Tag: personal bankruptcy

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

TRUSTEE BANKRUPTCIES FEES IN A SCARY CORONAVIRUS WORLD

The Ira Smith Trustee Team is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting. We hope that you and your family are safe and healthy.

If you would prefer to listen to the audio version of this trustee bankruptcies Brandon’s Blog, please scroll to the bottom and click on the podcast.

trustee bankruptcies
trustee bankruptcies

Trustee bankruptcies introduction

Are trustee bankruptcies filings high right now?

Every day we read or hear in the media about the life-threatening health challenges faced daily by Canadians. We also hear sad stories about people who have lost their job because of businesses having to close down.

The general public thinks that right now there is a lot of personal bankruptcy and corporate bankruptcy filings. In actual fact, the numbers are low. The 2 main reasons are:

  • Government support programs have helped support people and businesses. Most of the programs ended effective September 30, 2020.
  • Creditors are not chasing or harassing borrowers right now. Given that we are about 5 weeks away from Christmas, that will not change until some time in 2021.

I am receiving a lot of inquiries from people and entrepreneurs about their personal and business debt situation. I am doing a lot of initial consultations by telephone or video meeting. That tells me that there should be an increase in insolvency filings in 2021.

It may surprise you to hear that even a licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a bankruptcy trustee or trustee in bankruptcy) business could be having cash-flow problems. A recent court decision out of Ottawa highlights this issue. The purpose of this Brandon’s Blog is to discuss the court case and what it means for a trustee bankruptcies fee collection.

What are the fees of a licensed insolvency trustee?

This question is quite relevant, but the answer depends on what role the licensed insolvency trustee takes on.

A trustee in bankruptcy performs a wide variety of services, such as:

  • administrator in a consumer proposal;
  • the monitor under a Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA) corporate restructuring;
  • licensed insolvency trustee in either a summary administration or ordinary personal bankruptcy;
  • receiver over a company’s assets, either by private appointment or court appointment;
  • the licensed insolvency trustee in a corporate restructuring under the proposal provisions of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA);
  • as the licensed insolvency trustee in a corporate bankruptcy; or
  • act as a consultant in either a corporate or personal insolvency situation, advising either a creditor or the debtor.

The fee will certainly differ depending on what duty is played. Keep in mind that the costs of trustee bankruptcies are established under the BIA itself for all insolvency administrations under the BIA.

Personal bankruptcy administration where the non-exempt assets are estimated to be worth less than $15,000 is called a summary administration bankruptcy. Rule 128 of the BIA General Rules dictates the cost and disbursements in such trustee bankruptcies. This kind of fee is called a tariff. A tariff also exists in a consumer proposal file.

A bankruptcy is called an “ordinary” bankruptcy when the realizable assets are estimated at $15,000 or greater in personal bankruptcy. Every corporate bankruptcy is an ordinary administration. The BIA also regulates the trustee bankruptcies fee and disbursements.

With this information as background, I will now discuss the recent case out of the court in Ottawa.

A bankruptcy trustee needs cash flow too

The case involves a court application by an Ottawa bankruptcy trustee on 3 separate ordinary administration personal bankruptcy files. Normally, when a bankruptcy trustee wishes to get an interim draw towards its fees and disbursements in an ordinary administration, they either get the approval of the creditors at a meeting of creditors or, approval of the inspectors appointed in the bankruptcy administration.

The First Meeting of Creditors has to take place within 21 days of the date of bankruptcy. It is rare to have to call another meeting of creditors. So if the Trustee does not get approval for an interim draw at the outset from the creditors present at the First Meeting, that chance is gone quickly. If no inspectors are appointed, or a long time has passed and the Trustee has trouble finding the inspectors, getting inspector approval may also prove difficult.

But there is one more way for a Trustee to get approval to get an interim draw for its cash flow.

Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy (OSB) Directive no. 27R

The OSB publishes Directives from time to time. Trustees are bound by and obliged to follow all regulations provided by the OSB. This is so there will be consistency in the insolvency process across Canada. Directive 27R is titled “Advance of Trustee’s Remuneration for Bankruptcies Under Ordinary Administration.”. It was issued on February 10, 2010. The purpose of this Directive is to set out the correct procedure the Trustee should comply with when making an interim withdrawal or taking out an advance on remuneration for ordinary trustee bankruptcies.

To withdraw an advance on its compensation, the Trustee needs to obtain consent in the form of:

  • a resolution of a duly comprised meeting of creditors;
  • the resolution of a majority of the inspectors at a properly convened meeting of inspectors; or
  • make an application to the Court for an order approving such interim advance.

This is what this Ottawa Trustee did for 3 of its trustee bankruptcies.

trustee bankruptcies
trustee bankruptcies

The OSB did not like the court application

The OSB did not like the fact that the Trustee made this application. The OSB actually opposed the application, notwithstanding the Trustee was properly following all the requirements of Directive 27R. The Trustee brought to the court’s attention that it would still take some time to prepare its Final Statement of Receipts and Disbursements, submit it to the OSB to receive their comment letter and then apply to the court for taxation. The process would take many months.

The Trustee also highlighted for the court that these are not normal times. Due to the coronavirus pandemic, government and court staff were not working at their normal pace. The Trustee also pointed out that its own business had to lay off staff and its own cash flow was suffering. Therefore, the Trustee was making an application to the court for approval for an interim draw, as allowed. The Trustee highlighted what has gone on to date in each bankruptcy estate. The Trustee also provided proof of proper service on the OSB of this motion.

The decision does not indicate why the Trustee did not just go for inspector approval. Nevertheless, its position was that it was within its rights to make this application to the court and for the court to approve it.

The OSB’s basis for opposing this motion can be summarized as:

  • Interim draws approved by a court under Directive 27R are just to be made in special circumstances.
  • While COVID-19 is an exceptional situation, it is insufficient to call for the orders asked for by the Trustee.
  • The OSB additionally argues that the motion was not on notice to the creditors in the respective trustee bankruptcies estates concerned, who might actually object to the amount being claimed by the Trustee.
  • The OSB is worried that, if the motion is granted and the court order made, it could cause more need on the court’s time as more Trustees will seek similar orders in other trustee bankruptcies estates.
  • Finally, the OSB says that this matter is not urgent and therefore ought to not be dealt with right now. The Trustee should just go for final taxation in the normal course.

The OSB also provided two earlier court decisions where interim draws were not approved in support of its opposition.

The court sees COVID-19 creating urgencies, even for trustee bankruptcies

The court considered the OSB’s submissions and the cases it relied upon. The court distinguished those cases from the current motion for these trustee bankruptcies. Due to COVID-19, the Court found that it is not practical for the Trustee to need to wait on the receipt of the OSB Letter of Comment and then proceed to final taxation.

The court stated these are not normal times. The timelines for any of the steps involved in the final taxation process could be much longer, taking into consideration the stay-at-home orders that have been issued, even including the OSB team.

The judge stated that the court must deal with the situation as it presently exists and as it advances each day, and also make appropriate decisions as necessary. He stated that businesses in all industries have been laying workers off. This includes the insolvency industry. A lot of the businesses that are still operating are doing so with minimized staff. Those businesses are attempting to make the most out of their limited cash flow to sustain operations.

The court stated that it understands that the choice it makes on this motion might bring about an influx of cases for interim draws in trustee bankruptcies. If that becomes the case, the court will deal with it. In addition, the court recognized that, because of coronavirus, interim draws are a practical method of managing the liquidity crunch presently being experienced by Trustees. Even if there had been no coronavirus pandemic, Directive 27R still allows for such an application to the court in the trustee bankruptcies.

The Court was also conscious that accounting firms, and consequently licensed insolvency trustee businesses, have been proclaimed essential services in the Province of Ontario.

The court’s decision on the trustee bankruptices motion

As a result of all these findings, the court decided that licensed insolvency trustees must have the tools essential to maintain their operations and to permit people and companies to get access to the Canadian insolvency system. Therefore, the court held that Trustees need to be able to access the funds in their trust accounts that they have actually earned as fees, inclusive of HST.

Taking all this into account, the court exercised its discretion and ordered that the Trustee is approved to withdraw 75% of the fee that has been earned in the three trustee bankruptcies, including HST. The Trustee should then move to final taxation. There are already safeguards built into the final taxation process where creditors in each of the trustee bankruptcies estates can object to the taxation and the total fees if they wish to.

If the total final fees are approved, then the Trustee can withdraw the remaining 25%. If final taxation results in any fees less than the 75% interim draw approved in any of the trustee bankruptcies, then the Trustee will have to repay into the bankruptcy estate the specific amount(s).

The court ordered that any costs incurred on the motion was an overhead cost of the Trustee and was not recoverable from the trustee bankruptcies. Costs were neither sought nor awarded. My understanding is that the OSB is not appealing this decision.

Trustee bankruptcies summary

I hope you have enjoyed this trustee bankruptcies Brandon’s Blog. It is the first decision I am aware of that deals with the reality that like any other entrepreneur, a licensed insolvency trustee is running a business too.

Do you or your company have too much debt? Are you or your company in need of financial restructuring? The financial restructuring process is complex. The Ira Smith Team understands how to do a complex restructuring. However, more importantly, we understand the needs of the entrepreneur or the person who has too much personal debt.

You are worried because you are facing significant financial challenges. It is not your fault that you are in this situation. You have been only shown the old ways that do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team uses new modern ways to get you out of your debt troubles while avoiding bankruptcy. We can get you debt relief freedom.

The stress placed upon you is huge. We understand your pain points. We look at your entire situation and devise a strategy that is as unique as you and your problems; financial and emotional. The way we take the load off of your shoulders and devise a debt settlement plan, we know that we can help you.

We know that people facing financial problems need realistic lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” approach with the Ira Smith Team.

That is why we can develop a restructuring process as unique as the financial problems and pain you are facing. If any of this sounds familiar to you and you are serious in finding a solution, contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. team today.

