Categories
Brandon Blog Post

PRIVACY BREACH LAWSUIT AGAINST LICENSED INSOLVENCY TRUSTEE FAILS

privacy breach lawsuitPrivacy breach lawsuit: Introduction

A licensed insolvency trustee (formerly known as a bankruptcy trustee) and a Court appointed Receiver are both officers of the Court. As such, they have a duty of care to all stakeholders and parties. A decision of the Supreme Court of British Columbia released in late 2018 deals with an application to begin a class action privacy breach lawsuit against a licensed insolvency trustee (LIT or Trustee).

The case I am referring to is Netlink Computer System Inc. (re),2018 BCSC2309. Netlink Computer System Inc. (Netlink) was a British Columbia-based business that marketed computers and associated software solutions. In late 2017, Netlink went bankrupt.

Privacy breach lawsuit: The request to go ahead

As is required under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA), any party wishing to initiate litigation against a bankruptcy trustee must first get the permission of the Court to do so.

In the Netlink case, a former Netlink customer wanted to start a class action lawsuit against the Trustee. The customer claimed that the Trustee breached the personal privacy of Netlink’s customers by permitting their personal details to be revealed. The unproven claim was that the Trustee sold to or, otherwise, allowed 3rd parties to get personal information of the Netlink customers.

This particular customer wished to start an action versus the Trustee for breach of privacy. If leave is approved, this customer would then seek certification of his case as a class action lawsuit.

Privacy breach lawsuit: The issue in requesting the leave of the Court

The Court’s task was to figure out whether to exercise its discretion to allow the claim to go ahead. The Court had to look at the nature and scope of the proposed claim taking into account the evidence. Leave is rarely given. If leave was granted in this case, it would be the first time in Canada a bankruptcy Trustee has been taken legal action against in a potential class action proceeding.

The BIA does not give any type of specific advice about the elements the Court ought to take into consideration in thinking about an application for leave to start an action against a LIT. These have just been developed through case-law analyzing and using s. 215 of the BIA.

For almost 150 years, Courts and legal scholars have been of the view that the bar for approving the commencement of litigation I versus a Court-appointed receiver or Trustee is not a high one. It is designed to protect the receiver or LIT against only frivolous or vexatious actions which have no basis.

The leading cases on the issue of leave to go ahead with litigation against either a Court-appointed receiver or LIT can be summarized as follows;

  • Leave to take such legal action should not be given if the action is frivolous or vexatious. Manifestly unmeritorious claims need to not be allowed to continue
  • Actions need to not be allowed to continue if the evidence submitted on behalf of the action, does not show a cause of action against the Trustee.
  • The court is not required to make a final evaluation of the benefits of the claim prior to granting leave.

This threshold tries to strike the ideal balance between the security of bankruptcy trustees and Court appointed receivers from the interruption of an insolvency administration from unimportant or simply tactical suits and preserving to the maximum degree possible the legal rights of creditors and other stakeholders.

In this privacy breach lawsuit case, the claimant states that his affidavit evidence provides proof reveals a real case against the Trustee. The Trustee says that the proposed claim and the evidence on its behalf does not satisfy the relatively reduced threshold called for to prove leave.

The claimant described in his materials, his potential claim. . He also discloses that he has already begun a claim against the auction company who sold the bankruptcy company’s assets, Netlink and Netlink’s landlord. (The action versus Netlink has remained stayed due to the fact that Netlink is in bankruptcy). The proposed claim against the LIT is exactly the same and consists of practically the same phrasing as the action already started. There is no separate accusation that the Trustee did anything different from the auctioneer, Netlink, or the landlord.

The proposed claimant’s main points were:

  1. He purchased a product from Netlink and provided personal information, including, his name, address and credit card details.
  2. The Trustee contracted with the auctioneer to sell the assets.
  3. During that process, the Trustee allowed customers’ private information, including addresses, credit card numbers, and various other sensitive information (the “Private Information”) to be exposed and offered to or otherwise acquired by 3rd parties, including criminals.
  4. The Trustee provided the auctioneer computers and Netlink servers and other records containing the Private Information.
  5. Criminals that obtained the Netlink servers offered the information to other criminals, consisting of cybercriminals and identity thieves.
  6. The trustee knew that customer details are often included in the property of such bankrupt’s estates and it took no steps to safeguard the information when taking guardianship of Netflix’s property.
  7. The Trustee’s choice to offer the Private Information, or at a minimum, the Netlink servers including the Private Information, was intended and deliberate and was made knowing that Netlink customers had not consented to their details being shared.
  8. Customers have suffered damages.

Privacy breach lawsuit: This evidence

The Court examined the claims and the evidence. Unfortunately, the claimant did not have first-hand knowledge of what the Trustee did or did not do. Rather, the claimant submitted two sworn affidavits of what he believed took place. The information contained in the two affidavits was derived mainly from blog posts and YouTube videos that the claimant believed to be true.

The Trustee submitted 2 sworn affidavits of the LIT responsible for the Netlink file. The Trustee’s evidence was mainly why the relatively low threshold for allowing a claim against a Trustee or Court appointed receiver were not met. It did not provide much information about what the Trustee actually did (or did not do).

The Court had no choice but to rule that the claimant’s evidence was mainly hearsay and not admissible. With no real evidence before the Court to support the accusations, the Court dismissed the application and leave to begin the action against the Trustee was denied.

Privacy breach lawsuit: My take

Based on my reading of this case, I believe the Trustee was very lucky that there was no real evidence against it. There is no information indicating what steps the Trustee took to make sure that all Private Information was protected prior to the assets being sold. It is imperative that privacy breaches do not take place. Once a Trustee or Court appointed receiver to take possession of assets that may contain private or sensitive information, steps must be taken to ensure that the information does not fall into the hands of 3rd parties who have no right to that information. It does not matter whether the information is stored on computer hard drives, in the cloud, or physically in books or on paper.

The claimant still has its action against the auctioneer and the landlord. My understanding is that the landlord is involved because once the auction sale was completed and the auctioneer left the premises, there were still books, records and papers that contained some or all the Private Information. The landlord disposed of such papers in a way that did not protect the Private Information.

My Firm’s standard practice is to remove hard drives that contain Private Information so that computers would be sold minus a hard drive. With respect to physical records, any documents not required that would contain Private Information, we have shredded. We do not just throw it into a dumpster intact for someone to find. These are minimum steps required to protect Private Information.

Unfortunately, in the Netlink case, the Court’s Reasons for Decision does not include any information indicating the Trustee took such steps.

Privacy breach lawsuit: What does it all mean?

What it all means is that in any insolvency assignment, the LIT needs to know what it is he or she has taken possession and control of. Decisions must be made that protect the interests of all stakeholders, as best possible. There are always competing interests. The LIT must balance them all carefully when making decisions.

Do you have too much debt because you are a victim of identity theft? Does your company have too much debt and is in danger of shutting down? Is the pain and stress of too much debt now negatively affecting your health?

If so, contact the Ira Smith Team today. We have decades and generations of helping people and companies in need of financial restructuring and counselling. As a licensed insolvency trustee (formerly known as a bankruptcy trustee), we are the only professionals licensed and supervised by the Federal government to provide debt settlement and financial restructuring services.

We offer a free consultation to help you solve your problems. We understand your pain that debt causes. We can also end it right away from your life. This will allow you to begin a fresh start, Starting Over Starting Now. Call the Ira Smith Team today so that we can begin helping you and get you back into a healthy, stress-free life.privacy breach lawsuit

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

FINANCIAL NEW YEAR’S RESOLUTIONS 2019: WILL YOU KEEP YOUR FINANCIAL NEW YEAR’S RESOLUTIONS 2019?

financial new year's resolutions 2019

If you would prefer to listen to the audio of this financial new year’s resolutions 2019 version of this Brandon’s Blog (with an introduction from a celebrity guest), please scroll to the bottom and click on the podcast.

