Categories
Brandon Blog Post

COMPANY IS BANKRUPT: A COMPLETE GUIDE TO BANKRUPTCY SALES FOR BUYERS

An Introduction to Company Is Bankrupt Asset Sales

On May 13 of this year, I published Brandon’s Blog titled: NAVIGATING THE STALKING HORSE OFFER LEGAL MAZE: THE TOOL SHED BREWING BANKRUPTCY PROTECTION EXPERIENCE. This week I am expanding on that specific Brandon’s Blog to comment on bankruptcy asset sales in general.

For anyone interested in strategic acquisitions and investment opportunities, exploring bankruptcy sales can offer a unique avenue to acquire assets at distressed pricing. In this Brandon’s Blog, I delve into the intricacies of bankruptcy sales, particularly focusing on buying assets when a company is bankrupt in Ontario, to provide you with a comprehensive understanding of the process and considerations involved.

Types of Bankruptcy

Let’s embark on this journey together to unlock the potential of acquiring assets through bankruptcy sales. When I use the term “bankruptcy sale”, I mean all the various types of bankruptcy or insolvency processes. It could be in the context of a sale of assets by a court-appointed receiver or even the company that has filed for restructuring under bankruptcy protection and is looking to sell assets out of the ordinary course of business.

For this Brandon’s Blog, you can consider it to mean any court-supervised insolvency process, be it out of a sale of assets when the company is bankrupt or in receivership under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA). The issues are the same be it a bankruptcy or receivership.

When delving into the realm of bankruptcy sales, one encounters a landscape that offers both challenges and opportunities. The allure of acquiring distressed assets at potentially discounted prices is undeniable. Picture this: a sales process setting where bidders, including yourself, have the chance to engage in a fair competition, armed with the ability to conduct due diligence and submit bids for coveted assets. Such is the essence of a bankruptcy sale.

A bankruptcy sale isn’t just a run-of-the-mill transaction; it is a meticulously structured process governed by legal frameworks and case law. The principles applied from the leading case law act as a guiding light, laying down the procedures for sales that occur outside the typical course of business. It sets the stage for a structured process where the highest or best bid, subject to stakeholder approval, court approval, or both, emerges victorious.

The pivotal role of court approval in sale transactions cannot be overstated. It serves as the ultimate checkpoint, ensuring that the sale is conducted by the law and safeguarding the interests of all parties involved. Court approval is not merely a stamp of approval. The Court will only add its layer of legitimacy and finality to the transaction after it is satisfied that all legal standards have been met, assuring buyers of the validity of their acquisitions and unsuccessful buyers that the process was fair and transparent.

In the realm of bankruptcy sales, one must navigate the terrain with caution. While the prospect of purchasing assets free and clear of all creditor claims and liens is enticing, there are caveats to consider. Assets are typically sold in an “as-is, where-is” condition, with limited assurances from the licensed insolvency trustee who is the seller. The pace of proceedings is expedited, leaving little room for post-closing recourse or exhaustive due diligence.

Balancing these nuances is crucial for bidders eyeing strategic acquisitions in the bankruptcy sales arena. It requires a blend of foresight, adaptability, and a keen understanding of the intricacies of the process. Join me as we unravel the layers of bankruptcy sales and explore the dynamic landscape governing these kinds of transactions in Canada.

Gavel resting on bankruptcy sales documents in a courtroom.
company is bankrupt

Benefits and Downsides of Court-Supervised Sales When a Company is Bankrupt

As someone deeply involved in the field, I often find myself exploring the nuances of court-supervised sales, delving into their advantages and potential pitfalls. Let’s take a closer look at the intricacies of this unique opportunity.

Advantages of Purchasing Assets through Court-Supervised Sales

When I consider the benefits of acquiring assets from court-supervised insolvency process sales, one key advantage stands out – the opportunity to acquire assets at potentially distressed pricing. This presents a unique chance to make strategic acquisitions at potentially lower costs, providing a competitive edge in the market.

Moreover, the level playing field offered by court-supervised sales allows bidders to engage in fair competition, conduct thorough due diligence albeit in an environment where as much information as you would like may not be available, and submit bids directly to the licensed insolvency trustee. The ability to purchase assets free and clear of the company’s financial obligations and the secured debts and unsecured debts, with the transaction receiving court approval, provides a sense of finality and security that is highly valuable in such transactions.

Limitations and Challenges in Court-Supervised Sales

However, in the realm of Court-supervised sales, you need to be acutely aware of the limitations that come with this process. Assets in bankruptcy sales are always sold “as-is, where-is,” with such limited representations and warranties from the licensed insolvency trustee seller, there are essentially none. This, coupled with the fact that the licensed insolvency trustee was not the operator of the business utilizing those assets where the company was bankrupt. This makes due diligence both critical and yet challenging. The expedited timeline and lack of post-closing recourse further adds complexity to the transaction.

Additionally, since the company is bankrupt the buyer needs to bid without the safety net of due diligence and financing contingencies, which can be a daunting prospect. Balancing these limitations against the potential benefits requires a keen eye for detail and a strategic mindset.

Balancing Pros and Cons for Strategic Bidders

For strategic bidders, finding the equilibrium between the pros and cons of court-supervised sales is crucial. Evaluating the cost-benefit ratio, understanding the bidding process, and complying with the court-approved terms and conditions of sale are all essential steps in the process.

Navigating this complex landscape requires a strategic approach. By weighing these factors thoughtfully, the buyer must aim to make informed decisions that lead to successful and accretive acquisitions through the court-supervised sales process.

Company is Bankrupt: Tactical Considerations for Potential Bidders

If you are someone considering participating in a bankruptcy sale, understand the unique opportunity it presents to potentially acquire assets at favourable pricing. This process allows you to compete on a level playing field with other bidders, conducting due diligence and submitting bids directly to the licensed insolvency trustee.

One significant advantage of a bankruptcy sale is the ability to purchase assets free and clear of all creditor claims and liens, as finalized through court approval. The money you pay as the winning bidder stands in place of the assets. However, there are essential aspects to consider before diving into this opportunity.

Cost-Benefit Analysis of Participating in the Sale Process: Before getting involved, you need to evaluate the cost versus benefit of participating in the sale process. Understanding the potential risks and rewards is crucial for making informed decisions.

Key Elements of the Bidding Procedures: To make a successful bid, you must ensure that it meets all the necessary criteria and complies with the bidding procedures governing the bankruptcy sale. This requires attention to detail and a clear understanding of the requirements.

Strategies for Successful Participation in Bankruptcy Sales: To navigate the bankruptcy sale process effectively, you need to develop strategies that can help you stand out among other bidders. This involves setting clear goals, assessing the competition, and being prepared to act decisively.

By considering these tactical aspects carefully, you can position yourself for a successful experience in a bankruptcy sale. It’s about weighing the pros and cons, understanding the process, and strategizing effectively to make the most out of this unique opportunity.

Gavel resting on bankruptcy sales documents in a courtroom.
company is bankrupt

Company is Bankrupt: What the Court Requires

Being involved as a bidder in bankruptcy sales can be both exciting and daunting, laden with unique challenges and opportunities. Let’s delve into the intricacies of what the Court requires for the legal process to approve a particular sales process and sale of assets when the company is bankrupt or in receivership.

The Soundair principles

The Soundair principles are a collection of lawful standards developed by the Court of Appeal for Ontario in 1991 in the case of Royal Bank of Canada v. Soundair Corp., 1991 CanLII 2727 (ON CA). These principles are followed by all Canadian courts.

The Soundair principles are aimed at creating fairness and transparency in the sale of assets throughout bankruptcy or receivership cases. Thirty-one years later, it is still the leading case in Canadian insolvency asset sales rules and regulations. These concepts guide courts in evaluating whether the sale procedure carried out by a receiver (or a trustee in bankruptcy) has been fair and suitable.

Here are the Soundair principles in detail:

Diligent Efforts to Secure the Best Price: The receiver/trustee is obliged to exert sensible efforts to secure the highest possible price for the assets for the general benefit of creditors. This entails thoroughly advertising the assets for sale, soliciting competing bids, and ensuring that prospective purchasers are provided with sufficient information to submit proper offers to purchase. The goal is to get the highest sales price possible under the circumstances, to maximize the return for the benefit of creditors.

Fairness and Integrity in the Sale Process: It is essential to give all interested parties an equivalent opportunity to join the sales process and to avoid any potential purchaser from obtaining an unreasonable edge. Transparency and impartiality are vital, and conflicts of interest cannot be tolerated.

All Stakeholders’ Interests: The receiver/trustee must look out for the interests of all parties, secured creditors and unsecured creditors, shareholders, and any other appropriate stakeholders. It is very important for the licensed insolvency trustee to avoid preference for any party and to strive for a fair equilibrium of the interests among everybody affected because the company is bankrupt.

Input from significant creditors: This is a crucial consideration for the licensed insolvency trustee. While the trustee retains the ultimate decision-making authority, it is essential to carefully weigh and consider the recommendations and preferences of major creditors. Given that these creditors will bear financial implications based on the sale outcomes, their input carries substantial significance in the decision-making process.

Application of the Soundair principles

In practice, when a sale of assets is held because the company is bankrupt or in receivership, there are two stages of court review. First, the licensed insolvency trustee needs to get approval for the actual sales process itself. Then, the Court will review the process as implemented by the licensed insolvency trustee.

The Court’s reviews are to ensure conformity with these Soundair principles. This is the case if this is not a sale at arm’s length purchaser. The court will take into consideration the following elements:

Marketing Efforts: How the assets were advertised and marketed, including the period and reach of the advertising and marketing initiatives.

Number and Quality of Offers: The variety of offers obtained and whether they reflect reasonable market price. To assist the Court in determining the reasonableness of the offers received, the Trustee must provide evidence to the Court. An independent appraisal of the assets and other market data is the normal kind of evidence usedwhat a fair valuation of the assets is.

Transparency: Whether the sale process was conducted fairly and transparently, with appropriate details provided to all possible purchasers.

Stakeholder Consultation: Whether the licensed insolvency trustee has spoken with and taken into consideration the views of significant creditors and other stakeholders.

Authorization of Sale: Whether the proposed sale is supported by the significant creditors or as a minimum, is not being opposed.

The Soundair principles assist when a company is bankrupt or in receivership, in guaranteeing that the sale of assets in an insolvency context is carried out in a fashion that maximizes value, keeps fairness, and appreciates the interests of all the major stakeholders. By adhering to these concepts, the court aims to supply confidence in the integrity and fairness of the process and protect the rights of all stakeholders.

Gavel resting on bankruptcy sales documents in a courtroom.
company is bankrupt

Company is Bankrupt: Navigating Contracts and Leases

When it comes to Court-approved sales in bankruptcy proceedings, sometimes some contractual commitments or leases are in place. Even though the company is bankrupt or in receivership, a purchaser of the assets may need some or all of those contracts or leases to make the purchasing of those assets make sense. Expressed another way, having the assets may not be enough.

Having the rights and responsibilities that come with those contracts and leases may be required. Navigating contracts and leases is a crucial aspect that requires careful consideration and strategic decision-making. Let’s delve into some key points related to this intricate process.

Options Regarding Contracts and Leases

There are 2 primary options regarding contractual commitments and leases: rejection or assignment and assumption. Each option comes with its own set of implications and considerations that need to be weighed meticulously. Making the right choice can significantly impact the outcome of the sale process and the overall success of the bankruptcy proceedings.

Practical Challenges Regarding Contracts and Leases

There are some practical challenges regarding contracts and leases as follows:

Rejection: If there are contracts or leases that a purchaser does not require, this is the simplest. The purchaser will not purchase the licensed insolvency trustee’s right, title and interest, if any, in those obligations. By not purchasing those rights, the purchaser will simply not deal with them. The licensed insolvency trustee, acting as the receiver or bankruptcy trustee, will either ignore them or will formally reject them. Any rejection or repudiation will occur as part of the sales process.

Any claims by the party that contracted with the debtor company will be an unsecured claim caught in the court-supervised insolvency process as against the company and therefore, as against the pool of money obtained through the sales process. The Court will ultimately approve the distribution of funds by the Trustee, so the lessor/contracting party will be out of the money if the secured creditors suffer a shortfall.

Assumption and Assignment: One major challenge is determining whether contracts and leases can be assigned to the purchaser. In many cases, contracts contain anti-assignment clauses that prohibit transfer without consent from the other party.

Termination Rights: Contracts and leases might have termination clauses that can be triggered by the insolvency or the sale itself, complicating the continuity of these agreements.

Negotiating Consents: Obtaining necessary consents from counterparties to contracts and leases can be time-consuming and uncertain. Counterparties may demand changes to terms or additional payments as a condition for their consent. These negotiations normally are in addition to the process of purchasing the assets and do not involve the licensed insolvency trustee administering the sales process because the company is bankrupt or in receivership.

Legal Challenges: Even if a Trustee can theoretically assign a contract or lease, the counterparties might contest this in court, leading to potential delays and additional legal costs.

Successfully navigating contracts and leases in Canadian insolvency court-supervised sales requires a comprehensive understanding of the legal framework, meticulous attention to detail, and strategic decision-making. By carefully evaluating the options available, addressing challenges proactively, and adhering to legal requirements, potential purchasers can enhance the efficiency and efficacy of the sale process, ultimately maximizing the value of assets and securing a successful outcome in the proceedings.

Company is Bankrupt: Considerations for Governmental Approvals and Regulatory Reviews

Certain industries are regulated under provincial or federal government licenses or approvals. Purchasing the assets when a company is bankrupt or receivership is not enough to operate the business itself. The business operations require government approval. It is of paramount importance to navigate governmental approvals and regulatory reviews. These considerations are not mere formalities but critical steps that can significantly impact the success of the sale process.

Importance of Regulatory Approvals in Bankruptcy Sales: In the realm of bankruptcy sales, regulatory approvals play a pivotal role in ensuring that the transaction complies with all necessary laws and regulations. These approvals act as safeguards to protect the public. A prudent purchaser will make such regulatory approvals a buyer’s condition to purchase the assets.

Sometimes, such as my receivership file I referenced in my stalking horse Brandon’s Blog, we purposely made it a condition that the buyer is solely responsible for obtaining the necessary regulatory approval and not obtaining it is not a reason the purchaser can rely upon to not complete the transaction. The reason we did this is because we did not want the sale of assets to be conditional on obtaining regulatory approval. In such a circumstance, the purchaser must understand this and have a high expectation that they will be approved.

Transition Services Agreements for Regulated Industries: Operating in regulated industries adds another layer of complexity to bankruptcy sales. A sophisticated purchaser will recognize that they may need a transition services agreement as a crucial mechanism to facilitate the seamless transfer of assets while adhering to industry-specific regulations and requirements. These agreements outline the terms under which services will be provided post-sale, ensuring continuity and compliance.

Navigating Foreign Purchasers and Regulatory Requirements: Dealing with foreign purchasers introduces a host of additional challenges, particularly in terms of regulatory compliance. Understanding and adhering to the specific requirements imposed by different jurisdictions is vital to the sale’s success. Navigating these regulatory landscapes demands meticulous attention to detail and a comprehensive understanding of international laws. As the licensed insolvency trustee seller, it would be my preference to not sell to a foreign purchaser and have the sale hung up for a lengthy time pending the outcome of the regulator’s review of the suitability of the foreign purchaser.

Being mindful of these aspects is not just a matter of legal obligation but a strategic imperative. Failing to secure necessary approvals or overlooking regulatory nuances can derail the entire sale process, leading to potential legal repercussions and financial setbacks.

As someone immersed in the complex world of bankruptcy sales, I recognize the delicate balancing act required to maneuver through governmental approvals and regulatory reviews successfully. A purchaser needs to be informed, proactive, and meticulous in its approach, aiming to navigate these intricate processes with precision and expertise. If I must recommend a foreign purchaser in the sale of assets used in a regulated industry, I must have confidence in the purchaser’s ability to navigate the governmental approval process.

Gavel resting on bankruptcy sales documents in a courtroom.
company is bankrupt

Company is Bankrupt: Addressing Liabilities Affecting Bankruptcy Sales

It’s important to recognize the significance of addressing potential liabilities throughout the process. One key aspect that stands out is the need for thorough identification and mitigation of these liabilities, ensuring a smooth and successful acquisition. As stated above, most liabilities of the company are caught in the bankruptcy estate or receivership process.

The sales of assets vests them out of the company to the purchaser and the money obtained from the sale stands in its place. The licensed insolvency trustee must then make its recommendation to the Court for the distribution of the money as the priorities require.

However, sometimes some liabilities may on a practical level make it difficult to use the assets as an operating business, without addressing certain liabilities. Here are some essential talking points to consider:

Identification and Mitigation of Potential Liabilities: Before diving headfirst into a bankruptcy sale, it’s crucial to conduct a comprehensive review of potential liabilities associated with the assets up for acquisition. Identifying any existing or potential risks early on allows for strategic planning to mitigate these liabilities effectively.

Thorough Due Diligence and Legal Counsel Consultation: Engaging in thorough due diligence, possibly with the support of legal counsel, can provide valuable insights into the liabilities that may not be immediately apparent. Legal experts can offer guidance on navigating complex legal frameworks and ensuring compliance with regulatory requirements.

Understanding Exceptions to ‘Free and Clear’ Asset Sales: While the concept of purchasing assets ‘free and clear’ in a bankruptcy sale may seem straightforward, it’s essential to be aware of exceptions that could impact the transaction. Certain liabilities, such as environmental issues, may not be absolved despite the ‘free and clear’ nature of the sale. Also, the business may be reliant on one or two essential suppliers and without their cooperation, it will be impossible to operate a business utilizing those assets.

The concerns and interests of such creditors who cannot be replaced going forward in the business operations and their respective unsecured creditors’ claims must be addressed before completing the purchase of the assets.

By paying close attention to these critical aspects, potential buyers can approach bankruptcy sales with a well-rounded strategy, safeguarding their interests and minimizing potential risks. Collaborating with legal experts and conducting in-depth due diligence are pillars of success in navigating the complexities of bankruptcy sales.

Company is Bankrupt: The Insolvency Process and Sale Order Approval

When diving into the world of bankruptcy sales, there is a mix of thrill and caution that comes with the territory. It’s a realm where opportunities to acquire assets at distressed pricing collide with the need for strategic decision-making and quick actions. You see, a bankruptcy sale isn’t your run-of-the-mill transaction – it’s a structured process overseen by the Bankruptcy Court, designed to ensure fairness and transparency for all parties involved.

As I take you through the stages where the company is bankrupt, the bankruptcy process, the role of the Bankruptcy Court in sale order approval, and the key milestones in bankruptcy asset sales, you’ll start to see the intricate dance that occurs in the world of distressed asset acquisitions.

Stages of the Bankruptcy Process

Filing for Bankruptcy: It all begins with the company filing for bankruptcy (or being placed into a court-supervised receivership) overseen by the Bankruptcy Court.

Approval for the Sales Process Including the Bidding Procedures: Once the company is bankrupt or in a court-supervised receivership, the licensed insolvency trustee will seek approval for the sales process including the bidding procedures from the court, setting the stage for the asset sale process.

Marketing Assets: With the court’s approval, the licensed insolvency trustee starts marketing the assets to potential buyers, generating interest and gathering bids for the distressed assets.

Receiving Bids: Prospective buyers submit their bids, each vying for the opportunity to acquire the assets through the bankruptcy sale process.

Application to Court: The licensed insolvency trustee administering the bankruptcy or receivership process, will make its application to the Court, filing its evidence, which includes a Report to the Court explaining how the Court-approved sales process was conducted, the results of the process and the bids received, showing how the Soundair principles were adhered to and recommending a specific offer to be approved,.

