Tag: RRSP

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

RRSP BENEFICIARY: OUR REMARKABLE PLAN ON HOW THE INCOME TAX BILL ON DEATH FROM AN RRSP CAN BE REDUCED

rrsp beneficiary
rrsp beneficiary

We hope that you and your family are safe, healthy and secure during this coronavirus pandemic.

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. and Smith Estate Trustee Ontario are absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

If you would prefer to listen to the audio version of this Brandon Blog, please scroll to the very bottom and click play on the podcast.

RRSP beneficiary: Death of an RRSP annuitant

As I have written before, in addition to insolvency work, we also act as an independent Estate Trustee through our business Smith Estate Trustee Ontario. In our work as Estate Trustee of a deceased estate, we have come across an interesting topic when it comes to the will of the deceased and the inheritance of an RRSP beneficiary.

Understanding the tax implications of a beneficiary entitled to an RRSP inheritance can save or cost you thousands of dollars depending on how the RRSP is administered. The Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) has specific rules regarding what happens to an RRSP when its owner dies. Did you know that there are a number of tax implications that come with inheriting RRSPs? This is especially true when you are inheriting from distant relatives like grandparents, aunts, uncles, or cousins. As an assignee of a Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP), you are entitled to all of the funds in the plan, but it is possible that the account balance could be taxable.

In this Brandon Blog, I discuss the income tax ramifications on an RRSP beneficiary. By definition, since it is an RRSP available to be inherited, rather than a Registered Retirement Income Fund (RRIF) or an annuity, I am talking about:

  • someone who died before turning 72 years old; and
  • never had the opportunity to enjoy retirement.

I remind you that I am not an income tax practitioner, but rather, I am a licensed insolvency trustee. So this Brandon Blog is not meant as income tax advice and should not replace the advice of your qualified income tax advisor.

RRSP beneficiary designation: Designating your estate or other beneficiaries

Setting up an RRSP is a great way to save for retirement. You contributed to your plan each year and got a tax break from the government. This is a fantastic deal, so many people take advantage of it. If you only name the heir or heiress in your will, that should be sufficient. However, a will can be challenged. If you don’t name one at all for your plan, or if you are not a special type of grantee, there can be some serious tax implications.

The inheritor you name for your RRSP during your lifetime is the person who will receive the asset after your death. You can appoint a recipient directly in your RRSP plan document much in the way that you name one for your life insurance policy. I recommend that you do this. Do not just name your estate and then maybe name the real RRSP beneficiary in your will.

The CRA has adopted a special policy regarding the tax treatment of RRSPs. This policy is referred to as the deemed disposition rule. The deemed disposition rule applies to RRSPs. When the holder of an unmatured RRSP passes away, CRA deems that the RRSP was disposed of and the funds received, right before their death.

The calculation of the funds received is an amount equal to the reasonable market price of all the property kept in the RRSP at the time of death. This amount and any other balances the deceased got from the RRSP in the year of death need to be reported on the deceased’s year of death income tax return.

rrsp beneficiary
rrsp beneficiary

RRSP beneficiary tax implications: How can the income tax bill on death be reduced?

Understanding the tax implications of an RRSP beneficiary entitled to an RRSP inheritance can save or cost you thousands of dollars depending on how the RRSP is administered. The CRA has specific rules regarding what happens to an RRSP when its owner dies.

When a person passes away and leaves an RRSP, their estate has to pay the income tax liability on the RRSP when it’s paid to the RRSP beneficiary. However, you should first ask who is a qualified beneficiary? Eligible individuals who can qualify for such beneficiary designations are a spouse, a common-law partner, or a financially dependent (infirm) child or grandchild, they can utilize the “qualified beneficiary” RRSP exemption to reduce or remove the tax obligation. If there is no qualified beneficiary, the Estate Trustee will have to pay income tax calculated based on the entire amount of the RRSP.

So the challenges for beneficiaries, in general, are twofold: 1. Are you a qualified beneficiary? 2. Can a qualified beneficiary reduce their income tax bill?