Financial New Year’s resolutions 2019: Introduction

The New Year has arrived. I wish all of my readers a healthy, happy and prosperous New Year. By now, many people have made themselves promises on how they will improve in 2019. Many people make New Year’s resolutions, including financial new year’s resolutions 2019. In this Brandon’s Blog, I explore what are many of the common resolutions people make and what the chances are on people actually carrying them out.

Financial New Year’s resolutions 2019: The 8 most common resolutions

Other than the first one, in no particular order, the 8 most common New Year’s resolutions are:

Lose Weight. The Number 1 New Year’s Resolution is to drop weight. We’ve all seen it, or become aware of it. Many resolve to lose weight, but few truly complete it in the long-term. That is why January every year is when the weight loss programs, gyms and workout products advertise heavily.


Do Better Than Last Year. Often, life is simply hard. In between family members, good friends, your work, and all the various other stress and anxieties that life can toss at you, it simply appears sometimes that absolutely nothing can go right. And also some years are simply a plain draw. So, after a year of grinding via the days, weeks, and months, you’re prepared for a do-over. You’re prepared to do anything to make sure that the following year begins the very best way it can. So, this resolution is to merely attempt to have a better year than the last one.

Exercise. One of the most usual New Year’s resolutions has to do with ones very own health and wellness. Among the many health and wellness promises, is working out. When you consider it, it’s not just wishing to slim down (which is the number 1 resolution), it’s in fact about wishing to be more powerful, quicker and generally in better shape.

When your body is in peak condition, it does do far better. An in shape body functions far better, provides you with much more power, boosts your mind’s abilities and a lot more. DON’T try to push your body in the beginning to do more than it can handle. Any personal trainer will tell you to begin slowly and work yourself up from there. Set realistic goals for yourself.


Save More/Spend Less. Cash is what people need and the most common of all the financial New Year’s resolutions 2019 is to make sure that we have more of it in the New Year. This is especially true for most Canadians, who are living paycheque to paycheque.

The best way to start your financial plan for the New Year is to first look at what happened in the year that just ended. Reflect on your year. I’m certain you’ll realize some things about your immediate past financial behaviour. Some items that you wish you had not purchased or lost money on. Or, if you understood then what you currently know, you would certainly have done things in a different way and saved yourself a couple of bucks in the process.

In other words, look at your income and expenses carefully and budget properly for the New Year. Your proper budget must include saving a certain amount from each paycheque to put away in an emergency savings fund for when there is an unexpected, well, emergency. Your budget will also hopefully allow for other savings to be able to invest for the longer term.

Use the start of the brand-new year to begin preparing just how you could invest your new savings. In your personal financial plan or budget, concentrate on things you NEED versus the many things you WANT. By doing this one simple thing, you will find you will have more in your savings account. This is the best way to stay on track to meet your financial New Year’s resolutions 2019.


Get More Sleep. Depending upon the researcher you listen to, the body requires between 6-8 hours of rest. Our bodies can work on much less, yes, yet it’s not something that a lot of medical professionals advise. This is another one of the resolutions fitting into the health and wellness category.

Get A New Hobby/Skill. Whether we intend to confess or otherwise, most of us wish to be our best selves. We do not simply intend to be the individual that undergoes the movements, we intend to have something we can expect each week, and even take pride in.

So, with a brand-new year, comes a chance to learn new skills or do something different in our lives than just the “same old, same old”. For some, it, in fact, implies attempting to get new skills for getting a better paying job. For others, they see it as a possibility to handle a new pastime or discover something that they’ve always intended to do or learn.

Quit Smoking/Drinking. Humans are animals of routine, yet in some cases, those behaviours are actually, REALLY negative for you. Two of the ones that cover the “negative for you” checklist is alcohol consumption to such an excess that it is an addiction and smoking cigarettes. Like any addiction, this is very tough to do and many times requires the help of trained professionals.

Volunteer. While practically every one of these resolutions is created to aid oneself in one fashion or another, this one helps both the self and others. One of the best ways to help others is to volunteer your time. Volunteer to what? To help any place you can certainly. In some cases, it’s at a homeless shelter, or to assist a close friend in need. There are many opportunities to help the less fortunate. However the crucial point is that you place yourself 2nd, and the needs of others first. Spreading a little happiness can go a long way for a person. Therefore if you wish to assist others, do not hesitate to ask, “What do you need?”. You may be amazed by simply just how much you can help somebody.

Financial New Year’s resolutions 2019: Why do we do it?

We cannot forecast the future. In some cases, it’s tough to anticipate what will take place in the following couple of hours, not to mention the following 12 months. Why do we do it? Well, it’s mainly since we intend to think that we have some power over the future. If we can state to ourselves, “This year will certainly be different, this will certainly be the year I will make changes for me”, it’ll place us in the best attitude to get down to business and do things. The feeling that we have control over our lives is exceptional.

Financial New Year’s resolutions 2019: Will we keep our resolutions?

It begins straightforward. We look in the mirror, see what we don’t like and resolve to make the changes that probably should have been made a long time ago. We will establish worthy ventures to do simply that thing or things. However, most people will drop off the wagon within a short period of time. What? I’m not being mean, I’m being genuine. Making significant changes in your life is hard.


We are hyped for the New Year. We are. so tired of what occurred in the previous year that we are ready to make the changes we promised ourselves we would make. We may also have invested a lot of time informing other people what changes we will make in the New Year. But then life gets in the way and we fall short.

Financial New Year’s resolutions 2019: Falling short is OK

It does not matter that I fell short all my resolutions actually. I need to so that I can ensure that I can improve further! Of course, I should not try to fail them, but it is normal to fall short. No one is perfect. As long as you see that you have made improvements in the right direction, that is what really counts.

So, make sure that your goals are realistic. Even if you fall short, you have improved immensely and that will be your new starting point for the next New Year’s resolutions. I hope all of you improve your life in some area this year, and that will be your new starting point when 2019 comes to an end. This includes your financial New Year’s resolutions.

Do you need professional help to meet your financial goals?

As I stated above, sometimes professional help is required to meet a New Year’s resolution. We may not have all the skills required. Improving your financial situation may be one of those areas where professional help is required. Maybe you only need a coach to keep you focussed on performing your financial new year’s resolutions 2019. Perhaps on a personal level, you might require only some credit counselling or debt consolidation. On a more formal basis, you may need a debt restructuring plan in the form of a consumer proposal in order to eliminate your debts and get back on the right financial path. In some extreme cases, personal bankruptcy may be what is needed.

Perhaps your company is in need of financial restructuring. Perhaps your lender is threatening receivership or bankruptcy so you are in need of a financial advisor skilled in insolvency matters. A licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a bankruptcy trustee) is the only professional licensed and supervised by the Canadian Federal government skilled in both personal and corporate insolvency matters If you or your company have too much debt, call the Ira Smith Team for your free consultation. We understand your pain, and we have the prescription to end your pain forever. Call the Ira Smith Team today, so that you can begin your improved life for this New Year 2019, Starting Over, Starting Now!

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

INCOME TAX DEBT RELIEF: DO YOU KNOW THE WAY TO INCOME TAX DEBT RELIEF?

income tax debt reliefIncome tax debt relief: Introduction

As 2018 draws to a close, I want to wish all of our readers a very happy, healthy and prosperous New Year. I hope that 2019 will be a great year for all of us. You have no doubt been bombarded so far with emails, articles, and programs on getting income tax debt relief for 2018 by making sure that you have taken advantage of all possible deductions before the year ends tonight. I thought I would take a slightly different approach to talk about another rich and famous person who is in hot water with the IRS.

