Tag: personal bankruptcy canada

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

Define Conditional Discharge: The Truth About It Not Being An Automatic “Get Out of Debt Free” Card

Image reflecting the potential tha tan absolute discharge from bankruptcy is not automatic and showing the various attributes that define conditonal discharge.

A professional silver key turning in a lock, with thick metallic chains falling away, symbolizing the transition from bankruptcy to a fresh start once we know how to define conditional discharge.

Define Conditional Discharge: Introduction

Hello and welcome. If you are reading this, you might be feeling the weight of financial uncertainty on your shoulders. Please know that you are safe here, and you are certainly not alone. At Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc., we understand that life can throw unexpected curveballs, and facing the bankruptcy process is a brave step toward reclaiming your future. Our goal is to guide you through the fog with clarity, compassion, and a concrete plan to get you back on your feet.

In this Brandon’s Blog, we define conditional discharge, discuss what it means and discuss a 2021 Court of Appeal for British Columbia decision.

Define Conditional Discharge Key Takeaways

  • Bankruptcy isn’t always automatic: While many expect a simple end date, certain factors can lead you to define conditional discharge.
  • Conditions are “homework”: The court may define conditional discharge by requiring you to pay money or perform specific duties before your debts are legally wiped away.
  • You remain “undischarged”: Until conditions are met, you are an undischarged bankrupt and still subject to certain legal restrictions.
  • A Licensed Insolvency Trustee is your ally: We help you navigate these conditions to ensure you reach the finish line, the absolute discharge.

Define Conditional Discharge Highlights

  • What is a Conditional Discharge?
  • Why Do Courts Impose Conditions?
  • Common Conditions You Might Face
  • Comparing Discharge Types: Absolute vs. Conditional vs. Suspended
  • The “12-Year Trap”: A Real-World Case Study
  • How to Transition from Conditional to Absolute Discharge
  • Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

How Do You Define Conditional Discharge?

When you enter personal bankruptcy Canada, the ultimate goal is the discharge. This is the legal document that releases you from the obligation to pay back the debts you owed at the time you filed.

However, a discharge is not always a straight line. If there is an opposition to your discharge, perhaps from a creditor, the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy, or your own Trustee, the matter goes before an Associate Justice. Instead of granting you a clean break immediately, the court might issue a conditional discharge.

The important issue is how the court will define conditional discharge. What requirements does the court place on you to fulfill before you really do get discharged from your bankruptcy? It is the discharge, and not the filing for bankruptcy, that releases you from your debts.

I suggest that you should define conditional discharge as an “absolute discharge in principle, but with strings attached.” It means the court has decided you deserve a fresh start, but only after you complete a few more tasks or pay a bit more into the pot for your creditors.

A Licensed Insolvency Trustee in a professional Toronto office explaining discharge conditions to a client., including how to define conditional discharge

Why do courts impose conditions?

We know the tension put upon you when you feel like the goalposts have been moved. It is important to remember: it is not your fault that the law has these complexities. The court’s job is to balance your need for a fresh start with the rights of the people you owe money to.

The court typically imposes conditions if:

  1. Duties were missed: You may have forgotten to attend your mandatory counselling sessions (educational meetings designed to help you manage money better in the future).
  2. Surplus income exists: If your income is above a certain threshold, the law requires you to pay a portion of that “extra” money to your Trustee, and you haven’t paid it all.
  3. High tax debt: If you owe more than $200,000 in personal income tax, and that makes up 75% or more of your total debt, the law requires a court hearing. Under Section 172.1 of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA), you are defined as a High-Tax Debtor who is not eligible for an automatic discharge
  4. Conduct issues: If you weren’t fully transparent about your assets, or if you’ve been through bankruptcy multiple times before.

Define Conditional Discharge: Common conditions you might face

If you find yourself as one of the many undischarged bankrupts in the GTA, your court order will likely list one or more of the following “homework” assignments:

  • Payment of a specific sum: The court might order you to pay, for example, $5,000 over 12 months.
  • Performing duties: You might need to provide missing tax information or finally attend those two mandatory counselling sessions.
  • Surrendering assets: You may be required to turn over a specific piece of property that was previously undisclosed.