If you inherit an RRSP, is that someone will face a tax bill from CRA on the deemed disposition on death. The RRSP value will be taxed as income. Now, there are some situations in which you can reduce or eliminate the taxes. If the RRSP beneficiary is a qualified beneficiary, then the value of the RRSP can be taxed in the hands of the RRSP beneficiary, not the deceased’s estate.

RRSP beneficiary tax: Reduce the tax by rolling over

This first step of the rollover procedure is described as a “refund of premiums”. The second step is the tax-deferral portion. Where a qualified beneficiary adds the number of assets from the deceased’s RRSP in the year received (or within the first 60 days of the next year), the qualified beneficiary can declare a tax deduction under section 60(l) of the Income Tax Act (Canada) to eliminate the RRSP amount added to their income. This manoeuvre does not require the RRSP beneficiary to have sufficient RRSP contribution room. The result? This heir or heiress becomes a successor annuitant and gets a tax-deferred rollover.

To eliminate the tax on receipt of the RRSP funds, the RRSP assets are directly moved to the qualified beneficiary‘s RRSP. At tax time, the qualified beneficiary gets a T4RSP tax slip. The qualified RRSP beneficiary then includes the date-of-death RRSP amount in their taxable income but offsets it with a section 60(l) tax reduction.

The above rollover is typically seen when a qualified beneficiary is marked as the RRSP recipient. When this happens, the RRSP proceeds generally bypass the deceased’s estate, lowering probate fees (where applicable) and side-stepping the estate creditors as well as the need for complicated estate settlements.

rrsp beneficiary
rrsp beneficiary

CRA RRSP beneficiary rules: Who pays tax on inherited RRSP if the beneficiary is not a spouse, common-law partner or financially dependent children or grandchild – but is the Estate?

One of the most common errors made when determining the recipient for the RRSP is to assign the estate itself. This requires the RRSP asset to go through probate. The estate receives the tax-deferred growth that has actually been earned by the RRSP up to the date of death. However, it would additionally mean that the estate would be responsible for shouldering the tax burden on the distribution of the RRSP. This is not necessarily wrong, but from an estate planning perspective, it is the most expensive route to choose. Estate planners certainly would not choose this way unless for some reason there was no other choice.

The RRSP beneficiary problem we are dealing with or how to destroy an inheritance

The issue we are dealing with on a particular deceased estate file blends insolvency work with the work of an Estate Trustee. The deceased did not file income tax returns for the last few years of her life. We now have a pretty good handle on her income taxes and what her liability is for the years of unfiled tax returns, as well as the tax liability that will arise from the Estate trust tax return.

Based on what I have already told you about the taxation possibilities for an RRSP beneficiary, and what I am about to tell you, there is a huge problem for an RRSP beneficiary.

For confidentiality reasons, I cannot provide names and amounts, but I will explain the problem. The deceased maintained a self-directed RRSP contract through Royal Bank of Canada at Royal Bank Dominion Securities. The named beneficiary in the Registered Retirement Savings Plan document was a relative. This relative does not meet the definition of a qualified beneficiary.

So in the normal course, the Estate Trustee would work with the RRSP beneficiary to understand if there was going to be no taxable income inclusion because an RRSP rollover was taking place. If not, the estate should pay the tax, but the beneficiary obtains 100% of the value of the RRSP.

Another option is that the Estate Trustee would get the tax payable on the registered retirement income from the RRSP beneficiary and pay the income tax. The beneficiary would be left with the net amount and the tax would be paid. So everyone is square.

Which option is picked depends on if there are more assets and more beneficiaries or not.

In the situation I am acting in, the Estate is insolvent. There will not be enough money in the Estate to pay all the income tax owing, regardless of the source of the taxable income. The RRSP beneficiary also as I understand it, did not elect an RRSP rollover.

So now, in this case, where the Estate has insufficient funds to pay the taxes payable in full and the RRSP beneficiary:

  • is not a qualified beneficiary; and
  • did not do an RRSP rollover

the RRSP beneficiary will be liable for the income tax payable from the RRSP plan assets received. The real problem is that the year death, and therefore the year the RRSP beneficiary received their inheritance was 2018. We were appointed late in 2019 and we just now have been able to quantify the income tax payable.