Income tax debt relief: Even the rich and famous have income tax debt problems

We have previously written about rich and famous people who have debt problems and who have filed for bankruptcy. Their debt problems arose mainly out of irresponsible spending, financial mismanagement and income tax problems. These blogs were written to show you that it is not only ordinary people who run into trouble. People who many would think to have “all the money in the world” can also have financial problems. Financial mismanagement is not only an illness of the poor or middle class. It can strike anywhere or anyone.

Income tax debt relief: Some of our past rich and famous financial disaster blogs

Our previous financial mismanagement of the rich and famous includes:

FAMOUS CELEBRITY BANKRUPTCIES HAPPEN TOO

In this blog, I pointed out that many rich and famous people have gone bankrupt, including:

  • Samuel Clemens (Mark Twain)
  • Michael Jackson
  • Abraham Lincoln
  • Dorothy Hamill – Gold Medal Skater
  • Johnny Unitas – Football Hall of Fame
  • Milton Hershey – Founder Hershey’s
  • H.J. Heinz – Founder Heinz
  • Marvin Gaye
  • Mick Fleetwood – Fleetwood Mac
  • Walt Disney
  • Larry King
  • Burt Reynolds
  • PT Barnum
  • Tom Petty
  • David Cassidy
  • David Crosby
  • Ed McMahon
  • Henry Ford
  • M.C. Hammer
  • Toni Braxton
  • Natalie Cole
  • Robin Williams
  • 78% of former NFL players have gone bankrupt or are under financial stress because of joblessness or divorce within two years of retirement.
  • The National Endowment for Financial Education says that 70% of all people who suddenly receive large amounts of money will lose it within a few years.

FORMER PRO ATHLETES WHO ARE BROKE: EARN OVER $400 MILLION & GO BANKRUPT?

In this blog, I talked about former pro athletes who are broke. Former NBA star and broadcaster Charles Barkley estimates that 60% – 70% of professional athletes go broke for all or any of the following reasons:

  • Buying lavish gifts and giving money to family and friends
  • Unsupportable lifestyles
  • Mansions around the world
  • Yachts
  • Exotic cars
  • Bad business ventures
  • Bad money managers
  • Not understanding financial matters
  • Zero savings
  • No rainy day fund
  • No retirement plan

DEBT FORGIVENESS CRA: CANADA REVENUE AGENCY BEATS DONOVAN BAILEY

In this blog, I wrote about Canadian Olympian. Donovan Bailey and his income tax debt problems with Canada Revenue Agency (CRA). We also described his income tax debt relief settlement plan to cut his income tax debt.. It seems that Mr. Bailey was not able to outrun CRA. Therefore he needed a formal debt settlement plan.

DEBT SETTLEMENT VS CONSUMER PROPOSAL CANADA: ENGLISH REALITY TV STAR KATIE PRICE NEEDS

This blog was about UK celebrity Katie Price who had many financial problems. I spoke about her financial issues and her UK bankruptcy proceedings.

Income tax debt relief: Dionne Warwick

Grammy Award-winning vocalist Dionne Warwick has filed for bankruptcy because she was in need of income tax debt relief. The 72-year-old vocalist, well-known for hits such as “Do You Know the Way to San Jose” and “That’s What Friends Are For” submitted the bankruptcy documents in New Jersey, where she lives.

She listed assets of $25,500 and liabilities of greater than $10.7 million in her bankruptcy filing. Her largest debt is income tax debt of near $7 million owed in back tax obligations to the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) as well as greater than $3 million in tax obligations to the state of California. This includes interest and penalties.

She declared her present income as $20,950 a month, with monthly expenditures just $10 less than that. Dionne Warwick’s press agent, Kevin Sasaki, claimed that the vocalist’s personal bankruptcy was primarily the outcome of “irresponsible and gross financial mismanagement” in the late 1980s to the mid-1990s.

Income tax debt relief: Start 2019 off the right way

No one likes to pay taxes, but everyone hates having CRA tax debt problems. Do you require CRA debt forgiveness? If you’re considering bankruptcy because of income tax debt, or for any reason. We can show you bankruptcy alternatives to get CRA debt forgiveness. We can end your debt pain through a consumer proposal, debt consolidation, and credit counselling. Contact a professional that you can trust – Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc.

The Ira Smith Team has decades and generations of experience dealing with diverse issues and complex files, including negotiating with CRA. We deliver the highest quality of professional service. Don’t settle for less. Give us a call today and Starting Over, Starting Now you can overcome your financial difficulties.

Again I wish all of you a healthy, happy and prosperous New Year.

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

BANKRUPTCY BLOG REVIEW: A LOOK AT MY TOP 2018 BANKRUPTCY BLOGS

Bankruptcy blog review: Introduction

I hope that you are all enjoying quality family time together over the holidays. As 2018 is nearly over, I thought that it would be interesting to do a bankruptcy blog review on my Brandon’s Blog. So here is a review of the 7 most viewed blogs over the past year.

Bankruptcy blog review: The 7 most viewed blogs in 2018

BANKRUPTCY AND INSOLVENCY ACT: COURT MAY NOT LISTEN TO BANKRUPTCY TRUSTEE

This blog was about a very interesting case decided in the Court of Appeal of British Columbia. The bankrupt’s creditors applied to have the transactions reviewed under section I00 of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. B-3 (“BIA”). One of the areas of contention was that the judge in the lower court found he could not rely on the bankruptcy trustee’s opinion of value in the circumstances.

MORTGAGE LENDING CRITERIA SELF EMPLOYED: BIGGEST MYTH MAY BE RIGHT

In this Brandon’s Blog, I wrote about mortgage lending criteria self-employed, I discussed a Court decision that shows when it comes to a self-employed person’s mortgage, if there is a deemed trust claim by Canada Revenue Agency (CRA), you cannot solely rely upon the registry system.


STALKING HORSE CREDIT BID: WE NEED COURT APPROVAL BEFORE STARTING A COURT SUPERVISED SALES PROCESS

This bankruptcy blog review post came from our corporate case files. I discussed the decision making process the Court goes through when being asked to approve a stalking horse sales process and the stalking horse credit bid being recommended by the licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a bankruptcy trustee).


CREDIT KARMA CANADA REVIEW: IS IT REALLY FREE AND LEGITIMATE?

Since 2007, Credit Karma USA has attempted to simplify credit and finance for more than 60 million Credit Karma members. They advertise very heavily on US television to attract new members. Becoming a member is free, and it allows any member to get access to their free credit score and credit report, with the option to update every single week. Credit Karma also provides financial education to put credit into context.

Credit Karma Canada arrived this past year from the United States. Its website is creditkarma.ca. The purpose of this blog was to describe what Credit Karma Canada is and to let you decide if it would be helpful or not for you or someone you know.


IS GOODWILL A NON PROFIT ORGANIZATION? ARE YOU SCARED BECAUSE YOUR COMPANY HAS TURNED INTO ONE?

 

The Goodwill Toronto bankruptcy confused and astonished many people. After all, how can Goodwill, a non-profit organization, go bankrupt? Isn’t the very nature of a non-profit or not-for-profit that it doesn’t have to make a profit? This Brandon’s Blog discussed the issues.


FILING FOR BANKRUPTCY IN CANADA: MENTAL HEALTH & DISCHARGED BANKRUPTCY

 

This bankruptcy blogspot dealt with filing for bankruptcy in Canada and the bankruptcy discharge process when mental health issues are involved.


POOR CREDIT PERSONAL LOANS GUARANTEED APPROVAL CANADA: REDUCE AND DON’T INCREASE DEBT TO IMPROVE YOUR CREDIT SCORE

 

This Brandon’s Blog was a discussion about and a warning against being seduced by ads from companies for poor credit personal loans guaranteed approval. We pointed out the pitfalls of the products being offered. We also showed how people with poor credit can go about settling their debts and improving their credit score.