Comparing discharge types: A quick guide

Navigating debt relief Toronto requires knowing exactly where you stand. Use this table to understand the different flavours of discharge:

Discharge TypeWhat it MeansStatus of Your Debt
Absolute DischargeYou have completed everything. You are 100% finished.Debts are legally wiped away (with certain exceptions like child or spousal support).
Conditional DischargeYou have “homework” to do first (payments or duties).You are still responsible for your debts until conditions are met.
Suspended DischargeYour discharge is granted but won’t take effect until a future date.Debts are wiped away only once the suspension period ends.
Refused DischargeThe court denies your request due to extreme misconduct or non-compliance.You remain bankrupt and still owe all your debts.

The “12-Year Trap”: A real-world case study to define conditional discharge

To see how the court thinks, let’s look at the case of Perrier v. Canada (Revenue Agency). In this instance, a bankrupt individual was ordered to pay $150,000 at a rate of $1,000 per month as a condition of his discharge.

On the surface, it seems fair to ask someone to pay what they can. However, the Court of Appeal stepped in. They realized that at $1,000 a month, it would take the man over 12 years to finish. Since he was nearing retirement, this condition would have followed him into his golden years, effectively denying him the “fresh start” that personal bankruptcy Canada is supposed to provide.

The court reduced the amount to $45,000 over five years, proving that the conditions must be reasonable and attainable. This is why having a Licensed Insolvency Trustee Toronto, like the team at Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc., is vital; we ensure the court understands your reality.

A legal document with a bold 'CONDITIONAL' stamp and a judge's gavel, representing the formal court process and how to define conditional discharge.

How to transition from Define Conditional Discharge to “Absolute”

Being an undischarged bankrupt can feel like being in “financial purgatory,” but the path out is clear. Here is how we help you reach that absolute discharge:

  1. Provide you with an upfront warning: As your licensed insolvency trustee, if we are in a position where we feel we will need to oppose your absolute discharge, we will provide you with a warning and advise you on what steps you need to take to avoid our opposition. If a creditor opposes your discharge from bankruptcy, we look at their reasons and provide you with advice as to what you should do ahead of the court discharge hearing.
  2. Review the Conditional Order: We sit down with you to translate the “legalese” into plain English.
  3. Create a Payment Schedule: If money is owed, we help you budget so the payments are manageable.
  4. Complete the Tasks: We facilitate your counselling sessions and help you gather any missing documentation.
  5. The Certificate of Compliance: Once you’ve done your part, we notify the court or the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy. You will then receive your absolute discharge.

The “why” behind all of this is simple: we want you to have a life free from the shadow of debt. Completing these conditions is the final hurdle before you can truly say you have started over.

Define Conditional Discharge Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What happens if I can’t afford the payments in my conditional discharge?

If your circumstances change, for example, you lose your job or face a medical crisis, you aren’t stuck. After one year, we can help you apply back to the court to vary the order (change the terms) to something you can actually manage.

Can I still get credit while I have a conditional discharge?

As an undischarged bankrupt, you are legally required to disclose your bankruptcy status to any lender if you are seeking credit over $1,000. It is generally very difficult to get traditional credit during this phase.

How long do I have to meet the conditions?

The court usually sets a timeline, but if they don’t, the conditions remain in place until they are satisfied. The sooner you finish, the sooner you get your fresh start.

Does a conditional discharge show up on my credit report?

Yes. Your credit report will reflect that you are in bankruptcy until you receive your absolute discharge. Once you reach the absolute stage, the “clock” for how long the bankruptcy stays on your report finally starts ticking.

Starting Over, Starting NOW

Don’t let financial uncertainty dictate your future. If you or your business is struggling with debt, losing sleep, or facing legal action, . Call Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. today.

We offer a free, confidential consultation to discuss your situation, explain your options in plain language, and help you develop a clear, actionable plan. Our team of Licensed Insolvency Trustees is dedicated to providing the compassionate, professional support you need to regain control and achieve a debt-free life.

Take the first step towards a brighter financial future. Call us now.

The Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy licenses Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. Ira and Brandon Smith are members of the Canadian Association of Insolvency and Restructuring Professionals.