Call us now for a free consultation.

We will get you or your company back on the road to healthy stress-free operations and recover from the pain points in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

The Ira Smith Trustee Team is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting. We hope that you and your family are safe and healthy.

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

BANKRUPTCY SURPLUS INCOME: OUR ESSENTIAL GUIDE 4 YOU

The Ira Smith Trustee Team is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting. We hope that you and your family are safe and healthy.

Bankruptcy surplus income introduction

I have written many blogs about personal bankruptcy and consumer proposal insolvency matters over the recent past. I notice though that it has been many years since I have written about bankruptcy surplus income. I refer to it in many of my Brandon’s Blogs but have not described it in detail in quite a while.

In order to correct that situation, here I discuss the concept and application of bankruptcy surplus income in personal bankruptcy filings.

What is bankruptcy surplus income?

Surplus income is perhaps an inadequately worded expression. Very few individuals would certainly really feel that they have surplus income, especially when dealing with financial debt. Nonetheless, in the bankruptcy context, surplus income describes a calculation that figures out just how much cash monthly an individual must be paying into their bankruptcy estate for the benefit of their creditors.

When you file for personal bankruptcy in Canada you are able to retain most of the income that you make monthly. In order to have a practical level of living during the bankruptcy period, the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy Canada (OSB) establishes a net month-to-month earnings standard.

These earnings criteria take into consideration annual inflation and are derived from information collected by Statistics Canada annually. What you pay to your licensed insolvency trustee (Trustee) into your bankruptcy estate every month is determined by these standards. They are used to decide if a bankrupt has any bankruptcy surplus income.

I have to warn you though. The practical standard of living that the OSB permits is actually the Canadian poverty line. It matters not if you reside in one of Canada’s most pricey cities or in a rural area. There are no regional modifications made. The OSB lays out the meaning and calculation in its Directive No. 11R2. Every year the OSB updates the exemption limitations.

Click on this link for the up to date bankruptcy surplus income 2020 Directive No. 11R2-2020.

What happens to a person’s wages during bankruptcy?

You are still allowed to earn money and collect your wage or salary when you apply for bankruptcy under the Bankruptcy & Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA). As a matter of fact, lots of people apply for bankruptcy because their wages, salary, or bank account are being garnisheed or frozen either by Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) or a judgment creditor. As I have written in several Brandon’s Blogs, the filing of an assignment in bankruptcy knocks out the garnishee against your wages or salary and/or the freeze on your bank account.

Now that there is no longer a garnishee, your earnings on an after-tax basis are readily available to you. The Canadian bankruptcy process, which strives for fairness, states that your after-tax income is now available for contribution to bankruptcy surplus income. To provide you a feel for the personal exemptions permitted, on an after-tax basis, as established by the OSB, here is the 2020 table the Trustee needs to work off of:

Superintendent’s Standards – 2020

bankruptcy surplus income

How it works is that you look at the table and pick first how many persons are in your household. The next column marked “S” and “N”, is the exemption that the OSB standard that it gives your family. You can then do one of two things: (1) go across the top of the table that resembles the closest your household after-tax income (the household’s, not just yours); or (2) if you know the calculation, do the exact calculation.

bankruptcy surplus income
bankruptcy surplus income

Bankruptcy surplus income limits for 2020 Canada

To have bankruptcy surplus income payable, your after-tax regular monthly earnings need to be $200 or greater than the limit established by the OSB. The exact computation is to add the bankrupt’s after-tax monthly earnings to the bankrupt spouse’s after-tax month-to-month revenue, and the same for anyone else in the family that is contributing their income for household expenditures.

Take that sum and deduct your allowed exemption. Then subtract the reasonably few unique extra exemptions, if appropriate:

  1. medical expenses;
  2. support payments
  3. child care expenses
  4. court-imposed fines or penalties
  5. expenses as a condition of employment.

After that take the bankrupt’s percent of the complete household income bankruptcy surplus income which you just computed. Split that number in half which is the month-to-month surplus income that the bankrupt must pay.

So for example, take a look at the calculation below for an imaginary family of two where both spouses work and there are no extra special deductions:

Family Situation (Family unit of two)
Bankrupt’s available monthly income $2,800
Add: Other family unit member’s available monthly income 1,000
Family unit’s available monthly income$3,800
Minus: Superintendent’s standard for a family unit of two
2,793
Total monthly surplus income$1,007
Family Situation Adjustment
(2800 ÷ 3,800 = 73.68%
$1007 × 73.68% = $741.96)		$741.96
Payment required from bankrupt
($741.95 × 50% = $370.98)
$370.98

Bankruptcy surplus income calculator

To help you better understand everything that goes into the calculation, I want to share with you a tool I use to calculate bankruptcy surplus income. I am providing you with the link to the same spreadsheet that I use to do the calculation.

Here is the link:

Bankruptcy surplus income calculator

Your income is checked by the Trustee on a month-to-month basis and is balanced out over the entire period of your bankruptcy. If you have a short-term boost in earnings, such as from a bonus or commissions, or a short-term reduction, such as a temporary layoff, this will be factored in.

When do bankruptcy surplus income payments end?

For a 1st time bankrupt, without surplus income, you are entitled to get an automatic discharge after 9 months. This requires that neither the Trustee nor a creditor has opposed your bankruptcy discharge. If you are a 1st time bankrupt yet you do have surplus income, then you need to make monthly bankruptcy surplus income payments for 21 months. You are then entitled to an automatic discharge if all your surplus income payments are made and there is no opposition to your discharge.

If you have actually been bankrupt before and this is your 2nd (or more) bankruptcy, you will not have the ability to obtain a discharge in 9 months. Your bankruptcy will certainly be lengthened. A 2nd + bankruptcy lasts for a minimum of 24 months. If you have surplus income, a second-time bankrupt will certainly not have the capacity to obtain a bankruptcy discharge for 36 months. The monthly bankruptcy surplus income payments must be made for the very same 36 months.

Can I file bankruptcy if I make too much money?

The test to file for bankruptcy is not how much money do you make. The test is:

  • are you insolvent; and
  • have you committed one or more acts of bankruptcy within the six months preceding the filing of an assignment in bankruptcy or the launching of an application for a bankruptcy order.

But if you do make a lot of money, and go into bankruptcy, then no doubt you will have a large bankruptcy surplus income obligation to pay to the Trustee every month. That large amount may not fit into your monthly budget. You may not be able to afford that monthly bankruptcy surplus income payment.

So what can you do? You should speak to a Trustee about filing either a consumer proposal or a Division I Part III proposal. Both are filed under the BIA. Why? Depending on your assets, a proposal may work better for you. Although your proposal would have to be a better alternative for your creditors than your bankruptcy, it gives you the advantage of terming out the monthly payments.

It may work out that for a little more, you can get up to 60 months to pay. So rather than having only 24 or 36 months to make your total payment, as the case may be, you could get 60 months to pay only a bit more. Obviously, the proposal is more gentle on your budget than a bankruptcy. It is also easier on your credit score and credit report.

Bankruptcy surplus income summary – Are you in financial trouble?

To declare personal bankruptcy is a major life event. However, it is a necessary thing to rid yourself of crippling debt. Most people who declare bankruptcy have been faced with a major life event. The main examples are illness, pay cuts, job loss, or divorce. It is not your fault. I hope this bankruptcy surplus income Brandon’s Blog has given you helpful information.

Do you have too much debt? Are you in need of financial restructuring? The financial restructuring process is complex. The Ira Smith Team understands how to do a complex restructuring. However, more importantly, we understand the needs of the entrepreneur or the person who has too much personal debt.

You are worried because you are facing significant financial challenges.
It is not your fault that you are in this situation. You have been only shown the old ways that do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team uses new modern ways to get you out of your debt troubles while avoiding bankruptcy. We can get you debt relief freedom.

The stress placed upon you is huge. We understand your pain points. We look at your entire situation and devise a strategy that is as unique as you and your problems; financial and emotional. The way we take the load off of your shoulders and devise a debt settlement plan, we know that we can help you.

We know that people facing financial problems need realistic lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” approach with the Ira Smith Team. That is why we can develop a restructuring process as unique as the financial problems and pain you are facing. If any of this sounds familiar to you and you are serious about finding a solution, contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. team today.
Call us now for a free consultation.

We will get you or your company back on the road to healthy stress-free operations and recover from the pain points in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

The Ira Smith Trustee Team is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting. We hope that you and your family are safe and healthy.

bankruptcy surplus income canada

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

DECLARE BANKRUPTCY: A COMPLETE GUIDE ON WHAT IS IT LIKE TO DECLARE BANKRUPTCY

The Ira Smith Trustee Team is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting. We hope that you and your family are safe and healthy.

What is it like to declare bankruptcy?

What is it like to declare bankruptcy? It is a scary life event, but filing bankruptcy is not as bad or terrifying as the majority of people think. Actually, you have already been through the worst of it before you declare bankruptcy.

If it’s the right option for you, it will get rid of the tension, stress, and anxiety from your life that you have been lugging with you for a very long time. It does not require that much of your time. You will usually have 3 to 4 visits with the licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a bankruptcy trustee) (Trustee). If all works out, you will never ever see the inside of the bankruptcy court and all your debt will be removed.

The purpose of this Brandon’s Blog is to describe what it is like to declare bankruptcy and what the bankruptcy process is all about.

When to declare bankruptcy

Bankruptcy law exists to help people who have handled an unmanageable amount of debt. Most of the time, it is a result of unforeseen expenses or other unexpected life events that are no fault of the person. Two main examples of such life events are job loss and illness.

Before deciding to declare bankruptcy, make sure to explore all your alternatives, and weigh the benefits and negative aspects of each reasonable option. Part of the no-cost examination we give everyone is doing precisely that; going through the alternatives, taking into consideration the pluses and minuses of each, and making our ideal professional recommendation to every person’s unique scenario.

