditor can oppose a personal bankrupt’s discharge from bankruptcy. The grounds for opposing are set out in section 173 of the BIA. The creditor must inform the Trustee and the bankrupt of the opposition and the reasons in the proper form.

By filing the opposition, the bankrupt’s discharge hearing must now go to court to be adjudicated. The Trustee cannot provide the bankrupt with an automatic discharge, even if they have fulfilled all of their duties. The creditor will provide its evidence to the court to support the opposition. The Trustee must file a report on the conduct of the bankrupt both before and during the bankruptcy administration.

Based on all the evidence, the court will then decide what kind of discharge the personal bankrupt is entitled to; absolute discharge, conditional, and/or a suspended discharge. In certain cases, the court may issue a refusal to the bankrupt. That is what happened in the Nova Scotia case I will shortly describe.

This is what the bankruptcy meaning for the rights and duties of creditors are.

bankruptcy meaning

Bankruptcy meaning: Advising the bankrupt or the officer of the bankrupt corporation of duties

The Trustee must explain to the bankrupt or the officer of a bankrupt company, his/her responsibilities. The responsibilities are found in sections 158 and 159 of the BIA. The Trustee must also explain the bankruptcy offences. Those are outlined in sections 198, 199, 200, and 204 of the BIA.

The minimum level of information a Trustee can give to the bankrupt or the officer of a bankrupt corporation is (as applicable):

information on bankruptcy for consumer debtors;

the above essential passages from the Act;

responsibilities of a bankrupt or the officer of the bankrupt company; and

debtor financial information (type and guide).

In all cases, the bankrupt or the officer of the bankrupt company has to be served with a copy of the relevant sections of the BIA. The Trustee must also get an acknowledgment from the bankrupt, or officer of the bankrupt corporation, that she or he has actually been provided with, and understands his/her obligations. The signoff by the bankrupt/the company’s officer needs to be kept on file by the Trustee.

If a bankrupt or officer of the bankrupt company declines to sign, regardless of being offered, Trustees have to keep in their file details of the refusal (i.e. evidence of service as well as details as to the refusal).

Bankruptcy meaning: The duties of the bankrupt or the officer of the bankrupt corporation

The focus of the BIA is for personal bankrupt, to return the honest but unfortunate debtor back to society free of his or her debts. The premise is that the bankrupt, or the officer of the bankrupt corporation, will fulfill their duties with integrity and honesty. The duties are outlined in the OSB’s Directive No. 26. If you are interested, you can read them HERE.

But what if they don’t? What if the individual bankrupt does not fulfill all of their duties and essentially absents themself from the process once they have filed their assignment in bankruptcy. In that case, the Trustee has an obligation to oppose the bankrupt’s application for discharge and bring the matter to court. What is the bankruptcy meaning in such a case?

That is what happened in the Nova Scotia case that I will tell you about now. I believe it is very instructive.

Bankruptcy meaning: Why a bankrupt’s discharge hearing may come to court

The substantial majority of bankrupts execute their obligations under the BIA. As a result, only a minority of bankruptcies end up in court. Mr. Jewkes’ case is one of them.

The usual factors for a bankruptcy case needing to involve the court include:

outstanding financial disclosure; and/or
surplus income payment obligations.

Discharges for third or more bankruptcy filings also need to come to court for a discharge hearing. Occasionally, a creditor objects to the bankrupt’s discharge. All matters are listened to on their merits and a decision is rendered as appropriate for the particular bankruptcy meaning.

Sometimes, there has actually been a lack of action in a bankruptcy file due to a bankrupt’s own difficulties. She or he may have a mental or physical illness. They may have not have been able to communicate with the Trustee for completely valid reasons. They might have genuinely misunderstood the obligations incumbent upon them. It is the responsibility of the Trustee and, that falling short, the court, to set things straight.

And then there is Mr. Jewkes. None of the factors where the Trustee or the court could excuse him for a simple oversight or mistake which can easily be corrected were present.

Bankruptcy meaning: The Nova Scotia case

Mr. Jewkes filed an assignment in bankruptcy in 2019. He cited “relationship breakdown” as the reason for his bankruptcy. This was his first bankruptcy. He showed income on filing to put him just below the OSB’s guidelines for paying surplus income. His assets were minimal, although he did identify the sale of his old vehicle and a mobile home with little or no equity just prior to his bankruptcy.