So it will be 2021 or later that CRA may go to the RRSP beneficiary with their hand out. I don’t know if the RRSP beneficiary invested it all, spent it all, or a combination of the two. This my readers is how to destroy an inheritance.

RRSP beneficiary summary

I hope you enjoyed the RRSP beneficiary Brandon Blog post. If you are concerned because you or your business are dealing with substantial debt challenges and you assume bankruptcy is your only option, call me. It is not your fault that you remain in this way. You have actually been only shown the old ways to try to deal with financial issues. These old ways do not work anymore.

The Ira Smith Team utilizes new modern-day ways to get you out of your debt difficulties while avoiding bankruptcy. We can get you the relief you need and so deserve.

The tension put upon you is big. We know your discomfort factors. We will check out your entire situation and design a new approach that is as unique as you and your problems; financial and emotional. We will take the weight off of your shoulders and blow away the dark cloud hanging over you. We will design a debt settlement strategy for you. We know that we can help you now.

We understand that people and businesses facing financial issues need a realistic lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” method with the Ira Smith Team. Not everyone has to file bankruptcy in Canada. The majority of our clients never do. We help many people and companies stay clear of bankruptcy.

That is why we can establish a new restructuring procedure for paying down debt that will be built just for you. It will be as one-of-a-kind as the economic issues and discomfort you are encountering. If any one of these seems familiar to you and you are serious about getting the solution you need, contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. group today.

Call us now for a no-cost consultation.

We will get you or your business back up driving to healthy and balanced trouble-free operations and get rid of the discomfort factors in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

We hope that you and your family are safe, healthy and secure during this coronavirus pandemic.

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. and Smith Estate Trustee Ontario are absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

 

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

Debt problems: 8 Mistakes To Avoid When You Are Having Money Problems

debt problemsIntroduction

I have advised many entrepreneurs and non-business people who have debt problems. Many times, there are things they have done before coming to see me for a no-cost consultation that I wished they had not done. So, I thought I would discuss the 8 mistakes to avoid when you are having money problems.

1. Using money from your RRSP to pay debts

This can be a costly error. Using retirement funds to pay off debts can hurt you in numerous ways. The vast majority of retirement accounts are exempt. This means your creditors cannot get at them and you won’t lose them if you file for a consumer proposal or for bankruptcy (“an insolvency filing”).

Using retirement money to pay debts that can be discharged in an insolvency filing, like credit card and income tax debt, rarely makes sense. If you make an insolvency filing, you can eliminate the debt without spending any of your retirement funds. Using retirement funds to pay debt jeopardizes your future when you will be in more need of the funds due to lack of other income.

The withdrawal from the RRSP counts as income on which you will owe taxes and possibly even an early withdrawal penalty. Depending on how large the amount is, the added income and related income tax debt could affect the nature of your insolvency filing, the total amount you will still have to pay and provide problems with your discharge from bankruptcy.

2. Paying unsecured debts like credit cards, income tax and personal instead of secured debts like mortgages and car loans

Some creditors are so aggressive and sometimes predatory that they make you think that you must pay off their debts immediately or suffer severe consequences. Frightened by these tactics you may be tempted to pay their unsecured loans first and leave a secured loan unpaid. This creates multiple problems.

The two most common types of property subject to a security interest are probably the two most important things you own: your home and your car. A car loan creditor can repossess a car after one missed payment. If that occurs, you will lose your car and you will be responsible for any deficiency amount you still owe on your car loan after the car is auctioned off usually for significantly less than it is worth.

While a mortgage lender may not be able to kick you out of your home as quickly, arrears, a higher arrears rate of interest that kicks in upon default and late fees can significantly increase what you owe and make it very difficult to catch up. As a general rule, you should prefer to pay your secured creditors so you can keep your car and home, as opposed to paying unsecured creditors who don’t have near the recourse that a secured creditor has. This assumes that you will be able to afford the car and mortgage payments after we help you eliminate your debts and balance your budget.

In addition, if you decide to make an insolvency filing, the money paid to your unsecured creditors might as well have been thrown in the trash. Meanwhile, you will still have to catch up on your secured debts if you want to keep the property.