If you determine that bankruptcy is your only viable alternative as lots of other Canadians do each year remember that the blot on your credit score will not be forever. By using credit properly in the future and paying your debts on time, you can begin to reconstruct your credit rating and put bankruptcy behind you.

To declare bankruptcy, either a bankruptcy restructuring or bankruptcy liquidation likewise assists companies that have unrestrained debt levels. We also offer solutions to companies and businesses searching for debt settlement help.

declare bankruptcy
declare bankruptcy

What are the consequences for a person to declare bankruptcy?

Everyone assumes that if you declare bankruptcy, it takes a massive emotional toll on you. Our experience in working with people we help is the exact opposite. Their financial debts, the fear of not having the ability to pay it off along with the anxiety of the unknown is what is devastating to everyone.

Once people declare bankruptcy, they tell us that the automatic stay of proceedings and the involvement of the Trustee stopping creditors’ collection calls are great benefits. Individuals that file for bankruptcy have already looked over the cliff and feared the worst. When they figure out that their worst worries never happen, and they currently have peace and quiet from collection phone calls, they feel like a weight has been taken off of them. As we tell people, your creditors will certainly now bother the Trustee, not you!

Your bankruptcy is a matter of public record. The Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy (OSB) maintains a public database. The Trustee alerts your creditors, Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) as well as the OSB of your filing. People can look up any name they wish for $8 per search. Although it is public, very few people spend money to browse the OSB database. It is mainly for Equifax and TransUnion to place on your credit history report. It is also for the federal government to keep data concerning people and companies that declare bankruptcy in Canada. There are no billboards or flashing neon lights with your name on it for all the world to see.

The most effective repercussion when you declare bankruptcy is that you have the chance to release either all or most of your financial debts and start life once again hassle-free.

How do I declare bankruptcy?

Anybody who is insolvent and owes more than $1,000 qualifies for personal bankruptcy or also known as a consumer bankruptcy filing in Canada. If you are having a problem meeting your financial responsibilities or have actually stopped satisfying them, you remain in financial trouble.

The primary step is to get in touch with a federally licensed Trustee asap to discuss your options. The Trustee will certainly initially collect info from you regarding your assets, liabilities, your household income, and expenses. This allows the Trustee to get a very good understanding of your one-of-a-kind situation.

You and the Trustee will then review your choices. Bankruptcy is just one of the feasible range of options. There are numerous bankruptcy alternatives which include, however, are not restricted to, debt consolidation and consumer proposals.

The Trustee will use the information you gave to prepare the bankruptcy forms. When you declare bankruptcy, of the various bankruptcy files the Trustee prepares, you are signing, and the Trustee is filing what is called an assignment in bankruptcy.

What should I do before I declare bankruptcy?

Many people think there are several things they should do before they declare bankruptcy. Common questions include:

  • Should I transfer my interest in the matrimonial home to my spouse?
  • When should I transfer the cash in my bank account to my spouse’s bank account?
  • Should I stop working or not look for work so that I will not have to make any surplus income payments?

The reality is that by the time you are contemplating bankruptcy, it is too late. The time to do your valid creditor proofing is not when you are insolvent, but when you are solvent! When you are not experiencing any financial problems.

Transferring assets most likely will be successfully attacked by the Trustee. That means that the Trustee will go after the person you have transferred assets to for no or little value. You will not only have protected assets, but you will also have caused your loved one to incur legal costs and have to cough up the assets.

Declaring bankruptcy is an emotional as well as a scary thing. There is only one thing you should do before you declare bankruptcy. You must meet with a Trustee for a no-cost initial consultation and be honest with them. Make full disclosure so that the Trustee can provide you with your realistic options. The Trustee will also fully explain to you what the process will look like and what might happen to you if you declare bankruptcy.

When is bankruptcy a good idea? The answer depends on your situation

Bankruptcy is not naturally negative or excellent, but it is vital for the honest but unfortunate debtor who finds themselves in big trouble with financial debt. Bankruptcy is actually for honest people that have come upon tough times. They need to look to bankruptcy due to the fact that they can’t see a way out. Even the Bible calls for debt mercy at the end of every 7 years (Deuteronomy 15:1).

If you find yourself in a hard financial situation and cannot see a way out, meet with a Trustee. Do not let fears or stereotypes stand in the way of getting the relief and your household need. To declare bankruptcy must be considered as taking a positive step in helping you and your family begin again on the right track.

declare bankruptcy
declare bankruptcy

Is filing bankruptcy bad? Can it be good?

You’ll listen to a great many people effectively say: “bankruptcy is bad”. Yet why? Why is the general consensus that filing for bankruptcy is a negative thing? While it is true that when you declare bankruptcy or a consumer proposal it is evidence of difficulty with your finances, that’s not the whole story.

A large part of the reason that people state bankruptcy is bad is that they do not understand the procedure. No two bankruptcy instances are alike. People are forced into bankruptcy for a whole host of different factors, most of which are outside their control and for that reason, not their fault.

What Happens to a company when it goes to declare bankruptcy?

The BIA regulates exactly how companies can liquidate or restructure and recover from crippling debt. An insolvent company may make use of Part III Division I of the BIA to reorganize its business and try to end up being profitable again. Management remains in place to run the daily activities of the company. Any significant change in the business organization should need to be approved by the Trustee, the bankruptcy court, or both.

Under a pure liquidation bankruptcy filing, the company stops operations and goes completely dark. The Trustee is assigned to sell the firm’s possessions and the money is used to pay for the bankruptcy administration and to make a distribution to creditors. The priority of payouts is governed by the BIA.

Trust claimants and secured creditors are paid first. For instance, secured creditors take less risk due to the fact that the money that they lend is backed by the firm’s assets. If the lender is concerned that the assets may not at any time be enough to fully cover the loan, it will also require additional backup by way of the personal guarantee of the entrepreneur. That personal guarantee can be either an unsecured promise or additional collateral by the entrepreneur pledging personal assets. They do this to limit their risk of loss if the company declares bankruptcy.

Bondholders have a better potential for recovery than shareholders because bonds are a financial debt of the business. The company promises to pay interest on the money it takes in through the sale of bonds. The company also promises to repay the principal according to the terms of the bond issuance.

Shareholders own the company and also take a higher risk. They might make more if the company does well, yet they could lose money if the company is not successful. The shareholders are last in line to be repaid if the company stops working. Bankruptcy laws establish the order of payment.

If I declare bankruptcy, what happens with the CRA garnishee?

If you declare bankruptcy or file a consumer proposal, personal income tax debt is one type of debt in the category of ordinary unsecured debts. When you’ve filed for bankruptcy or a consumer proposal, CRA can’t take any kind of further collection activity against you. This includes wage garnishment or freezing your bank account. Your Trustee will certainly alert CRA once you declare bankruptcy. The Trustee will also advise CRA to quit any type of collection activity against you.

What is it like to declare bankruptcy summary?

To declare personal bankruptcy is a major life event. However, it is a necessary thing to rid yourself of crippling debt. Most people who declare bankruptcy have been faced with a major life event. The main examples are illness, pay cuts, job loss, or divorce. It is not your fault. I hope this Brandon’s Blog has given you helpful information.

Do you have too much debt? Are you in need of financial restructuring? The financial restructuring process is complex. The Ira Smith Team understands how to do a complex restructuring. However, more importantly, we understand the needs of the entrepreneur or the person who has too much personal debt.

You are worried because you are facing significant financial challenges.
It is not your fault that you are in this situation. You have been only shown the old ways that do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team uses new modern ways to get you out of your debt troubles while avoiding bankruptcy. We can get you debt relief freedom from one of the alternatives to bankruptcy.

The stress placed upon you is huge. We understand your pain points. We look at your entire situation and devise a strategy that is as unique as you and your problems; financial and emotional. The way we take the load off of your shoulders and devise a debt settlement plan, we know that we can help you.

We know that people facing financial problems need realistic lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” approach with the Ira Smith Team. That is why we can develop a restructuring process as unique as the financial problems and pain you are facing. If any of this sounds familiar to you and you are serious in finding a solution, contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. team today.
Call us now for a free consultation.

We will get you or your company back on the road to healthy stress-free operations and recover from the pain points in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

The Ira Smith Trustee Team is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting. We hope that you and your family are safe and healthy.

declare bankruptcy
declare bankruptcy
Categories
Brandon Blog Post

CREDITORS: ALARM BELLS RING WHEN FINANCIAL RESTRUCTURING HEADS SOUTH

Introduction

The purpose of this Brandon’s Blog is to describe the final type of bankruptcy in Canada. I will describe it from the viewpoint of creditors. Previously I’ve blogged about the three types of bankruptcies in Canada. I also wrote about the personal bankruptcy process and the corporate bankruptcy process in Canada.

Personal bankruptcy and corporate bankruptcy in Canada

From the first two, the personal bankruptcy process and the corporate bankruptcy process, that was from the perspective of a person or company filing an assignment in bankruptcy. I also wrote about a person or company being pushed into bankruptcy by one or more creditors through a bankruptcy application and a bankruptcy order.

Today’s blog is to talk about the third type of bankruptcy and that is a deemed assignment in bankruptcy. The deemed assignment is most commonly associated with when a financial restructuring under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA) heads south.

Creditors and a deemed assignment in bankruptcy

In Canada, very large corporate restructurings are done under the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act. A person or a company of any size can also restructure under the BIA. This blog is about restructuring under the BIA to illustrate the third way a person or company can go bankrupt through a deemed assignment in bankruptcy.

The reason people or companies would file for a financial restructuring is to get a time out from its creditors taking action against them trying to collect on debts. People who owe more than $250,000 and companies who have too much debt qualify to restructure under the financial restructuring debt settlement provisions of the BIA. A restructuring filing gives them the needed time out to formulate a plan for settling the debt.

If a person owes $250,000 or less, then there is a different restructuring provision of the BIA available. That provision is the consumer proposal restructuring debt settlement section. If a consumer proposal restructuring attempt fails, that ultimately does not end up in being a deemed assignment in bankruptcy.