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , –

Disclaimer: This analysis is for educational purposes only and is based on the cited sources and professional expertise as a Licensed Insolvency Trustee. The information provided does not constitute legal or financial advice for your specific circumstances. Every situation is unique; the outcomes discussed may not apply to your particular case. Please contact Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. to discuss your specific needs.

About the Author:

Brandon Smith is a Senior Vice-President at Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. and a Licensed Insolvency Trustee serving clients across Ontario. His experience includes consumer insolvency and complex court-ordered receivership and corporate bankruptcy administration, giving him practical insight into navigating challenging financial situations to achieve optimal outcomes for businesses, creditors, and professionals. Brandon stays current with landmark developments in Canadian insolvency law, ensuring his clients benefit from a cutting-edge understanding of their rights and options.Image reflecting the potential tha tan absolute discharge from bankruptcy is not automatic and showing the various attributes that define conditonal discharge.

#BankruptcyCanada #DebtReliefToronto #InsolvencyTrustee #FinancialFreshStart #ConsumerProposal #IraSmithInc #defineconditionaldischarge #define conditional discharge

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

BANKRUPTCY IN CANADA: THE STEP-BY-STEP CANADIAN PERSONAL BANKRUPTCY PROCESS

Introduction

The purpose of this Brandon’s Blog is to explain to you the personal bankruptcy in Canada process. By doing so I hope it will be a less scary topic for you.

Are you insolvent?

The first step is meeting with the trustee to explore options. The first thing the licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a bankruptcy trustee) (Trustee) needs to determine is if the person is insolvent.

Insolvent means that you cannot pay your debts as they come due and that if you liquidated all of your assets it would not be enough to repay all of your liabilities. If you’re not insolvent then you cannot take advantage of the provisions of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada).

What are my options?

If you’re not insolvent the options that are available to you are:

  • help with your budgeting;
  • perhaps credit counselling mixed in with that to help you better understand your income and expenses; and
  • how to live within your means

Perhaps also there is the opportunity, if you still have a good enough credit score, to get a debt consolidation loan. This would be a loan that would be equal to the total of all your other debts but at a lower interest rate and with a smaller monthly payment than the total monthly payments you currently need to make to stay current with all your debts.

If you are insolvent then the options available to a person is either a:

bankruptcy in canada
bankruptcy in canada

The purpose and topic in this blog are bankruptcy so that is what I will focus on. There will be other videos made on the topics of a consumer proposal, budgeting, credit counselling and debt consolidation.

How does bankruptcy in Canada work?

So the personal bankruptcy in Canada process as I mentioned starts with meeting the Trustee to explore your options. Then with the Trustee, determining whether or not you are insolvent and then making the right choice. Does that mean that bankruptcy is the best process for your needs, or can you avoid bankruptcy?.

So given that we’re talking about bankruptcy in Canada, what are the steps? First, the Trustee will prepare the documentation for your review. The documentation consists mainly of the assignment in bankruptcy document, your statement of affairs and your monthly family budget.

The statement of affairs is a multi-page document that indicates what your assets are and the names and addresses and individual amounts owing to each of your creditors. Your monthly family budget shows your monthly cash in and cash out.

An important part of the bankruptcy in Canada process is rehabilitation. Financial rehabilitation. So it is expected upon entering personal bankruptcy in Canada that your monthly family budget will balance. That is your income after tax will be sufficient to pay your monthly family expenses.

What does declaring bankruptcy mean in Canada?

Once that is all prepared and you’ve sworn your statement of affairs the Trustee can begin the bankruptcy process itself. That includes e-Filing the documentation I just spoke about with the Superintendent of Bankruptcy’s local office.

The Superintendent of Bankruptcy local office representative will review it to make sure that it is all in order. Then the local office will issue a certificate confirming your bankruptcy and the appointment of the Trustee.

It is at the time when the Superintendent actually issues the certificate that the person’s bankruptcy starts.

So when bankruptcy occurs then certain things must happen. The bankruptcy administration takes place. The bankruptcy administration will include:

  • Providing the trustee with any non-exempt assets that you may own. The Trustee will sell those assets to raise money to be able to make a distribution of some sort to your creditors.
  • The next part of the bankruptcy administration is that the bankrupt person must attend 2 counselling sessions for personal bankruptcy in Canada. These two counselling sessions are meant to help the person financially rehabilitate themselves.