Finally, you might have to explain to the licensed insolvency trustee why you were able to pay certain creditors, but not others, so close to the filing. Such payments may be considered preferences that the trustee can force the creditor to return in a bankruptcy. It is always better to avoid such a problem and keep your secured debts current, even if you have to neglect the unsecured ones.

3. Maintaining accounts at a bank or other financial institution where you owe money

Almost every bank and financial institution will require you to sign an agreement authorizing the bank to automatically garnish your account if you miss a payment owed to it. In other words, if you have your mortgage and a savings account at the same bank and you miss a mortgage payment, the bank can take it from your savings account. This is called a setoff.

You should transfer your accounts, other than for the one account need to pay your monthly loan payment, to another institution where you don’t owe money to avoid this situation. You can keep a minimum amount in that one account and replenish it monthly so you can’t lose much in case of a setoff.

4. Using a second mortgage or home equity line of credit to pay off credit cards or other unsecured debt

As mentioned previously, credit card and other unsecured debt can be discharged in an insolvency filing. If you don’t make your mortgage payments, you could lose your home.

If the amount you borrow against your home doesn’t get you out of debt, you may have no choice but to end up not being able to afford the higher payments, in bankruptcy, having wasted money that could have been used elsewhere. To make matters worse, you have allowed a second lien against your home, which increases your monthly expenses and the length of time before you are able to pay your home off. In addition, the second mortgage, is a secured debt, will not be dischargeable in an insolvency filing and you may end up losing your home.

Don’t fall for the advertisements that suggest you consolidate your debts with a home equity loan. This strategy only makes sense after you have seen a licensed credit counsellor and have created and understood your balanced budget. The licensed insolvency trustees at Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. are also licensed, credit counsellors.

5. Not filing your tax returns

If you do not file your tax returns on time, you will have an issue if you make an insolvency filing. Your case will not be closed and your debts will not be discharged until you file your missing income tax returns with the Canada Revenue Agency (“CRA”) and they have a chance to review it. The CRA will not allow you to get through the insolvency filing without ensuring your returns have been filed.

It will also be impossible for us to properly advise you on whether you can avoid bankruptcy through a consumer proposal because will not know the total amount you owe to CRA. You always need to bring your income tax filings current BEFORE making an insolvency filing. Better not to have this problem delay a filing when you really need to protect yourself immediately at that time.

6. Telling a creditor that you intend to pay

When you have debt problems, it is always best not to say anything to a creditor than to promise the creditor that you will pay. Once you tell creditors to expect money, their harassment will grow every day they don’t receive the promised money.

7. Making a written promise to pay or making a partial payment on an old debt

Creditors are barred from collecting a debt once the limitation period has run. The limitation period on a particular unsecured debt incurred in Ontario is 2 years. Making a written promise to pay or making a partial payment on the debt (no matter how small) may reset the clock on the creditor’s ability to take legal action.

8. Ignoring pending lawsuits

Pending lawsuits on debts is an obvious sign that you have debt problems. Ignoring pending lawsuits is a huge mistake as these lawsuits lead to judgments. Upon receiving a judgment, the creditor will be able to garnish your wages and freeze your bank accounts.

If you are sued on a debt, it’s wise to at least consult a lawyer. You may have legal defenses. It is normally best to make an insolvency filing either before or immediately upon a judgment being made against you. That way, the creditor who received the judgment cannot enforce against your wages or bank accounts. You are protected in an insolvency filing by an automatic stay of proceedings.

Debt problems summary

I hope you found this Brandon’s Blog, What is a Consumer Proposal, helpful. Sometimes things are too far gone and more drastic and immediate triage action is required.

Do you have too much debt? Are you in need of financial restructuring? The financial restructuring process is complex. The Ira Smith Team understands how to do a complex restructuring. However, more importantly, we understand the needs of the entrepreneur or the person who has too much personal debt. You are worried because you are facing significant financial challenges.

It is not your fault that you are in this situation. You have been only shown the old ways that do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team uses new modern ways to get you out of your debt troubles while avoiding bankruptcy. We can get you debt relief freedom.