Finalizing Sale with Court Approval: The sale approval order, once issued by the Bankruptcy Court, finalizes the transaction, paving the way for the transfer of assets to the successful bidder.

Each stage in the insolvency process plays a crucial role in the successful sale of distressed assets, ensuring that the interests of all stakeholders are protected and that the process remains transparent and fair.

Role of Court Resulting in the Sale Approval Order

The Court acts as the guardian of the bankruptcy or receivership process, overseeing the sale approval order and ensuring that all legal requirements and considerations are met. Its role is pivotal in maintaining the integrity of the asset sale process, providing a level playing field for prospective buyers and all stakeholders.

When a sale order is presented to the Court for approval, the court scrutinizes the terms of the transaction, ensuring that it aligns with the laws and the best interests of the parties involved. By granting the sale approval order, the court adds a layer of legitimacy and finality to the asset sale, safeguarding the rights of the buyer and seller.

Key Milestones and Deadlines in Bankruptcy Asset Sales

Deadlines are a crucial aspect of any bankruptcy or receivership asset sale, dictating the pace and efficiency of the process. Key milestones and deadlines serve as guideposts throughout the sale process, ensuring that each step is taken within the specified timeframe to maintain the momentum and integrity of the transaction.

From the initial filing for bankruptcy or receivership to the finalization of the sale order, adhering to these milestones and deadlines is essential for a smooth and successful asset sale. These markers not only provide clarity and structure to the process but also instill confidence in all parties involved, signalling a well-managed and efficient transaction.

Company is Bankrupt Conclusion: Key Takeaways for Successful Asset Acquisitions

As we wrap up our discussion on successful asset acquisitions in bankruptcy sales, let’s reflect on the pivotal points that can guide us toward making informed and strategic decisions in this unique process:

  1. Firstly, navigating bankruptcy proceeding sales requires a nuanced understanding of the key considerations that come into play. Assets are sold “as-is, where-is,” with limited warranties and protections for buyers. This necessitates a careful evaluation of the risks and rewards before participating.
  2. Secondly, being well-informed is crucial when participating. The competitive nature of these sales demands swift decision-making and strategic bidding strategies. Having a clear grasp of the process and a thorough assessment of the assets can give bidders a competitive edge.
  3. Lastly, the guiding principles for acquiring distressed assets successfully revolve around finding the balance between opportunity and risk. Whether you are a strategic investor or a financial bidder, understanding the intricacies of bankruptcy sales and aligning your acquisition strategy with your overall goals is key to driving value from these transactions.

I hope you have enjoyed this company is bankrupt Brandon’s Blog. Do you or your company have too much debt? Are you or your company in need of financial restructuring? The financial restructuring process is complex. The Ira Smith Team understands how to do a complex restructuring. However, more importantly, we understand the needs of the entrepreneur or the person who has too much personal debt.

You are worried because you are facing significant financial challenges. It is not your fault that you are in this situation. You have been only shown the old ways that do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team uses new modern ways to get you out of your debt troubles while avoiding bankruptcy. We can get you debt relief freedom.

The stress placed upon you is huge. We understand your pain points. We look at your entire situation and devise a strategy that is as unique as you and your problems; financial and emotional. The way we take the load off of your shoulders and devise a plan, we know that we can help you.

We know that people facing financial problems need a realistic lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” approach with the Ira Smith Team.

That is why we can develop a restructuring process as unique as the financial problems and pain you are facing. If any of this sounds familiar to you and you are serious about finding a solution, contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. team today.

Call us now for a free consultation. We will get you or your company back on the road to healthy stress-free operations and recover from the pain points in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

The information provided in this Brandon’s Blog is intended for educational purposes only. It is not intended to constitute legal, financial, or professional advice. Readers are encouraged to seek professional advice regarding their specific situations. The content of this Brandon’s Blog should not be relied upon as a substitute for professional guidance or consultation. The author, Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. as well as any contributors to this Brandon’s Blog, do not assume any liability for any loss or damage resulting from reliance on the information provided herein.

Gavel resting on bankruptcy sales documents in a courtroom.
company is bankrupt
Categories
Brandon Blog Post

DEBT RELIEF OPTIONS: OUR COMPREHENSIVE GUIDE FOR IDENTIFYING RELIABLE DEBT ADVICE

Debt relief options: Introduction

Suppose you ever find yourself overwhelmed by the weight of excessive financial responsibilities. In that case, it becomes crucial to seek trustworthy recommendations for selecting a reliable service provider who can assist you with various options to alleviate your financial debts and provide you with the most beneficial financial guidance. Amidst the vast array of available assistance choices, it might seem daunting to pinpoint genuine resources that can genuinely assist you without any hidden agendas. It holds great significance for your future well-being to be able to distinguish between deceitful scammers and genuine helpers.

Fear not, for there exists an infinite realm of dependable suppliers specializing in financial debt relief options eagerly awaiting your discovery. From the information in this Brandon’s Blog, you can boldly conquer your present economic challenges, obtain the appropriate assistance from the right individuals, and make well-informed decisions that will emancipate you from the shackles of debt -Starting Over, Starting Now!

Debt relief options: What is debt relief?

Debt relief encompasses a myriad of technical strategies and detailed processes designed to lessen or eradicate the weighty load of unresolved financial obligations for individuals and businesses. It entails the implementation of deliberate and targeted measures to alleviate the pressing strain on one’s economic well-being, engage in negotiations for the revision of loan terms, or reach mutually agreeable resolutions with creditors.

Debt relief options take on many diverse forms, including but not limited to debt consolidation, the pursuit of debt settlements, the formulation and execution of comprehensive debt management plans, and, in the most dire circumstances, the contemplation of bankruptcy as an ultimate solution.

The overarching objective that underpins the concept of all debt relief options is to furnish individuals or entities with a revitalized opportunity, empowering them to reclaim a solid footing in their fiscal affairs, reinstating stability, and propelling them toward a more tenable and enduring financial equilibrium.

debt relief options
debt relief options

Debt relief options: Why managing debt is crucial

In today’s modern society, more and more Canadian households are struggling with debt. The prevalence of indebtedness has emerged as an unsurprising reality in the lives of numerous individuals. From the weighty load of educational loans to the looming presence of bills linked to credit cards, the accumulation of debts can swiftly escalate and become overwhelming if not effectively handled.

The management of indebtedness is not solely a matter of personal responsibility but a skill that can yield a profound impact on one’s financial well-being and prospects for the future. By grasping the significance of debt management, individuals can make well-informed decisions concerning their finances, elude the treacherous clasp of debt cycles, and ultimately achieve lasting financial stability.

Efficiently handling indebtedness is vital in safeguarding your financial freedom. Uncontrolled debts can result in missed payments, penalties, exorbitant interest rates, and even bankruptcy. Debt management ensures that you retain control over your finances and empowers you to take charge of your own life. Seeking guidance from reliable professionals specializing in debt relief will furnish you with practical options tailored to your unique financial situation, enabling you to resolve your debt issues. Hence, skillfully managing your debts is paramount in establishing a solid financial foundation.

Given its implications on credit ratings, financial independence, and overall peace of mind, the management of indebtedness assumes critical importance. Whether you are a recent graduate burdened with educational loans, a homeowner grappling with a mortgage, or simply an individual juggling multiple credit card bills, this article on Brandon’s Blog is specifically crafted to cater to your needs.

Debt relief options: Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy (Canada)

On the 27th of June of this year, a notice was issued by The Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy (OSB), stressing the significance of understanding the perils associated with the unregulated Debt Advisory Marketplace, while simultaneously aiding consumers in identifying trustworthy sources of debt assistance.

One must bear in mind that unregulated advisors have the potential to impose exorbitant charges, varying from a few hundred dollars to several thousand dollars, for services that they are not legally permitted to offer. Furthermore, they may demand payment for redundant or repetitive services both prior to, during, and subsequent consultations.

In order to safeguard oneself from deceptive schemes, it is highly recommended to exercise prudence and seek guidance from duly authorized and regulated professionals.

debt relief options
debt relief options

Debt relief options: The difference between good and bad debt relief service providers

If you find yourself inundated with mounting financial obligations and in search of a way out, rest assured that you are not alone in this predicament. It is not uncommon for individuals to confront economic difficulties that can result in substantial levels of indebtedness. Nevertheless, it is crucial to bear in mind that there are avenues accessible to assist you in regaining command over your fiscal circumstances.

Debt relief service providers can play a pivotal role in facilitating your journey toward financial stability. However, it is of utmost importance to distinguish between reputable and unscrupulous providers. The ensuing discussion will delineate the characteristics that set reputable debt relief service providers apart from those who may not have your best interests at heart. By comprehending these distinctions, you will be empowered to make an astute decision and select a provider that genuinely aids you in your choice of debt relief options for accomplishing your financial objectives.

When embarking on your quest for debt relief options, it is imperative to identify trustworthy sources. Trustworthy debt relief service providers exhibit transparent fee structures and refrain from making grandiose promises to their clients. Additionally, they boast a dependable accreditation program, thereby ensuring the credibility of their services. Conversely, unscrupulous debt relief service providers make untenable pledges and levy concealed fees, exacerbating the accumulation of debt. Armed with this understanding, individuals can safeguard themselves against dubious service providers and reclaim control over their financial affairs.

I shall delve into the significance of credibility, transparency, experience, and success rates when it comes to selecting a debt relief service provider.

Debt relief options: Factors to consider when choosing a debt relief service

Certification and accreditation of the debt relief service provider

When it involves seeking support with handling as well as decreasing your financial debts, it is crucial to work with professionals that are accredited, licensed and supervised by a government body. This is where accreditation and certification play a significant function.

By choosing a financial debt relief service provider that is licensed as well as well-recognized, you can have satisfaction knowing that you are working with a respectable company that complies with licensing requirements, market criteria and best practices. Qualification and certification ensure that the service provider fulfills detailed standards as well as possesses the needed knowledge to provide you with the full range of debt relief options and financial advice and successfully help you manage your financial debt. Furthermore, they guarantee that the solution abides by relevant regulations, legislation and standards.

In today’s financial landscape, rip-offs, as well as unethical practices, exist, making it vital to shield on your own and also make informed choices. By going with a certified and accredited financial debt relief professional, you can rely on that the professionals you are collaborating with have undergone rigorous training as well as satisfy the highest possible requirements in the market.

Throughout this blog post, we will delve into the importance of certification and accreditation, the benefits they offer, and how they can assist you in making informed decisions when selecting a debt relief service provider. Whether you are considering credit counselling, debt consolidation, or debt settlement, understanding the significance of certification and accreditation will empower you to navigate the complex world of debt relief with confidence.

Join us as we explore this topic in detail and equip you with the knowledge you need to make the best choices for your financial well-being. It’s time to take control of your financial future and choose a debt relief service provider that has your best interests at heart.

Transparent fee structure

Dealing with the issue of debt can elicit an overwhelming and stressful encounter; nevertheless, collaborating with a distinguished debt alleviation firm can offer respite from the burden. However, it is crucial to exercise caution when opting for a debt alleviation firm, as not all firms are forged equally. One pivotal aspect to contemplate is the firm’s fee framework, as any esteemed debt alleviation firm must possess a transparent fee framework that is effortlessly understandable and does not obscure any covert expenses.

Transparency constitutes an essential constituent of debt alleviation services, as consumers merit a lucid comprehension of the expenses and potential outcomes linked to the rendered services. An esteemed debt alleviation firm will provide an all-encompassing breakdown of all fees associated with their services, encompassing upfront fees, monthly fees, and success fees. Moreover, they ought to provide upfront disclosure about any prospective risks or limitations associated with their services, rather than proffering unrealistic promises or guarantees.

Customer reviews and rating

One crucial factor to consider when selecting a debt relief service is customer reviews and ratings. A professional debt relief company will provide genuine reviews and ratings of their services from their satisfied clients. By looking at these reviews and ratings, you can discern whether the debt relief service has a history of delivering results and exceptional customer service. High ratings and positive reviews are typically an indication that the company has a reputable track record of helping individuals get out of debt. Therefore, it is vital to do your research and make sure you choose a company that has a proven history of delivering excellent results.

debt relief options
debt relief options

Debt relief options: Tips for managing your debt

Below are my best tips for finding debt solutions:

Credit counselling

Using a community-based non-profit credit counselling agency to address consumer debt difficulties can generate numerous benefits. Below are some vital advantages to take into consideration:

Professional Support: These agencies used trained and licensed credit counsellors that possess considerable expertise in personal money and debt restructuring. They can supply valuable suggestions customized to your specific situation, providing a tailored plan to conquer your financial debt challenges.

Financial Guidance and Education: These community-based credit counselling agencies regularly offer support for budgeting and deliver programs that concentrate on financial literacy. By collaborating with such an agency, you can learn how to create a budget plan, focus on expenditures, and also develop sustainable financial methods. Improving your financial literacy will enable you to make informed decisions as well as stop possible future debt problems.

Debt Management Plans: These agencies may offer Debt Management Programs (DMPs) as a feasible service for settling your financial obligations. Via a DMP, the agency bargains with your creditors to lower rates of interest, waive charges and develop a consolidated payment plan. This strategy can make the process of financial debt settlement more convenient as well as accelerate your progress toward ending up being debt-free.

Financial Institution Relationships: These non-profit credit counseling agencies have actually developed links with a range of financial institutions being the banks and credit unions. Because of this, they might be able to properly work out useful terms and payment options for you, thereby decreasing interest rates to an affordable annual percentage rate and also month-to-month payments.

Emotional Support: All debt relief options can be challenging and mentally draining as you work your way through them. Community-based credit counselling agencies understand the psychological toll that money difficulties can have on people and their households. They cultivate a helpful environment where you can honestly reveal your worries as well as get experienced advice. This enables you to really feel much more empowered and inspired to conquer your financial obstacles.

Non-profit Status: These agencies run as nonprofit organizations and place a top priority on assisting people in need rather than producing profits. They typically provide their solutions for small fees, or in many cases, free of charge. This makes their solutions much more available and also budget-friendly for those experiencing financial difficulties. We always recommend using non-profit community-based debt counselling firms as one of the debt relief options that can be utilized. We never suggest utilizing financial debt settlement for profit companies.

Confidentiality and Privacy: These community-based agencies focus on client confidentiality and privacy. They take great care with your personal financial information and also make sure that individual details are kept safe and secure.

Debt consolidation

Debt consolidation is a preferred choice for individuals looking to combine numerous debts into one manageable debt with a single monthly payment. This debt relief option entails getting a single loan that can repay all of your existing financial obligations. This one personal loan is at a lower interest rate than the average interest rate charged on all your current outstanding debts and streamlines the settlement process.

Nevertheless, it is essential to carefully weigh the benefits and drawbacks of debt consolidation and the terms of all debt consolidation loans being offered to you. Look for a trusted financial partner, evaluate the terms and costs related to the consolidation loan, and consider your ability to stay current with the brand-new repayment timetable. With the appropriate approach, financial debt consolidation can be a wise technique for taking control of your funds.

Individuals have several choices when it pertains to combining debt. The concept is that either:

  1. your credit history is good enough so that you can obtain an unsecured loan; or
  2. you are choosing to use security for the loan.

For example, you may have 5 charge cards all with unpaid debts. You are pressing the upper limits of your authorized credit and the interest rates are very high. If you can get a home equity line of credit at a much lower annual interest rate, the benefit is evident. So it would be a clever option to use security to get a consolidation loan.

If you didn’t intend to or really did not have security to provide, you may have a good enough credit score to obtain an unsecured loan. If you can get this sort of funding, the annual interest rate charged will be more than for a secured loan, but still much less than you are paying on your credit cards. So this too would be a smart method to go with.

Debt settlement

Debt settlement is a debt relief choice that includes working out with your creditors an arrangement to pay them less than the total you owe them in order to settle all your financial debts for less than what is owed. This option can help to reduce your total financial debts into amounts that you can repay and prevent you from needing to file for bankruptcy.

Nevertheless, it ought to be noted that this debt relief option can have a negative impact on your credit rating and may cause taxable income obligation effects if any of the debts you are comprising were taken on to earn income. This option is best for those who have just a few creditors and have the financial literacy ability and are not afraid to contact and negotiate with their creditors on their own.

If you don’t believe you can do it on your own, stay away from the for-profit debt settlement companies as they are not looking out for your best interests. The best way to do a debt settlement plan if you are not confident that you can do it on your own is either the DMP described above, or a consumer proposal, described below.

Consumer proposal

If you’re battling with financial debt, a consumer proposal may be a great debt settlement plan for you. This debt relief solution is a legal process carried out under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA). It enables you to pay back part of your debt over time. The benefit to you of a consumer proposal is that as soon as you end up repaying the part that you agreed to, you will be totally debt-free. The unpaid balance is eliminated too.

To get this government-sanctioned financial debt settlement strategy, you need to be insolvent and also have unsecured debts of $250,000 or less owing to all your unsecured creditors (omitting any type of secured debts registered against your personal residence such as mortgages or lines of credit).

This type of repayment plan is a good choice for people who are:

  • Employed;
  • can budget plan their money to make the required month-to-month regular payments;
  • want to avoid and choose the best alternative to bankruptcy; and
  • can’t stand all the collection calls from the debt collectors any longer.

Under the BIA, a licensed insolvency trustee (previously called a bankruptcy trustee) is the only party allowed under Canadian law to administer a consumer proposal. The licensed insolvency trustee is named the consumer proposal administrator.

The licensed insolvency trustee will submit the needed documents to the OSB. All interest charges and all collections calls stop on the day you file your consumer proposal. You can take up to 5 years to pay the amount promised under your consumer proposal.

When you submit a consumer proposal, any legal action your unsecured creditors have actually started against you is frozen and stopped. That goes for any legal action any of your creditors were threatening to start also. If a creditor currently has a judgment against you and is having your wages garnisheed, that stops too. You get that legal protection by making an insolvency filing under the BIA.

The licensed insolvency trustee who oversees your consumer proposal is responsible for negotiating with your unsecured creditors to reduce your unsecured original debts on your behalf. Upon successful acceptance of your proposal by the required majority of your creditors, you will be obligated to make monthly payments as per the agreed-upon terms of the proposal. You make your one monthly payment to the licensed insolvency trustee who takes care of making the promised payments to creditors.

Bankruptcy

Bankruptcy is a legal recourse that enables individuals or companies to discharge or restructure their financial liabilities. While it is the last option anyone should consider in the hierarchy of debt relief options, bankruptcy may be the most appropriate solution in certain circumstances.

It is crucial to weigh the consequences and benefits before opting for bankruptcy. A seasoned licensed insolvency trustee can guide you through the process and provide insights on the other debt relief options mentioned earlier.

Bankruptcy should not be taken lightly. Nevertheless, if carefully considered and implemented, it can offer a fresh start and an opportunity to rebuild credit scores for a stronger financial future.

I will not delve into the intricacies of the bankruptcy process and its workings in this Brandon’s Blog post. If you need to learn more about the bankruptcy process and if it is right for you, call me.

debt relief options
debt relief options

Debt relief options: Conclusion

Managing financial debt can indeed be a difficult as well as emotionally draining experience. However, there are reliable sources offered to give guidance and support. When looking for assistance with debt problems, I recommend 2 trusted resources: non-profit community-based credit counselling agencies and licensed insolvency trustees. Stay away from a for-profit debt settlement company.

I hope you enjoyed this debt relief options Brandon’s Blog. Financial stress is a growing concern in Canada, affecting individuals of all ages and income levels.

Creating a solid financial plan can be the key to unlocking a brighter and more prosperous future. By taking control of your finances, you can prioritize your expenses, set clear financial goals, and build a strong foundation for your dreams to come true. With the right mindset and approach, financial planning can empower you to regain control, eliminate this issue as a source of stress in your life and find peace of mind.