The deemed assignment in bankruptcy, the third type of bankruptcy in Canada, is really the topic of this blog.

Financial restructuring under the BIA

So the BIA has a financial restructuring section. The debtor needing a timeout can either file their restructuring proposal straight away or first buy some extra time by filing a notice of intention to make a proposal. If a debtor first files a notice of intention to make a proposal, within 10 days after that, they need to file a cash flow statement in the prescribed form plus related extra documents (unless the time period is extended by the court). The restructuring proposal must be filed within 30 days after the filing of the notice of intention to make a proposal.

When a debtor files the actual restructuring proposal a cash flow statement has to be filed with it as well. It will be an original one if the debtor goes straight away to the filing of the proposal or an updated one if they first filed the notice of intention to make a proposal.

Meeting of creditors to consider the proposal

Once filed the Licensed Insolvency Trustee (formerly called a bankruptcy trustee) (Trustee) must notify the creditors of the filing of a notice of intention to make a proposal and the restructuring proposal. The Trustee must call a meeting of creditors within 21 days of the filing of the restructuring proposal.

The creditors get to vote to approve or not approve the restructuring proposal creditor acceptances by voting and must be in the requisite majority calculated as a simple majority in number and at least 2/3 of the dollar value of all claims voting either in person at the meeting or by proxy and voting letter delivered to the trustee prior to the start of the meeting.

The need for Court approval

After creditors accept the Proposal, the Trustee must get the restructuring proposal approved by the court. For the court approval process, the court considers if:

  • the restructuring proposal, are the terms of the restructuring proposal fair and calculated to benefit the general body of creditors?
  • Did the Trustee properly follow all required procedural steps including properly holding and counting the voting by the creditors?

As long as the answers to these questions are yes and the restructuring proposal took the interests of all stakeholders into account, then the court will approve the restructuring proposal. Then the company or the person must successfully complete it including making all payments required under the restructuring proposal.

How can a restructuring proposal fail or head south?

A financial restructuring plan under the BIA can fail if:

  • the person or company fails to file the required cash flow statement and related documentation within the 10 day period after the filing of the notice of intention to make a proposal or the debtor;
  • fails to file a financial restructuring proposal within the 30-day time limit after the filing of the notice of intention to make a proposal or such greater time period authorized by the court;
  • the requisite majority of creditors voting do not accept the restructuring proposal;
  • the court does not approve the restructuring proposal; or
  • the restructuring proposal is accepted by the creditors and approved by the Court but the debtor fails to make the payments and do any other things contained in the restructuring proposal.

When the debtor is automatically bankrupt when there is an event of default in the Proposal

Under the following situations, the person or company will be deemed to have filed an assignment in bankruptcy if the person or company:

  • fails to file the required cash flow statement;
  • the debtor fails to file the financial restructuring proposal on time;
  • the requisite majority of creditors voting do not accept the restructuring proposal; or
  • the court does not approve the restructuring proposal

Under any of these conditions, the person or the company is automatically deemed to have filed an assignment in bankruptcy. You can go back and review my earlier blogs for the personal bankruptcy process and for what the corporate bankruptcy process is all about.

You can do the same thing when the restructuring proposals are accepted by the creditors and approved by the court but the debtor fails to make payments or do any of the other things contained in the restructuring proposal.

A Proposal default that does not automatically mean bankruptcy

Unlike the other events of default, when the debtor fails to make a payment under the Proposal, there is not an automatically deemed assignment in bankruptcy. Rather the Trustee has to give notice to the debtor and if there are any the inspectors in the restructuring to them also. The person or company attempting to restructure then has 30 days to remedy the default. If they do not remedy the default after the 30 day period then the Trustee has to issue a notice of default which is sent to the debtor, the creditors, and to the Superintendent of Bankruptcy.

After giving notice of default, the Trustee does not have to do anything else. Any one of the creditors can then bring a court motion to annul the restructuring proposal. If the Trustee has the funding to do so and is directed by the inspectors, the Trustee can also bring that motion.

If the motion is brought and is successful then and only then is the person or company deemed to have filed an assignment in bankruptcy.

But if nobody brings the motion the company or person actually just floats out there and the Trustee is entitled to go for taxation of its receipts and disbursements, make whatever distribution it can with the funds on hand and then go get its discharge.

Three types of bankruptcy in Canada

So to recap, the three types of bankruptcies in Canada are:

  • filing an assignment of bankruptcy;
  • a bankruptcy application and the issuance of a bankruptcy order; and
  • as explained in this blog, a deemed assignment in bankruptcy.

I hope you enjoyed this blog on creditors, a financial restructuring proposal and the process for a deemed assignment in bankruptcy. The IraSmith team is available to help you at any time. We offer sound advice and a solid plan for Starting Over Starting Now so that you’ll be well on your way to a debt-free life in no time.

Do you have too much debt? Are you banking on some outside event that you have no control over, like an inheritance or gambling winnings to save you or your company?

If yes, then you need immediate help. The Ira Smith Team comprehends just how to do a debt restructuring. Much more notably, we know the demands of the business owner or the person who has too much debt. Due to the fact that you are managing these stressful financial problems, you are anxious.

It is not your fault you cannot fix this issue on your own. You have just been shown the old ways. The old ways do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team makes use of new contemporary ways to get you out of your debt troubles while avoiding bankruptcy. We can get you debt relief now.

At Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc., we take a look at your whole condition and layout a strategy that is as unique as you are. We take the load off of your shoulders as a part of the debt negotiation approach we will create just for you.

We understand that individuals facing financial troubles require a lifeline. That is why we can establish a restructuring procedure for you as well as end the pain you feel.

Call us now for a no-cost consultation. We will certainly get you or your business back on the road to a well balanced and healthy life and end the pain factors in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

creditors

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

3 TYPES OF BANKRUPTCIES: DO WE REALLY NEED IT?

3 Types of bankruptcies introduction

Two weeks ago I described the personal bankruptcy process Canada. Last week I described the Canadian corporate bankruptcy process. This week I want to start talking about the 3 types of bankruptcies in Canada.

3 types of bankruptcies: Voluntary and involuntary bankruptcy

In the last two weeks, I talked about both the personal and corporate bankruptcy processes. The way I described the bankruptcies it was all about the voluntary process of entering bankruptcy by filing an assignment in bankruptcy. That’s the 1st type of bankruptcy out of the 3 types of bankruptcies.

The second type which I will be speaking about today is the involuntary process of being pushed into bankruptcy. So how does one get placed into bankruptcy on an involuntary basis? It’s by a bankruptcy application.

3 types of bankruptcies: The bankruptcy application – the involuntary method

In order to file a bankruptcy application, one or more creditors must file the application to place the debtor, corporate or personal into bankruptcy. The creditor or group of creditors

must have unsecured debt of at least $1000 and the debtor must have committed at least 1 act of bankruptcy in the six months preceding the date of the bankruptcy application the acts of bankruptcy are laid out in the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada).

3 types of bankruptcies: Acts of bankruptcy

So what are they? A debtor commits an act of bankruptcy in each of the following cases:

  • If in Canada or elsewhere the debtor makes an assignment of its property to a trustee for the benefit of its creditors.
  • A debtor makes a fraudulent gift delivery or transfer of all or part of its property.
  • The debtor makes any transfer of its property or any part of it that creates a charge on it that would be void as against a trustee and bankruptcy.
  • If with the intent to defeat or delay creditors the debtor departs out of Canada and absence itself.
  • If the debtor permits any execution or another process to be levied against it where it’s property is seized in order to be sold and the debtor does not redeem its property.
  • If the debtor exhibits to any meeting of creditors a statement of assets and liabilities that shows the debtor is insolvent if the debtor removes disposes of property or attempts to do so intending to defraud defeat or delay creditors.
  • If the debtor gives notice to any creditor that payments are being suspended or if the debtor ceases to meet its liabilities generally as they become do a bankruptcy application must be accompanied by an affidavit attesting to the debt and the alleged acts of bankruptcy3 types of bankruptcies

3 types of bankruptcies: What a bankruptcy application must look like

The affidavit must be deposed by a creditor or a representative of a creditor especially a corporate creditor and that representative must have personal knowledge of the facts. The bankruptcy application must be filed with the court having jurisdiction based on the location of the debtor. A bankruptcy application cannot be withdrawn without the permission of the court.

If there is a concern that the debtor’s assets might dissipate between the date of filing the bankruptcy application and the date of the court hearing the application the court can appoint the proposed licensed insolvency trustee to preserve and protect the assets but not too otherwise interfere in the running of the debtor’s business.

A notice of the time and place of the court hearing and all the motion material being used by the creditor or group of creditors must be served on the debtor.

3 types of bankruptcies: The bankruptcy order

A bankruptcy order could be issued 10 days after the service on the debtor of the bankruptcy application if it is not opposed or otherwise defended by the debtor. If it is defended then there will have to be a trial for the court to determine if a bankruptcy order should be issued and whatever the court decides. It is, of course, subject to the parties’ rights of appeal.

The debtor is bankrupt once the bankruptcy order is issued. The bankruptcy order puts on hold the enforcement rights of the creditors except for secured creditors holding valid security as soon as a bankruptcy order has been made the debtor’s property vests in the bankruptcy trustee and the bankruptcy administration begins.

To refresh yourself about personal bankruptcy administration check out my blog from two weeks ago. For a review again of the administration of a corporate bankruptcy check out my blog from last week.

Now the title of this blog is three types of bankruptcy. In the last two weeks, I have described voluntary bankruptcy for both an individual and a corporation by the filing of an assignment of bankruptcy. This week I talked about the involuntary bankruptcy process of the bankruptcy application for a bankruptcy order.

Next week I will discuss the third out of the 3 types of bankruptcies in Canada.

3 types of bankruptcies summary

I hope you enjoyed this 3 types of bankruptcies blog. The Ira Smith team is available to help you at any time.