 

Bankruptcy blog review: Conclusion

 

These are my 7 top viewed Brandon’s Blogs in 2018. Four are about personal debt issues or personal bankruptcy blog items and three are about corporate insolvency issues. Three are about a review of a then-recent court case.

I hope that the year 2019 will be a happy, healthy and prosperous New Year for you and your families.

Have you taken on too much debt in 2018 or the years before? Is the pain and stress of too much debt now negatively affecting your health?

If so, contact the Ira Smith Team today. We have decades and generations of helping people and companies in need of financial restructuring and counselling. As a licensed insolvency trustee (formerly known as a bankruptcy trustee), we are the only professionals licensed and supervised by the Federal government to provide debt settlement and financial restructuring services.

We offer a free consultation to help you solve your problems. We understand your pain that debt causes. We can also eliminate it right away from your life. This will allow you to begin a fresh start, Starting Over Starting Now. Call the Ira Smith Team today so that we can begin helping you and get you back into a healthy, stress-free life.bankruptcy blog review

 

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

WEPPA CALCULATION CANADA: EMPLOYEES’ WEPP MONEY INCREASES ON EMPLOYER BANKRUPTCY OR RECEIVERSHIP

weppa calculation canada

WEPPA calculation:  Introduction

As part of the Federal Budget 2018, the Wage Earner Protection Program Act calculation (WEPPA calculation) has increased the maximum payout.  We have written before about the Wage Earner Protection Program Act (WEPPA).  However, to understand the recent change, it would make sense for me to check again what the WEPPA is.

How did it arise?

A change to the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA) developed a device for employees of an employer that entered either bankruptcy or receivership to be paid for wages or benefit claims owed, built up in the 6 months before the company became bankrupt or was put into receivership.

The WEPPA became legislation because of the federal government’s previous worry that when you experienced “my firm owes me money and declared bankruptcy” there was seldom a possibility for workers to get any of the salaries owed.

WEPPA calculation:  Who can’t file?

.Nevertheless, you are normally not qualified if, throughout the duration for which qualified earnings are overdue, you:

  • were a director or officer of the company;
  • had a management position in the company; or
  • were management whose duties consisted of making financial decisions and/or making binding choices on the settlement or non-payment of amounts owing.

WEPPA calculation Canada: Who is qualified for the WEPP?

You might be if:

  • your previous company has actually entered bankruptcy or receivership; and
  • you have unpaid wages, salaries, vacation pay or reimburse expenses from the company during the 6 months prior to the date of bankruptcy or receivership.

WEPPA calculation:  Budget 2018 maximum payout increase

The WEPPA gives financial backing to Canadian employees, owed money when their company goes into either bankruptcy or receivership. The WEPPA offers a prompt settlement of qualified earnings.  The amount of qualified earnings is an amount equal to 4 weeks maximum insurable earnings under the Employment Insurance Act ($3,977 for 2018).

The Federal government in its Budget 2018 stated that the maximum payout would be increased by raising the maximum settlement from 4 weeks to 7 weeks of insurable revenues, which will amount to $6,960 in 2018.  This is a boost of nearly $3,000 for each former employee. The rise to the maximum payout received Royal Assent on December 13, 2018. This increased calculation is retroactive for bankruptcies or receiverships that happened on or after February 27, 2018, the day Budget 2018 was tabled.

Receivers and licensed insolvency trustees (LIT) (formerly called bankruptcy trustees) are obliged to tell employees of the Wage Earner Protection (WEPP) program and give employees details about amounts owing to them. From the day of bankruptcy or receivership, trustees and receivers have 45 days to send Trustee Information Forms showing the amounts owing to employees.  Employees have 56 days to send their Service Canada WEPP application to the WEPP. The present handling time for a WEPP settlement is within 35 days of receipt of a finished WEPP Canada application and Trustee Information Form.

WEPPA calculation:  Do you have way too much debt?


Have you lost your job because your employer went into bankruptcy or receivership?  Is the pain and stress of too much debt now negatively affecting your health?

If so, contact the Ira Smith Team today.  We have decades and generations of helping people and companies in need of financial restructuring and counselling.  As a licensed insolvency trustee, we are the only professionals licensed and supervised by the Federal government to provide debt settlement and financial restructuring services.

We offer a free consultation to help you solve your problems.  We understand your pain that debt causes. We can also end it right away from your life.  This will allow you to begin a fresh start, Starting Over Starting Now. Call the Ira Smith Team today so that we can begin helping you and get you back into a healthy, stress-free life.

To all my readers, I wish you and your family a very Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays.

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

FINANCIAL LITERACY BOOKS ARE GREAT BUT MAY NOT BE YOUR BEST RESOURCE

Financial literacy books: Introduction


The power of today’s technology enables one to discover ways to learn without needing to look very hard for it. The Internet has changed the ways we learn and in general, approach life. To gain financial literacy, financial literacy books are now merely one of many ways we can use to improve our financial acumen.

The academic system, for the most part, still uses classical teaching methods. As a standard, literacy is defined as the ability to write and read. Financial literacy is the ability of people to learn and understand basic financial concepts, strategies and information.

Unfortunately, financial literacy is not so common after all. With 21st century education, financial reading and financial writing can be used to make financial liberty. Financial literacy ought to not be a far-flung idea for people, starting at a very young age.

Financial literacy books: Think differently

In his best-selling book “What I Didn’t Learn in School however I Wish I Had“, author Jamie McIntyre talks about the relevance of financial literacy and 21st-century education. From the title of his book, he freely tells us that we are not discovering what could have been general information for success. The standard view forces the most people to be and follow a structure in a system before all the modern tools available to us today.

As a self-made millionaire, Jamie McIntyre advocates that to be a financial success, people need to be doing the opposite of what others have actually been doing for so long. By being financially literate, we can find reasons why people fail and discover ways to avoid these factors.

Financial literacy transcends the standard read-write approach. By having a different method or viewpoint to one’s life, financial literacy can be used to establish various monetary strategies with the hope of accomplishing financial flexibility.

Financial literacy books: There are many methods to increase financial literacy

To become financially literate, there are many ways people historically have learned about finance, with some new ones. I think some people would say that we can take financial courses or try to get the best financial advice from the best financial advisor. Others may suggest to read the best financial advice books of all time or go to the most popular money advice websites.

However, a research paper released in September 2018, may just give us a glimpse into a different way of gaining financial literacy.

Financial literacy books: What is financial literacy?

Financial literacy is the ability of people to get an understanding when it comes to standard monetary strategies and information. With 21st century education, financial reading and monetary writing can be used to obtain monetary flexibility. Financial literacy needs to not be a far-flung idea for individuals of any age.

Financial literacy books: A new research study

A brand-new research study discovered that people with reduced financial knowledge have a tendency to find out more and make far better choices about money if they are helped by peers that have comparable degrees of financial expertise. This is the case more than if they read financial literacy books or got financial advice from people with much more financial experience and knowledge.

The study, Peer Advice on Financial Decisions: A case of the blind leading the blind?, was released in September 2018. The research showed that the majority of university undergrads with little financial acumen learned better after looking for help from a peer that was in a similar way unenlightened and not somebody having a lot more financial savviness.

While this may strike you as being strange, the study described why it makes good sense. Learning was better between people who can understand and had the patience for each other’s learning gaps stated Professor Sandro Ambuehl, a co-author of the research and an assistant prof at the University of Toronto’s Rotman School of Management. His fellow researchers are B. Douglas Bernheim of Stanford University, Fulya Ersoy of Loyola Marymount University and Donna Harris of the University of Oxford.

Financial literacy books: A new way of learning

What this suggests to me is that one of the best ways to teach financial literacy is to start in the elementary schools and continue it throughout high school. Let groups of students interact with their peers to learn together on age proper financial and investment definitions, terms, subjects and strategies. The study suggests that and not leaving it up to people to try to learn it for themselves, promoting learning in peer groups, may be the easiest and most efficient way for learning financial literacy.