Individuals must take proactive measures to address financial difficulties and promptly seek assistance when necessary. It is crucial to recognize that financial stress is a prevalent concern and seeking help is a demonstration of fortitude, rather than vulnerability. Should you encounter challenges in managing your finances and find yourself burdened by stress, do not delay in pursuing aid.

Revenue and cash flow shortages are critical issues facing people, entrepreneurs and their companies and businesses that are in financial distress. Are you now worried about just how you or your business are going to survive? Are you worried about what your fiduciary obligations are and not sure if the decisions you are about to make are the correct ones to avoid personal liability? Those concerns are obviously on your mind.

The Ira Smith Team understands these concerns. More significantly, we know the requirements of the business owner or the individual that has way too much financial debt. You are trying to manage these difficult financial problems and you are understandably anxious.

It is not your fault you can’t fix this problem on your own and it does not mean that you are a bad person. The pandemic has thrown everyone a curveball. We have not been trained to deal with this. You have only been taught the old ways. The old ways do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team uses innovative and cutting-edge methodologies, to adeptly navigate you through the intricacies of your financial challenges, ensuring a resolution to your debt-related predicaments without resorting to the rigours of the bankruptcy process. We can get you debt relief now!

We have helped many entrepreneurs and their insolvent companies who thought that consulting with a Trustee and receiver meant their company would go bankrupt. On the contrary. We helped turn their companies around through financial restructuring.

We look at your whole circumstance and design a strategy that is as distinct as you are. We take the load off of your shoulders as part of the debt settlement strategy we will draft just for you.

The Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. team understands that people facing money problems require a lifeline. That is why we can establish a restructuring procedure for you and end the discomfort you feel.

Call us now for a no-cost consultation. We will listen to the unique issues facing you and provide you with practical and actionable ideas you can implement right away to end the pain points in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

debt relief options
debt relief options
Categories
Brandon Blog Post

CANADIAN INSOLVENCY CASES: DECODING THE DETAILED TAXATION PROCESS FOR SUCCESSFUL COURT OFFICER FEES APPROVAL

Canadian insolvency: Introduction

As Canadian insolvency laws progress, so do the regulations surrounding the taxation of court officer fees. These fees often make up a considerable proportion of the expenses incurred during insolvency proceedings. It is absolutely essential for insolvency practitioners, legal professionals, and other parties involved in such cases to comprehend the critical factors that affect the taxation of court officer fees.

Knowing the taxation procedure for court officer fees in Canadian insolvency cases that are supervised by the court is significant for various reasons. The following points highlight some of the crucial aspects to consider:

  1. Promoting Transparency and Accountability: The taxation procedure guarantees transparency and accountability in the assessment of court officer fees. It encompasses an autonomous evaluation of the charges imposed by court-appointed officials, such as trustees, receivers, monitors, or liquidators. By comprehending this procedure, interested parties can ascertain that the fees are reasonable and justified.
  2. Safeguarding Stakeholder Interests: Insolvency proceedings encompass multiple stakeholders, including lenders, borrowers, and stockholders. The taxation process aids in safeguarding their interests by scrutinizing the fees imposed by court officers. It ensures that the charges align with the services rendered and prevents exorbitant or unwarranted levies.
  3. Fostering Confidence in the System: By establishing a robust taxation process, the court-supervised insolvency system in Canadian proceedings instills confidence among stakeholders. They can place their trust in the fact that the fees imposed by court officers undergo independent scrutiny and are not arbitrary. This bolsters the overall credibility and integrity of the Canadian insolvency process.
  4. Alleviating Financial Burdens: Insolvency proceedings can present financial hardships for both debtors and creditors alike. Familiarizing oneself with the taxation process enables stakeholders to identify any potential excessive fees and seek recourse if necessary. This helps mitigate additional financial burdens on parties already grappling with financial difficulties.
  5. Facilitating Efficient Resolution: The taxation of costs process fosters efficiency in resolving disputes pertaining to court officer fees. In the event of a disagreement over the charges imposed, a taxation hearing is conducted to settle the dispute. By grasping the intricacies of the process, stakeholders can navigate it adeptly, leading to a prompt resolution and averting unnecessary delays.

To provide a comprehensive overview, it is of utmost importance to grasp the intricacies of the taxation procedure pertaining to the fees charged by court officers in Canadian insolvency proceedings under court supervision. Such understanding not only ensures transparency but also safeguards stakeholder interests, fosters confidence in the system, mitigates financial burdens, and facilitates the efficient resolution of disputes related to fees.

In this Brandon’s Blog, I delve into the multifaceted aspects that shape the taxation of costs. Through this exploration, my aim is to offer valuable insights that will assist you in navigating this intricate domain. Come join us as we embark on an exploration of the nuanced intricacies of Canadian insolvency law and the myriad factors influencing the taxation of court officer fees.

Understanding The Role of Court Officers in Canadian Insolvency Cases

Definition and Role of Court Officers

Within the framework of a Canadian insolvency proceeding supervised by the court, a crucial role is fulfilled by the Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT). Acting as a court-designated official, the LIT plays an integral part in facilitating the management of the case and ensuring a fair and efficient process.

Endowed with accreditation from the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy (OSB), LITs as insolvency professionals are highly skilled experts possessing extensive expertise and experience in the realm of bankruptcy and insolvency. They act as unbiased and autonomous professionals, tasked with overseeing the insolvency proceedings in compliance with legal norms and regulations.

As a court-appointed officer, the LIT’s responsibilities are multifaceted and encompass a wide array of duties. These may encompass:

  • When confronted with the financial circumstances of a debtor, it becomes imperative to adopt a comprehensive methodology. Licensed Insolvency Trustees (LITs) excel at appraising the debtor’s assets and ascertaining the optimal strategy for disbursing them among creditors. Through meticulous evaluation of the debtor’s fiscal position, LITs can contribute to guaranteeing a just and impartial allocation of assets to all relevant parties. With their proficiencies in debt and asset administration, LITs serve as invaluable for individuals confronted with financial problems.
  • Facilitating meetings of creditors: LITs organize and conduct meetings where creditors can voice their concerns, vote on important matters, and provide their consent or objections regarding the insolvency process.
  • Developing a proposal or managing bankruptcy proceedings: Depending on the type of insolvency proceeding (such as a consumer proposal or bankruptcy), LITs may assist debtors in developing a proposal to settle their debts or administer the bankruptcy process if the proposal is not viable.
  • Investigating the affairs of the debtor: LITs have the authority to investigate the debtor’s financial affairs, including examining their records, transactions, and conduct, to identify any fraudulent activities or preferences that may impact the distribution of assets.

The above is the case regardless of whether it is a personal insolvency administration or a corporate insolvency one.

canadian insolvency
canadian insolvency

Types of Court Officers in Canadian insolvency cases

In the course of Canadian insolvency proceedings, the court possesses the authority to carry out diverse designations involving a LIT to supervise and manage the operation. These designations hinge upon the nature of the insolvency instance and the particular circumstances. Here, I present the normal kinds of designations that a court could enact:

Bankruptcy Trustee

In scenarios of personal or corporate bankruptcy, the LIT acting as the trustee of the bankrupt estate is automatically an officer of the court. The trustee assumes the responsibility of administering the bankruptcy, handling the assets, and disbursing the proceeds to creditors in accordance with the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA).

Interim Receiver

In certain Canadian insolvency cases, the court may opt to appoint an interim receiver under the BIA, who will serve as a temporary custodian. The primary goal of an interim receiver is to safeguard and preserve the debtor’s assets during the insolvency process.

They are authorized to take control of the debtor’s property and make necessary arrangements to ensure its proper management and security. Typically, an interim receiver is appointed when:

  1. there is a risk of asset dissipation before the court hears an Application for Bankruptcy Order; or
  2. when the debtor intends to sell some or all of its operating assets during a Division I Proposal administration and requires court approval for the sale, with the LIT who is acting as Proposal Trustee also assisting in the sale.

Proposal Trustee

In cases where an insolvent debtor files a consumer proposal or a corporate proposal under the BIA, the LIT acting as the proposal trustee of the insolvent debtor is automatically an officer of the court. The proposal trustee is accountable for evaluating the proposal, conducting meetings with creditors, supervising the restructuring process and the implementation of the approved proposal and making the necessary distribution to the unsecured creditors.

Monitor

In larger corporate insolvencies under the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA), the court designates a LIT to act as a monitor. The monitor acts as an independent third party and oversees the affairs of the debtor, ensures adherence to the CCAA procedure, and reports to the court and creditors. The monitor also oversees the restructuring process and the implementation of the restructuring plan.

Receiver

In the course of a Canadian insolvency proceeding, a receiver appointed by the court assumes control and oversees the management of a debtor’s assets. The receiver’s principal purpose revolves around the preservation of creditors’ interests and the facilitation of an organized administration process.

The appointment through a court-ordered receivership commonly occurs in situations where the debtor has defaulted and has no capacity to fulfill its financial obligations or when the need arises to safeguard and conserve the value of the debtor’s assets.

The receiver possesses extensive authority granted by the court to competently execute their responsibilities. These authorities encompass aspects such as assuming possession and control of the debtor’s assets, managing and liquidating assets, collecting outstanding debts, investigating the debtor’s financial matters, and disbursing proceeds to creditors in alignment with the court’s directives.

Liquidator

The court can appoint a liquidator in the case where the debtor company is solvent but the business is no longer viable. The company, with the assistance of the LIT who is the court-appointed liquidator, can collect on and sell its assets and there will be sufficient funds to pay off all the creditors and have money left over to distribute to the shareholders.

What do all of these court officers have in common?

All of the above various court officer appointments have one thing in common. To ensure an impartial and equitable process, the LIT appointed as the court officer assumes the role of an autonomous entity separate from the debtor and the creditors. They remain accountable to the court and bear a fiduciary duty toward the stakeholders involved.

The appointment of a court officer aims to facilitate the systematic resolution of the Canadian insolvency case (or in the case of a liquidation, the liquidation administration) while safeguarding the interests of the stakeholders involved, by entrusting the responsibilities to the LIT acting as an independent party possessing the requisite expertise in asset management and the resolution of financial disagreements and predicaments.

The appointments will differ depending on the specific circumstances of each case. The court possesses the discretion to enact appropriate designations with relevant powers granted to the LIT as the court officer to ensure the efficient administration and safeguarding of the rights of the debtor and creditors.

canadian insolvency
canadian insolvency

Understanding court officer fees in Canadian insolvency cases

In the realm of Canadian insolvency procedures, the proficiency of court-appointed officers is paramount and unswerving, as they assume a pivotal and irreplaceable function in the management and safeguarding of assets to benefit creditors. LITs bear the weighty responsibility of overseeing the course of insolvency proceedings, ensuring an impartial allocation of assets, and facilitating intricate financial resolutions.

As a testament to their outstanding contributions, court-designated officers are rightfully entitled to specific remunerations, acknowledging their unwavering commitment and specialized expertise. This section of the article aims to embark upon a comprehensive exploration of the diverse fee structures associated with court-appointed officers within the Canadian insolvency administration framework.

Initial retainer fee

Prior to their appointment and as a condition of consenting to act, court-appointed officers may necessitate an initial retainer fee. This fee acts as an upfront payment for their services and covers the preliminary expenses associated with commencing the insolvency administration process. The determination of the retainer fee typically hinges on the intricacy of the case and the complexity of the estate. The retainer amount is credited against the total fees earned as approved by the court.

Fee for administrative purposes

The administration fee constitutes an additional classification of court officer fees. Its objective is to cover the continuous administrative expenses accrued during the process of insolvency administration. This is the professional fee of the court officer, calculated by the hours worked by each level of staff of the court officer, at their standard hourly rates. This is the most common type of court officer fee.

Asset Realization or performance-based fee

It is possible in unique situations where the sale of assets will be very complex, the court officer earns an asset realization fee. It is earned only if the LIT is successful in disposing of the assets belonging to the insolvent estate or obtains a value above some pre-determined threshold amount. The court officer’s hard work in assessing, marketing, and selling assets is crucial to ensuring that creditors receive the best possible returns. Generally, the asset realization fee is calculated as a percentage of the total value of the realized assets or as a percentage of the revenue generated above the pre-determined threshold from the sale of assets.

Disbursements

In addition to the aforementioned fees, court-appointed officers are entitled to charge for their reasonable disbursements incurred during the course of their duties. Disbursements may encompass expenses relating to travel, professional services, legal fees incurred by the court officer, court filings, third-party valuations or appraisals, and other essential costs directly associated with the administration of the insolvency proceedings. The court officer is obligated to maintain meticulous records and furnish comprehensive accounts of the disbursements (and fees) for scrutiny and approval.

Significance of the checks and balances in the court taxation process for court officer fees

In all of the above cases, it is crucial to underscore those court-appointed officer fees and disbursements are subject to judicial oversight and scrutiny to ascertain their reasonableness and justifiability in light of the services rendered. The court possesses the authority to review and endorse these fees, factoring in elements such as the complexity of the case, the qualifications of the court officer, the scope of work performed, and the benefits conferred upon the stakeholders involved.

Court-appointed officers engaged in Canadian insolvency administrations are entitled to a potentially diverse array of fees, commensurate with their indispensable role in the management and preservation of assets. These fees encompass the initial retainer fee, administration fee, asset realization fee, performance-based fee, and reasonable disbursements. By duly compensating court-appointed officers for their unrivalled expertise and unwavering commitment, the insolvency administration process can proceed seamlessly, instilling confidence among creditors regarding the equitable and effective management of the insolvent estate.

canadian insolvency
canadian insolvency

Taxation process for court officer fees

The intricate procedure of taxing court officer charges in Canadian insolvency cases is a multifaceted framework that is influenced by numerous pivotal elements. Grasping these elements is of utmost importance for court officers and stakeholders alike, as it directly affects the amount of remuneration received by court officers for their labour and what is accessible to be allocated to the creditors in the priority of their ranking.

By conducting comprehensive evaluations of numerous Canadian insolvency cases, the court has established a series of benchmarks for the taxing process in scrutinizing and endorsing the fee and disbursements of a court officer. The taxing process is impelled by a variety of distinctive elements that necessitate meticulous attention to detail.

In essence, by acquiring a lucid comprehension of the taxing process and its implications, court officers can ensure that they obtain equitable compensation for their labour, while concurrently providing clients with a valuable service. Here are the elements that a court scrutinizes when determining the appropriateness of the fee and disbursements levied by its court officer.

Canadian insolvency cases: What are the factors that the court considers in the taxation of costs process for court officer fees

Preparation and submission of taxation of costs materials

The court officer’s application for the approval of its fee and disbursements is like any other court application. There needs to be the proper legal documents and evidence. The evidence is normally the court officer’s report to the court accompanied by invoices and detailed time dockets, sufficient to show what steps were taken in the administration for the specific date range, by who and at what professional hourly rate. This would be the case not only for the court officer but also for legal counsel providing legal services to the court officer.

This evidence would be accompanied by a sworn affidavit from an official from the court officer’s firm and the legal firm providing legal advice to the court officer, attesting to the accuracy of the time kept and that the hourly rates charged were the standard hourly rates. This would be for the administrative fee described above. If the court officer or its legal counsel feels they are entitled to any other type of fee, that evidence would also have to be put forward. An example would be a signed and accepted engagement letter between the court officer and the applicant in the original litigation that resulted in the appointment of the court officer.

The remaining procedures and documents are the ones that the lawyer acting on behalf of and providing legal advice to the court officer normally does such as obtaining a court date and preparing the notice of motion, factum and draft order, filing it with the court, effecting service on all interested parties and providing proof of service.

canadian insolvency
canadian insolvency

The Ontario court pays close attention to and follows several significant legal cases regarding the taxation of court officer fees when assessing the amounts in issue. These cases are:

Bank of Nova Scotia v. Diemer, 2014 ONSC 365 at paragraph 3, citing Re Bakemates International Inc., [2002] O.J. NO. 3659 (Ont. C.A.) – These cases establishes the essential principle that court officers must provide evidence to support the fairness and reasonableness of their requested compensation when seeking approval from the court. The court acknowledges its power to modify the fees and charges imposed by court officers, ensuring a just outcome is achieved.

Re Nortel Networks Corporation et al, 2017 ONSC 673 at paragraph 15, quoting Bank of Nova Scotia v. Diemer, 2014 ONSC 365 at para. 19, aff’d 2014 ONCA 851 – The court is not obligated to scrutinize the intricate details of dockets, hours, explanations, or disbursements. Instead, it has the authority to take into account all pertinent factors and make a more comprehensive assessment when awarding costs or fees. The Court of Appeal has emphasized that the primary focus should be on the achieved results, rather than the amount of time expended in achieving them.

Jethwani v. Damji, 2017 ONSC 3524 at paragraph 49 quoting HSBC Bank Canada v. Mahvash Lechcier-Kimel, 2014 ONSC 1690; aff’d 2014 ONCA 721.- In the context of a court-supervised Canadian insolvency case, if the actions of the court officer are considered imprudent and/or unreasonable, the fees and disbursements for the amounts in issue resulting from such conduct may be deemed unfair and unreasonable. This means that the court officer may not be entitled to receive full compensation for their services if their actions during the administration are deemed inappropriate or unreasonable.

Analyzing the prudence and reasonableness of the court officer’s conduct entails subjective interpretation, usually falling within the purview of the supervising court in Canadian insolvency proceedings. The court will consider an array of factors, including the accomplishments of the court officer, the encountered challenges, and the alignment of actions with the court’s directives and the best interests of all parties involved.

Should the court determine that the court officer’s actions were imprudent or unreasonable, they possess the authority to make appropriate adjustments to the fees and expenses. This adjustment is rooted in the notion that compensation ought to correspond to the level of performance and reasonableness demonstrated throughout the entire Canadian insolvency case.

What will the court specifically consider during the taxation process?

Based on the above cases, the Canadian courts will consider a non-exhaustive list of factors in determining whether a Court officer’s fees are fair and reasonable, including the:

  • nature, extent and value of the assets handled;
  • complications and difficulties encountered;
  • degree of assistance provided by the company, its officers or employees;
  • time spent;
  • court officer’s knowledge, experience and skill;
  • diligence and thoroughness displayed;
  • responsibilities assumed;
  • results of the court officer’s efforts; and
  • cost of comparable services and service providers in the jurisdiction when performed in a prudent and economical manner.

    canadian insolvency
    canadian insolvency

Canadian insolvency court officer best practices: Enhancing performance and safeguarding interests

In my view, court officers should adopt a set of best practices that can greatly contribute to their effectiveness. These practices should include the implementation of a signed engagement letter in Canadian insolvency court proceedings.

The Importance of a signed engagement letter

The signed engagement letter holds immense significance as it meticulously outlines the extent, nature, and expenses associated with the tasks to be undertaken by a court officer in Canadian insolvency court proceedings. By formalizing the agreement between the court officer and the Applicant, this document sets clear expectations and offers a wide array of benefits to both parties involved.

1. Ensuring clarity and defining the scope of work

With a signed engagement letter, the responsibilities and duties of the court officer become unambiguously clear. It provides a precise delineation of the work’s scope, encompassing specific tasks, deadlines, and deliverables. Such lucidity fosters a mutual understanding between the court officer and the Applicant, effectively minimizing potential misunderstandings or future disputes.

The possession of a signed engagement letter serves as concrete legal protection for both the court officer and the Applicant. It acts as tangible evidence of the agreed-upon terms, substantially reducing the likelihood of contractual conflicts. In instances of disagreements or misunderstandings, this engagement letter stands as a binding agreement, effectively safeguarding the interests of both parties.

3. Transparent cost structure

The engagement letter offers a transparent overview of the expenses associated with the court officer’s services. It explicitly outlines the fee structure, payment terms, and any additional costs that may arise throughout the court proceedings. This transparency enables the Applicant to aptly plan their budget, effectively averting any unforeseen financial surprises.