We offer sound advice and a solid plan for Starting Over Starting Now so that you’ll be well on your way to a debt-free life in no time. For more information on a no-cost basis please visit our website or call us.

Do you or your company have excessive debt and looking for debt restructuring? Would not it be great if you could do a turn-around?

The Ira Smith Team understands how to do a debt restructuring. More notably, we comprehend the requirements of the business owner or the person who has too much individual debt. Because you are dealing with these stressful financial issues, you are anxious.

It is not your fault you can’t fix this problem on your own. You have only been taught the old ways. The old ways do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team makes use of new contemporary ways to get you out of your debt problems while avoiding bankruptcy. We can get you debt relief now.

We look at your whole circumstance and design a strategy that is as distinct as you are. We take the load off of your shoulders as part of the debt settlement strategy we will draft just for you.

We understand that people facing money problems require a lifeline. That is why we can establish a restructuring procedure for you and end the discomfort you feel.

Call us now for a no-cost consultation. We will get you or your business back on the roadway to healthy and balanced worry-free operations and end the pain points in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.3 types of bankruptcies

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

BANKRUPTCY IN CANADA: THE STEP-BY-STEP CANADIAN PERSONAL BANKRUPTCY PROCESS

Introduction

The purpose of this Brandon’s Blog is to explain to you the personal bankruptcy in Canada process. By doing so I hope it will be a less scary topic for you.

Are you insolvent?

The first step is meeting with the trustee to explore options. The first thing the licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a bankruptcy trustee) (Trustee) needs to determine is if the person is insolvent.

Insolvent means that you cannot pay your debts as they come due and that if you liquidated all of your assets it would not be enough to repay all of your liabilities. If you’re not insolvent then you cannot take advantage of the provisions of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada).

What are my options?

If you’re not insolvent the options that are available to you are:

  • help with your budgeting;
  • perhaps credit counselling mixed in with that to help you better understand your income and expenses; and
  • how to live within your means

Perhaps also there is the opportunity, if you still have a good enough credit score, to get a debt consolidation loan. This would be a loan that would be equal to the total of all your other debts but at a lower interest rate and with a smaller monthly payment than the total monthly payments you currently need to make to stay current with all your debts.

If you are insolvent then the options available to a person is either a:

bankruptcy in canada
bankruptcy in canada

The purpose and topic in this blog are bankruptcy so that is what I will focus on. There will be other videos made on the topics of a consumer proposal, budgeting, credit counselling and debt consolidation.

How does bankruptcy in Canada work?

So the personal bankruptcy in Canada process as I mentioned starts with meeting the Trustee to explore your options. Then with the Trustee, determining whether or not you are insolvent and then making the right choice. Does that mean that bankruptcy is the best process for your needs, or can you avoid bankruptcy?.

So given that we’re talking about bankruptcy in Canada, what are the steps? First, the Trustee will prepare the documentation for your review. The documentation consists mainly of the assignment in bankruptcy document, your statement of affairs and your monthly family budget.

The statement of affairs is a multi-page document that indicates what your assets are and the names and addresses and individual amounts owing to each of your creditors. Your monthly family budget shows your monthly cash in and cash out.

An important part of the bankruptcy in Canada process is rehabilitation. Financial rehabilitation. So it is expected upon entering personal bankruptcy in Canada that your monthly family budget will balance. That is your income after tax will be sufficient to pay your monthly family expenses.

What does declaring bankruptcy mean in Canada?

Once that is all prepared and you’ve sworn your statement of affairs the Trustee can begin the bankruptcy process itself. That includes e-Filing the documentation I just spoke about with the Superintendent of Bankruptcy’s local office.

The Superintendent of Bankruptcy local office representative will review it to make sure that it is all in order. Then the local office will issue a certificate confirming your bankruptcy and the appointment of the Trustee.

It is at the time when the Superintendent actually issues the certificate that the person’s bankruptcy starts.

So when bankruptcy occurs then certain things must happen. The bankruptcy administration takes place. The bankruptcy administration will include:

  • Providing the trustee with any non-exempt assets that you may own. The Trustee will sell those assets to raise money to be able to make a distribution of some sort to your creditors.
  • The next part of the bankruptcy administration is that the bankrupt person must attend 2 counselling sessions for personal bankruptcy in Canada. These two counselling sessions are meant to help the person financially rehabilitate themselves.

You will discuss with the Trustee things such as budgeting, issues that led you into bankruptcy and how you can correct that behaviour and any problems you might be experiencing during the bankruptcy process.

  • Finally, if all goes well there is the bankruptcy discharge. That is where the person has made it through and upon their discharge, they are discharged of all of their debts other than those that might be secured, have a trust claim status or meet the definition of those few types of debts such as court fines and penalties that cannot be discharged by way of bankruptcy.

But things like credit card debt and income tax debt are discharged through the bankruptcy process.

Personal bankruptcy Canada

So if you have debt issues meet with a Trustee. There is no charge to do so and you will walk away with a better idea of how to fix your debt issues with or without resorting to personal bankruptcy in Canada.

I hope you enjoyed the bankruptcy in Canada video. The Ira Smith team is available to help you at any time. We offer sound advice and a solid plan for Starting Over Starting Now.

We understand your pain. We will make sure that no bill collectors call you. We will take all the headaches and stress you are experiencing off of your hands and put it onto our shoulders. We will fix things so that you can move forward in a healthy way, pain-free, guilt-free and debt-free.

It is not your fault that you are in this situation. You could not fix it yourself because you have only been taught the old ways. The old ways do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team uses new ways that will return you immediately to a stress-free life while getting rid of your debt.

So that you can immediately be well on your way to debt and stress-free life in no time, for more information on a no-cost basis, please call us now.

The Ira Smith Team comprehends just how to do a complex restructuring. However, more notably, we understand the needs of the business owner or the person that has too much personal financial debt. You are worried due to the fact that you are encountering significant economic obstacles.

It is not your mistake that you are in this scenario. You have been only shown the old ways which do not function anymore. The Ira Smith Team utilizes new contemporary ways to take you out of your financial debt problems while preventing bankruptcy. We can get you financial debt relief.

The stress and anxiety placed upon you is massive. We comprehend your discomfort factors. We look at your entire situation and also devise a technique that is as special as you and also your issues; economic as well as emotional. The methods we use takes tons off of your shoulders. We devise a financial debt negotiation strategy, we understand that we can help you.

We understand that individuals encountering monetary troubles need a reasonable lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” method with the Ira Smith Team. That is why we can create a restructuring process as unique as the financial problems and also discomfort you are encountering. If any one of these seems familiar to you and you are serious about getting a solution, contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. team today.

Call us now for a no-cost appointment. We will certainly get you or your firm back driving to healthy stress-free operations as well as save you from the discomfort factors in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

bankruptcy in canada
bankruptcy in canada
Categories
Brandon Blog Post

HOW TO FILE FOR BANKRUPTCY IN CANADA: PERSONAL BANKRUPTCY MODUS OPERANDI

how to file for bankruptcy in canada

If you would prefer to listen to the audio version of this how to file for bankruptcy in Canada Brandon’s Blog, please scroll to the bottom and click on the podcast below

Introduction

I am most often asked by people how to file for bankruptcy in Canada. When I receive that question, I tell people that there are a few steps that need taking before the actual filing. These steps are the process I use to make sure that the person can actually benefit from personal bankruptcy. I don’t just put someone into bankruptcy and hope that it will work out alright for them. I have to make sure upfront that there is a benefit for them. It has to make sense.

Getting over the initial fear

It takes a lot for a person to overcome that initial fear and reach out to phone me. They are admitting that they have financial problems. I understand the fear a person has. My role in that first phone call or meeting, for which there is no charge, is to help the person get over their fears. I answer the most important questions the person wants to be answered. I also need to remind them that the answers are by necessity, generic. Once I have their specific information, then I can answer their questions in a way that is specific to their situation.

How do I apply for bankruptcy in Canada?

The first step in the application process is providing me with detailed information about your specific situation. We get this information by having you complete our initial assessment intake sheet. We call ours the Debt Relief Worksheet.

The Debt Relief Worksheet collects the information we need to do a proper initial assessment. The information collected includes:

  1. Basic details such as name, address and marital status.
  2. A listing of all your assets and your debts.
  3. Your employment.
  4. Your household monthly cash flow/budget.
  5. Questions whose answers are important to understanding who you are.

You can click here to see a copy of our Debt Relief Worksheet.

The free assessment

Once I have a fully completed Debt Relief Worksheet, I can then analyze the information and provide you with an assessment designed specifically for you. Normally, when you first submit the information to me, I will have to follow up on questions for you to answer. This is all normal.

Once I have the full picture, I can properly assess what bankruptcy will mean for you. This will lead us to a discussion of alternatives to avoid bankruptcy that is right for you. It may be that you have a specific issue that can be dealt with outside of bankruptcy. Once resolved, the rest of your situation is manageable without resorting to a filing under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, RSC 1985, c B-3 (BIA).

The next possibility is you can’t fix things on your own, but you still do not need a licensed insolvency trustee (formerly known as a trustee in bankruptcy) (Trustee) to do a BIA filing on you. Perhaps with credit counselling, you can get your budget under control and pay down your debts.

If the right answer is that you do not need to file under the BIA, I will tell you so and connect you with the proper help that you need. The cost for me to review your situation and provide you with the right alternatives available to you is zero. It will not cost you anything.

Consumer proposal vs bankruptcy

If you do need a formal insolvency filing, we have to figure out which one. We are still looking at if you can avoid bankruptcy. We do this by looking at your whole situation. We first look at what bankruptcy means to you. What would the outcome of your bankruptcy be?