Our provincial governments should be taking the lead in encouraging our teachers to start teaching financial literacy to children at a very young age. The study indicates that by having peers work in groups to learn about financial matters, may just be the way for us to have more financially literate adults and a society that has great financial literacy. Peer groups working together to increase their financial knowledge may just be the best resource.

Financial literacy books: Do you have too much debt?

Do you feel that you don’t have sufficient financial literacy? Do you believe that the lack of knowledge has led to you making financial mistakes? Have these mistakes caused you to now have too much debt? Is the pain and stress of too much debt now negatively affecting your health?

If so, contact the Ira Smith Team today. We have decades and generations of helping people and companies in need of financial restructuring and counselling. As a licensed insolvency trustee (formerly known as a bankruptcy trustee), we are the only professionals licensed and supervised by the Federal government to provide debt settlement and financial restructuring services.

We offer a free consultation to help you solve your problems. We understand your pain that debt causes. We can also end it right away from your life. This will allow you to begin a fresh start, Starting Over Starting Now. Call the Ira Smith Team today so that we can begin helping you and get you back into a healthy, stress-free life.financial literacy books

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

HOW BANKRUPTCIES WORK FOR BUSINESSES IN TORONTO AND VAUGHAN ONTARIO CANADA

How bankruptcies work for businesses: Introduction

how bankruptcies work for businesses

How bankruptcies work for businesses: Introduction

Recently I have written several blogs focussing on insolvency and specifically the topics of consumer proposal and personal bankruptcy. To round out the discussion, this Brandon’s Blog discusses how bankruptcies work for businesses in Canada.

To be clear, the goal for either personal bankruptcy or corporate bankruptcy is to avoid bankruptcy. We have many tools in our toolbox to help people and companies avoid bankruptcy through restructuring. It is only when the person has stewed over their personal or business problems for too long that they come to us when it is too late. When it is too late, our hands are tied for creative problem-solving.

How bankruptcies work for businesses: Where we start

When a business owner comes to our office for a free consultation, we start with some basics. The first thing we do is ask certain questions that will allow us to get a financial snapshot of the business. We need to know about the assets and liabilities of the business.

We need to understand who all the creditors are and what the assets are. Which creditors may have a deemed trust claim or a secured claim against the assets. What is the total and nature of the unsecured debts?

That information tells us what choices we may have in helping the business recover: is an informal debt settlement restructuring possible;

what do we think about the likelihood of a formal restructuring under either the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (R.S.C., 1985, c. B-3) (BIA) or the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act (R.S.C., 1985, c. C-36) (CCAA); or is the business too far gone and therefore bankruptcy or just shutting down are the only options remaining.

How bankruptcies work for businesses: The proprietorship

If the business is unincorporated, then the person is carrying on their business in the form of a proprietorship. They are conducting business in their personal name. They may use a business style, but the legal reality of a proprietorship is that the individual, in their personal capacity, is carrying on business. So, the assets and liabilities that are created in the business, is owned by and is the responsibility of the person.

So, in this situation, it will be a personal insolvency discussion. The available remedies will be:

  • an informal restructuring;
  • (consumer) proposal debt settlement plan; or
  • personal bankruptcy

If you wish to find out more about personal insolvency, or how bankruptcies work for individuals, you can read some of my previous blogs. Good examples are WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN BANKRUPTCY AND INSOLVENCY CANADA or CANADIAN DEBT SOLUTIONS: AVOIDING THE BANKRUPTCY PROCESS MIGHT BE THE RIGHT THING.

How bankruptcies work for businesses: Incorporated businesses

So now we have gone through the starting point I just described and we have determined that we are dealing with an incorporated business. We first focus on many issues before even discussing how bankruptcies work for companies.

First, we want to know how well does management understand its own business problems. If management does not have a good handle on their business problems, then they first need to get that deep understanding. They may know that monthly when looking at the numbers, they see that losses are continuing. Management, especially in an entrepreneurial or family-owned company, may feel ashamed because they don’t feel like they’ve made good decisions. Or they are aggravated and embarrassed because family members have told you the company is finished.

If you know in your heart that if you do not do something today, you may be risking the entire business.

How bankruptcies work for businesses: Know your numbers

To restructure companies for a successful turnaround, you first need to know your numbers and what they mean. The goal is to have the company producing sufficient cash levels and for everyone in the business to be earning a fair market-based income.

Management must look at the entire business and ask:

  • Where’s the profit?.
  • Do we have the money to actually run and scale the business?
  • What is getting in the way for the business to charge the revenue its products or services are worth?
  • Do we have the necessary cash and people resources will we need for a turnaround?
  • Are there lines of business or locations that need to be shed to increase profitability?
  • What expenses can we cut without harming our core business?
  • Which contracts do we need to cut to return to profitability and growth?
  • Do we have the proper reporting systems to give us the information we need to get prompt and accurate information?
  • Can we properly analyze the business issues and take the necessary corrective action?
  • Do we have the right people to carry on the business while implementing the turnaround?
  • Are we experienced enough to carry out our own turnaround or do we need outside professionals to help us with it?
  • Do we know what the impediments are to having a successful informal restructuring or do we need to look at a formal restructuring process?

How bankruptcies work for businesses: Now that we have the information…

These are the main questions that first must be answered for any business experiencing financial difficulties and facing insolvency. This is especially true for more complex companies. New systems or techniques may need to be implemented. If management can answer these questions for themselves, we want to hear those answers. If not, then a financial advisor may need to be retained. My Firm has been regularly retained, either by a company or its lender, to answer these questions and provide our recommendations. This kind of assignment is called a Business Viability Review.

After we provide our recommendations, we then work with the company to help them decide if they can carry out the recommendations and strategies themselves, or if they need our help to do so. If management can do it on their own, many times the lender will want us to stay involved by monitoring the company’s progress and reporting back to both the company and the lender.

How bankruptcies work for businesses: What if informal restructuring isn’t possible

The aim is always to avoid bankruptcy but it’s practical to recognize what it is and when it could be suitable. Companies are complex organisms. There may be the need to shed unprofitable contracts or long-term agreements that are just too expensive to continue with. It may be that disposing of such onerous contracts, leases or agreements is crucial to have a viable ongoing business. Many times a formal restructuring process is necessary to legally end those types of agreements.

It is the largest of company restructurings that we hear about in the news. From the United States, we read about Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection filings. In Canada, we read about restructurings under the CCAA. The largest of companies do not represent the size of the majority of Canadian companies.

For the biggest of companies, they can get relief and press back on creditors. There is an old adage which says: “If you owe the bank a bit of money, they own you. If you owe the bank a huge amount of money, you own them.”. In that way, in the largest company restructurings, the business can get a long time to either sell particular assets where the cash will help them rebound. They will also get the time they need to “rightsize” their employee numbers and shed unprofitable contracts. Loan changes with their secured lender or banking syndicate is also on the table and accomplished, more often than not. Their sheer size demands it and they get it.

How bankruptcies work for businesses: The reality for the majority of Canadian companies

Canadian business is full of entrepreneur-owned companies. So, that is what I will focus on in this Brandon’s Blog. If the business owner(s) come to us early enough, then we can decide if an informal restructuring will work or if not, what needs to be done in a formal restructuring. For any business that owes less than $5 million, it will normally be a BIA restructuring debt settlement proposal. We have done many successful company restructuring proposals under the BIA.

The answers to all the questions I posted above, will tell us what the restructuring needs to look like, how long it will take, and what our projections show about the profitability and viability of the business after a successful implementation of the restructuring plan.