You will discuss with the Trustee things such as budgeting, issues that led you into bankruptcy and how you can correct that behaviour and any problems you might be experiencing during the bankruptcy process.

  • Finally, if all goes well there is the bankruptcy discharge. That is where the person has made it through and upon their discharge, they are discharged of all of their debts other than those that might be secured, have a trust claim status or meet the definition of those few types of debts such as court fines and penalties that cannot be discharged by way of bankruptcy.

But things like credit card debt and income tax debt are discharged through the bankruptcy process.

Personal bankruptcy Canada

So if you have debt issues meet with a Trustee. There is no charge to do so and you will walk away with a better idea of how to fix your debt issues with or without resorting to personal bankruptcy in Canada.

I hope you enjoyed the bankruptcy in Canada video. The Ira Smith team is available to help you at any time. We offer sound advice and a solid plan for Starting Over Starting Now.

We understand your pain. We will make sure that no bill collectors call you. We will take all the headaches and stress you are experiencing off of your hands and put it onto our shoulders. We will fix things so that you can move forward in a healthy way, pain-free, guilt-free and debt-free.

It is not your fault that you are in this situation. You could not fix it yourself because you have only been taught the old ways. The old ways do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team uses new ways that will return you immediately to a stress-free life while getting rid of your debt.

So that you can immediately be well on your way to debt and stress-free life in no time, for more information on a no-cost basis, please call us now.

The Ira Smith Team comprehends just how to do a complex restructuring. However, more notably, we understand the needs of the business owner or the person that has too much personal financial debt. You are worried due to the fact that you are encountering significant economic obstacles.

It is not your mistake that you are in this scenario. You have been only shown the old ways which do not function anymore. The Ira Smith Team utilizes new contemporary ways to take you out of your financial debt problems while preventing bankruptcy. We can get you financial debt relief.

The stress and anxiety placed upon you is massive. We comprehend your discomfort factors. We look at your entire situation and also devise a technique that is as special as you and also your issues; economic as well as emotional. The methods we use takes tons off of your shoulders. We devise a financial debt negotiation strategy, we understand that we can help you.

We understand that individuals encountering monetary troubles need a reasonable lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” method with the Ira Smith Team. That is why we can create a restructuring process as unique as the financial problems and also discomfort you are encountering. If any one of these seems familiar to you and you are serious about getting a solution, contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. team today.

Call us now for a no-cost appointment. We will certainly get you or your firm back driving to healthy stress-free operations as well as save you from the discomfort factors in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

bankruptcy in canada
bankruptcy in canada
Categories
Brandon Blog Post

#VIDEO – IS SURPLUS INCOME IN BANKRUPTCY POPULAR? #

[monkeytools msnip=”http://monkeyplayr.com/playr.php?u=5173&p=20577″]

This is one of the most popular questions about bankruptcy we are always asked. The concept of surplus income in bankruptcy doesn’t seem to make much sense. After all, if you are bankrupt, how can you have surplus income? So let’s start at the beginning and clear up all the confusion. That way we can explain the answer to the question “What is surplus income in bankruptcy?”.

The answer

Heading into bankruptcy, your licensed insolvency trustee (LIT) must make an assessment. The more you earn, the more you must contribute. A definition is:

The amount of a debtor’s total income that exceeds what is necessary to maintain a reasonable standard of living. A reasonable standard of living is according to the standards set by the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy. This is also sometimes called the OSB surplus.

The actual Superintendent’s standards are right at the poverty line so don’t get happy when you see words like “reasonable standard of living”. The bankrupt must make payments out of this surplus income to the LIT for distribution among the creditors.

The Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy sets limits for what a family can earn. The larger your family, the more you can keep. The thresholds increase each year. The government has established a list of earnings levels for households of different sizes.

If the household’s revenue exceeds the level set by the government then you have surplus income. Payments are made to your LIT. The government’s instructions about surplus income are in the Superintendent’s Directive 11R2.