Some of the factors we consider are:

  1. Your assets that would not be exempt and therefore would be handed over to us as your Trustee.
  2. Have you ever been bankrupt before?
  3. Are your debts $250,000 or higher, not including any mortgages or other loans secured by your principal residence?
  4. Do you owe $200,000 or more to Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) for unpaid income tax?
  5. Are all your tax filings up to date?
  6. Your income and do you have a surplus income?
  7. If you do have surplus income, what would your monthly payment be and can you afford it in your budget?
  8. Based on the information you gave us, can we determine the likelihood of any creditor opposing your discharge from bankruptcy?
  9. Any other special circumstances you have told us about.

The answers to these questions help us determine if you need to file for bankruptcy or not. In many cases, I help people avoid bankruptcy by filing a consumer proposal. As I have written before, in many cases, it is possible to avoid bankruptcy.

By filing a viable consumer proposal debt settlement plan, you are offering to pay your creditors a fraction of what you owe. You are promising to make monthly payments for a time period not greater than 60 months. A successfully completed consumer proposal will release you from your debts that exist at the time of your filing.

Those that are eligible to file a consumer proposal choose this option. They are happy to avoid bankruptcy. Our assessment and the advice we give you on consumer proposal vs bankruptcy is still free.

How to file for bankruptcy in Canada

If we decide that bankruptcy is necessary, we will then prepare the required documents. These documents include your sworn Statement of Affairs and your monthly cash flow budget. The Statement of Affairs is a document that:

  1. Identifies you.
  2. Lists your assets with their respective estimated realizable value.
  3. Indicates which assets are exempt from seizure, if any.
  4. Lists your creditors by name and amount owing.

Part of the filing process is that the insolvent person swears that the document is accurate. This is done in our office as our Trustees are also commissioners for taking oaths for the work we do. All of this is done in my office.

I then electronically file the sworn Statement of Affairs and other required documents with the Superintendent of Bankruptcy. Once the Official Receiver, who is the Superintendent of Bankruptcy’s local official, reviews and accepts the filing, the insolvent person is officially bankrupt.

This is how a person files for bankruptcy in Canada.

What happens if I declare bankruptcy in Canada?

Once you declare bankruptcy (or file a consumer proposal), all collection and enforcement action against you stops. Creditors can no longer sue you or harass you trying to collect the outstanding debts. You are now protected by the stay of proceedings.

Then the Trustee needs to take possession of your assets that are not exempt from seizure under provincial law. Before you file, I always tell you what those assets are and what will happen.

If you declare bankruptcy (or file a consumer proposal), you will have to attend two counselling sessions. Those sessions are conducted in my office by the Trustee who is also a qualified credit counsellor.

If you have met all of your duties and responsibilities in your bankruptcy, including the payment of surplus income if required, you are then entitled to a discharge from bankruptcy. If no creditor or the Trustee objects to your discharge, then you receive an absolute discharge. If there is something in your activities or your background where there is an objection to your discharge, then the matter must be heard in the bankruptcy court.

Before you file, I will give you my best-educated guess on the likelihood of an objection to your discharge arising.

Will I lose my house if I file bankruptcy in Canada?

If you declare bankruptcy, there are various ways and conditions in bankruptcy that you will NOT lose your house.

Everybody who owns a house and also experiences financial issues is worried about losing their house. Losing your home is possibly among the most terrible concerns people with a huge debt load that is crushing them have. This is exactly how it functions if you file for personal bankruptcy in Ontario.

In Ontario, the provincial regulation that describes what is excluded from seizure is called the Execution Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. E.24. For a full checklist of all bankruptcy Ontario exemptions, please review my Brandon’s Blog, BANKRUPTCY IN ONTARIO CANADA SECRETS EXPOSED.

The exemption in Ontario for your house is $10,000 of equity. The present thinking is that if your equity is $10,000 or less, if you go bankrupt, then your entire equity is excluded from seizure by the Trustee. Nonetheless, if your equity is $10,001 or greater, your whole equity in your home is NOT exempt and also is readily available to your Trustee for the benefit of your creditors.

Keep in mind that we are talking about your equity. In determining your equity, we first have to determine the market value of the house. We then deduct any mortgages or other loans registered against the property. The net result of this calculation represents your equity. If you own the home jointly with your spouse, then it is half of that number that is your equity. The other half belongs to your spouse.

If someone is available and willing to purchase your equity from the Trustee for its value, then the Trustee will collect that money. Once the Trustee sells its interest in the equity of your home, the Trustee no longer has an interest. If the person purchasing your equity is your spouse, another relative or friend, they are doing it so that you will not have to leave your home.

If that happens, then you will not lose your house if you file for bankruptcy. If you have no equity because the loans registered against your home is equal to the home’s value, again, you will not lose your home.

How much does it cost to file bankruptcy in Canada?

The expense of declaring bankruptcy is something you will certainly need to take into consideration. Just how much you will need to pay to go bankrupt relies on a number of variables, including:

  • your month-to-month income;
  • what assets you own;
  • the size of your family members; and also
  • whether you have ever been bankrupt in the past.

You are required to your surplus income into your estate every month. Surplus income is defined by the federal government. If your household makes over a certain amount every month, you pay a component of your earnings over that base set by the government each year. That base is essentially the poverty line.

The surplus income computation is reasonably complicated. I recommend you bring your current pay stubs to your meeting with me to make sure that I can accurately estimate it for you.

The fee a Trustee is entitled to charge in an ordinary personal bankruptcy must be approved by the Court. In a bankruptcy where there really are no assets, the fee is set in the statute.

If you have non-exempt assets, the Trustee sells them and receives the proceeds of the sale(s). If you have surplus income to pay, the Trustee collects those payments from you. The Trustee’s fee, which is the cost of the bankruptcy, comes from the money collected by the Trustee. So, in this example, where the Trustee has collected more than the cost of the bankruptcy approved by the Court, there is no additional cost to you at all. In this way, the Trustee is free!

If there are no assets or surplus income, then the bankrupt has to make monthly payments to the Trustee to cover the cost of the bankruptcy. If the bankrupt person cannot afford to, then you will have to get a relative to put up the money necessary to pay for the cost of your filing for bankruptcy. In this case, the government approved fee is in the range of $1,800.

Summary

I hope this Brandon’s Blog gives you a good idea of how to file for bankruptcy in Canada. We know that having too much debt is very stressful.

The Ira Smith Team understands how to help you rid yourself of your debts. However, more importantly, we understand your emotional needs. You are worried because you are facing significant financial challenges. You are worried not only about yourself but also your family.

The stress placed upon you due to your financial challenges is enormous. We understand your pain points. We look at your entire situation and devise a strategy that is as unique as you and your problems; financial and emotional. The way we deal with your problems and devise a debt settlement plan, we know that we can help you.

We know that when you are facing financial problems you need a realistic lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” approach with the Ira Smith Team. That is why we can develop a debt settlement plan for you as unique as the financial problems and pain you are facing. If any of this sounds familiar to you and you are serious in finding a solution, contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. team today.

Call us now for a free consultation. We will get you back on the road to a healthy stress-free life. We will help you to recover from the pain points in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

 

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

BANKRUPTCY TRUSTEE IN ONTARIO: REMARKABLE CARE NEEDED TO TAKE OVER A CLAIM

bankruptcy trustee in ontario
bankruptcy trustee in ontario

If you would prefer to listen to an audio version of this bankruptcy trustee in Ontario Brandon’s Blog, please scroll to the bottom and click on the podcast.

Bankruptcy trustee in Ontario: Introduction

As a bankruptcy trustee in Ontario (now called a licensed insolvency trustee ), there are many times where our investigation indicates that the bankrupt (usually a bankrupt corporation) has a claim against another party. The claim may very well be a good one worthy of pursuing. However, like with any potential litigation, there could be not enough funds to pay for pursuing that claim in the Court, or it may be unwise for a bankruptcy trustee in Ontario (Trustee) to assume the litigation risk.

In cases like this, the licensed insolvency trustee can offer up the opportunity to the creditors to take on the action in their own name. One or more creditors can get an order under s. 38 of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. B-3 (BIA) from the Registrar in Bankruptcy, authorizing the assignment to them by the licensed insolvency trustee of the bankrupt company‘s right to advance that claim and if necessary, sue.

Without going into all the finer details and circumstances, any creditor or group of creditors who obtain that right can keep any amount collected under that claim up to the total of their claim against the bankrupt company plus the costs they spent in obtaining that award. Any surplus must be paid over to the bankruptcy trustee in Ontario.

A recent decision of the Court of Appeal for Ontario highlights an interesting issue regarding the interplay between advancing such a claim by a creditor and the limitation period in Ontario.

Bankruptcy trustee in Ontario case background information

The Ridel family used an investment and stock brokerage company called e3m Investments Inc. (e3m). In December 2006, the Ridels issued a Statement of Claim versus their account representative, as well as his employer, e3m. The action was for negligence, breach of contract and violation of fiduciary obligation in the monitoring of their financial investment accounts.

After a ten-day court hearing, judgment was issued against e3m as well as the account representative in Ridel v. Cassin, 2013 ONSC 2279. The judgment was especially scathing of both the account rep and e3m. The judgement, in the amount of $1,036,245.85, was upheld on appeal. As a result, the account representative needed to make an insolvency filing. My Firm administered the successfully completed Division I restructuring Proposal of the account representative. Given the judgement, he needed to do an insolvency filing and it was in his best interests to attempt to restructure to avoid bankruptcy. The Ridel family controlled the voting in his successful Proposal. e3m filed for bankruptcy on January 20, 2015.

The bankruptcy trustee in Ontario case before the Court of Appeal

On July 31, 2019, the Court of Appeal for Ontario released its decision in Ridel v. Goldberg, 2019 ONCA 636. The underlying claim was one the bankrupt company may have had against its Director and majority shareholder.

On October 25, 2016, the Ridels, as an unsecured creditor of e3m, got an order under s. 38 of the BIA. They obtained an assignment of the claim of e3m against its sole Director, a Mr. Goldberg. Since e3m was found liable under the Ridel judgement, e3m could have a claim and institute proceedings against its Director, Mr. Goldberg.