4. Aligning expectations

By explicitly defining the nature of the work to be performed, an engagement letter ensures a shared understanding between the court officer and the Applicant. It empowers the Applicant to comprehend the services they will receive and the level of assistance they can expect from the court officer. Simultaneously, it grants the court officer the opportunity to clarify their role and set realistic expectations for the Applicant, thus fostering a productive and harmonious working relationship.

5. Professionalism and credibility enhancement

When a court officer provides a signed engagement letter, it showcases their professionalism and credibility. This letter is proof that the officer is dedicated to upholding ethical standards and providing high-quality services. It also reassures the client that they are working with a skilled and responsible court officer. Overall, a signed engagement letter is a crucial element that enhances the court officer’s reputation and builds trust with their clients.

6. Documentation for effective record-keeping

The engagement letter assumes a pivotal role as an indispensable document for meticulous record-keeping purposes. It ensures that all pertinent details regarding the court officer’s engagement and the scope of work are meticulously documented in writing. This comprehensive documentation becomes invaluable when the need for future clarifications or reviews of the work arises.

In summary, incorporating a signed engagement letter into court proceedings is an indispensable best practice for court officers. It fosters clarity, safeguards legal interests, establishes transparent cost structures, aligns expectations, enhances professionalism and credibility, and facilitates effective record-keeping. By adhering to these practices, court officers can significantly enhance their performance and effectively safeguard the interests of all parties involved.

Advantages of meticulous record-keeping for fee statements in court-supervised Canadian insolvency proceedings

Within court-supervised Canadian insolvency proceedings, the court officer assumes a pivotal role in managing the intricate financial aspects of the process. The presence of comprehensive and precise documentation of fee statements yields substantial advantages for both the court officer and the stakeholders involved. Let’s delve into these benefits in greater depth:

1. Transparency and accountability

Thoroughly documented fee statements establish transparency and accountability concerning the financial transactions carried out by a court officer. They empower stakeholders to obtain a lucid comprehension of the imposed fees and the corresponding services rendered. By upholding meticulous records, the court officer can manifest their unwavering dedication to impartiality and ethical conduct, fostering trust among the stakeholders.

2. Justification of fees

Court officers are entitled to receive fair compensation for the provision of their services. By diligently documenting fee statements, court officers can substantiate the fees they levy. These records delineate the precise tasks undertaken, the invested time, and the intricacy of the involved work. Such comprehensive details enable stakeholders to grasp the value that the court officer brings forth and diminish the likelihood of fee-related disputes.

By ensuring the scrupulous documentation of fee statements, court officers can mitigate the risk of legal issues and the need for additional legal services stemming from erroneous or incomplete records. Given the exacting financial reporting requirements within court-supervised Canadian insolvency proceedings, precise and comprehensive fee statements contribute to adherence to regulatory standards, thereby minimizing the potential for legal entanglements.

4. Augmented stakeholder confidence

Stakeholders, encompassing creditors, the debtor being the insolvent company, and the court itself, repose profound trust in court officers’ ability to navigate the intricacies of insolvency proceedings. Meticulously documented fee statements act as tangible evidence of the court officer’s professionalism and dependability. This documentation instills stakeholders with the assurance that the court officer conducts their duties transparently and diligently, cultivating confidence in the overall process.

5. Efficient resolution of disputes

In situations where fee disputes or disagreements arise, the presence of thorough documentation becomes invaluable. Detailed records provide a foundation for resolving conflicts through negotiation or formal channels. They serve to facilitate discussions, clarify any misinterpretations, and reach mutually agreeable solutions. This expedites the resolution of disputes and upholds positive relationships between the court officer and stakeholders.

6. Adherence to reporting requirements

Court-supervised Canadian insolvency proceedings necessitate compliance with various reporting obligations, including financial disclosures. Meticulous documentation of fee statements ensures adherence to these reporting requirements. Accurate and well-documented fee statements streamline the preparation of essential reports, facilitate the maintenance of audit trails, and fulfill regulatory obligations. This enables court officers to fulfill their responsibilities effectively and ensures the smooth progression of proceedings.

7. Cultivation of professional reputation

Maintaining meticulous documentation of fee statements contributes to the cultivation of a court officer’s professional reputation. Accurate and organized records serve as a testament to the court officer’s unwavering commitment to professionalism and attention to detail. This meticulousness resonates positively within the legal and insolvency communities, potentially opening doors to future opportunities and referrals.

canadian insolvency
canadian insolvency

Advantages of timely and effective communication for court officers and stakeholders

Timely and effective communication plays a vital role in the court officers’ quest to maintain transparency and foster positive relationships with stakeholders. By giving due importance to clear and consistent communication concerning their actions, activities, and fees charged, court officers bring forth numerous benefits for themselves and the stakeholders involved. Let’s delve into these advantages in detail:

1. Improved comprehension and trust

Timely and effective communication empower court officers to articulate their actions and activities in a manner that stakeholders can readily grasp. By providing regular updates and reports, court officers ensure that stakeholders possess a comprehensive understanding of the progress and status of the proceedings. This level of transparency nurtures trust and instills confidence in the court officers’ capabilities, thereby fostering a productive and harmonious working relationship.

2. Heightened collaboration and cooperation

Maintaining open channels of communication enable court officers and stakeholders to exchange relevant information and actively engage in the proceedings. Effective communication facilitates seamless collaboration, leading to improved decision-making and problem-solving. This collaborative approach streamlines the legal process and paves the way for a more efficient resolution.

3. Timely resolution of issues

Timely communication empowers stakeholders to promptly address any concerns or issues that may arise. By promptly sharing information and seeking feedback, court officers can identify and resolve potential challenges or conflicts in a timely manner. This proactive approach minimizes disruptions, reduces delays, and ensures that the proceedings stay on track.

4. Transparent cost structure and budget management

Effective communication regarding fees charged equip stakeholders with a clear understanding of the costs involved in the legal process. Court officers can provide detailed explanations of the fees charged, including any additional expenses. This transparency empowers stakeholders to effectively manage their budgets, enabling them to anticipate and plan for the financial aspects of the proceedings.

5. Mitigation of misunderstandings and disputes

Clear and timely communication acts as a safeguard against misunderstandings and potential disputes. By providing comprehensive explanations of their actions and activities, court officers can address any questions or concerns that stakeholders may have. This proactive approach reduces the likelihood of conflicts and ensures a smoother legal process.

6. Stakeholder satisfaction and retention

When court officers prioritize effective communication, stakeholders feel valued and actively involved in the proceedings. Regular updates, timely responses, and clear explanations contribute to stakeholder satisfaction. Satisfied stakeholders are more likely to continue working with the court officers in the future and may even provide valuable referrals, thus enhancing the court officers’ reputation and expanding their professional network.

Timely and effective communication ensures that court officers adhere to legal and ethical standards. By providing regular updates and accurate information, court officers demonstrate their commitment to transparency and accountability. This adherence to standards upholds the integrity of the legal process and instills confidence among stakeholders.

Canadian insolvency: Conclusion

I hope you enjoyed this Canadian insolvency Brandon’s Blog on the issue of the taxation of a court officer’s fee and disbursements. Managing your personal or business financial affairs in today’s ever-challenging and changing business landscape is no small feat, but with the right plan in place, it’s possible to stay or get back on track.

Revenue and cash flow shortages are critical issues facing people, entrepreneurs and their companies and businesses that are in financial distress. Are you now worried about just how you or your business are going to survive? Are you worried about what your fiduciary obligations are and not sure if the decisions you are about to make are the correct ones to avoid personal liability? Those concerns are obviously on your mind.

The Ira Smith Team understands these concerns. More significantly, we know the requirements of the business owner or the individual that has way too much financial debt. You are trying to manage these difficult financial problems and you are understandably anxious.

It is not your fault you can’t fix this problem on your own. The pandemic has thrown everyone a curveball. We have not been trained to deal with this. You have only been taught the old ways. The old ways do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team uses innovative and cutting-edge methodologies, to adeptly navigate you through the intricacies of your financial challenges, ensuring a resolution to your debt-related predicaments without resorting to the rigours of the bankruptcy process. We can get you debt relief now!

We have helped many entrepreneurs and their insolvent companies who thought that consulting with a Trustee and receiver meant their company would go bankrupt. On the contrary. We helped turn their companies around through financial restructuring.

We look at your whole circumstance and design a strategy that is as distinct as you are. We take the load off of your shoulders as part of the debt settlement strategy we will draft just for you.

The Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. team understands that people facing money problems require a lifeline. That is why we can establish a restructuring procedure for you and end the discomfort you feel.

Call us now for a no-cost consultation. We will listen to the unique issues facing you and provide you with practical and actionable ideas you can implement right away to end the pain points in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

canadian insolvency
canadian insolvency
Categories
Brandon Blog Post

CONTACTING AN ONTARIO LICENSED INSOLVENCY TRUSTEE: PREPARE TO GET THE BEST RESULTS FROM YOUR INITIAL CONSULTATION

<h2>

Licensed insolvency trustee

If you’ve found yourself grappling with personal debt, or your company is in a tight spot because of corporate debt, seeking the guidance of a licensed insolvency trustee is a smart choice. Trustees possess the expertise and resources to assist you in navigating your financial predicament and getting back on the right course.

Before engaging in a conversation with a licensed insolvency trustee, it’s crucial to adequately prepare yourself to make the most of your preliminary consultation. This Brandon’s Blog outlines the essential steps that need to be taken to ensure a fruitful discussion. By adhering to these recommendations, you can be confident that you will derive maximum benefit from your complimentary consultation and obtain the necessary advice to chart your path toward resolving your financial challenges.

Without any further delay, let’s explore the preparations required for your initial consultation with an Ontario Trustee.

Understanding the role of an Ontario licensed insolvency trustee

An Ontario licensed insolvency trustee is a crucial player when it comes to handling financial troubles. Their key function is to help individuals and businesses in navigating the insolvency landscape and find the most effective and feasible options. Trustees are highly educated and licensed specialists who have a deep understanding of the federal government’s Canadian bankruptcy and insolvency legislation and how to apply it in every situation.

When you are drowning in personal or business debt, a Trustee can be your guiding light. They will assess your financial scenario, assist you to recognize your rights and realistic options, and offer experienced advice tailored to your personal story. Whether it’s recommending a debt consolidation loan, outlining the consumer proposal process, strategizing on the financial restructuring of businesses with debt problems or assisting in a personal bankruptcy filing, Trustees can help you get through the one that is best for you, making certain that you make educated choices each step of the way.

It is very important to note that Trustees are objective debt professionals. They aim to discover a reasonable and fair resolution that takes into consideration both your needs and the legal realities that your creditors face. So, if you’re facing economic obstacles and require someone with competence to guide you through the maze, a Trustee is definitely the individual to rely on.trustee

When should you consult a Trustee?

Navigating financial difficulties can be a challenging and overwhelming experience. If you find yourself struggling with mounting debts and unsure about the best way forward, it may be time to consult a licensed insolvency trustee. We specialize in helping individuals and businesses regain control of their financial situations. But when exactly should you seek our expertise? Here are some key scenarios where consulting a Trustee can be beneficial:

  1. Increasing debt burden: If your debts are continuously piling up, and you find it difficult to make timely payments, it’s a red flag that you should consult a licensed insolvency trustee. They can assess your financial situation, evaluate your debts, and provide guidance on the available options to alleviate your debt burden.
  2. The threat of legal action: When creditors are making their collection calls and are threatening legal action or have already initiated collection action, it’s crucial to seek professional assistance. A licensed insolvency trustee can help you understand your rights, explore potential solutions, and negotiate with creditors on your behalf.
  3. Loss of income or job: Sudden job loss or a significant reduction in income can have a severe impact on your financial stability. If you’re facing difficulties meeting your financial obligations due to these circumstances, consulting a licensed insolvency trustee can help you navigate through the challenges and explore strategies for recovery.
  4. Inability to repay debts: In the event that you have arrived at the point where the repayment of debts is no longer feasible, despite having explored alternative methods such as debt consolidation or negotiation, it is time to enlist the services of a Trustee who will offer guidance in navigating the insolvency process.
  5. Mounting stress and anxiety: The mounting stress and anxiety that often accompanies financial difficulties can have a debilitating impact on one’s mental and emotional well-being. Should you find yourself feeling overwhelmed, consistently stressed, or experiencing anxiety as a result of your financial situation, don’t hesitate to seek the guidance of a licensed insolvency trustee.

Remember, consulting a licensed insolvency trustee is not limited to these scenarios alone. If you have any concerns about your financial situation or feel uncertain about the best course of action, it’s always wise to seek professional advice. These experts can evaluate your unique circumstances and provide tailored solutions to help you regain control of your finances and pave the way toward a brighter financial future.

Importance of preparation for an initial consultation with the Trustee

Preparation is key when it comes to your initial consultation with an Ontario-licensed insolvency trustee. This is the moment where you get to meet and chat about your financial situation, explore possible solutions, and set yourself on the path to financial recovery. So, why is preparation so important? Well, here’s why:

First off, being prepared helps you make the most of your time with the Trustee. This consultation is a limited window, no longer than 1 hour, so having your ducks in a row and providing accurate information upfront allows the Trustee to understand your situation quickly and give you tailored advice. Time is precious and there is none to waste!

In order to optimize the benefits of your consultation with a Trustee, it is crucial to first correctly prepare for it. By devoting some time to think about how you got to your current financially challenged state, to consider your financial goals and concerns, you can establish a definitive plan of action. This will facilitate a focused and productive dialogue during the consultation, ensuring that the Trustee can address your unique needs with precision and efficiency.

It behooves you to also undertake thorough data collection and organization. This entails meticulously gathering and cataloging all pertinent information related to your financial history, liabilities, assets, income, and expenditures. By undertaking this preparatory work, you will be equipped with a comprehensive and precise understanding of your financial landscape. This will enable the Trustee to offer optimal guidance and recommendations that are tailored to your specific financial needs.

It is crucial to have a comprehensive understanding of the available debt relief options in Canada. Conducting thorough research beforehand allows you to enter the consultation with a well-informed perspective, equipped to ask pertinent questions, evaluate potential risks and benefits, and make prudent decisions regarding your financial future. This sense of empowerment is invaluable.

It is equally essential to consider the Trustee’s credentials and suitability. As a discerning individual, you must assess the Trustee’s expertise, approach, and values to ensure a fruitful partnership. Investing time and effort to gather recommendations, read reviews, and gauge compatibility will guarantee that you have selected a competent professional with whom you can establish an excellent working rapport.

Last but not least, when you come prepared, you exude confidence and engagement. Your thorough preparation gives you a boost of self-assurance, knowing that you’ve done your homework. This means you can actively participate in the consultation, ask relevant questions, and make the most of the Trustee’s guidance. It’s the difference between being in the financial game or being mired and lost!

To sum it all up, preparation is the secret sauce for a successful initial consultation with an Ontario licensed insolvency trustee. It helps you make the most of your time, gain clarity, gather necessary info, understand your options, evaluate the Trustee, and approach the discussion with confidence and engagement. So, put in the effort, get prepared, and get ready to pave your way to financial recovery and stability.trustee

The benefits of speaking with an Ontario Licensed Insolvency Trustee before you make any financial decisions

The benefits of speaking with an Ontario licensed insolvency trustee before you make any financial decisions.

Engaging in dialogue with an Ontario Trustee prior to making any financial determinations can yield considerable advantages. An Insolvency Trustee holds the expertise to both understand and dissect your financial problems and circumstances and acquaint you with the array of choices at your disposal. Trustees possess the proficiency to appraise your financial state and counsel you on the optimal resolution for your particular predicament. The Trustee, like me, may also hold the designation of Chartered Insolvency and Restructuring Professional.

If you find yourself facing economic challenges, it could be a good idea to get in touch with an Ontario Trustee. These professionals are skilled in offering counsel and guidance to individuals and companies grappling with monetary issues. They hold a license and are regulated by the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy Canada. By seeking assistance from a Trustee, you can obtain the support necessary to navigate the intricacies of financial predicaments. Through their aid, you will acquire valuable insights that can influence your decision-making and guide you toward a more prosperous financial future.

Financial assessment

One of the primary benefits of consulting with an Ontario Trustee is receiving a comprehensive financial assessment. LITs possess the expertise to review your financial situation objectively, taking into account your assets, debts, income, and expenses. This assessment allows them to gain a holistic understanding of your financial standing and identify potential solutions tailored to your specific needs.

Debt relief options explained

In times of financial adversity, it is imperative to have an in-depth understanding of the various debt relief options at your disposal. By consulting with a qualified Ontario Trustee, you can gain comprehensive insights into potential solutions, including debt consolidation, consumer proposals, and bankruptcy.

Trustees will inform you of the benefits and drawbacks of each alternative, offering a complete assessment of the potential outcomes and consequences associated with any given choice. Rest assured that with their guidance, you can make an informed decision that will alleviate your financial distress and pave the way toward a brighter fiscal future.

Tailored solutions for your unique situation

Every individual’s financial situation is unique, and what works for one person may not work for another. By consulting with a Trustee, you gain access to personalized solutions that address your specific circumstances. LITs take the time to understand your financial goals, evaluate your resources, and design a strategy that maximizes your chances of achieving a stable financial future.

When you find yourself struggling with overwhelming debt, it’s common for creditors to take legal action against you. Seeking assistance from a Trustee can help you navigate these legal challenges. LITs can provide protection from creditors who have started legal proceedings. An insolvency process will invoke a stay of proceedings, that puts a temporary halt on creditor actions, giving you breathing room to implement one of your potential debt relief solutions.

Expert negotiations with creditors

Engaging with creditors and negotiating debt repayment terms can be a daunting and stressful process. However, an Ontario Licensed Insolvency Trustee takes that job and all the stress that comes with it off your shoulders, by being the one negotiating with your creditors. Their expertise and knowledge of the legal and financial framework ensure that you receive fair treatment and that your rights are protected throughout the process.

Financial education and future planning

Speaking with an Ontario Trustee offers more than just immediate debt relief. LITs can provide financial education and guidance to help you develop healthy financial habits and plan for a more secure future. They can offer advice on budgeting, saving, and rebuilding credit, equipping you with the necessary tools to achieve long-term financial stability. Two mandatory financial counselling sessions are part of the services to individuals included automatically in any consumer insolvency process.

The key questions to ask to gain a better understanding of the process and your options

In order to optimize the outcome of a discussion with a Trustee regarding your financial situation, it is imperative to approach the exchange with a clear and organized mindset. Engaging in dialogue with a trustee can furnish indispensable observations and aid in discerning informed resolutions for your fiscal outlook. The following segment offers advantageous suggestions to anticipate the tenor of the conversation and how best to equip yourself for it, guaranteeing that you derive the utmost advantage from your interaction with the trustee.

1. Gather Relevant Financial Documents

It is crucial to gather all pertinent financial documents ahead of time. This includes bank statements, tax returns, credit card statements, loan agreements, and any other records that pertain to your financial situation. By providing the Trustee with a full picture of your financial standing, they can deliver practical advice and personalized solutions that are tailored to your unique circumstances. Don’t leave anything behind – come prepared with all the necessary information.

Before meeting with a Trustee, gather all relevant financial documents, such as bank statements, tax returns, credit card statements, loan agreements, and any other records pertaining to your financial situation. These documents will provide the Trustee with a comprehensive understanding of your financial standing, enabling them to offer accurate advice and tailored solutions.

2. Be Transparent and Honest

It’s crucial to be open, transparent, and honest about your financial circumstances during the conversation with the Trustee. A professional code of ethics and confidentiality binds them, so you can feel confident in sharing sensitive information. Providing a complete and accurate picture of your financial situation will enable them to offer the best possible guidance and solutions.