What can I deduct for surplus income in bankruptcy?

There are some allowable deductions this calculation in bankruptcy:

  1. child support payments
  2. spousal support payments
  3. child care expenses
  4. expenses associated with a medical condition
  5. Court-imposed fines or penalties that are in the process of being paid
  6. expenses permitted by the Income Tax Act (or similar provincial legislation) that are a condition of employment
  7. any other debt where a stay of proceedings has been lifted by the Court and a recourse authorized
  8. interest paid on debts that are not dischargeable in bankruptcy under paragraph 178(1)(g) of the Act

If my salary changes, does my calculation change?

During your bankruptcy, you will have to report your monthly income and expenses to your LIT. The LIT must perform the surplus income calculation every time your income changes while you are in bankruptcy. You must make up any extra amount required if your income rises while you are in bankruptcy.

In a debt settlement restructuring, the amount you and your creditors have agreed upon is the same amount you pay. There is no monthly reporting of your income to your LIT and no recalibration to an increased amount if your income rises. Therefore, in a consumer proposal, surplus income in bankruptcy must be considered. This is to make sure that your consumer proposal is a better alternative than bankruptcy.

What now if I have too much debt?

If you’re considering bankruptcy you need the services of a LIT. Contact Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. We provide the depth of expertise found in a large company, delivered in an informal setting. We ensure you will receive a high quality and cost-effective service.

With a joint 50+ years of experience dealing with diverse issues and complex files, the Ira Smith team delivers the highest quality of professional service. Take the first step to Starting Over, Starting Now.

THIS VLOG WAS INSPIRED IN PART BY OUR eBOOK – PERSONAL BANKRUPTCY CANADA: Not because you are a dummy, because you need to get your life back on track

 

surplus income

 

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

#VIDEO – BANKRUPTCY INFORMATION ONLINE: WHAT EVERY CANADIAN OUGHT TO KNOW#

[monkeytools msnip=”http://monkeyplayr.com/playr.php?u=5173&p=20586″]

Is there bankruptcy information online?

There is a large amount of bankruptcy information online. Just go to the website of any Licensed Insolvency Trustee or bankruptcy lawyer. There is information about:

  • Canadian bankruptcy
  • the Canadian Bankruptcy Act (BIA)
  • general insolvency information

The Ira Smith Trustee website

On our website, you will find bankruptcy information online such as:

The other source for information online

You can also find relevant bankruptcy information online at the Superintendent of Bankruptcy Canada website.

To take action you have to take it offline

Once you have gotten the online information, to take action, you need to take it offline. It is not possible in Canada to file online yourself.

To file either a consumer proposal to make debt settlement or bankruptcy, you need to select a Licensed Insolvency Trustee. A Licensed Insolvency Trustee administers the insolvency process in Canada.

The 10 Step Program of the Canadian Insolvency System

  1. Meet with a trustee to talk about your personal situation and your options.
  2. Work with the trustee to complete the required forms.
  3. The trustee filing your consumer proposal or bankruptcy and notifying your creditors.
  4. You attend a meeting of creditors if required.
  5. You attend two counselling sessions.
  6. Subject to your provincial exemptions, the trustee sells your assets; you may also have to make surplus income payments to the trustee.
  7. In certain circumstances, you may have to attend an examination by an officer at the OSB.
  8. The trustee prepares a report to the OSB describing your actions during the bankruptcy.
  9. You attend the discharge hearing if required.
  10. Your discharge and then the trustee completes the administration.

This is why to take action in the Canadian insolvency system you have to take it offline

How To Take Action To Achieve Debt Settlement

If you’re in deep financial difficulties and are looking for a way out, there is help for you. You need help from experts in debt – professional trustees.

We are:

  1. regulated by the Canadian government, as are our fees;
  2. licensed and have undergone a background check by the RCMP;
  3. subject to a stringent code of ethics; and
  4. required to maintain our competence by completing ongoing mandatory professional development each year.

Are you an individual or company who feels your situation is hopeless? Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. can prepare and put in place the plan MADE JUST FOR YOU. The plan will free you from the burden of your financial challenges. With our help, you will go on to live a productive, stress-free, financially sound life.