His creditors were the normal run of the mill kind of creditors in consumer files:

credit cards;
an unsecured line of credit;
a collection agency was after him, possibly for another credit card debt;
two mobile phone accounts; and
a utility company.

And that is where it ended. He has actually not provided the required income and expense information. He has not offered the Trustee with details required to prepare and file his pre-bankruptcy or post-bankruptcy income tax returns. He has not gone to his two mandatory credit counselling sessions. He has not complied with his payment arrangement for the Trustee’s fee. He has not given corroboration or accounting for his pre-bankruptcy vehicle and mobile home sales. His discharge hearing was held in August 2020. He did not show up for his own discharge hearing either by video or telephone.

The Trustee requested that the hearing be adjourned. The Registrar in bankruptcy court was not prepared to use more court resources and he denied the Trustee’s request.

Rather, he had enough and let his feelings be known. The bankrupt got his stay of proceedings. Notice of the bankruptcy was mailed out to the creditors. The collection calls from creditors or collection agencies stopped.

Garnishments, if such existed, ended. After that, this bankrupt went on with life and took the attitude that everyone else can take a hike.

Bankruptcy meaning: The Registrar’s decision

The Registrar wanted to send a bankruptcy meaning message that this kind of behaviour will not be tolerated. The Registrar decided that this bankruptcy meaning message will be sent by the:

bankrupt’s application for discharge being refused;
bankrupt having leave to apply on his own for discharge once he has fulfilled all of his duties;
Trustee finishing the administration and applying for its discharge forthwith;
Trustee being directed, upon its discharge, to write to all known creditors advising of the Trustee’s discharge and that the effect under the BIA is that the stay of proceedings protecting the bankrupt has ended and all creditors are free to begin or resume collection action against him.

This fourth point is not normal. It is obvious that the Registrar was fed up with this bankrupt and others who feel they can avoid performing their duties. The Registrar wanted to send a strong bankruptcy meaning message.

bankruptcy meaning

Bankruptcy meaning summary

I hope you have enjoyed this bankruptcy meaning Brandon’s Blog. Hopefully, you have better insight now into the fact that a sick insolvent company’s business can be saved by doing a sale of its assets to a healthy organization.

The stress placed upon you is huge. We understand your pain points. We look at your entire situation and devise a strategy that is as unique as you and your problems; financial and emotional. The way we take the load off of your shoulders and devise a debt settlement plan, we know that we can help you.

We know that people facing financial problems need a realistic lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” approach with the Ira Smith Team.

Call us now for a free consultation.

We will get you or your company back on the road to healthy stress-free operations and recover from the pain points in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

Tags assignment in bankruptcy, bankrptcy, bankrptcy and insolvency act, bankruptcy meaning, bankruptcy process, BIA, code of ethics for trustees, duties of the bankrupt, financial counselling, Ira Smith Trustee, licensed insolvency trustee, Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy, officer of the bankrupt corporation, OSB, trustee, trustee in bankruptcy

Brandon Blog Post

HOW HERTZ TEACHES US MODERN AND RISKY RULES OF BUSINESS BANKRUPTCY IN CANADA AND THE USA

Post author By Brandon Smith
Post date June 8, 2020

The Ira Smith Team is fully operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

Stay healthy, well balanced and safe and secure everyone.

If you would prefer to listen to the audio version of this business bankruptcy in Canada and the USA Brandon’s Blog, please scroll to the bottom and click play on the podcast.

Business bankruptcy in Canada Introduction

Late in the day on Friday, May 22, 2020, Hertz Global Holdings Inc. (Hertz) filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in Delaware. The filing gives Hertz some breathing room to operate its business. During this time, Hertz also needs to come up with a business turnaround plan and a debt restructuring plan that creditors can support. The movement of Hertz stock last week teaches us some modern and risky rules of business bankruptcy in Canada and the United States.

Corporate bankruptcies and the Hertz investors

Hertz stock closed on the NASDAQ exchange on May 22 at US$2.84. It dipped to a low of US$0.40 on May 26. Legendary investor Carl Icahn sold all of his Hertz shares at an average price of $0.72. He dumped his 39% stake in Hertz at a loss of nearly $2 billion. Last Friday Hertz shares closed at US$2.57 per share. This morning, the trading touched US$3.40 per share.

So Hertz is up handsomely since May 26. Hertz has filed for bankruptcy protection. It doesn’t make sense that investors should be pushing the stock up. Hertz is selling off its fleet and further depressing the used car market. So far there is no indication that a business plan and debt reduction plan has been developed, let alone accepted by the creditors.