3. Prepare a List of Questions and Concerns

To make the most of your conversation with the Trustee, prepare a list of questions and concerns in advance. Consider what specific areas of your financial situation you’d like to address or any uncertainties you may have. Having a well-prepared list will ensure that you cover all relevant topics and get the information you need during the discussion.

4. Understand the Available Options

Educate yourself about the various debt relief options available to you before the conversation with the Trustee. Research bankruptcy laws, debt consolidation, consumer proposals, and other relevant solutions. This background knowledge will allow you to have a more meaningful discussion with the Trustee, as you can ask targeted questions and better understand their recommendations.

5. Take Notes During the Conversation

During your conversation with the Trustee, it’s helpful to take notes. Jot down key points, advice, and recommendations provided by the Trustee. These notes will serve as a reference later on and help you recall important details when making decisions about your financial situation.

6. Ask About Potential Consequences and Long-Term Implications

Inquire about the potential consequences and long-term implications of different debt relief options. Understanding the pros and cons, as well as any legal or financial ramifications, will enable you to make an informed decision. The Trustee can provide insights into how each option may impact your credit score, assets, and future financial stability.

7. Discuss a Realistic Financial Plan

Collaborate closely with the Trustee to formulate a pragmatic and attainable fiscal blueprint. This comprehensive scheme must harmonize with your aspirations while considering your revenue, expenditures, and liabilities. Leveraging the Trustee’s proficiency, forge a viable budget and delve into tactics that can curtail your debt burden and enhance your long-term financial standing.trustee

How to follow up after the consultation with the licensed insolvency Trustee to ensure all your concerns are addressed before making any decisions

After finishing your initial consultation with a licensed insolvency trustee, there will always be some lingering questions or concerns. You should always follow up with the Trustee to clear up any confusion. It is definitely a lot of information to digest in one consultation. This will empower you to better understand the process, your available options, and any further actions you may be required to take.

Be sure to take notes of all crucial details discussed during the session and jot down any additional questions that come to mind. You may contact the Trustee via phone or email to seek clarification on any doubts or queries before making any critical financial decisions. By engaging in a follow-up conversation with your Trustee, you can ensure that you are fully informed and confident in your financial decisions.

Common things that people want to know from the Trustee during the initial consultation

What are my debt solution options? A Trustee provides a wide range of options for debt relief that are tailor-made to suit your specific needs. For individuals, this could involve presenting a consumer proposal or a Division I restructuring proposal to unsecured creditors, allowing you to negotiate a repayment plan based on your financial capacity. For corporations, if timely intervention is possible, it may entail financial restructuring. Your Trustee will carefully consider the pros and cons of each option and recommend the most suitable course of action based on your unique circumstances. In certain cases, bankruptcy may be the only viable solution.

How will this affect my credit score? Many individuals express concerns about potential negative impacts on their credit score when meeting with a Trustee. However, it is important to note that the act of simply meeting with a Trustee does not have any direct impact on your credit score. It is the chosen insolvency process itself that can have an effect on a person’s credit rating.

What are the costs involved? When seeking the assistance of a Trustee, it becomes crucial to take into account the related expenses. The charges imposed by a Trustee vary based on the chosen insolvency procedure and are contingent upon the complexity of one’s financial predicament and the extent of services provided.

However, it is of utmost importance to acknowledge that these expenses are subjected to regulation by the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy Canada and necessitate court approval in instances of bankruptcies and consumer proposals. Throughout the primary consultation, the Trustee will furnish an open and all-encompassing breakdown of all charges, guaranteeing absolute transparency and lucidity during the course of action.

Is this consultation confidential? Yes, it is a confidential consultation. However, keep in mind that we are not lawyers.

Trustee conclusion

To wrap things up, it’s of utmost importance to have thorough preparation in place to ensure a highly productive initial consultation with a Trustee. I’ve delved into various pivotal measures you can adopt to optimize the utilization of your time during the consultation and obtain relevant guidance pertaining to your debt-related predicaments.

Bear in mind, forthrightness and transparency regarding your financial circumstances are vital, enabling the Trustee to furnish tailor-made solutions that align with your unique requirements, whether it is a personal or corporate matter. Lastly, seize the opportunity presented by this cost-free consultation to pose any inquiries or voice any apprehensions that may be lingering within. The Trustee is dedicated to aiding you in navigating through your financial hardships and ultimately steering you toward a triumphant financial destiny.

I hope you enjoyed this Trustee Brandon’s Blog. Managing your personal or business financial affairs in today’s ever-challenging and changing business landscape is no small feat, but with the right plan in place, it’s possible to stay or get back on track.

Revenue and cash flow shortages are critical issues facing people, entrepreneurs and their companies and businesses. Are you now worried about just how you or your business are going to survive? Are you worried about what your fiduciary obligations are and not sure if the decisions you are about to make are the correct ones to avoid personal liability? Those concerns are obviously on your mind. Coming out of the pandemic, we are also now worried about the economic effects of inflation and a potential recession.

The Ira Smith Team understands these concerns. More significantly, we know the requirements of the business owner or the individual that has way too much financial debt. You are trying to manage these difficult financial problems and you are understandably anxious.

It is not your fault you can’t fix this problem on your own. The pandemic has thrown everyone a curveball. We have not been trained to deal with this. You have only been taught the old ways. The old ways do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team uses innovative and cutting-edge methodologies, to adeptly navigate you through the intricacies of your financial challenges, ensuring a resolution to your debt-related predicaments without resorting to the rigours of the bankruptcy process. We can get you debt relief now!

We have helped many entrepreneurs and their insolvent companies who thought that consulting with a Trustee and receiver meant their company would go bankrupt. On the contrary. We helped turn their companies around through financial restructuring.

We look at your whole circumstance and design a strategy that is as distinct as you are. We take the load off of your shoulders as part of the debt settlement strategy we will draft just for you.

The Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. team understands that people facing money problems require a lifeline. That is why we can establish a restructuring procedure for you and end the discomfort you feel.

Call us now for a no-cost consultation. We will listen to the unique issues facing you and provide you with practical and actionable ideas you can implement right away to end the pain points in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.trustee

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

WHEN TO FILE BANKRUPTCY: OUR COMPREHENSIVE GUIDE ON WHEN IS THE RIGHT TIME TO FILE FOR BANKRUPTCY

When to file bankruptcy to get a fresh start

Definition of Bankruptcy

Are you feeling overwhelmed by unmanageable debt? Then bankruptcy might be the perfect solution
for you. Bankruptcy can be defined as a legal process that can help people and businesses get out of their financial binds.

Though the thought of filing for bankruptcy may be daunting, it can be the best option when you’re facing unexpected expenses or other emergency situations.

To make sure you’re making the right decision, it’s important to understand when to file bankruptcy and what you can expect. Bankruptcy allows a person to get back on top of their finances and start fresh. Weighing the pros and cons of filing for bankruptcy can be an alarming task, but it can ultimately be the best when your back is against the wall with debt. This Brandon’s Blog lets you find out when to file bankruptcy, what you should expect and what the bankruptcy alternatives are.

What is Bankruptcy and How Does it Work?

Bankruptcy in Canada is a liberating process for those who have found themselves under a burden of debt. The Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA) provides debtors with a discharge from most debts, allowing them to have a fresh start in their financial lives. The process is designed to help those who cannot pay their bills as they come due, and have no way of paying back their debt load. By taking advantage of the bankruptcy discharge, individuals can find themselves free from the chains of debt and start anew. On the other hand, unlike a person, a company that files for bankruptcy will not survive in the long run, and thus, there is no discharge process for a company.

when to file bankruptcy
when to file bankruptcy

When to File Bankruptcy?

Don’t let debt take the life out of you! Bankruptcy law can give you the fresh start you need. Although not to be taken lightly, a bankruptcy filing can be an absolute lifesaver when the debt becomes too much to bear.

Filing for bankruptcy is no small decision and has the potential to drastically alter your financial future. It’s essential to be informed on when to file bankruptcy and the process involved to ensure that your credit and ability to access money in the future are not adversely affected.

Start the legal process off right by filing for bankruptcy with the help of a licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a bankruptcy trustee) (LIT or Trustee). The LIT will submit all the documents at once and get the ball rolling.

When an individual has too much consumer debt and files for bankruptcy, the LIT takes possession of their property and assets (subject to provincial government exemptions). The Trustee is the appointed authority in charge of liquidating the assets and depositing the proceeds into a trust account that will eventually be distributed among the creditors in the priority laid out in the BIA.

It is crucial to understand when to file bankruptcy and the process involved to make informed decisions about one’s financial future.

When to file bankruptcy: Identifying signs of financial distress

Here are 5 common signs of financial distress:

  1. Consistent inability to pay billsConsistent inability to pay bills can be a difficult and stressful situation for individuals and companies. There are various options for managing late bill payments, however, missing bill payments can have negative financial impacts. It is important to be proactive in finding a solution, as missing bill payments may result in consequences such as eviction, cutting off of necessary supplies and financial penalties. Options for managing late bill payments vary, depending on the type of bill, such as rent or mortgages as opposed to suppliers of goods or services.
  2. Increased collection activity and legal threats – Balances in collections are the result of outstanding debts that have not been paid. The collection process and the behaviour of debt collection agencies and debt collectors are stressful. Provincial law dictates the rights of consumers when it comes to debt collection and debt collectors.The statute of limitations to collect a debt is also a matter of provincial jurisdiction. Debts are statute-barred after the period prescribed by the law for bringing legal action against the consumer to collect a debt. A debt is considered time-barred if the applicable statute of limitations has expired.
  3. Are you buried in debt and feeling overwhelmed? A hefty burden of financial obligations without a plan of attack can lead to a seemingly never-ending cycle of debt, with high-interest payments and a lack of hope. Alternatively, an overly ambitious plan can leave you feeling like freedom from debt is unattainable. The stress of debt can have a major toll on your mental health. It’s time to take control and devise a sensible debt repayment strategy to ultimately become debt-free and reduce the interest you pay.
  4. Tempted to use a credit card for all your needs? Be careful; it can be easy to go overboard and put yourself into financial hardship. When you use credit cards, you risk overspending, inflating your credit utilization ratio, and even opening yourself up to identity theft and credit card fraud. Don’t take the chance – think twice before swiping!
  5. Increasingly relying on personal loans from friends and family – The dangers of relying on loans from friends and family include broken promises or agreements. There may be confused assumptions about the loan, which can lead to misunderstandings.Additionally, not setting up clear and defined terms for repayment could lead to problematic personal relationships. A loan from friends and family could also provide tax problems depending on how it is set up and how interest payments, principal repayments and/or loan forgiveness are treated on tax returns, or not, as the case may be.

    when to file bankruptcy
    when to file bankruptcy

When to file bankruptcy: The process of filing for bankruptcy

The process of filing for bankruptcy in Canada is handled by a Trustee under the supervision of the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy Canada (OSB) under the BIA. The time to complete the bankruptcy process for a 1st time bankrupt with no surplus income, where neither the Trustee nor any creditor opposes the individual bankrupt’s discharge is 9 months. If a first-time bankrupt gets a discharge at the 9-month point, then they have received an automatic discharge from the LIT. During bankruptcy, the creditors can no longer harass the bankrupt person or carry out legal proceedings or wage garnishments.

The LIT provides an information form for the person to complete, and uses that information to prepare and then file the bankruptcy paperwork. The LIT needs personal information (name, address, birth date), a list of creditors and a list of assets. The LIT then files the bankruptcy documents electronically with the OSB and then they will issue a Certificate confirming the acceptance of the bankruptcy filing. It is the day and time of the issuance of the OSB’s certificate that marks the beginning of the bankruptcy process.

When to file bankruptcy: What is the impact of filing for bankruptcy?

Once your bankruptcy is filed, there is an immediate stay of proceedings. This means that unsecured creditors cannot begin or continue lawsuits, wage garnishees, or even contact you to request payment. Within five days of the bankruptcy starting, the LIT will send a copy of the bankruptcy paperwork to creditors so they can file a claim.

Overview of the bankruptcy process

Can I keep my assets when I file for bankruptcy? In most cases, yes. However, the trustee may sell some assets to pay off your creditors. The assets you can keep will depend on your province’s exemptions. The Trustee’s job is to manage the sale of the bankrupt’s assets and place the proceeds into a trust, safeguarding them for the creditors. In other words, the Trustee is a guardian of funds, making sure everything is handled properly.

Are you worried that filing for bankruptcy will destroy your credit? Don’t fret – while bankruptcy will certainly leave its mark on your credit report, it’s far from a death sentence. Once your bankruptcy is approved, you can start taking steps toward restoring your financial health. A fresh start is waiting – be smart and make decisions that will get you back on the right track!

Wondering just how long you’ll be in bankruptcy? That all depends! If it’s your first-time bankruptcy filing with no surplus income, it should only last nine months. But if you’ve filed for bankruptcy more than once and don’t have surplus income, it will take 21 months. For those who have surplus income, this process will take longer.

2 financial counselling sessions. In a consumer restructuring or bankruptcy administration under the BIA, the debtor is required to go through two financial counselling sessions with the LIT. The reason is that one of the objectives of the BIA is financial rehabilitation. Financial education and teaching financial literacy tips are important parts of that rehabilitation.

Requirements for filing bankruptcy

To be eligible to file for bankruptcy in Canada, you must meet certain requirements. You must owe at least $1,000 in unsecured debt and be unable to pay your debts as they come due. You must also be insolvent, meaning you owe more than the value of the assets you own. Additionally, you must either reside, do business or have property in Canada. There are other acts of bankruptcy contained in the BIA, but the normal requirement is as I just described.

Role of Trustees in the bankruptcy process

The role of a LIT in Canada is to assist individuals or companies in the bankruptcy process as laid out by the BIA. They help to explain to the debtor the various options in dealing with their debt and provide advice on the best course of action. The Trustee also prepares the necessary paperwork, including reviewing the debt and completes the process from start to finish. One of the key responsibilities of the Trustee is to take possession of the property not exempt under provincial law, or subject to a trust or secured claim. The LIT then does this by selling the available assets and depositing the funds in trust for the creditors in the bankruptcy administration.

when to file bankruptcy
when to file bankruptcy

When to file bankruptcy: Alternatives to Bankruptcy

There are several alternative solutions that a LIT can recommend to a debtor in solving their debt problems. Bankruptcy is always the last resort and is to be avoided if at all possible. The main alternative solutions are:

Debt consolidation and debt management plans

In Canada, consolidation loans are available to assist individuals in reducing their high-cost debt payments. If you qualify for such a loan, it is an advantageous solution. These debts may include credit cards, payday loans, and unpaid tax obligations. By consolidating higher-interest-rate debts into one lower-interest-rate loan, it is possible to make affordable monthly payments and work toward eliminating debt.

If you’re in need of financial help, a Debt Management Plan (DMP) may be the answer. A DMP is an effective way to repay credit card debt, and with the help of a non-profit, no-cost credit counselling agency, you can get the support to make it work. The agency will assess your situation to ensure that a DMP is the best option for you. Put your debt worries to rest and take the first step towards a sound financial future with a DMP.

Both debt consolidation and debt management plans aim to help individuals in Canada manage their debt effectively.

Credit counselling and financial planning

Credit counselling and financial planning can help someone who has many debts. The services are provided by accredited credit counsellors working for non-profit credit counselling organizations. A credit counsellor will assess the financial situation of an individual and provide tips on dealing with debt. Financial planning and budgeting will be an important part of the process.

If the individual decides to sign up for a DMP, the counsellor will contact creditors on their behalf to request reducing or eliminating the interest rate or fees on their debts. In some cases, the creditors may agree to these requests.

Debt settlement, restructuring and negotiation with creditors

Debt restructuring, also known as debt negotiation, is the process of negotiating the terms and conditions of debt repayment with creditors. This process can be carried out by the consumer or company themselves seeking alternative repayment options. The goal is to reach a mutually agreed-upon arrangement that is more manageable for the consumer or company to repay their debt. It can involve the forgiveness of interest, stopping the interest clock and even the forgiveness of principal. If the company or consumer handles the discussions themselves, or with the help of their accountant, it is called an informal restructuring.

When a consumer or company restructures their debt with the help of a LIT under the BIA, they would file either a consumer proposal or a Division I proposal restructuring. A large company could also restructure under the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act.

When to file bankruptcy: Conclusion

Personal bankruptcy or corporate bankruptcy, and when to file bankruptcy, is a big decision, but it can be the right one when you’re overwhelmed with debt. You can make an informed decision by understanding the basics of bankruptcy, including when to file and what to expect. If you’re struggling with debt and considering bankruptcy, it’s important to speak with a professional who can help you assess your options. Bankruptcy can be a fresh start for your financial future, but it’s important to understand the consequences and work with a professional to determine if it’s the right choice for you.

I hope you enjoyed this when to file bankruptcy Brandon’s Blog.

Revenue and cash flow shortages are critical issues facing entrepreneurs and their companies and businesses. Are you now worried about just how you or your business are going to survive? Those concerns are obviously on your mind. Coming out of the pandemic, we are now worried about its economic effects of inflation and a potential recession.

The Ira Smith Team understands these concerns. More significantly, we know the requirements of the business owner or the individual that has way too much financial debt. You are trying to manage these difficult financial problems and you are understandably anxious.

It is not your fault you can’t fix this problem on your own. The pandemic has thrown everyone a curveball. We have not been trained to deal with this. You have only been taught the old ways. The old ways do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team makes use of new contemporary ways to get you out of your debt problems while avoiding bankruptcy. We can get you debt relief now.

We have helped many entrepreneurs and their insolvent companies who thought that consulting with a trustee and receiver meant their company would go bankrupt. On the contrary. We helped turn their companies around through financial restructuring.

We look at your whole circumstance and design a strategy that is as distinct as you are. We take the load off of your shoulders as part of the debt settlement strategy we will draft just for you.

We understand that people facing money problems require a lifeline. That is why we can establish a restructuring procedure for you and end the discomfort you feel.

Call us now for a no-cost consultation. We will listen to the unique issues facing you and provide you with practical and actionable ideas you can implement right away to end the pain points in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

when to file bankruptcy
when to file bankruptcy
Categories
Brandon Blog Post

RECEIVERSHIP IN CANADA: THE COMPLETE STORY OF WHOSE HAPPY RECEIVER IS IT ANYWAY?

Receivership in Canada: What does receivership mean?

I have just read a decision of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice Commerical List dealing with an important aspect of receivership in Canada. The case is concerned with what happens when two equally applicable provincial laws appear to be working at cross purposes in the context of the receivership in Canada process.

I will explain the case and the process of company receivership in Canada. By understanding the process, the case will make more sense.

Secured lenders may enforce their security to recover loans from borrowers who have defaulted. This remedy available to secured creditors when a borrower, usually a company defaults, is known as receivership.

What does going into receivership in Canada mean?

A receivership is a legal process available to secured creditors, whereby a company’s affairs, business and property are entrusted to a receiver to manage and eventually sell the assets. Secured lenders may enforce their security to recover loans from borrowers who have defaulted. This remedy available to secured creditors is known as receivership.

If a business debtor does not make payments or otherwise defaults on a secured loan, the secured creditor would have the right to appoint a receiver to collect the money owed. Before appointing a receiver, a secured creditor must first issue a “Section 244” notice of intention to enforce security. This is a notification that secured creditors must send to defaulting debtors before appointing a receiver. Section 244 refers to that section number in the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA).

The notice states that the security covers certain assets, that the company in default owes a specified amount to the secured creditor, and that the creditor may enforce the security after 10 days. The company in default may waive the notice period and consent to the appointment of the receiver.