Contact Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. today. Starting Over, Starting Now you can free yourself from debt.

THIS VLOG WAS INSPIRED IN PART BY OUR eBOOK – PERSONAL BANKRUPTCY CANADA: Not because you are a dummy, because you need to get your life back on track

bankruptcy information online

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

STUDENT LOANS DEBT: WILL BANKRUPTCY ELIMINATE IT IF YOU ARE NOT THE STUDENT?

student loans, student loan, student loan debt, ira smith trustee, amazon.ca, starting over starting now, licensed insolvency trustee, bankruptcy, bankruptcy alternatives, credit counselling, consumer proposals, debt consolidation, Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, BIA, student loans, debt, debts, personal bankruptcy, declare personal bankruptcy, student debt, student debt bankruptcy, Bankruptcy Reform Act, Bankruptcy Code, Code, toronto bankruptcy, vaughan bankruptcy, bankruptcy toronto, bankruptcy vaughan, consumer proposal toronto, consumer proposal vaughan, vaughan consumer proposal, toronto consumer proposal, personal bankruptcy vaughan, personal bankruptcy toronto, toronto personal bankruptcy, vaughan personal bankruptcy, ccaa, corporate bankruptcy;

An interesting American case about student loans debt

Student loans debt is nearly impossible to get rid of in bankruptcy. A case winding its way through the US court system has piqued our intellectual interest. A father, who is a discharged bankrupt, is taking the lender who HE borrowed funds from for his child’s education to Court. The lender is continuing to pursue collection efforts against the father on the basis that the provisions of the Bankruptcy Reform Act of 1978, as amended, codified in Title 11 of the United States Code and commonly called the “Bankruptcy Code” (“Code”), does not release the father from what is in reality student loans debt. The father is taking the lender to Court for a ruling that by virtue of his discharge, he is released from that debt like all his other debts. It has raised the question whether the same student loans debt rules should apply in that case.

The Canadian perspective

We are not qualified to express any opinion on the US legal case before the US Court, but we are qualified to discuss the issue from the Canadian perspective. We started thinking whether this same situation could arise in Canada for student loans.

Last week we discussed student debt bankruptcy from the perspective of the student. Previously, we have written blogs and created a vlog about student loan debt, including:

So this week, we’re discussing student loan debt and bankruptcy from a very different and interesting angle. Could a Canadian lender take the position against a Canadian parent borrower who on the loan application described the purpose of the loans for the funding of his or her child’s Canadian post-secondary education, that the loans qualify as student loans under the applicable Canadian statutes, including, the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA). Stated otherwise, are such loans the same as student loans under Canadian law and can bankruptcy cut such loans if you’re not the student?

Are student loans necessary?

Many young Canadians need student loans to get a post-secondary education. To qualify as Canadian student loan debt, the loans must be issued under a specific Canadian student loan statute: the (i) Canada Student Loans Act; (ii) Canada Student Financial Assistance Act; (iii) Apprentice Loans Act; or (iv) any enactment of a province that provides for loans or guarantees of loans to students.

All students need financial help to be full-time university students. The only real places that such assistance can come from is either the parents, if they are willing and able to do so, student loans, or both. Many Canadian parents pay a hefty part of students’ tuition fees, even if it means sacrificing their financial stability, to help their children avoid a post-graduation life burdened by tens of thousands of dollars of student debt. Others may wish to, but they cannot afford to do so.

So are student loans and the resultant debt necessary? In most cases, yes.

Can a parent co-sign for or guarantee their child’s student loans?

The short answer is no. As I have already stated, to qualify as a student loan, the loan has to be made under the provisions of one of the Federal loan statutes mentioned above, or any such similar Provincial legislation. Nowhere in those student loans statutes is there a place for either a guarantor or cosigner. In fact, the Federal statutes all have similar language stating that upon the death of the borrower, the Federal government will repay the outstanding part of the loan. In addition to there not being any sections that allow for a guarantor or cosigner, the specific section dealing with the death of the borrower does not limit the government’s guarantee by using words like “….and if the lender is unable to collect in full from any guarantor or cosigner”. The reason is simple, student loans cannot be guaranteed or otherwise borrowed by anyone other than the student.