How bankruptcies work for businesses: Company bankruptcy

In a company bankruptcy, the Licensed Insolvency Trustee (formerly called a bankruptcy trustee) (Trustee) takes possession of the assets, properties, and undertakings of the company. This assumes that there are not secured creditors who have all the assets of the company tied up. If there are, then the company may not need to go into bankruptcy. Rather, a secured creditor will take enforcement action by making a demand on the insolvent company. However, if the loan is not repaid in time, then the secured lender will appoint a receiver to take possession of the assets covered by the lender’s security. In Canada, this is normally a Chartered Bank and all the assets are secured.

Sometimes a company in receivership needs to also file for bankruptcy. The main reason would be to aid in maximizing the recovery on the assets. For example, the company is a retail chain. The only way to maximize the recovery is to run the business and sell off the assets from one or more stores. One way to guarantee quiet enjoyment of the stores the receiver needs to stay in is to have a bankruptcy. That is because, under Provincial commercial tenancy law, a trustee in bankruptcy has a certain time to stay in the premises, undisturbed, as long as the current rent is paid.

How bankruptcies work for businesses: Receivership or bankruptcy

Whether there is a receivership or bankruptcy, there are many steps that a receiver or trustee have in common. These include:

  • Determining whether or not the recovery on assets will be maximized if the business is operated by the receiver or Trustee.
  • What impediments are there in running the business?
  • What is the best way to sell off the assets? As an entire group or parcels of assets that make sense to keep together, or one by one?
  • Are there any third party assets not owned by the company on the premises or other locations?
  • Are there assets owned by the company in any other locations?
  • Is there proper insurance and physical security over the assets?
  • Once the assets are sold and the cash received, what claims are there against the funds and what is the priority of all the potential claimants?

How bankruptcies work for businesses: The entrepreneurial company reality

Most mid-size and small companies when they’re in difficulty, do not submit a formal restructuring plan or file for bankruptcy at all. They just shut down by closing the doors. The owner will get the company’s final income tax and other information returns completed and filed. They will make sure that employee wages are paid current. Hopefully, source deductions and HST are fully paid up.

Wages, source deductions and/or HST that are not fully paid, are a personal liability of the Directors of the company. In the entrepreneurial companies, the owner(s) have probably personally guaranteed bank loans, premises and equipment leases or have raised funds to start and invest in the business by taking out at a mortgage against their home.

This brings us to the reality of most midsize and small businesses. The business failure leads to personal insolvency issues. Many times we advise entrepreneurs that their company filing an assignment in bankruptcy is not necessary. Rather, they should just shut down their business and then we will deal with their personal insolvency issues. This will allow the entrepreneur to get a fresh start.

Now what is required is getting a job in their field and earning a salary without the risk and challenges of running their own business. Once they get their fresh start, are back on their feet and saved up some money, they can decide if being an employee or starting a new business will be their future.

How bankruptcies work for businesses: Does your company have too much debt?

Is your company insolvent and needs to restructure? Is your business viable but can only continue if it can reorganize its debt? We know your pain and understand the stress you are living with. The Ira Smith Team has decades and generations of experience in company restructurings of all sizes.

Contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Team. If we can meet with you in our free first consultation early enough, we can create and help you start a restructuring and turnaround plan. This will allow your company to continue to do business, create jobs and be profitable for many years to come.

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

CONSUMER PROPOSAL CANADA PART OF BANKRUPTCIES LAWS IN ONTARIO?

Introduction

I prepared this vlog to explain the differences between a consumer proposal (CP), one of the bankruptcies laws in Ontario and bankruptcy. This discussion is based on the inquiries that we are asked often. Hopefully, this information will help you understand better specifically what a CP debt settlement strategy is and how it will certainly assist you to remove all your financial obligations. All this while AVOIDING personal bankruptcy.

Main benefits of a CP

Take into consideration several of the benefits of the CP vs. bankruptcy:

    • Unlike informal debt negotiation, the CP creates a forum where every one of your unsecured creditors must take part in for your debt restructuring.
    • You keep your property.
    • Legal actions against you on your property and debts, such as wage garnishments, cannot continue.
    • You do not require to file an assignment in bankruptcy

CP vs. bankruptcy

How do I recognize if I have a financial problem?

If you are having difficulty satisfying your debts or have actually quit paying them, you are probably insolvent. Another sign of insolvency is that if your assets if liquidated, will not bring in enough money to pay off your debts. When you are all stressed out over the money you owe, for sure you will know that you have financial problems.

How do I know if I qualify for either a CP or bankruptcy?

Any person that is insolvent and owes greater than $1,000 is qualified to file either a CP or an assignment in bankruptcy in Canada.

Will I have to give up my assets?

As soon as you file for bankruptcy you will certainly have to give up your non-exempt property to the Trustee. These possessions will be marketed and sold. The cash from the sale of your property will be used to pay for the cost of the bankruptcy administration. The balance will be dispersed among your creditors.

In CP, you will not be giving up your assets. You are making an offer to your creditors less than the total amount you owe. According to the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (R.S.C., 1985, c. B-3) (BIA), your CP has to be a better result for your unsecured creditors than they would receive in your bankruptcy.

What occurs to my wages or salary?

Nothing. You receive it as normal.

In a CP that has been (deemed) accepted by your creditors and approved by the Court, you begin to make your payments. There are no other requirements for your income in CP.

In bankruptcy, nothing happens to your income either. However, in a bankruptcy, unlike a CP, your Trustee at the outset has to decide if you are required to make voluntary contributions to your bankruptcy case based off of your income. If so, this is called a surplus income requirement. Also, you will have to file monthly statements of income and expense with the Trustee. Your surplus income requirement can change, depending on if your income goes up or down. There is no such requirement in CP.

Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) has frozen my bank account and has garnished my earnings. Exactly how can I deal with that?

As stated above, once you file a CP, there is a stay of proceedings. Upon receiving notice from the Trustee, CRA stops the garnishee process and lifts the freeze on your account(s). The same is true in bankruptcy.

Will I still owe money after I declare bankruptcy or file a CP?

Perhaps, because of neither a CP nor bankruptcy covers:

How much time will I be under the insolvency proceeding?

The duration of time in bankruptcy will depend on whether this is an initial or 2nd (or more) bankruptcy, whether you have to pay surplus income and if your discharge is opposed or not. Depending on your circumstances, it can be anywhere from 9 months to many years.

In a CP, you can take up to 60 months to pay the total amount you promised to pay. Payments in a CP are required monthly.

Will anyone find out that I have filed either a CP or for bankruptcy?

As soon as you file for bankruptcy or a CP, your Trustee must file a notification with the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy Canada (OSB) to start either process. The OSB does run a public database showing the status of all files.

In either a CP or bankruptcy, your Trustee must send a notice to all of your creditors. So they will know.

In a CP or a shortened summary administration bankruptcy, the Trustee does not place a legal notice in the local newspaper advertising that you filed. In an ordinary administration bankruptcy, the Trustee must publish a notice.

Generally, it is only the OSB, your Trustee and your creditors who are aware of your filing.

Is my partner or spouse impacted by my CP or bankruptcy?

Your partner/spouse will not be impacted by your CP or bankruptcy unless he/she co-signed as a borrower or has guaranteed payment for any of your debts. If they have guaranteed some or all of your debts, then those specific creditors can ask your spouse for payment in full.

NOTE: There is a body of case-law to suggest that if your CP is fully performed, then there is no debt left for your guarantor to make good on. That type of discussion is too technical for this general blog. If you are in this situation, your spouse should get legal advice before agreeing to pay anything. No such argument could even be considered in a bankruptcy situation.

Just how will my CP or bankruptcy impact my existing divorce case?

In Canada, CP and bankruptcy filings do not conflict with the majority of the divorce procedures. In a bankruptcy, the Trustee will stand in the shoes of the bankrupt spouse. Ontario is an equalization Province; not a division of assets Province. If the bankrupt spouse is entitled to an equalization payment, that will come to the Trustee.