As far as assets, they have locations and a database of customers. But every major rental car company also has locations and a database. Whenever business and leisure travel resumes to pre-COVID-19 levels, if you can’t rent a car from Hertz you will rent it from a different company. So what are the non-fleet assets worth?

So on the surface, the investor money finding a home in Hertz stock and pushing up the stock price doesn’t make sense. So, are there savvy investors getting into Hertz or are they all just following the herd and will all end up losers?

Why Hertz filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection

Since 2014, Hertz has had four different CEOs. It is difficult to develop and implement a cohesive business strategy with such turmoil in the senior management ranks. As the coronavirus pandemic brought travelling to a sudden halt, Hertz suffered dramatically as a mass of its revenue depended on business travellers and vacationers renting vehicles when arriving at their destination airport. Nobody knows how long it will take until travel gets back to where it was and what Hertz needs it to be.

Hertz’s debt has been increasing as it invested heavily in its vehicle fleet. They may have also missed the mark in the mix of vehicles consumers want, requiring it to take on even more debt to make further fleet purchases. Hertz could no longer afford to make the interest payments on its debt load. At the time of its bankruptcy filing, Hertz had US$1 billion of cash and US$13 billion of debt.

The $13 billion in financing Hertz made use of to acquire its fleet of 500,000 automobiles. The financing was done via what is known as asset-backed securities. These are connected straight to the value of the vehicles. When the value of the cars drops, Hertz must make up the difference in cash within about three months, unless values rebound before that time.

However, with the coronavirus pounding the brakes on the economy and eliminating employment for so many, the drop in the value of used vehicles is expected to remain that way for a long time. Hertz knew that it could not make up the difference to its lenders when they made a demand, which was their right. Hence the bankruptcy filing.

The modern risky rules of investing in business bankruptcy in Canada and the USA

Normally, in a public company restructuring, it is not only the creditors that take a hit. Shareholders usually get a good drubbing. Share values fall and new shares are issued to raise capital. This further dilutes the holdings and value of those holdings for shareholders. But investors must believe that Hertz will come back. How else can you explain the surge in the share price?

Before this year, the company had ten consecutive quarters of positive growth. They were still losing money, just not as much. Investors must believe that Hertz will be able to survive. They must believe that the company although leaner and smaller, this is the time to jump on an opportunity to make money.

I am not a financial advisor, I am not saying whether this is a good or bad investment. It certainly is a very risky one. All I am saying is that as a licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a trustee in bankruptcy) administering business bankruptcy in Canada, this does not make any sense to me.

I guess only time will tell if these investors pushing up the stock price are insightful risk-takers or losers. Carl Icahn doesn’t believe it.

Business bankruptcy in Canada and the USA summary

I hope you have found this business bankruptcy in Canada and the USA Brandon’s Blog helpful.

The Ira Smith Team family hopes that you and your family members are remaining secure, healthy and well-balanced. Our hearts go out to every person that has been affected either via misfortune or inconvenience.

We all must help each other to stop the spread of the coronavirus. Social distancing and self-quarantining are sacrifices that are not optional. Families are separated from each other. We look forward to the time when life can return to something near to typical and we can all be together once again.

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. has constantly used clean, safe and secure ways in our professional firm and we continue to do so.

Revenue and cash flow shortages are critical issues facing entrepreneurs and their companies and businesses. This is especially true these days.

If anyone needs our assistance for debt relief Canada COVID, or you just need some answers for questions that are bothering you, feel confident that Ira or Brandon can still assist you. Telephone consultations and/or virtual conferences are readily available for anyone feeling the need to discuss their personal or company situation.

The Ira Smith Team is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

Stay healthy, well balanced and safe and secure everyone.

Tags Bankruptcy, bankruptcy filing, bankruptcy protection, business bankruptcy, business bankruptcy in canada, carl icahn, chapter 11, chapter 11 bankruptcy, company restructuring, corporate bankruptcies, covid-19, Hertz, Ira Smith Trustee, licensed insolvency trustee, restructuring, trustee in bankruptcy

What is in the Canadian Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act?

What is the purpose of the Canadian Bankruptcy & Insolvency Act?

What options are available under the Canadian Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act?

Consumer proposal

Commercial proposal

Receivers and Secured Creditors

Bankruptcy

Canadian Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act: Can bankruptcy protect you from creditors?