Under the BIA, only a licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a trustee in bankruptcy) can be a receiver. No other party is licensed to administer a receivership in Canada.

receivership in canada
receivership in canada

Receivership in Canada: What is the difference between a court-appointed receiver and a privately appointed receiver?

A privately-appointed receiver is a licensed trustee who is appointed by a contract between the insolvency trustee and the secured creditor. A private receiver is typically used when there is no dispute to ranking among secured creditors or various claims to ownership of the company’s assets. The powers of a receiver listed in the security document give the privately appointed receiver more limited powers than a court-appointed receiver gets under a court order.

A receiver is court-appointed when the secured creditor makes an application to the court for the appointment of a receiver with more expanded powers. Like a privately-appointed receiver, a court-appointed receiver takes control of a company’s property because of financial distress and when there is a dispute among secured creditors and others as to the ranking of secured claims and ownership of property.

Both kinds of receivers are tasked with protecting and preserving the value of the company or property and are certainly given broader powers by the court to do so.

How is receivership in Canada different from bankruptcy proceedings?

Many people mistakenly use the terms “receivership” and “bankruptcy” interchangeably. However, bankruptcy and receivership are two distinct legal proceedings with different implications.

Bankruptcy vs. receivership can be confusing, but once you understand the key differences between the two, it is fairly straightforward. Whether it is a private appointment or a court-appointed receiver, the differences between bankruptcy and receivership in Canada are the same.

A receivership is a legal remedy available to secured creditors to enforce their security rights against a defaulting debtor. A receiver is appointed to manage the debtor’s property and assets and sell them under a properly run and fair sales process.

The Canadian bankruptcy process is a distinct legal process. An insolvency trustee does not represent secured creditors in bankruptcy proceedings. Instead, under the bankruptcy regime, they represent the unsecured creditors of the bankrupt estate. A corporate debtor may be subject to both bankruptcy and receivership proceedings simultaneously.

One of the major differences has to do with the creditors. In a bankruptcy administration, the bankruptcy trustee must call a meeting of creditors. This is where the insolvency trustee provides its report on the affairs and conduct of the bankrupt debtor and unsecured creditors get to vote on any matters of importance. In receivership, there is no such requirement to hold a meeting of creditors.

receivership in canada
receivership in canada

What are the key distinctions between receivership in Canada and liquidation?

So you know what receivership is by now. The federal BIA doesn’t govern liquidation, that’s done under the provincial Business Corporations Act or Wind-Up Act.

A liquidation is for a solvent company where the shareholders, Officers and directors decide to cease business operations. The company puts up its assets for sale and uses the proceeds to pay off its creditors with cash. Any funds left over are then distributed to the shareholders.

A liquidator can be appointed either privately by the company’s directors or by a court order. Liquidation is therefore different from both bankruptcy and receivership in Canada.

Can individuals be placed into receivership in Canada?

The answer is yes. When a secured creditor wishes to take enforcement action upon the security agreement they have against a debtor’s property, as indicated above, they have the remedy of receivership in Canada. This remedy allows them to collect as much of their secured debt as possible.

There are no restrictions as to who can go into receivership in Canada. One of our more famous (infamous?) receivership cases over the years has been the receivership of the assets, property and undertaking of Norma and Ronauld Walton.

receivership in canada
receivership in canada

Receivership in Canada: Whose receiver is it anyway?

Now for the court case where two different provincial laws caused a fight amongst secured creditors over the appointment of a receiver. The case is Canadian Equipment Finance and Leasing Inc. v. The Hypoint Company Limited, 2618905 Ontario Limited, 2618909 Ontario Limited, Beverley Rockliffe and Chantal Bock, 2022 ONSC 6186. The two competing provincial statutes are the Mortgages Act and the Personal Property Security Act.

The business is conducted through two affiliated entities. One owns the property and the other operates the business. This is quite a typical arrangement.

One creditor funded the purchase of equipment and took PPSA security over it. Another creditor funded the acquisition of the real property and has a traditional mortgage security. The security agreements extend over different assets, and the outcome is usually uncomplicated.

However, when equipment that has been purchased is attached to real property, there is disagreement about whether and how it can be removed, and whether such removal will negatively affect the value of both the equipment and the real property. The question is now more complicated: which creditor’s rights should take priority over this matter?

Both the equipment lender and the mortgagee are seeking to enforce their security. The equipment lender has filed a motion with the court to appoint a receiver over both the operating company (Opco) that owns the pledged equipment and the holding company (Holdco) that owns the real estate. This would allow the receiver to manage and sell the assets of both companies in order to repay the outstanding debt.

In this case, Opco was a commercial marijuana operation that was unable to get off the ground due to its heavy debt load and startup problems.

Although the mortgagee began power of sale enforcement proceedings, they do not object to a receiver being appointed over the equipment only. The mortgagee wishes to continue its power of sale proceedings and opposes the receiver being appointed over the building. The mortgagee in possession is of the opinion that the equipment is attached to the building and cannot be removed.

The mortgagee concurred that the court has the power to assign a receiver over the property of both Opco and Holdco according to section 101 of the Ontario Courts of Justice Act. They stated that, if a receiver is appointed, the receiver needs to be a firm chosen by them.

Both the licensed insolvency trustee firm preferred by the mortgagee and the firm nominated by the equipment lender filed a consent to act with the court.

What are the conditions under which a receiver may be appointed?

The court looked at numerous factors in order to make a decision on whether or not to appoint a receiver, and if so, which one, including those that have historically in receivership in Canada cases been taken into account in such determinations:

  1. Although it is not essential for a creditor to establish irreparable harm if a receiver is not appointed where the appointment is authorized by the security documentation, the court considered if no order is made, will irreparable harm be caused?
  2. The size of the debtor company’s equity in the assets and the need for protection or safeguarding of assets during litigation are important factors to consider when assessing the risk to the security holder.
  3. The kind of property it is.
  4. The potential for the assets to be wasted or dissipated.
  5. The need to safeguard the property until a legal ruling is made.
  6. The parties’ respective balance of convenience needs to be considered when making the decision.
  7. Pursuant to the loan documentation, the creditor has the right to an appointment.
  8. Enforcing the security instrument when the security holder experiences or anticipates difficulties with the debtor.
  9. The principle of appointing a receiver should be approached with caution.
  10. The court will determine whether appointing a receiver is necessary to enable the receiver to carry out its duties efficiently.
  11. The effect a receivership order will have on the parties.
  12. The parties’ conduct.
  13. How long a receivership may last.
  14. The financial impact on the parties.
  15. The likelihood of maximizing return to the parties is increased.
  16. The goal of ensuring the smooth running of the receiver’s duties.

As everyone agreed that all assets of both Opco and Holdco should be sold to maximize recovery for all creditors, but cannot agree on the process by which that should be undertaken, resulting in the entire process being stalled, the judge was satisfied that it is just and convenient to appoint a receiver.

The court found that either proposed receiver was acceptable and decided that the receiver nominated by the mortgagee would be appointed by the court to administer all assets. The receiver would eventually come back to court with a sales plan to maximize the value of all the assets subject to the security of all stakeholders.

receivership in canada
receivership in canada

How the entrepreneur can avoid receivership in Canada

As a business owner, the way to avoid the receivership process is long before financial difficulties ever become serious financial problems. Here are a few tips on how to do just that:

  • Keep a close eye on your finances. This means regularly reviewing your income and expenses, and making sure you have a good handle on your cash flow.
  • Stay current on your bills. This includes not only making timely payments but also staying on top of any changes in your billing terms or amounts.
  • Keep good records. This means having up-to-date financial statements and documentation for all of your income and expenses.
  • Make a plan. If you do find yourself in a financial bind, have a plan in place for how you’ll get out of it. This may include negotiating with creditors, seeking new financing, or making cuts to your expenses.
  • Seek professional help from a licensed insolvency trustee with commercial insolvency experience. If your business is viable and you seek help early enough, there may be many options. The most common ones are refinancing with or without financial restructuring. Reviewing your business allows us to make restructuring recommendations allowing your viable company to become healthy and profitable once again.

Receivership in Canada summary & speak with a licensed insolvency trustee

I hope you enjoyed this receivership in Canada Brandon’s Blog.

Revenue and cash flow shortages are critical issues facing entrepreneurs and their companies and businesses. Are you now worried about just how you or your business are going to survive? Those concerns are obviously on your mind. Coming out of the pandemic, we are now worried about its economic effects of inflation and a potential recession.

The Ira Smith Team understands these concerns. More significantly, we know the requirements of the business owner or the individual that has way too much financial debt. You are trying to manage these difficult financial problems and you are understandably anxious.

It is not your fault you can’t fix this problem on your own. The pandemic has thrown everyone a curveball. We have not been trained to deal with this. You have only been taught the old ways. The old ways do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team makes use of new contemporary ways to get you out of your debt problems while avoiding bankruptcy. We can get you debt relief now.

We have helped many entrepreneurs and their insolvent companies who thought that consulting with a trustee and receiver meant their company would go bankrupt. On the contrary. We helped turn their companies around through financial restructuring.

We look at your whole circumstance and design a strategy that is as distinct as you are. We take the load off of your shoulders as part of the debt settlement strategy we will draft just for you.

We understand that people facing money problems require a lifeline. That is why we can establish a restructuring procedure for you and end the discomfort you feel.

Call us now for a no-cost consultation. We will listen to the unique issues facing you and provide you with practical and actionable ideas you can implement right away to end the pain points in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

receivership in canada
receivership in canada

 

 

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

DISCHARGE FROM BANKRUPTCY CANADA: OUR DETAILED STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE

What are the implications of discharge from bankruptcy Canada?

If you are experiencing financial troubles and can’t pay your debts, you can file for bankruptcy in Canada. This legal process lets you off the hook for your debts and start fresh. Once you’re discharged from bankruptcy, you’re no longer responsible for those debts (other than for a few exceptions noted below). Filing for bankruptcy is stressful. We understand how difficult and stressful the bankruptcy process can be, so we hope that this will be a helpful resource for you.

Once the Trustee has completed their duties under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) with respect to the administration of your property and the bankruptcy estate, the next step in the bankruptcy process is they must apply for a discharge. This will occur after the Trustee has applied for your discharge from bankruptcy Canada, even if you did not get an absolute discharge.

This Brandon’s Blog is for people who have made a bankruptcy filing but have not yet been discharged. If your Licensed Insolvency Trustee has been discharged or is otherwise unable to help you with a second discharge application, this blog will provide you with the information you need to get through the process on your own.

Discharge from bankruptcy Canada: What are the implications if you are not discharged from bankruptcy?

If your previous application for discharge was unsuccessful, you remain an undischarged bankrupt and your Trustee is not obliged to make another application on your behalf. However, you should check with your Trustee first as they may or may not be prepared to do so.

We often receive calls from individuals who claim that their Trustee has been discharged, but they have not been. They express confusion as to why their Licensed Insolvency Trustee will not make an application for their discharge from bankruptcy. A quick search reveals that in these cases, the individual received a conditional discharge, but has not yet fulfilled all of their conditions to get a bankruptcy discharge. That is why their conditional discharge has not yet been converted into an absolute discharge.

If you filed an assignment in bankruptcy and are still an undischarged bankrupt, you may be able to apply for discharge from bankruptcy. An insolvency Trustee only needs to make one application on your behalf. Once the Trustee obtains their discharge, they do not need to make your application for discharge on your behalf again.

The Licensed Trustee cannot be discharged until all bankruptcy administration requirements have been met, including making the first discharge application on behalf of the bankrupt person.

discharge from bankruptcy canada
discharge from bankruptcy canada

Discharge from bankruptcy Canada: How do you obtain a bankruptcy discharge in Canada?

Automatic discharge from bankruptcy is typically granted unless there are exceptional circumstances. If there is opposition to the automatic discharge, the discharge application must be brought before the court for a hearing.

If you did not complete all of your bankruptcy duties as the bankrupt person, such as providing income and expense statements, attending required financial counselling sessions, and/or paying surplus income, your Trustee had reasons to oppose your automatic discharge and scheduled a hearing with the court.

The Report of Trustee on Bankrupt’s Application for Discharge sets out the reasons for the insolvency Trustee’s opposition to a bankrupt’s application for discharge. This document is on file with the court.

If a bankrupt does not receive a discharge at the time of the court application, it is usually because they have not yet done what is required. The associate justice/registrar who heard the application at court may have therefore adjourned the application (i.e. stated it was to be heard at a later date, which may or may not have been set).

The court may have adjourned your discharge application or imposed conditions that must be met before you are entitled to a discharge. The disposition sheet from the hearing will state what the court decided in this regard.

Discharge from bankruptcy Canada: What are the steps to clear my bankruptcy?

It’s not unusual for people who didn’t do what they were supposed to at first to try and get back on track and do what’s required to get their discharge. You must comply with your duties during bankruptcy to the best of your ability and be prepared to explain to the court any deficiency in doing so.

For example, to get your discharge, you must be able to provide details and evidence of your income and expenses during bankruptcy. You probably recall that you were required to provide the Trustee with your monthly income and expense reports. If you’re unable to provide the court with those details, the court may want to review your income tax returns for that period. If you want the court to rescind or vary the conditions imposed, you must show that you complied with the conditions to the best of your ability.

There are many examples of trying your best to meet the conditions but maybe not perfectly. If the court orders you to pay a certain sum of money to the Trustee by a certain date, you can make the court-ordered additional payment but not by the specified date. If you were required to make surplus income monthly payments but didn’t make them all, that’s one reason there were conditions attached to your discharge. You can apply to the court to change the date and get your discharge.

Another one is that you didn’t finish all your required credit counselling sessions. You could finish them and then provide proof of completion to the court.

discharge from bankruptcy canada
discharge from bankruptcy canada

Completing your own application for discharge from bankruptcy Canada

Making your own application to be discharged from bankruptcy can be a bit daunting, but don’t worry—just follow a few simple steps and you’ll be all set. Here are some tips to help you get your application ready and submitted without the help of a bankruptcy trustee or a bankruptcy lawyer.

To begin, you’ll want to locate your bankruptcy file at the court office. Once you have your file, be sure to look through it thoroughly to find:

  • your bankruptcy court file number;
  • the Report of Trustee on the Bankrupt’s Application for Discharge under section 170 of the BIA;
  • any order issued by the bankruptcy court at the original discharge hearing; and
  • the court’s disposition sheet from any previous discharge hearing identifies what the court previously ordered or decided.

You will need copies of these documents. You can ask the court office to make copies for you. They will charge you a fee for photocopying. You should check the Report of the Trustee, the court’s disposition sheet, and any court order to see what you failed to do and what conditions the court has imposed. Also, it is not a bad idea to find out who attended your last application for discharge.

You should check the Report of the Trustee, the court’s disposition sheet, and any court order(s) in the file to see what you didn’t do and what conditions (if any) the court has imposed. Lastly, you need to schedule a date for your discharge hearing with the bankruptcy court.

You will be required to prepare the following documents and file them with the court:

  • a notice of hearing for a bankrupt person’s application for discharge;
  • your affidavit explaining why you believe you are entitled to the discharge order sought;
  • an affidavit of service; and
  • a draft of the order sought.

The Associate Justice/Registrar in Bankruptcy hearing your application for discharge may make any order he or she sees fit. If the order you are seeking is made, he or she may accept and sign it in court on the day you appear, which may save you a period of time later on.

Requisition – Notice of hearing for bankrupt’s discharge from bankruptcy Canada hearing for discharge

The first step in obtaining a discharge in bankruptcy is to file a Notice of Hearing for Bankrupt’s Application for Discharge with the court. That document would have first been filed by the Trustee when the Application for discharge is first scheduled. If you have a copy of it, it will be a good precedent for you to follow.

A requisition must be filed again by you in order to have the matter brought back before the court.

discharge from bankruptcy canada
discharge from bankruptcy canada

Discharge from bankruptcy Canada:The Affidavit

An affidavit is a formal, written statement that provides key information in your legal case. Any evidence you want the court to consider in your application must be submitted in an affidavit. Your affidavit should describe the events leading up to your bankruptcy, and your current financial situation.

You must swear or affirm your affidavit before a notary public or commissioner of oaths. Make sure that your affidavit only includes evidence that is relevant to your application for discharge.

The court is familiar with a standard form of affidavit for discharge applications. You should familiarize yourself with that normal format. You should also include:

  • additional information about why you did not seek a bankruptcy discharge earlier;
  • is this a 1st-time bankruptcy, 2nd-time bankruptcy or more;
  • why you have not been able to comply with the bankrupt’s duties or the requirements of an earlier court order; and
  • state the reasons you are wanting to be discharged now.

You will need to attach any relevant documents to your affidavit in support of your application, including a statement of your current income, expenses, assets, liabilities and any previous bankruptcy information.

Discharge from bankruptcy Canada:Affidavit of Service

To serve documents, you must provide a written copy to the party to be served. You need to obtain a signature or other confirmation, such as an email, to confirm that the document was properly served. You will need to serve the filed Requisition and all filed Affidavits and documents on:

These parties may attend your hearing and make submissions.

In order to provide proper service within the required time period before your discharge hearing, you must familiarize yourself with the rules. You must also provide proof of service at the hearing, especially if no one else attends. This proof of service can be the signature of everyone served to show the date they were served.

An Affidavit of Service can also be filed with the court. This Affidavit of Service is separate from the Affidavit filed with the court regarding your reasons for entitlement to anabsolute bankruptcy discharge certificate.

discharge from bankruptcy canada
discharge from bankruptcy canada

At the discharge from bankruptcy Canada hearing

When you appear in court for your discharge hearing, you will be able to present your case to either an Associate Justice or Registrar in Bankruptcy. If your application is being opposed, the creditors opposing your discharge need to file a notice of opposition. In this case, the hearing will be in front of a bankruptcy Judge. This is the normal process followed:

  1. You explain why you believe you are entitled to the order you are seeking, for example, an absolute discharge from bankruptcy.
  2. Anyone opposing your application explains his or her position.
  3. The Judge or Registrar may ask questions relating to the affidavits and documents you have filed and make suggestions or give directions.

When presenting your position at the hearing, remember to:

  1. Clearly state what order you are seeking from the Registrar in Bankruptcy or Judge.
  2. Outline the facts supporting your application in a concise manner.
  3. Explain the law on the subject and how it applies to the facts of your case.

Your conduct before and during bankruptcy will be taken into consideration when making a decision on your application for discharge. The Trustee’s report will provide information on your conduct before and during bankruptcy, which will be taken into account. if you did not attend the required financial counselling
sessions, did not file required statements of income and expense, and/or did not make the required surplus income payments to the Trustee for the benefit of your creditors.

The court will consider the relevant factors and make the appropriate order, or it may adjourn the hearing for further information or conditions to be met. Some of the types of orders the court may make are:

  • An order of discharge that is absolute and therefore you are immediately discharged from bankruptcy.
  • A conditional discharge may be granted. Examples of conditions are:
    • if the debtor pays any unpaid surplus income,
    • the debtor pays the outstanding balance for any asset that was agreed to be paid for; or
    • if the debtor pays a sum of money to the Trustee toward their debt obligations, as decided by the court.
  • A discharge that has been suspended.
  • The court may refuse to issue a discharge order if it is not satisfied that you have made full and adequate disclosure, or if there are issues with your conduct.

Discharge from bankruptcy Canada: Order for discharge

The Judge or Registrar in Bankruptcy will grant a discharge order at the end of the hearing. The type of discharge will be one of the kinds indicated above. If you prepared a draft order and the Registrar in Bankruptcy or Judge finds it acceptable, they will sign it and you can then have it filed with the court. However, if your application was opposed, keep in mind that one of the opposing parties may choose to appeal the discharge order.

If you have not prepared your order before the hearing, you should do so after the hearing and submit the order in duplicate to the court. The court office will then send the order to the Registrar in Bankruptcy or Judge who heard your application for signing. Once you receive your copy of the signed order, your discharge will be official.