In a CP, the Trustee does not get involved at all in any way. The BIA does not interfere at all with non-financial divorce issues such as custody. It also does not have any effect on support or alimony.

Consumer Proposal Canada or bankruptcy: Conclusion

I hope this consumer proposal discussion about the differences between a Consumer Proposal Canada and bankruptcy has been helpful to you.

Do you have severe debt and don’t know where to begin to fix it? Are your debt issues causing you to lose sleep? Is too much debt triggering stress and anxiety, discomfort and pain? We know that discomfort better than anyone and we can get it out of your life.

If so, call the Ira Smith Team today. We have years and generations of experience helping people and companies seeking financial restructuring or a debt settlement strategy. As a licensed insolvency trustee, we are the only specialists recognized, accredited and supervised by the Federal government to give insolvency advice and remedies to assist you and to prevent bankruptcy.

Call the Ira Smith Team today so you can end the stress and anxiety financial problems create. With the special roadmap, we will develop with and special to you, we will promptly return you right into a healthy, balanced hassle-free life.

You can have a no-cost appointment to assist you so we can fix your debt troubles. Call the Ira Smith Team today. This will certainly allow you to make a fresh start, Starting Over Starting Now.

consumer proposal bankruptcies laws in ontario

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

EMPLOYEE BENEFITS CANADA: ENHANCING RETIREMENT SECURITY IN CANADIAN INSOLVENCY AND BANKRUPTCY

,employee benefits canada

If you prefer, you can listen to the employee benefits Canada podcast.  Please scroll down to the bottom of the page for the audio.

Employee benefits Canada:  Introduction

The Federal government supports the proposition that Canadians are entitled to a risk-free, safe, secure and sensible retired life.  Corporate financial troubles have increased problems about the safety of pension plan, wage and benefit payments for employees and senior citizens.   Employee benefits Canada is now being looked at by the Federal government.

The most recent case that has brought these issues to the forefront has been the Sears Canada liquidation.  Federal politicians have sponsored several private member’s bills which have now caught the serious attention of our Federal government.    Two such Bills were brought forward by Hamilton Mountain NDP MP Scott Duvall and Senator Art Eggleton.  The Federal government wants to make employee benefits Canada news.

Employee benefits Canada: My previous blogs

I have written on the issue in several blogs:

  1. TORONTO BUSINESS BANKRUPTCY PROTECTION: NDP WANTS FEDERAL INSOLVENCY LAWS CHANGED SO THERE IS PENSION PLAN SECURITY WHEN FINANCIALLY TROUBLED BUSINESSES FAIL – September 27, 2017
  2. SEARS CANADA IS CLOSING: THE #1 REASON YOU HAVE TO RUN AND NOT JUST WALK TO REDEEM YOUR GIFT CARDS AND CREDITS – October 18, 2017
  3. SEARS CANADA CLOSING: POLITICIANS WANT NEW LAWS TO PROTECT PENSIONERS DUE TO SEARS CANADA CLOSING – November 1, 2017
  4. SEARS CANADA DEFINED BENEFIT PENSION PLAN SHORTFALL: MP SCOTT DUVALL COMES THROUGH ON HIS PROMISE IN CANADIAN PARLIAMENT – November 8, 2017
  5. CORPORATE BANKRUPTCIES CANADA: SENATOR EGGLETON PROPOSES NEW PENSION FUND CANADA LAW – October 22, 2018

Arising out of certain policy statements in the Fall 2018 Budget, the Federal government is looking for responses from pensioners, employees, firms, professionals and various other stakeholders to take a macro, evidence-based strategy to try to provide better-retired life protection for all Canadians.

Employee benefits Canada: Canada’s retirement income system

Canada’s retirement income system (RIS) is currently based upon 3 columns:

  1. Old Age Security (OAS) and the Guaranteed Income Supplement (GIS) give a fundamental degree of retired life earnings.Canada Pension (CPP) gives standard a certain wage substitute for employees, funded by payments from employees, companies and the self-employed.
  2. Employer-based pension – Defined Benefit (DB) and Defined Contribution (DC)).
  3. Income tax-assisted personal saving vehicles, such as Registered Retired Savings Plan (RRSP) and Tax-Free Savings Accounts (TFSA).

Employee benefits Canada:  Insolvency and Bankruptcy Law

In 2008-2009, the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (R.S.C., 1985, c. B-3) (BIA) and the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act (R.S.C., 1985, c. C-36) (CCAA) was changed.  Under the BIA, in a receivership or bankruptcy, arrears of wages was given a super-priority.  Approximately $2,000 per staff member must be paid before secured creditors. Any unfunded normal employer pension plan contributions (as distinct from any unfunded pension liability determined by an actuarial evaluation) also have a super-priority in either a bankruptcy or receivership.  

As far as a corporate restructuring proposal under the BIA, the amendment also states that the Court cannot approve any Proposal that does not provide for the same treatment.  The CCAA was similarly modified to be consistent with corporate restructuring under the BIA.

Employee benefits Canada: Corporate governance

The Canada Business Corporations Act (CBCA) supplies the fundamental business administration structure for Federally incorporated companies.  Although good corporate governance is important for all business stakeholders, it must be followed and implemented to be of any use.

As I indicated above, the Sears Canada defined benefit pension plan shortfall has caused the Federal government to now look at a variety of options to try to better protect employees and retirees for both pensions and benefits.

Employee benefits Canada:  The Feds are looking for stakeholder comments

The Federal government wants to listen to the thoughts of stakeholders on what further actions that might be embraced to boost retired life safety for workers and senior citizens impacted by company bankruptcy.  Specifically, the Federal government wants stakeholder response on increased security for workers’ claims in insolvencies, including changing the BIA and CCAA to make sure that there is a super-priority to pay unfunded pension plan contributions and benefits claims ahead of the claims of secured creditors.

Many options are being considered that the Federal government wants stakeholder comments on by the end of this year.

Employee benefits Canada:  Pension options being looked at

Possible pension options being considered are:

  • Solvency reserves: A solvency reserve is an account the employer could contribute to so that pension deficits can be eliminated.   I doubt this would work. If the company could afford to pay into a solvency reserve, they could also afford to just pay off the pension payment deficit.
  • Pension plan financing relief: The Minister of Finance has the authority to offer companies with pension plan financing relief to assist in the long-term survival of the company pension. The Minister’s authority could be boosted to assist companies with a pension plan deficit experiencing financial problems.  This type of help, being a moratorium on pension payments, could come with specific conditions. Such special conditions could include a moratorium on the payment of dividends, share redemptions and senior executive bonuses.
  • Self-managed accounts: Upon the bankruptcy of the company, the DB plan ends.  In that case, the only option is to transfer each former employees’ respective entitlement to purchase an annuity.  So, the expected benefit will never materialize because of the underfunding. Federal pension legislation (and provincial legislation to follow) could provide extra options.  It could allow rolling over of each entitlement into a self-managed plan such as an RRSP.  This way there is an opportunity to recoup some of the lost benefits over time.

Employee benefits Canada:  Corporate governance options being looked at

  • Limitations on the company: Dividends, share redemptions and senior management bonuses could be restricted under the CBCA in situations where a company is in arrears of pension contributions.  Once the arrears are caught up, then such special payments could continue. As federally incorporated companies are the minority of all companies in Canada. The Provinces would also have to invoke similar legislation.  An annual filing mechanism, perhaps through the Canada Revenue Agency, would also have to be established so that companies could be monitored.