The s. 38 order supplied the Ridels with the legal authority to assert e3m’s claim against Mr. Goldberg “to recover the damages for which e3m became liable pursuant to [the 2013 Judgment, as amended] in their own name and at their own expense and risk, based on Mr. Goldberg’s failure to fulfil his obligations as a director and officer of e3m by abdicating his responsibility to supervise the Ridels’ accounts at e3m”.

The Ridels launched their lawsuit proceedings in the lower Court against Mr. Goldberg the day they obtained the s. 38 order, October 25, 2016. The Ridels were trying to get a summary judgement. Mr. Goldberg raised several defences, including, the Ridels’ claim was statute-barred under the Limitations Act, 2002, S.O. 2002, c. 24, Sched. B (Limitations Act).

The lower court judge dismissed the Ridels’ action on two fronts. First, the judge found that there were concerns about needing a trial. Second, the lower court judge agreed that the claim should be dismissed because of the expiration of a two-year limitation period The Ridels appealed the lower court’s decision to the Court of Appeal for Ontario.

bankruptcy trustee in ontario
bankruptcy trustee in ontario

The fascinating part (for me anyway) of the Court of Appeal’s decision

The unanimous Court of Appeal ruling agreed with the lower court judge’s decision that the action the Ridels took by way of an assignment document from e3m’s licensed insolvency trustee was statute-barred under the Limitations Act. However, the appeal court review of the lower court decision disagreed with the reasons given by the lower court. Upon agreeing that the Ridel’s action should be dismissed based on it being barred by the Limitations Act, the appeal court did not wade into whether or not the lower court judge’s decision was correct that summary judgement should not be granted as there was a triable issue.

The arguments given for the limitation period are somewhat complex. I will attempt to summarize them here so as not to be confusing. The lower court judge held that the Ridels as applicants knew of the existence of the potential claim of e3m against its Director as early as in July 2006. Since they did not launch the e3m claim in a court action until October 2016. Hence, the limitation period of 2 years made that claim statute-barred.

The Ridels state that the limitation period cannot have actually begun up until after e3m was bankrupt. Before then, they could not take an assignment of any claim from e3m’s licensed insolvency trustee, especially a potential claim by the company against its Director (and Officer).

They also stated it is impossible to get an s. 38 order before the company actually is bankrupt.

The lawyer for the Ridels did not argue the testing of the timing of their very own understanding of the Director’s misdeed in regard to e3m. Rather, he focussed on the fact that the Ridels were not in a place to do anything concerning it, at a minimum, until the bankruptcy of e3m.

The appeal court went through a detailed analysis of the relevant statutes and case law. The Court of Appeal confirmed that the action launched was not a claim by the Ridels personally, but rather the company’s claim of which they took a court-approved assignment. So the appeal court agreed substantially with the Ridels that they could not have started their action until they took the assignment from the e3m licensed insolvency trustee.

When was e3m’s knowledge of its claim?

So the appeal court said what is important, since it is e3m’s claim and not the claim of the Ridels, when did e3m first become aware of the potential claim against its Director? The appeal court stated it fully understood why the Director would not have had e3m sue him or otherwise enjoin him in the original claim against the account rep and e3m. However, when did e3m first become aware of the potential of its claim?

On the proof in this matter, regardless of the Ridels’ or Goldbergs’ understanding of the case or his aversion to act against himself in support of e3m, at the very least, by April 2013, every one of the other e3m investors/shareholders had received a copy of the Reasons for Decision and Judgment against the account rep and e3m. It included different referrals to the Director’s misbehaviour. Those investors had the capacity to make e3m file a claim against the Director.

The Court of Appeal for Ontario judges determined that e3m recognized that: 1. an injury had actually happened; 2. its loss was brought on by an act or omission; 3. the act or omission was purportedly that of the Director, and 4. an action against the Director was a proper way to treat it. Regardless of the Director’s control to protect against such a lawsuit, the investors might have taken control of e3m’s board of directors and cause e3m to make such a case versus Goldberg.

So the appeal court decided that e3m first recognized that it may have a claim against the Director in April 2013, but the action was not commenced until October 2016. Accordingly, it was outside of the 2 year limitation period and the action was statute-barred.

So what does this mean for a bankruptcy trustee in Ontario?

As the bankruptcy trustee in Ontario in either a corporate bankruptcy or personal bankruptcy, many times we find as a result of our investigation that the bankrupt may have a claim against another party. More often than not, we either do not have sufficient funds or are not prepared to risk the funds in the Estate to the litigation risk. So, what we do is communicate with all known creditors to advise of the potential claim and that the licensed insolvency trustee is either unwilling or unable to act upon it. Accordingly, we are giving the creditors a chance to apply to the Court to take an assignment of such action under s.38 of the BIA.

Creditors seriously considering taking over the bankrupt’s claim must seriously consider the issue of whether or not launching a court action will be met with a defence that the claim is statute-barred, amongst other defences that may be available to the defendant(s). The Court of Appeal for Ontario has clearly communicated that the creditor taking an assignment of the bankrupt’s claim, cannot be in a better position than the bankrupt itself. The first knowledge that a claim exists will be when the bankrupt first had the knowledge, not the date that the creditor obtained the right to sue or any other date.

Bankruptcy trustee in Ontario Canada conclusion

The business world contains normal daily risks. This case clearly shows that. Are your company’s viability and solvency being threatened by claims against it, or for any other reason?

Is your company experiencing financial problems and requires debt relief? Are you on the brink of filing for bankruptcy just like e3m was because of your debts? Or are you an individual that has too much debt and you are looking at personal bankruptcy as your solution? Don’t wait until it is too late to properly restructure your company’s financial affairs. You don’t have to be another one filing bankruptcy in Canada. We can show you the various alternatives to bankruptcy.

As a licensed insolvency trustee, we are the only professionals who have met the requirements of the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy Canada to obtain a trustee licence. One of those requirements to be trustees in bankruptcy is to pass an oral board of examination.

Insolvency trustee’s operations are licensed, authorized and their duties supervised by the federal government to offer insolvency advice and to implement solutions under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada). We are a licensed insolvency trustee operating in Ontario Canada and we will help you to select what is best for you to free you from your debt issues.

Contact the Ira Smith Team today so we can use our qualifications to get you or your company the debt relief that you deserve. We will eliminate the anxiousness, tension, discomfort and pain from your life that your bills and your cash problems have caused. With the unique roadmap, we develop just for you, you can eliminate your debts and we will promptly return you right into a healthy and balanced problem-free life.

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

BANKRUPTCY ACT CANADA: ARE YOU REALLY PREPARED FOR IT?

Introduction

No person wishes to go make a filing under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (R.S.C., 1985, c. B-3) (Bankruptcy Act Canada), however occasionally it is inevitable. You might think that people who file are just those that are careless with their finances. However, with most of the people I see, it is usually an event outside of their control that pushes them over the edge.

In personal bankruptcy, things such as illness, divorce, job loss, unanticipated catastrophes, identity theft and fraud are many times the causes of insolvency. Of course, lack of proper budgeting, overspending and inappropriate uses of credit are also involved. In corporate insolvency, the #1 cause always seems to track back to management.

Insolvency filings happen every year. In 2018, a total amount of 128,846 insolvency filings were made with the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy (OSB). This is 2.4% more from 2017. Consumer insolvency filings increased 2.5% (125,266 filings), while company filings dropped 0.8% to 3,580.

At the very same time, people choosing to avoid bankruptcy by filing a proposal continued increasing in 2018, bringing this number to a brand-new level. Proposals represented 52.6% of consumer filings in 2017. In 2018, they expanded by 6.6% to 56% of all personal filings.

Are you considering a Bankruptcy Act Canada filing, or at least speaking to a Licensed Insolvency Trustee (formerly called a trustee in bankruptcy) (Trustee)? In order to help you start your fact-finding, I want to tell you what will happen to your bank accounts, retirement accounts and your other important financial funds. Understanding what to anticipate can assist you to stay clear of some pricey blunders.

Bankruptcy or (consumer) proposal

Being insolvent is that you are not able to settle your financial debts. People with severe financial problems can make Bankruptcy Act Canada filing by filing either for bankruptcy, a consumer proposal or Division I proposal.

Proposals are official methods controlled by the Bankruptcy Act Canada for personal filings. Dealing with a Trustee you make a proposal to:

  • Pay your creditors a portion of what you owe them over a particular time period not going beyond 60 months
  • Extend the time you need to settle the debt
  • Or a mix of both

The Proposal is made via the Trustee, who uses the money in your proposal fund to pay the cost of administration and distribution to each of your creditors their pro-rata share. A consumer proposal needs to be finished within 5 years from the day of filing.

Proposal

People with severe financial problems can apply for bankruptcy. They can also try to avoid bankruptcy by using the Proposal provisions of the Bankruptcy Act Canada.

There are numerous advantages to avoiding bankruptcy. The main differences between proposals and bankruptcy are:

  • Unlike informal debt settlement, a Proposal produces a binding discussion forum where each of your unsecured creditors has to participate in for your debt restructuring.
  • You can keep your property, including your home, if you can afford to in your budget.
  • Lawsuits against you and enforcement proceedings, such as wage garnishments, cannot begin or continue.
  • In a successfully completed Proposal, you do not need to file for bankruptcy.

Keep in mind that financial institutions have “set-off” legal rights, implying that if you declare bankruptcy or file for bankruptcy when you’re behind in payments to them, they will take the funds in your accounts to try to cover all or some of what you owe them. This is notwithstanding that there is a stay of proceedings once a Bankruptcy Act Canada filing takes place and such an offset really should not take place.

So if you are thinking of filing either for bankruptcy or a proposal, I want you to be prepared for what might happen to your financial assets.