When you receive a copy of the signed order, you must provide a copy to the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy. They will in turn notify the credit bureaus and Canada Revenue Agency of your discharge.

When you have received your absolute discharge, you are no longer legally responsible for repaying debts that you incurred before your assignment in bankruptcy. You will get rid of debt with some exceptions set out in Section 178 of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act. They are:

  • payment of child support or alimony;
  • student loans, if you have not been a full-time or part-time student for less than 7 years;
  • a fine or penalty imposed by the court; or
  • debt resulting from fraud.

    discharge from bankruptcy canada
    discharge from bankruptcy canada

Discharge from bankruptcy Canada: Are you tired of being in debt?

Bankruptcy law and the bankruptcy process can be complex, so it may be worth retaining a bankruptcy lawyer to help you apply for your discharge. Ultimately, it is up to you, but hopefully, this guide to discharge from bankruptcy Canada will lay out the steps you need to take if you wish to apply for a discharge yourself.

I hope that you found this discharge from bankruptcy Canada Brandon’s Blog informative. If you’re sick and tired of carrying the burden of debt and ready to live a much better life, we can assist. We know exactly how it really feels to be in debt as well as feel like you’re never going to get ahead. We have actually helped lots of people and businesses that were in your position reach financial stability, so we understand it’s feasible for you to prosper in your objective of ending up being debt-free. Nevertheless, it will certainly require some work on your part. We’ll be right here to assist you with every action necessary.

The financial restructuring process is complex. The Ira Smith Team understands how to do a complex restructuring. However, more importantly, we understand the needs of the entrepreneur or the person who has too many personal unsecured debts, Credit card debt, income tax debt liability, unsecured loans or personal obligations from the running of your company or from being a business owner. These are all types of debt we can help you eliminate. We are aware of your financial difficulties and understand your concerns. Filing bankruptcy is the last option we explore only after we have exhausted all other options to avoid bankruptcy, such as financial restructuring through a debt repayment plan.

It is not your fault that you are in this situation. You have been only shown the old ways that do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team uses new modern ways to give you the best management advice to get you out of your outstanding debt troubles while avoiding bankruptcy. We can get you debt relief freedom.

The stress placed upon you is huge. We understand your pain points. We are sympathetic to the financial difficulties you are experiencing and would like to help alleviate your concerns. We want to lighten your load by coming up with a debt settlement plan crafted just for you.

We realize that people and businesses in financial difficulty need practical advice and a workable solution in an easy-to-understand financial plan. The Ira Smith Team knows that not everyone has to file for bankruptcy in Canada. Most of our clients never do, as we are familiar with alternatives to bankruptcy. We assist many people in finding the relief they need.

Call or email us. We would be happy to give you a no-cost initial consultation. We can find you the perfect solution to tailor a new debt restructuring procedure specifically for you, based on your unique economic situation and needs. We provide a full range of services to people and companies. If any of this sounds familiar to you and you’re serious about finding a solution, let us know. We will get you back to living a happy life, whether or not there is an economic recession in Canada.

Call us now for a no-cost initial consultation. We are licensed professionals.

discharge from bankruptcy canada
discharge from bankruptcy canada
Categories
Brandon Blog Post

HOW TO FILE BANKRUPTCY ONLINE: OUR KNOCKOUT STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE

File bankruptcy online: You can file bankruptcy online in Canada!

Can I file bankruptcy online in Canada? This is a question we’ve been getting a lot lately. And the answer is yes, you can file bankruptcy online in Canada; just not by yourself.

The only ones the federal government authorizes in Canada to do bankruptcy filings are licensed insolvency trustees. Since March 2020, the process for meeting with a bankruptcy trustee to discuss bankruptcy has changed and can be done online. This may be helpful if you’re considering bankruptcy for your individual situation.

In this Brandon’s Blog, I explain how, with the help of a licensed insolvency trustee, you can meet all the legal requirements and file bankruptcy online for the Canadian bankruptcy process.

Why you can file bankruptcy online in Canada

There’s virtually nothing you can’t do online these days. The lockdowns increased our reliance on online shopping for things like groceries, clothes, office supplies, and even toilet paper.

The internet also includes a wealth of knowledge on any subject you can think of, including financial topics. I find that anyone contacting me who is struggling with their, or their company’s financial problems, has already looked into the various options available to them in dealing with debts like income taxes and credit cards.

Although people may not be familiar from their online research with all the ins and outs of insolvency and bankruptcy, this is to be expected. However, callers are generally well-informed about different options for dealing with secured creditors and unsecured creditors.

Nowadays, people expect to be able to do everything online – including filing for bankruptcy in Canada. Those who think bankruptcy might be a solution for them, are curious to understand if they can declare bankruptcy online. Thanks to the COVID-19 pandemic, online everything is a way of life.

file bankruptcy online
file bankruptcy online

Why you should file bankruptcy online

The Canadian government oversees the administration of the insolvency process in Canada through the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy Canada (OSB). The OSB is part of Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada (Industry Canada). They ensure that consumer proposals, corporate financial restructuring and bankruptcies are handled in accordance with federal law. This process protects the rights of both debtors and creditors and helps to ensure a fair and orderly resolution to financial difficulties.

The OSB is responsible for administering Canadian bankruptcy law under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA), as well as certain duties under the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA). They license and regulate the insolvency profession, ensure an efficient and effective regulatory framework, and supervise stakeholders. The OSB is independent of the Government of Canada in carrying out its regulatory, administrative, and supervisory duties.

As a result of the outbreak of COVID-19, the OSB issued guidance to Trustees on how certain aspects of the Canadian bankruptcy and insolvency process have changed. This document, entitled Temporary Guidance for LITS During the COVID-19 Pandemic, provides direction on how to navigate these changes.

As concerns about COVID-19 grew in Canada, licensed insolvency trustees took action to reduce in-person meetings. The OSB supported the Trustee community in these initiatives while maintaining the stability of Canada’s insolvency system.

Many of the same temporary measures remain in place today. Most clients find it more convenient and less stressful to continue filing for bankruptcy online. So how do we file bankruptcy online in Canada?

Assessing your financial situation and considering bankruptcy alternatives

No matter what form of insolvency process we are discussing to deal with a specific debt situation calling for either financial restructuring with a debt settlement payment plan through a consumer proposal or Division I Proposal, or personal bankruptcy, the process always starts in the same way. It’s not important what type of bankruptcy or insolvency process we’re talking about if we are dealing with a limited liability company or with someone considering bankruptcy for individuals.

When it comes to corporate insolvency, it’s important to have a clear understanding of the company’s current financial position and what its chances are for a successful financial restructuring. In consumer insolvency cases, the first step is to assess the debtor’s individual situation.

When a person contacts me to discuss their personal financial situation, we would have our initial chat. If the person wished to explore their available options in more detail, I would need to collect additional information from them to enable a proper assessment. Before we discuss which actual filing may be appropriate, it is important for me to know things like their assets and liabilities, their monthly income, and their household size.

If they would like me to continue our no-cost consultation and provide them with a proper assessment, I email them our standard intake form called the Debt Relief Worksheet. I ask them to please make sure to fully complete it and include any backup documents that are requested.

The backup documents we typically request are quite standard – a copy of their most recent bank statement, their last filed tax return, and the notice of assessment. Once I have a chance to review everything and ask any follow-up questions, I’ll be able to provide tailored advice based on their unique situation.

The counseling before filing bankruptcy that we give is perhaps even more important than any counselling sessions after filing. So far, we’ve been able to do everything over the telephone and online.

file bankruptcy online
file bankruptcy online

Is filing bankruptcy online an option for getting rid of debt?

Now that I have all the necessary information, I can perform the rest of the initial assessment. There could be several options available for those struggling with debt, and filing for bankruptcy may be an option for some. However, it’s important to understand the process and what it entails before making a decision.

Continuing with the online model, I meet with the person and do the rest of the assessment by phone or video meeting. I explain what I see as the realistic debt relief options for the person, explain why and discuss what is involved with each option and answer any questions they may have.

At the end of the meeting, I provide the person with a list of resources that can help them make their decision. I’m always available to answer any questions they may have throughout the process. Filing for online bankruptcy may very well be an option for getting rid of debt, but it should be the last option.

Something else to remember is that an insolvency proceeding will lower your credit score as it appears on your credit report. Declaring bankruptcy will have a worse effect than a debt management plan through a BIA-approved financial debt restructuring program repayment plan.

What documents do you need in order to file bankruptcy online?

To discuss what documents you need for a bankruptcy application in order to file bankruptcy online in Canada, we will assume that the person chose the bankruptcy option. By now, I have enough financial information to prepare all the necessary bankruptcy documents.

Examples of statutory bankruptcy forms which are part of the bankruptcy paperwork include the:

  • statement of affairs, indicating both the person’s eligible assets and those exempt from seizure under provincial law with related bankruptcy schedules;
  • list of creditors that is used for the creditor mailing list to send out the notice to creditors;
  • person’s statement of monthly income and expenses;
  • bankruptcy assignment
  • notice to bankrupt of their bankruptcy duties; and
  • estate information summary.

We schedule a video meeting with the debtor once all the statutory and financial documents are ready for signing. We can either email the documents or upload them to our secure signing portal and provide the debtor with a private, secure link. We’re happy to use online technology to have our meeting and explain all the documents, witness their signing, and get the signed documents from them.

We take the signed documents and file them in the Industry Canada OSB electronic online filing system. The OSB issues the bankruptcy certificate once the electronic filing is accepted. The day and time of the certificate is the exact moment the person is officially bankrupt.

file bankruptcy online
file bankruptcy online

Duties during bankruptcy include credit counselling sessions

The duties of a bankrupt person are set out in section 158 of the BIA. They include:

  • to identify all of their property and allow the Trustee or anyone authorized by the Trustee to take possession of all the debtor’s property;
  • to give the Trustee all books, records, documents and papers related to their property or affairs, including, but not limited to, title papers, insurance policies, and tax records and returns;
  • providing full disclosure of all assets and liabilities;
  • helping the trustee when required with assistance from time to time;
  • if one or more creditor meetings are required, you must attend; and
  • attending the two mandatory bankruptcy credit counseling sessions run by the Trustee.

We can meet with the bankrupt person over video meetings to provide counselling sessions and help them to fulfil their online bankruptcy duties.

Is it always going to be possible to file bankruptcy online in Canada?

The OSB has extended the option to conduct online service delivery of the Canadian insolvency options available under the BIA. Licensed insolvency trustees can continue to use online methods. It has provided some peace of mind for many people.

The OSB has been consulting with the insolvency community on potential amendments to relevant directives, with the goal of implementing an online alternative to meeting in person. While allowing flexibility, the changes they are contemplating would emphasize that while trying to be flexible, the changes being contemplated would emphasize that debtors will have the choice to either meet in person or online.

It looks like the OSB is warming up to the idea that remote filing through online resources, whether we are talking about BIA-approved debt repayment plans or bankruptcy may very well be here to stay. The OSB is trying to balance the benefit to debtors as well as the bankruptcy process continuing to be for the benefit of creditors. Can it all continue to be accomplished by online resources and technology? So far the average person, be they Canadian debtors or Canadian creditors, seem to want to continue with the choice of having insolvency administration online.

file bankruptcy online
file bankruptcy online

Are you deep in debt? We can help!

I hope you enjoyed this Brandon’s Blog on how to file bankruptcy online. Are you or your company in need of financial restructuring? Are you or your company unable to survive the COVID pandemic and its aftermath? The financial restructuring process is complex. The Ira Smith Team understands how to do a complex restructuring. However, more importantly, we understand the needs of the entrepreneur or the person who has too much personal debt. You are worried because you are facing significant financial challenges.

It is not your fault that you are in this situation. You have been only shown the old ways that do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team uses new modern ways to get you out of your debt troubles while avoiding bankruptcy. We can get you debt relief freedom.

The stress placed upon you is huge. We understand your pain points. We look at your entire situation and devise a strategy that is as unique as you and your problems; financial and emotional. We know that we can help you the way we take the load off of your shoulders and devise a debt settlement plan.

We realize that people and businesses in financial difficulty need practical advice and a workable solution in an easy-to-understand financial plan. The Ira Smith Team knows that not everyone has to file for bankruptcy in Canada. Most of our clients never do, as we are familiar with alternatives to bankruptcy. We assist many people in finding the relief they need.

Call or email us. We can tailor a new debt restructuring procedure specifically for you, based on your unique economic situation and needs. If any of this sounds familiar to you and you’re serious about finding a solution, let us know.

Call us now for a no-cost initial consultation.

file bankruptcy online
file bankruptcy online

 

 

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

INSOLVENCY TRUSTEE: TURNS OUT CERTAIN ACTIONS AGAINST THE TRUSTEE CANNOT BE UNLEASHED WITHOUT COURT PERMISSION

What does an insolvency trustee do?

In simple terms, the only professional who can help you with a government-regulated insolvency proceeding that may allow you to be discharged from your debt is an insolvency trustee. This may be the best solution for individuals with significant financial difficulties.

An insolvency trustee is responsible for carrying out the administration of an insolvency file in accordance with the requirements of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA). The insolvency trustee is responsible for ensuring that both creditors and the public interest are protected during the debt relief options of bankruptcy, consumer proposal, or Division I proposal process. This includes ensuring that assets are properly managed, sold and the cash distributed and that the bankruptcy or insolvency process is carried out in a fair and orderly manner.

A licensed insolvency trustee is federally regulated

The Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy (OSB) licenses and provides ongoing oversight for insolvency trustees, who must adhere to federal standards of practice, including the Code of Ethics for Trustees.

If you have a problem with a licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a bankruptcy trustee) that you can’t solve, you can file a complaint with the OSB. Your complaint will be reviewed and assessed. You may even want to consider taking legal action against the insolvency trustee if your situation is extreme.

Section 215 of the BIA states:

“Except by leave of the court, no action lies against the Superintendent, an official receiver, an interim receiver or a trustee with respect to any report made under, or any action taken pursuant to, this Act.”

The BIA recognizes that a party may have a legitimate grievance against an insolvency trustee for something that was done or not done during a bankruptcy administration. The BIA tries to balance the need to protect legitimate claims against the Trustee with the need to prevent parties from using the threat of litigation to gain leverage.

insolvency trustee

Who is a person of insolvency?

The above is an introduction to today’s insolvency trustee Brandon’s Blog. In June of last year, I wrote about this bankrupt person in the blog TRUSTEE IN BANKRUPTCY: CERTAIN ACTIONS AGAINST TRUSTEE CAN BE UNLEASHED WITHOUT FIRST REQUIRING COURT PERMISSION. That Brandon Blog dealt with a decision of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice.

The person of this insolvency was a serial bankrupt, filing bankruptcy four times in 12 years: 2004, 2006, 2011, and 2016. Each time he used the same insolvency trustee. He operated a sole proprietorship painting business. So technically, each time he went bankrupt, a new sole proprietorship began.

The plaintiff alleges that the licensed insolvency trustee (LIT) was negligent, committed fraud, breached their fiduciary duty, and was unjustly enriched, starting with the confidential consultation and throughout each personal bankruptcy administration. The bankrupt discovered during his 4th bankruptcy that his former spouse had misappropriated substantial sums from his business between 2003 and 2018. Ultimately, he determined that the amount of the misappropriations was approximately $206,000.

The bankrupt’s fourth bankruptcy was annulled by filing a consumer proposal with a different insolvency trustee that was accepted by his creditors. He and his current spouse then commenced an action not against the corporate licensed insolvency trustee of record who handled all four bankruptcies, but rather against the person, who is a licensed insolvency trustee, who carried out the individual bankruptcy processes.

The bankrupt person and his new spouse are seeking relief against the individual as though he were the Trustee of record. The central allegation is that he, as the “Licensed Insolvency Trustee” providing bankruptcy services for each of the bankruptcies, ought to have detected the misappropriations and, once told about them, he should have sued the former spouse. So they are blaming the Trustee for the bankrupt businesses with debt problems!

The plaintiff went to court to determine whether they needed the court’s permission to proceed with their case under section 215 of the BIA against the bankrupt person’s insolvency trustee. The plaintiff believed they did not need permission, but if they did, they should be granted it. The defendant Trustee argued that permission was needed and should not be granted. The judge ruled that the plaintiff does not need to get permission from the court to start this legal process.

Insolvency trustee appeals lower court decision

On July 13, 2022, the Court of Appeal for Ontario released its decision of the three appellate judge panel on the insolvency trustee‘s appeal of the lower court decision. The OSB obtained intervener status and was represented by legal counsel on the appeal. The OSB supported the insolvency trustee‘s position.

The motion judge, sitting in the bankruptcy court, determined that permission was not required under s. 215 to commence the legal action. However, she expressly did not determine whether, if permission were required, it should be granted. Therefore, she did not address whether the person’s status as an undischarged bankrupt would impact the decision.

The motion judge found that the litigation did not require permission under section 215 for two reasons:

  1. she believed that actions against trustees in their personal capacity do not require permission; and
  2. she found that actions that allege omissions do not require such permission.insolvency trustee

Is the appeal as of right, and if not, should leave to appeal be granted?

The Court of Appeal for Ontario first had to decide if the licensed insolvency trustee has an automatic right to appeal the lower court decision and if not, should leave to appeal be granted?

The appellate court stated that it would be willing to grant leave to appeal because the proposed appeal, falls within the proper scope of section 215 of the BIA for 3 reasons:

  1. This case raises an important issue – the circumstances in which an insolvency trustee can be sued without leave of the court – that is of general importance to the practice in bankruptcy/insolvency matters.
  2. The case is prima facie meritorious.
  3. The appeal would not unduly hinder the progress of the person’s bankruptcy proceedings.

The Court of Appeal for Ontario, therefore, gave the Trustee the opportunity to appeal the lower court’s decision.

Insolvency trustees and bankrupts are obliged to work with the court

The lower court found that the action did not require leave under section 215 of the BIA. This is because the judge decided it was against the Trustee in a personal capacity. The Trustee was now appealing this decision. The Trustee argued that section 215 of the BIA applies when a director, officer, or employee of the corporate trustee is sued for the Trustee’s conduct, just as it would if the corporate trustee were sued. The appellate court agreed, relying on a decision from the Supreme Court of British Columbia.

The purpose of BIA section 215 is to ensure that the bankruptcy process is not obstructed by the Trustee being hindered by actual or threatened vexatious lawsuits in connection with the administration of the bankruptcy.

In Canada, most licensed insolvency trustees are corporations. The BIA imposes numerous duties on them. A corporate entity can only discharge its duties through its directors, officers and employees. If the scope of section 215 were limited to protecting only the corporate trustee, then Trustees would be unable to properly carry out their duties.

The Court of Appeal for Ontario in this cased determined that this type of distinction between the corporate trustee and its staff would contravene the clearly expressed will of Parliament as evidenced by the statutory language. To allow such would be to subvert the fundamental purpose of section 215.

The key question in determining whether s. 215 applies is whether the connection contemplated by the section is present. This question is answered by examining the relationship between the alleged wrongdoing complained of in the Action and the role of a trustee. The appellate court looked at the proposed action by the bankrupt person and his current spouse and saw that there was the required connection. Therefore the Court of Appeal for Ontario agreed with the position of the Trustee and the intervener in finding that section 215 does apply in this case.

The other reason the motion judge came to her conclusion was that the action also alleged omissions. The lower court judge determined that a claim for omissions is not covered by section 215. The appellants and the intervener argued that action may fall outside of section 215 only when the crux of the action is the failure to do something expressly and specifically required by the BIA.

The common law claims here arise from alleged failures to act, rather than from failures to do something specifically and expressly required by the BIA. The Court of Appeal believes that section 215 applies to this action, and the motion judge was incorrect in concluding otherwise.