Will bankruptcy eliminate student loans debt?

Student loans are nearly impossible to get rid of in bankruptcy. Section 178(1) of the BIA states:

“(g) any debt or obligation in respect of a loan made under the Canada Student Loans Act, the Canada Student Financial Assistance Act or any enactment of a province that provides for loans or guarantees of loans to students where the date of bankruptcy of the bankrupt occurred:

(i) before the date on which the bankrupt ceased to be a full- or part-time student, as the case may be, under the applicable Act or enactment, or

(ii) within seven years after the date on which the bankrupt ceased to be a full- or part-time student;

(g.1) any debt or obligation in respect of a loan made under the Apprentice Loans Act where the date of bankruptcy of the bankrupt occurred

(i) before the date on which the bankrupt ceased, under that Act, to be an eligible apprentice within the meaning of that Act, or

(ii) within seven years after the date on which the bankrupt ceased to be an eligible apprentice;”

So if you’re a student, bankruptcy will only end student loans if you’ve ceased to be a full or part-time student for more than seven years and either declare personal bankruptcy or make a debt proposal to your creditors, most likely through a consumer proposal. The only other option is to attempt to seek from the Court relief because of undue hardship, but this is very difficult, if not impossible.

What is required to meet the burden of undue hardship?

If the Court is satisfied that you meet the two-pronged test, you’ll be discharged from your student loans obligations in bankruptcy only if the :

  • acted in good faith in connection with your obligation to repay your student loan debt; and (emphasis added)
  • have experienced, and will continue to experience, financial difficulty that will prevent you from repaying this debt

It’s then up to the bankruptcy court to decide whether they forgive your loans, either in full or in part. One of the difficulties in trying to prove undue hardship is that there is no clear definition for what makes up hardship; each bankruptcy court across Canada may use a slightly different interpretation. The only thing that’s clear is that you must prove that having to continue to pay the student loans after bankruptcy would be a financial hardship for you. If you try this route, the Court will look at ALL of your income and expenses.

The Court may decide you are not trying hard enough, or, may look at things like your small car you use to get to work, which you purchased used (instead of taking public transit), your cell phone and your internet expenses, and decide that these are luxuries you do not need. If you are a smoker, the Court may very well decide that if you were not addicted to tobacco, you could start to repay some part of your student loans.

If you think my examples are picayune or silly, just look up the case of Fournier (Re), 2009 CanLII 31606 (ON SC).

Will bankruptcy eliminate student loan debt if you are not the student?

I don’t know what the eventual disposition of the US case which I mentioned at the beginning of this blog will be, but based on all the above, in my view in the Canadian context, a parent, relative or friend cannot guarantee, cosign or borrow for a loan that qualifies as a Canadian student loan. If you borrow to fund your child’s education, then you are borrowing under an ordinary commercial transaction and the applicable student loan sections of the BIA do not apply.

So if you have borrowed for this purpose, only the normal provisions of the BIA apply, and you will get a discharge from that and your other debts upon your discharge from bankruptcy. However, if you pledged any of your assets in support of such borrowings, such as your home, the lender does have the right to enforce its security against such assets if you cannot repay, whether you are bankrupt or not.

What should you do if you have too much debt?

If you’re drowning because of your finances, we know we can help you. Although many people believe that bankruptcy is the only way of out serious debt, that’s not always the case. Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc.can discuss other bankruptcy alternatives with you which include credit counselling, debt consolidation and consumer proposals.

If we get to see you early enough, at the first sign of trouble, you can use and carry out one of the bankruptcy alternatives, to free you from the burden of your financial challenges to go on to be a productive, contributing member of society and not be plagued by debt problems.

Bankruptcy law is very complicated and requires the expertise of a professional licensed insolvency trustee. Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. is here to help. With a cumulative 50+ years of experience dealing with diverse issues and complex files, we can get you back on your feet Starting Over, Starting Now. We can help. Call us today.


People consider us bankruptcy experts because we wrote the eBook which is sold on Amazon.ca, explaining the Canadian personal insolvency and bankruptcy system, specifically directed to the person stressed out with too much debt.

 

Call a Trustee Now!