A word on cross-border insolvencies

Canadian Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act: Personal bankruptcy

Canadian Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act summary

The bankruptcy trustee in Vaughan: We transformed into a licensed insolvency trustee Vaughan

Role of a Licensed Insolvency Trustee Vaughan (formerly called Trustee in Bankruptcy Vaughan)

Find the right option with the help of a Licensed Insolvency Trustee Vaughan

Personal situation insolvency

Corporate insolvency

Selecting The Right Licensed Insolvency Trustee in Vaughan

Experience and professionalism

Interacting with them on many levels is essential

Licensed insolvency trustee Vaughan: Are you able to agree on the same concepts?

Websites for licensed insolvency trustee Vaughan

You can meet with more than one Trustee

3 Best Licensed Insolvency Trustees in Vaughan, ON

Licensed insolvency trustee Vaughan summary

What does the bankruptcy trustee investigate – What is a bankruptcy trustee?

What does the bankruptcy trustee investigate – Tell your bankruptcy trustee everything

What does the bankruptcy trustee investigate? What if I fail to remember to divulge something?

What does the bankruptcy trustee investigate? What can I do?

What does the bankruptcy trustee investigate? What if I have outstanding tax returns?

What does the bankruptcy trustee investigate? What happens If I overreported income?

What does the bankruptcy trustee investigate? Suppose I am not divulging certain information?

What does the bankruptcy trustee investigate? – Collection of information by bankruptcy trustee also allowed under PIPEDA

What does the bankruptcy trustee investigate? – Can I sell my stuff before filing bankruptcy?

What does the bankruptcy trustee investigate and look for in bank statements?

Red flags the bankruptcy trustee looks for at the meeting of creditors

What does the bankruptcy trustee investigate – When the bankruptcy trustee suspects fraud?

What does the bankruptcy trustee investigate summary

Trustee in Bankruptcy: No action against Trustees without leave of court

Action against the trustee in bankruptcy background

The plaintiff’s claim against the trustee in bankruptcy

The court’s analysis

Trustee in bankruptcy: The court’s decision

Finding a good, Licensed Insolvency Trustee (Trustee In Bankruptcy) Near You

Bankruptcy and divorce: Equalization payment introduction

Bankruptcy and property: Insolvency 101 on what happens to property in a personal bankruptcy

What are equalization payments in divorce?

Rusinek & Associates v. Arachchilage & Baliah, 2020 ONSC 1090 (CanLII)

Bankruptcy and equalization payments: Court of Appeal for Ontario says the timing of the bankruptcy matters

How does an unpaid equalization payment intersect with bankruptcy?

What happens to joint debt if you file for bankruptcy?

Equalization payment and Ontario divorce and bankruptcy summary

How much does a consumer proposal cost: Only pay a Trustee for consumer proposal services

How much does a consumer proposal cost: Getting rid of debt

How much does a consumer proposal cost: Get a personalized debt free plan

How much does a consumer proposal cost: A negotiated debt settlement

The Cost of a Consumer Proposal in Ontario

How much does a consumer proposal cost: Consumer proposal costs in Ontario

How much does a consumer proposal cost: Get a personalized debt free plan today

File bankruptcy in Canada online introduction

Can I file bankruptcy in Canada online?

How the coronavirus pandemic pushed bankruptcy online

Trustees already use an online bankruptcy filing system

File bankruptcy in Canada: The rest of the process is the same as before

File bankruptcy in Canada online: A word of warning

File bankruptcy in Canada summary

If you would prefer to listen to the audio version of this trustee bankruptcies Brandon’s Blog, please scroll to the bottom and click on the podcast.

Trustee bankruptcies introduction

What are the fees of a licensed insolvency trustee?

A bankruptcy trustee needs cash flow too

Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy (OSB) Directive no. 27R

The OSB did not like the court application

The court sees COVID-19 creating urgencies, even for trustee bankruptcies

The court’s decision on the trustee bankruptices motion

Trustee bankruptcies summary

Bankruptcy meaning introduction

Bankruptcy meaning: The stakeholders

Bankruptcy meaning: Duties of the Trustee

Bankruptcy meaning: Duties of creditors

Bankruptcy meaning: Advising the bankrupt or the officer of the bankrupt corporation of duties

Bankruptcy meaning: The duties of the bankrupt or the officer of the bankrupt corporation

***File bankruptcy in Canada*: The rest of the process is the same as before**

**A bankruptcy trustee needs cash flow too**

**The court’s decision on the trustee bankruptices motion**