Employee benefits Canada:  Bankruptcy and insolvency options being looked at

  • Increased “look-back” time: The BIA permits a court to reverse dividends paid or share redemptions made by an insolvent company within one year preceding the date of bankruptcy. The BIA and CCAA additionally allow a court to invalidate reviewable transaction (transfers at undervalue) by the Debtor as much as 5 years prior to the insolvency. In order to further connect corporate behaviour with employee interests, the “look-back” period in the BIA and the CCAA can be amended to include the unwinding of executive benefits, dividend payments and share redemptions at a time when there were also unfunded pension liabilities. The legislation could be amended to state that the recovered funds must go to paying down the pension payment arrears.  I would also go one step further to make the amount approved by the Directors of the corporation to be paid out while there were pension plan contribution arrears a personal liability of such Directors.
  • Improved openness in CCAA rules: In CCAA, the borrower business negotiates with its creditors on a debt settlement plan.  The process is conducted under court supervision.  The legislation could be amended so that when there is an underfunded pension plan, it would be mandatory to have legal representation for the employees who are participants in such pension plan.  This could be accomplished by amending the CCAA legislation to need that upon the motion to get the Initial Order the administrator of the pension plan must be an initial stakeholder that is consulted and served with the Initial Order motion material.  The plan administrator has the statutory right to retain legal counsel and be represented at all Court hearings.

Employee benefits Canada:  The solutions are varied and complex

As you can see, the range of possible solutions are varied and complex.  However, one thing is for sure though. The Federal government has now awoken to the issue of shareholders being enriched off of the backs of the workers.  The Sears Canada CCAA liquidation has brought the issue to the forefront. It will be very interesting to see how the Federal government proceeds in 2019.

Employee benefits Canada:  Is your company bogged down by too much debt?

Is your company under fire as a result of too much debt, including pension plan contribution arrears? Is your business looking for reorganizing to get debt alleviation?

The Ira Smith Team has years as well as generations of experience helping people and companies in financial difficulty. If your company needs a corporate restructuring debt negotiation strategy, we have the experience.  We will end your stress, anxiety and discomfort.   Whether it is a BIA or CCAA debt restructuring, we can help you.  We will return you and your company to a healthy, balanced and efficient pain-free life.

Our method for every case is to establish a remedy where Starting Over, Starting Now takes place. This begins the minute you consult with us and walk through our front door. You’re merely one telephone call away.  Therefore, with our help, you will take the required steps to go back to leading a healthy and balanced problem-free life.

Call us today for your free first consultation.

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN BANKRUPTCY AND INSOLVENCY CANADA

What is the difference between bankruptcy and insolvency Canada: Introduction

Encountering major money troubles is life-shattering, especially if you automatically think that bankruptcy is your only alternative. As a matter of fact, lots of people erroneously think that serious financial difficulties immediately suggest the only answer is bankruptcy. The most common question I am asked is, “what is the difference between bankruptcy and insolvency Canada”.

What is the difference between bankruptcy and insolvency Canada: Insolvency

If you are having problems meeting your financial obligations or have stopped meeting those financial obligations as they come due you are insolvent, not bankrupt. Insolvent is a cash flow problem; bankruptcy is a legal state. You can read a detailed discussion on the definition of being insolvent in my last week’s vlog INSOLVENT DEFINITION: A NEW FOCUS FOR TORONTO BANKRUPTCY TRUSTEE.

Bаnkruрtсу is a legal рrосеѕѕ under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (R.S.C., 1985, c. B-3) (BIA) that helps you to resolve уоur debts if they have become unmanageable. If you have relatively few assets and low іnсоmе and dесіdе to file for bаnkruрtсу, you will probably fіlе under the streamlined Summary Administration part of the BIA.

If you have realizable assets that will produce a value greater than $10,000, then your bankruptcy would be administered under the general administrative provisions. Don’t worry about these distinctions right now. For now, just know that the summary administration rules are shortened, and the cost of the bankruptcy administration is fixed by a tariff set by the Superintendent of Bankruptcy.

In either case, you will turn over to your Licensed Insolvency Trustee (“LIT”) (formerly known as a bankruptcy trustee) all уоur рrореrtу that is not exempt (protected) by law. The LIT will sell your property and the proceeds will be used to рау for the bankruptcy administration and then make a distribution to уоur сrеdіtоrѕ.

What is the difference between bankruptcy and insolvency Canada: Assets exempt in a bankruptcy in Ontario

In Ontario, where my practice is, the following assets are exempt from seizure in a personal bankruptcy:

  1. Your necessary clothing without any dollar restriction.
  2. Family furnishings and appliances up to a value of $13,150.
  3. Your tools and other personal property used to earn income from your occupation up to a value of $11,300.
  4. One vehicle with equity of no more than $6,600.
  5. Registered Retirement Savings Plan and Registered Retirement Income Fund savings, other than payments made within the 12 months immediately before the bankruptcy filing.
  6. The equity in your house if up to the amount of $10,000. Note that the current thinking is that if your equity is more than $10,000, then your exemption is zero.

If you have very little property, all of it may be рrоtесtеd so that you will not lose it.

What is the difference between bankruptcy and insolvency Canada: Surplus income

How much уоur сrеdіtоrѕ will get in this process dереndѕ on how much уоur unрrоtесtеd property can be ѕоld fоr and whether you will be required to pay “surplus income” to your LIT. For a detailed discussion on surplus income, read my May 28, 2013 blog CAN YOU REALLY HAVE SURPLUS INCOME IF YOU’RE BANKRUPT?

Among all the things that seem to perplex many people when it involves the bankruptcy procedure is surplus income. It’s tough to get your head around the concept of surplus income when you are heading towards bankruptcy. Can that really be true if you are insolvent?

What is the difference between bankruptcy and insolvency Canada: What is surplus income

Surplus income in a bankruptcy describes the amount the bankrupt must pay to the Trustee monthly. The Canadian bankruptcy system attempts to balance your right to end your debt and start over with the rights of creditors to be paid.

To permit Canadians to keep a sensible right to make a living throughout the bankruptcy administration, the federal government has established limits or standards on revenue a person can keep (after tax obligations and certain limited deductions) throughout their bankruptcy. The Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy establishes the limit restriction every year tied into the cost of living.

How do you figure surplus income?

The Federal Government establishes the formula used to calculate surplus income payments. The same formula is used for all of Canada.

The limits for surplus income are based off across the country “poverty line”. Surplus income has absolutely nothing to do with what you have left over monthly. It is a federal government formula that considers your revenue, specific non-discretionary costs as well as your household size.

The calculation is to find if you will need to contribute from your earnings monthly to your Trustee, for the benefit of your creditors.

Bankruptcy discharge

The final step of your bankruptcy process will be to get your discharge. Your discharge from bankruptcy acts as the trigger to discharge you from all of your debts. This means that you will not have to рау them (with possibly certain exceptions depending on your circumstances).

Whether you get an absolute discharge from your bankruptcy will depend essentially on your conduct. Before your bankruptcy, did you treat all your creditors the same? Does anyone feel aggrieved by your actions? That will decide if any of your creditors will oppose your discharge.

For an in-depth discussion of the personal bankruptcy discharge process, check out our vlog BANKRUPTCY DISCHARGE: THE TOP 8 THINGS THE BANKRUPTCY COURT WILL CONSIDER ON ANYONE’S BANKRUPTCY DISCHARGE APPLICATION.

Is your debt keeping you up at night?

Do you have extreme debt and have no concept of how to handle it? Are your debt woes keeping you up at night and causing you stress, pain and maybe even depression? We understand that pain and can cut it from your life.

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. has helped many companies and people throughout the Greater Toronto Area (GTA) juggling too much debt in their lives that requires a blueprint for Starting Over, Starting Now. Do not delay. Help is 1 phone call away. You can fix your financial troubles while avoiding bankruptcy as long as you take swift action. Call the Ira Smith Team today for your free consultation.what is the difference between bankruptcy and insolvency canada

Call a Trustee Now!