The stress placed upon you is huge. We understand your pain points. We look at your entire situation and devise a strategy that is as unique as you and your problems; financial and emotional. The way we take the load off of your shoulders and devise a debt settlement plan, we know that we can help you.

We know that people facing financial problems need realistic lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” approach with the Ira Smith Team. That is why we can develop a restructuring process as unique as the financial problems and pain you are facing. If any of this sounds familiar to you and you are serious in finding a solution, contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. team today.

Call us now for a free consultation. We will get you or your company back on the road to healthy stress-free operations and recover from the pain points in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

CANADA BANKRUPTCY AND INSOLVENCY ACT GRANTS STAY OF EXECUTION

canada bankruptcy and insolvency act

Canada bankruptcy and insolvency act introduction

The Canada Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act is a federal statute. It attempts to balance the rights of an insolvent debtor with the rights of creditors to get paid. One of those balancing acts is that when you file under the statute, the person filing is granted a stay of proceedings. What that means is that debt collection and enforcement activities are stopped and cannot continue without the prior permission of the Court.

I recently read a very interesting decision of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice out of Ottawa, ON. What that case also shows is that if the insolvent and the then bankrupt person just told the truth, he would have been much better off.

Before getting into the actual case, there are a few questions that I am regularly asked that I would also like to answer. I think those answers will also help with understanding this case.

What is the purpose of the Canada Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act?

The main purpose of the Canada Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act is to help the honest but unfortunate debtor. It is designed to allow a person or a company to get financial rehabilitation through financial restructuring. It also allows a person the same opportunity to shed their debts through bankruptcy.

As mentioned above, at the same time, the rights of the creditors to get paid are also balanced. So that is why in a true restructuring, the creditors must receive more money than if the person or company went bankrupt. That is also why in a bankruptcy, the debtor must give up all their assets to the licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a bankruptcy trustee) (Trustee). The only assets not given up are those for which there is an exemption under either provincial or federal law. That is also why there is the concept of surplus income payments in a personal bankruptcy filing.

The presumption is that the debtor is honest but unfortunate. That is both before and during their insolvency process. As you will see from the case description below, the debtor was not honest and it is his lies that got him into trouble.

The insolvency process begins with the requirement that in order to obtain relief from debt, the insolvent debtor will be truthful. That is why a filing is initiated by a sworn statement of affairs.

Is insolvency a criminal offence?

As you may recall from some of my prior Brandon’s Blog posts, being insolvent is a financial condition. It is that:

  • your debts are greater than your assets;
  • if you liquidated your assets there would not be enough money to pay off your debts in full; and
  • you have generally ceased paying your debts when they come due.

So becoming insolvent is not a criminal offence.

Similarly, filing for either a consumer proposal, Division I Proposal or for bankruptcy is not a criminal offence. However, if you really are not the honest part of the honest but unfortunate person the Canada Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act is designed to help, you must seek the advice of a lawyer before filing anything.

There are also certain offences a person could commit under the actual bankruptcy statute. Some are quasi-criminal in nature. Again, if you think you are in trouble, you need the advice of a lawyer.canada bankruptcy and insolvency act

canada bankruptcy and insolvency act

Now for the case – Re Brennan, 2019 ONSC 4712 (CanLII)

On August 8, 2019, this decision of The Honourable Mr. Justice Kershman was released. The case involved the bankruptcy of Mr. Lawrence Brennan (Mr. Brennan) and his creditor, Mr.André Robert (Mr. Robert).

Mr. Robert made an application to the Court to lift the stay of proceedings stopping Mr. Robert from enforcing his judgment against Mr. Brennan’s asset. Mr. Robert said that Mr. Brennan supplied incorrect and deceptive details relating to the presence of a Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP) throughout a judgment debtor exam on July 10, 2018.

Mr. Robert brought this motion for:

  1. An Order stating that the stay of proceedings according to sections 69 to 69.31 of the Canada Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. B-3 does not apply in regard to Mr. André Robert, yet is restricted to the seizure of Mr. Brennan’s RRSP with the Lawyers Financial Investment Program.
  2. An Order proclaiming that Mr. Robert will be qualified to proceed with his enforcement process for repayment of his judgment, plus interest and the cost of enforcement restricted to Mr. Brennan’s above-noted RRSP.
  3. Indemnification for the costs of this motion.