The Court of Appeal for Ontario sent this case back down to the bankruptcy court to decide whether the former bankrupt and his current wife should be allowed to sue the Trustee.insolvency trustee

What you need to know about LITs

Neither myself nor my firm has any kind of involvement in this issue. I have not read any of the pleadings in this action. I wish to be clear with you and let you know, based only on the information available to the public from the court decisions, what I would certainly have done in carrying out the personal bankruptcies if I was the Trustee.

If you’re experiencing financial difficulties and are considering insolvency, the first step is to consult with an insolvency trustee. During this consultation, the Trustee will collect information about your financial affairs and make recommendations about the best course of action for you.

The individual conducting the assessment must inquire about the debtor’s property and financial affairs. They shall prepare a statement of the debtor’s financial affairs, including their assets and liabilities, based on the information obtained from the debtor.

It is also necessary to get a clear and up-to-date monthly income and expenditure statement, which details all income (gross and net), all expenditures (including special needs, alimony, support or maintenance payments, and medical and prescription expenses). The debtor must also be prompted to provide information on all transfers under value they may have made concerning their assets.

There are a few options available to debtors who are struggling financially and looking to improve their financial situation. These debt relief programs include:

  • non-legislative debt solutions such as debt consolidation or financial counselling sessions performed by credit counselling agencies (insolvency trustees must provide two mandatory credit counselling sessions with the debtor as part of either a proposal or bankruptcy);
  • consumer proposals under Division II of the BIA;
  • a proposal under Division I of the BIA for those that do not qualify for a consumer proposal; and
  • as a last resort, bankruptcy.

What are the duties of an insolvency trustee?

Each debt management plan option has different rights and responsibilities for both the debtor and the creditors. It’s important for the debtor to understand all of the available debt management solutions. I would discuss each one with the debtor and help them choose the one that would be the best for their individual situation. In this particular case, I would want to drill down with the debtor to have him identify the causes of their insolvency. This inevitably would lead to a discussion with this debtor as to why his business seems to be losing so much money every year.

In order to fulfill my duties, I would want to drill down with the debtor to have him identify the causes of their insolvency. This inevitably would lead to a discussion with this debtor as to why his business seems to be losing so much money every year. If the debtor had been able to afford the monthly payments for a consumer proposal to annul his fourth bankruptcy using a different Trustee, could he have avoided filing for bankruptcy a fourth time altogether? I don’t have enough information to know the answer to that question.

I am required to review the bankrupt’s banking transactions for the 12 months prior to the date of bankruptcy as a Trustee. I am looking for any large or unusual transactions, especially large amounts of cash being paid to relatives or friends. This is important in bankruptcy proceedings because the Trustee has a duty to keep creditors updated on any legal proceedings, reviewable transactions, and preference payments. The Trustee needs to consider taking action against anyone to recover funds or, at the very least, opposing the bankrupt’s absolute discharge.

This review is only possible if the bankrupt has accurate records. In this case, if the bankrupt had the records and I reviewed them, I would have either found or not found any unusual transactions. If I did the review, it may have uncovered the alleged fraud.

The former bankrupt claims that the insolvency trustee should have sued the former wife for taking cash out of his business fraudulently. As a Trustee, I must first determine whether there are sufficient funds available to do so. If there are funds available, I must then carefully consider whether pursuing legal action is in the best interests of the estate.

This also assumes that the Trustee’s lawyer has given the opinion that this is a strong case to pursue. The Trustee must be very cautious because if the case is lost, the Trustee will be responsible for the other party’s legal costs awarded by the court. If the bankruptcy estate has insufficient funds, the Trustee will be held personally responsible. This is not a desirable outcome.

If I had found evidence of the alleged fraud and I either did not have sufficient funds to launch a legal action or I did not think it was a wise use of estate funds, there is one more thing I could do and would have done.

I would write to all known creditors and the bankrupt to advise that there is a potential asset in the form of litigation against the bankrupt’s former wife. However, the Trustee does not have sufficient assets to begin the litigation and as a result, I must refuse to pursue this asset. I would also explain section 38 of the BIA. This section allows creditors to obtain court approval to pursue legal action in their own name. If successful, they are able to keep their costs and the full amount of their claim from the recovery. This could be a great option for creditors who wish to fund the legal action.

If the facts that come out align with my explanation of the steps I would have taken, then my prediction is that the former bankrupt and his current wife will not be successful in persuading the court to allow them to continue their action against the Trustee. I will keep watch.insolvency trustee

The insolvency trustee is here to help you with your problem debt

I understand that you’re struggling with debt and I’m here to help. I am an insolvency trustee and I want to help you find a way to shed your debt, eliminate your challenging debt issues, improve your financial future and get all that stress and worry out of your life, Starting Over Starting Now.

I hope you found this insolvency trustee Brandon’s Blog interesting. Among the many problems that can arise from having too much debt, you may also find yourself in a situation where bankruptcy seems like a realistic option.

If you are dealing with substantial debt challenges and are concerned that bankruptcy may be your only option, call me. I can provide you with debt help.

You are not to blame for your current situation. You have only been taught the old ways of dealing with financial issues, which are no longer effective.

We’re passionate about permanently solving your financial problems with you and getting you or your company out of debt. We offer innovative services and alternatives, and we’ll work with you to develop a personalized preparation for becoming debt-free which does not include bankruptcy. We are committed to helping everyone obtain the relief and financial wellbeing they need and are worthy of.

You are under a lot of pressure. We understand how uncomfortable you are. We will assess your entire situation and develop a new, custom approach that is tailored to you and your specific financial and emotional problems. We will take the burden off of your shoulders and clear away the dark cloud hanging over you. We will design a debt settlement strategy for you. We know that we can help you now.

We realize that people and businesses in financial difficulty need practical advice and a workable solution in an easy-to-understand financial plan. The Ira Smith Team knows that not everyone has to file for bankruptcy in Canada. Most of our clients never do, as we are familiar with alternatives to bankruptcy. We assist many people in finding the relief they need.

Call or email us. We can tailor a new debt restructuring procedure specifically for you, based on your unique economic situation and needs. If any of this sounds familiar to you and you’re serious about finding a solution, let us know.

Call us now for a no-cost initial consultation.insolvency trustee

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

LICENSED INSOLVENCY TRUSTEE FEES: WHAT UNDENIABLE EVIDENCE IS NEEDED FOR COURT APPROVAL OF INSOLVENCY TRUSTEE FEES?

Licensed insolvency trustee fees: How is a licensed insolvency trustee paid?

Are your debts or your company’s debts and financial situation causing you so much stress that you are considering speaking to a licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a bankruptcy trustee or trustees in bankruptcy), but you are worried about the licensed insolvency trustee fees? Are you concerned about the professional fees to be paid because you think that businesses with debt problems already cannot afford to hire professionals? Your concerns are valid and relevant but you should not let that stop you from your initial inquiry. An insolvency trustee will always provide you with a no-cost initial consultation, discuss realistic options and explain the cost of each option to you.

Licensed insolvency trustee fees are set by bankruptcy laws and rules contained in the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA). They are reviewed by the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy and must be approved by the bankruptcy court. Fees are either drawn from the funds accumulated in the insolvency file from the sale of assets in the receivership or bankruptcy administration or the monthly payment funding of the restructuring proposal. If there are insufficient assets in the insolvency file, then the insolvency trustee gets its fee from a third-party retainer.

In this Brandon’s Blog, I describe how licensed insolvency trustee fees are calculated. Then, I review a recent Ontario court decision to show what kind of evidence the Trustee needs to provide the court in order for its fees to be approved.

Licensed insolvency trustee fees: Disbursements included in a streamlined personal insolvency process

Licensed insolvency trustees offer a range of services for both individuals and businesses. For individuals, there are two streamlined insolvency processes:

Licensed insolvency trustee fees in a summary administration personal bankruptcy

The summary administration personal bankruptcy process applies when the assets of the bankrupt person to be sold are expected to sell for $15,000 or less. Licensed insolvency trustee fees for a summary administration personal bankruptcy are set by a formula called a tariff.

In a summary administration bankruptcy, the fees that insolvency trustees are entitled to are calculated as follows:

  • 100 percent on the first $975 or less of receipts;
  • 35 percent on the portion of the receipts exceeding $975 but not exceeding $2,000;
  • 50% of receipts exceeding $2,000;
  • for counselling fees of $75 per session, totalling $150; and
  • an allowance for administrative disbursements of $100.

The reason the formula refers to receipts (of cash) rather than net proceeds from asset sales is that, in any personal bankruptcy, there are two types of cash receipts: 1. from the sale of assets; and 2. surplus income payments made by the bankrupt person, if any.

Licensed insolvency trustee fees: How much will it cost me to file a consumer proposal?

The calculation of the amount you need to offer your creditors in your consumer proposal has no relation to what the licensed insolvency trustee fees will be. Licensed insolvency trustee fees for a licensed trustee acting as the Administrator in the consumer proposal process is also governed by a tariff. It is calculated as follows:

  • $750 on the filing of the proposal with the official receiver;
  • $750 on the approval or deemed approval by the court;
  • 20% of moneys distributed payable on distribution; and
  • counselling fee of $75 for each counselling session for a total of $150.

In a consumer proposal, administrative disbursements are paid out of the above fee calculation.

In both summary administrations and consumer proposals where the licensed insolvency trustee fees are only the tariff, there is no need for court approval.

licensed insolvency trustee fees
licensed insolvency trustee fees

What factors influence licensed insolvency trustee fees in other administrations?

There are no streamlined provisions for any corporate insolvency administration. In addition to administering summary administration bankruptcies and consumer proposals, licensed insolvency trustees also can provide the following services:

  • business review of a company to identify its solvency and future prospects so that financial advice can be given
  • ordinary administration personal bankruptcy
  • commercial bankruptcy
  • personal Division I restructuring proposal to creditors (for consumers who cannot qualify for a consumer proposal)
  • corporate Division I restructuring proposal
  • private corporate receivership
  • court-appointed corporate receivership
  • winding-up corporate liquidation, either voluntary or court-supervised
  • corporate restructuring under the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act

In all of the above government-regulated insolvency proceedings/insolvency procedures, there are only two factors that influence the licensed insolvency trustee fees. They are:

  1. Hours spent by the level of staff working.
  2. The professional hourly rate of the staff.

Licensed insolvency trustee fees: How does an insolvency practitioner receive compensation?

In all of the non-streamlined insolvency processes, I just described, how the licensed trustee gets the fees it is charging requires approval. In private appointments, the licensed trustee needs the approval of the client. In a court appointment or administration for bankruptcy services or any other mandate under the BIA, the licensed trustee needs court approval.

What evidence do licensed insolvency trustees need to provide to prove the time that was spent doing the work? The documentation expected of a licensed trustee is the same that is expected from an insolvency lawyer or any other kind of lawyer. What is expected are detailed time dockets, so that everyone can see who spent what time, on what day on what activity.

But what if proper dockets are not kept? Well, that is exactly what the court case I want to describe to you is all about.

licensed insolvency trustee fees
licensed insolvency trustee fees

Licensed insolvency trustee fees: How do practitioners of insolvency get compensated – it takes a Final Statement of Receipts and Disbursements

I am writing this Brandon’s Blog to be informative, not to embarrass anyone. So I will not be providing the case reference of the case I am now going to describe. This is actually the second such case in Ontario that I am aware of in the last 12 months.

The case deals with a bankruptcy trustee who submitted its final statement of receipts and disbursements (SRD) to the court for approval. Contained in this final statement is amongst other things, the line item for the fee and disbursements the Trustee is seeking court approval for. The court expects to see a sworn affidavit from someone on the insolvency trustee’s staff who has knowledge of the time spent and the fee charged outlining what was done and why it was necessary. The court also expects to see detailed time dockets.

In this case, and the very similar one that came before it, the insolvency trustee’s material did not include detailed time dockets. Both Trustees applied for taxation of their SRD in an individual debtor’s Division I Proposal. In both cases, the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy issued clean letters of comment. The primary issue raised on this taxation is whether the insolvency trustee’s fees are to be approved. In the ordinary course, the debtor and the creditors have not been given notice of the taxation but it would appear that there is unlikely to be any objection.

The taxation raises the question of how the Trustee is supposed to establish its entitlement to fees when there is no time dockets kept or otherwise available to support the trustee’s claim. In this case (and the one before it), the Trustee is relying solely on the terms of the proposal. The proposal contains the methodology for calculating the fees to be taken by the Trustee in administering the proposal. The Trustee is relying on the fact that a Proposal is a contract between the debtor and its creditors, the court has already approved the Proposal and the Proposal includes the Trustee’s remuneration.

Licensed insolvency trustee fees: Bankruptcy trustees – why not keep accurate time records?

The Trustee requested fees (plus HST) based on the formula set out in the debtor’s proposal. While the Trustee provided an affidavit in support of its taxation, the Trustee did not provide any evidence of actual time spent at each staff level. The taxation came before the Associate Justice on September 1, 2021. She adjourned the taxation and requested time dockets.

The Trustee filed a report in response to the September 1, 2021 endorsement and request for time dockets, supporting the taxation and approval of the fees claimed, but no time dockets were included. In its report, the Trustee noted that it did not keep formal, detailed time records, as the terms of the Trustee’s fees and expenses are set forth in the Proposal as a “fixed fee” formula. This fee formula was accepted by creditors and approved by the Court. Therefore, the Trustee is relying upon that in not keeping time dockets.

The Trustee advised that its rationale for the development of a fixed fee formula to be charged by the Trustee, and for its decision to eliminate time docketing in such Division I proposals containing a formula for fixing a fee, were as follows:

  1. The fixed fee formula was designed by the Trustee to provide more certainty about the costs of administration for the Division I proposal. This formula also takes into account contingencies such as the time needed to negotiate the terms of the proposal and to verify the debtor’s financial information.
  2. The fixed fee formula was designed to make billing and accounting more efficient by eliminating the need to track chargeable time.
  3. The fixed fee formula was based on the consumer proposal tariff, to a certain extent.
  4. The fixed fee formula’s structure helped the Trustee keep initial costs low, so creditors could start getting dividends from the debtor’s monthly payments sooner.
  5. The fixed fee formula was designed to minimize unexpected increases in costs of administration and a resulting decrease in dividends.
  6. Not once has a creditor balked at the Trustee’s fixed fee.
  7. The court approved the proposal with the fixed fee formula, so the Trustee did not keep time dockets.
  8. There are many proposals whose administration is underway or completed that the Trustee has relied upon the fixed fee formula, and therefore has not maintained time dockets.
  9. The trustee’s fees, as claimed under the fixed fee formula, have not been objected to by the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy Canada.

    licensed insolvency trustee fees
    licensed insolvency trustee fees

Licensed insolvency trustee fees: The court’s analysis and decision

The BIA provides for the determination of a Trustee’s remuneration in section 39. The Associate Justice said that s. 39(5) of the BIA provides the jurisdiction to increase or reduce the remuneration claimed by a Trustee. Further, the court was not a “rubber stamp” obliged to approve the fees claimed by the Trustee merely because they were in the Proposal. The court noted that it is common for Trustees to request remuneration based on the time spent and hourly rates charged. The burden is on the Trustee to convince the court that the amount claimed for remuneration is warranted.

The Associate Justice listed the following principles that must be considered when it comes to taxation:

  • Trustees should be given proper compensation for their services.
  • Prevent unjustifiable payments for Trustee fees that harm the insolvent estate and its unsecured creditors.
  • The efficient and conscientious administration of an estate for the benefit of creditors and, to the extent that the public is concerned, in the interests of the proper carrying-out of the objectives of the BIA, should be encouraged.

This Associate Justice also dealt with the previous case I mentioned above, which involved the taxation of a statement of receipts and disbursements in a Division I proposal where no time dockets were kept. In that case, she held that the lack of time dockets was not fatal to the approval of fees. She said the court is in a difficult position when there is no corroborative evidence as to the time and effort spent in the administration of the proposal.

So due to the lack of evidence justifying the time spent by the various staff members of the Trustee firm at their normal hourly rates, the Associate Justice was forced to look at the entirety of the Trustee’s administration. She found issues with it and therefore concluded that the Trustee was not entitled to the full fee being requested, based on the formula contained in the Division I Proposal. The Associate Justice determined, with the benefit of hindsight as to how the Division I Proposal turned out, that the debtor could have filed a consumer proposal and the creditors would have then been better off with a higher dividend distribution.

The Associate Justice ruled that, in this case, fees and disbursements will be set on a consumer proposal tariff basis. The proposal fund totalled $31,500. Using the formula for a consumer proposal, the Trustee was therefore entitled to fee and disbursements of $7,620 (plus HST) and not the $9,973.46 fee and $14,252.01 of disbursements (plus HST) formula amount.

The Associate Justice was also very critical of the Trustee’s administration and she had strong words overall for Trustees coming to court without proper evidence of the time spent when requesting approval for fees and disbursements at taxation. Her warning was that she did not accept the Trustee’s submissions that:

  • The court’s jurisdiction over approving the SRD and the fees to be claimed by the Trustee is replaced by the approval of the creditors and the OSB. Creditor and OSB approval are not determinative when it comes to taxation, but their approval is still relevant.
  • The appropriateness of the Trustee’s fees is not considered in an application for court approval of a Division I proposal. The court is not prevented from taxing the Trustee’s fee and disbursements upon the taxation of the SRD.
  • Any benefits to having a set fee remove the court’s jurisdiction to approve the Trustee’s fees. If the Trustee decides to save time by not documenting their hours worked, they do so at their own risk. The responsibility is always on the Trustee to justify their fees.
  • Creditors who want to know how much the Trustee’s fee will be cannot override the Trustee’s responsibility to explain to the court why the fee is fair and reasonable.

The court directed the Trustee to redo its SRD on the basis decided by the court, resubmit it to the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy for its comment letter and then resubmit the entire package to the court for the taxation order.

A tough day in court to be sure.

Licensed insolvency trustee fees: Call us for debt-free solutions

I hope you found this licensed insolvency trustee fees Brandon’s Blog interesting. Among the many problems that can arise from having too much debt, you may also find yourself in a situation where bankruptcy seems like a realistic option.

If you or your business are dealing with substantial debt challenges and are concerned that bankruptcy may be your only option, call me. I can provide you with debt relief advice in setting up one of various possible debt management plans using debt relief options for you or your company.

You are not to blame for your current situation. You have only been taught the old ways of dealing with financial issues, which are no longer effective. We are debt professionals who know how to use the new innovative tools to solving debt problems while avoiding a bankruptcy filing.

We’re passionate about permanently solving your financial problems with you and getting you or your company out of debt. We offer innovative services and alternatives, and we’ll work with you to develop a personalized preparation for becoming debt-free which does not include bankruptcy. We are committed to helping everyone obtain the relief they need and are worthy of.

You are under a lot of pressure. We understand how uncomfortable you are. We will assess your entire situation and develop a new, custom approach that is tailored to you and your specific financial and emotional problems. We will take the burden off of your shoulders and clear away the dark cloud hanging over you. We will design a debt settlement strategy for you. We know that we can help you now.

We realize that people and businesses in financial difficulty need a workable solution. The Ira Smith Team knows that not everyone has to file for bankruptcy in Canada. Most of our clients never do, as we are familiar with alternatives to bankruptcy. We assist many people in finding the relief they need.

Call or email us. We can tailor a new debt restructuring procedure specifically for you, based on your unique economic situation and needs. If any of this sounds familiar to you and you’re serious about finding a solution and improving your financial future, let us know. Starting Over, Starting Now.

Call us now for a no-cost consultation to find out what your debt relief options are.

licensed insolvency trustee fees
licensed insolvency trustee fees
Call a Trustee Now!