Your bank account

In a bankruptcy, the cash in your bank account is a property which must be paid over to the Trustee. Upon your filing, the Trustee will put all your banks on notice to provide the funds in any accounts maintained with them to the Trustee. As noted above, the bank may very well offset cash in your savings or chequing account against the money you may owe them, including credit card debt.

In a Proposal, you do not lose control of the money in your bank accounts. Rather, they are considered by the Trustee in formulating the type of Proposal you should offer your creditors. Remember, your Proposal must offer your creditors a better alternative than your bankruptcy would. However, even though there is a stay of proceedings invoked once you file your Proposal, it is not uncommon for a bank where you maintain an account and to whom you owe money, to take the money in your account and offset it against what you owe them.

So the moral of this story is that you are best to have bank accounts at financial institutions to whom you do not owe any money.

Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP), Registered Retirement Income Fund (RRIF) or Deferred Profit Sharing Plan (DPSP)

In a bankruptcy, your RRSP, RRIF or DPSP are excluded from seizure. However, the Trustee is entitled under the Bankruptcy Act Canada to receive the equivalent to any amounts contributed to these accounts in the 12 months preceding your filing date. In a Proposal, this 12-month amount must be included by the Trustee in the calculation of what amount your Proposal should offer your creditors.

Canada Pension Plan (CPP) and Old Age Security income (OAS)

Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) is the only one permitted to garnish your CPP earnings if you have an unpaid personal income tax. By filing either for bankruptcy or a Proposal, the stay of proceedings will be invoked and CRA will have to stop the garnishment of your CPP and you will get the CPP payments you are qualified for.

However, the earnings obtained from CPP and OAS will certainly be taken into account by the Trustee in determining if you have any surplus income payment obligation in bankruptcy. In a Proposal, that amount also has to be considered in developing your Proposal.

Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA), Registered Education Savings Plan (RESP) and other non-registered account investments

In a bankruptcy, just like any other non-exempt property, the amount held in your TFSA and any other non-registered investment account must be paid to the Trustee. In a Proposal, these amounts need to be taken into account in determining what type of Proposal to make. It may very well be that these accounts are collapsed in order to help fund a Proposal.

Similarly, RESPs are not excluded in personal bankruptcy. In a Proposal, the amount must be considered as an asset in calculating how much must be offered in your Proposal to stand a chance for success.

The reason that an RESP is not excluded from seizure in bankruptcy is relatively straightforward. Your child does not acquire ownership or other entitlement to the RESP funds as parents can take possession of the funds prior to the child becoming a post-secondary school student. For that reason, it is the parents who have ownership of the funds.

Consequently, the Trustee of an insolvent mother or father that has an RESP can collapse it. If the parent in bankruptcy wants the RESP to not collapse, adequate arrangements need to be made with the Trustee for the equal amount of funds in the RESP at the filing date be paid to the Trustee for the bankruptcy estate and the bankrupt’s creditors.

Annuity revenue in bankruptcy

Annuities are agreements where you pay a company (normally an insurance company) a specific amount, in order to get regular monthly payments for a specific period of time or for the remainder of your life.

If an annuity contract is properly set up with an insurance company, it will be exempt from seizure in bankruptcy. However, the income stream it produces will be considered by the Trustee in determining whether the bankrupt person has a surplus income obligation.

Your RRIF can also be considered as an annuity as it provides a legislated stream of payments. The RRIF is exempt from seizure in a bankruptcy, other than for any contributions in the 12 months immediately prior to filing. Like an annuity, the entitlement to payments will be considered by the Trustee in doing the surplus income calculation.

In a Proposal, you don’t give up ownership of an annuity contract or RRIF, but the income must be considered in preparing a suitable Proposal.

Bankruptcy Act Canada summary

Do you have financial problems? Do you not have enough money to pay your bills in full when due?

As a Trustee, we are the only professionals licensed, authorized and supervised by the federal government to offer insolvency advice and to implement solutions under the Bankruptcy Act Canada. A consumer proposal is a federal government licensed debt settlement plan to eliminate your debt. We will help you to select what is best for you to free you from your debt issues.

Call the Ira Smith Team today so we can eliminate the anxiousness, tension, discomfort and pain from your life that your cash problems have caused. With the unique roadmap, we develop just for you, we will promptly return you right into a healthy and balanced problem-free life.

Call the Ira Smith Team today. We have generations and decades of experience helping people and companies looking for debt restructuring and a debt settlement plan to AVOID bankruptcy.

You can have a no-cost consultation so we can work with you to fix your money troubles. Call the Ira Smith Team today. This will certainly allow you to go back to a new healthy and balanced life, Starting Over Starting Now.

bankruptcy act canada

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

CONSUMER PROPOSAL STORY 4 – TRUE STORIES

Introduction

This consumer proposal story 4 Brandon’s Blog is about how four of our clients were able to enter into a government approved debt settlement program, shed their debt and restart their lives.

As I have written in previous blogs, a consumer proposal is the only government approved debt settlement plan. It is designed for people who have $250,000 or less in total debt, other than for any debts secured against their home such as a mortgage or secured home equity line of credit.

If the consumer proposal receives the (deemed) acceptance by the required majority of creditors and it also receives (deemed) court approval, then the consumer proposal is approved. The insolvent person must now make the payments to the licensed insolvency trustee who is the consumer proposal administrator.

The following four real client consumer proposal story situations of mine I believe are representative of the kind of person we help end the pain and anxiety their debts are causing them. I have changed the names of the people for this Brandon’s Blog.

Buzz

This client is a 56-year-old married male. I will call him Buzz. He has annual income, net of income tax of $100,000. He has assets with a net realizable value of $1,000. His consumer debt totalled $71,000.

In reviewing his budget and affairs, we calculated that in personal bankruptcy, he would be required to contribute surplus income for 36 months as he was previously bankrupt. His surplus income obligation in bankruptcy was just over $34,000 in equal monthly instalments of $944.44.

We advised him that since his budget had room for him to make monthly payments, he should consider a consumer proposal. We drafted and filed his consumer proposal requiring him to pay $40,000 in total over 5 years. This resulted in equal monthly payments each of $667.

Buzz’s creditors accepted his consumer proposal and he is making the payments. This way he avoided bankruptcy and ended up with an approved debt settlement plan with monthly payments he can afford.

Woody

This client is a 65-year-old single male. I will call him Woody. He has annual income, net of income tax of $27,600. He has assets with a net realizable value of $500. His consumer debt totalled $108,000.

In reviewing his budget and affairs, we calculated that in personal bankruptcy, he would be required to contribute surplus income for 9 months as he was never previously bankrupt. His surplus income obligation in bankruptcy was just over $1,880 in equal monthly instalments of $208.89.

We advised him that since his budget had room for him to make monthly payments, he should consider a consumer proposal. We drafted and filed his consumer proposal requiring him to pay $24,000 in total over 5 years. This resulted in equal monthly payments each of $400.

Woody’s creditors accepted his consumer proposal and he is making his payments. This way he avoided bankruptcy and ended up with an approved debt settlement plan with monthly payments he can afford.

Mr. & Mrs. Potato Head

Our 3rd client is a 47-year-old married man and his 43-year-old wife. I will call them Mr. & Mrs. Potato Head. Their yearly income, net of tax obligations was $51,996. Their assets had a realizable value of $953. They are collectively responsible for the exact same consumer financial debts amounting to $31,820.

In assessing their budget, we computed that in a bankruptcy, they would need to pay surplus income for 9 months as neither were bankrupt before. Their surplus income responsibility in a joint bankruptcy was $5,271 in regular monthly instalments of $585.67.

We encouraged them that given their budget plan had room to make month-to-month payments, they must take into consideration the possibility of making a consumer proposal. We prepared and filed their consumer proposal needing them to pay $7,020 over 3 years. This led to regular monthly payments each of $195.

Mr. & Mrs. Potato Head’s creditors approved the consumer proposal and they are making their payments. In this manner, they will not go bankrupt and wound up with an accepted debt negotiation strategy with month-to-month payments they can manage.

Jessie

This client is a 67-year-old married female. I will call her Jessie. She has annual income, net of income tax of $58,416. She has assets with a net realizable value of $250. Her consumer debt totalled $67,000.

In examining her budget plan, we determined that in bankruptcy, she would be called for surplus income payments for 36 months as she was once a bankrupt. Her surplus income commitment in a bankruptcy would be $17,465 in regular monthly instalments of $485.13.

Considering that her spending plan had space to make month-to-month repayments, we encouraged her to seriously think about making a consumer proposal. We composed and submitted her consumer proposal needing her to pay $21,500 over a 40 month period. This would be regular monthly payments each of $537.50.

Jessie’s creditors approved her consumer proposal and she is making her repayments. By doing this she stayed clear of bankruptcy and wound up with an approved debt negotiation strategy with regular monthly repayments she can manage.

Consumer proposal story summary

I hope these real-life consumer proposal story 4 examples gives you a better idea of the kind of people this debt settlement program strategy is meant to help. It is a way for people to shed their debt and get back on a proper footing.

Are you in financial distress? Do you not have adequate funds to pay your financial obligations as they come due?

If so, call the Ira Smith Team today. We have decades and generations of experience assisting people looking for financial restructuring, a debt settlement plan and to AVOID bankruptcy.

As a licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a bankruptcy trustee), we are the only professionals accredited, acknowledged and supervised by the federal government to provide insolvency advice and to implement approaches to help you remain out of personal bankruptcy while eliminating your debts. A consumer proposal is a government approved debt settlement plan to do that. We will help you decide on what is best for you between a consumer proposal vs bankruptcy.

Call the Ira Smith Team today so you can eliminate the stress, anxiety, and pain from your life that your financial problems have caused. With the one-of-a-kind roadmap, we develop just for you, we will immediately return you right into a healthy and balanced problem-free life.

You can have a no-cost analysis so we can help you fix your troubles. Call the Ira Smith Team today. This will allow you to go back to a new healthy and balanced life, Starting Over Starting Now.

consumer proposal story

Call a Trustee Now!