Mr. Robert’s argument was that, had it not been for Mr. Brennan’s bankruptcy, there would be no stay of proceedings and he would have the ability to take Mr. Brennan’s RRSP according to the Execution Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. E.24.

The honest but unfortunate debtor

Mr. Robert is a lawyer. Mr. Brennan and others sought and obtained his legal advice. Mr. Robert then billed Mr. Brennan and each of his colleagues for the legal work. They thanked Mr. Robert by not paying him.

Mr. Robert went to Court to claim his legal fees and won. He then sent the Sheriff to seize any assets that could be found belonging to the defendants, including Mr. Brennan. That exercise awarded Mr. Robert with the princely sum of just under $65. So, Mr. Robert then notified Mr. Brennan that he was required to attend a judgment debtor examination. The purpose of this exam was for Mr. Brennan to answer questions, truthfully under oath, as to the nature, extent and location of all of his assets.

Throughout the judgment debtor exam, Mr. Robert asked Mr. Brennan if he possessed any kind of RRSPs. Mr. Brennan said, under oath, that he did not. This response was substantiated by Mr. Brennan’s written financial form, which was finished by Mr. Brennan as a component of the examination under oath.

It turns out that Mr. Brennan lied under oath to Mr. Robert. Seventeen days later, Mr. Brennan filed for bankruptcy. In his sworn statement of affairs completed as part of his bankruptcy filing, Mr. Brennan attested that he owned an RRSP in the amount of $13,017.00 held by the Lawyers Financial Investment Program.

Mr. Brennan may have been unfortunate, but prior to his assignment in bankruptcy, he was not honest.

Seizure of an RRSP – in bankruptcy and no bankruptcy

The evidence before the Court was that there were no contributions to Mr. Brennan’s RRSP in the 12 months prior to his date of bankruptcy. There was also evidence that there was no insurance element to the RRSP either.

This is important for 2 reasons:

  • If there is an insurance element to an RRSP, and the beneficiary is what is called a “designated beneficiary”, normally a spouse, parent, child or grandchild, then the RRSP is exempt from seizure under Ontario law.
  • In bankruptcy, an RRSP is exempt from seizure under federal law. The only amount that can be recouped by a Trustee is any contributions made to the RRSP within the 12 months prior to the date of bankruptcy.

So in this case, none of those conditions existed. The issue before the Court was because under Ontario Law, absent a bankruptcy, a judgment creditor can execute against a defendant’s RRSP. In other words, if there is no bankruptcy, in Ontario, the judgment creditor can seize the RRSP.canada bankruptcy and insolvency act

canada bankruptcy and insolvency act

Mr. Brennan’s defence

Mr. Brennan represented himself in Court. His defence consisted of that he:

  1. Did not understand that he had any RRSPs in his name.
  2. Informed Mr. Robert around one month prior to the examination that he would certainly need to go bankrupt.
  3. Needs the Court to have pity for his circumstances.

Certainly not the most compelling defence in the circumstances.

The Court agrees with Mr. Robert

The Court went through an analysis of the Canada Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act as well as the relevant Ontario laws. The Court concluded that:

  1. The RRSP currently in this bankruptcy is exempt from seizure but was available to be seized before the bankruptcy. If Mr. Brennan had been truthful in his examination under oath, Mr. Robert would have seized the RRSP through the Sheriff in enforcing his judgment.
  2. Therefore, the Court lifted the stay according to section 69.4 of the Canada Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act to be equitable so that Mr. Andre can seize them.
  3. To alleviate any kind of tax obligation effects, the Court ordered that 30% of the RRSP should be subtracted at source and also to the Canada Revenue Agency to the credit of Mr. Brennan’s current year income tax account. The remaining amount of the RRSP is to be paid to the Sheriff of the Judicial District of Ottawa, who will disperse it in conformity to the Execution Act and the Creditors Relief Act.

The moral to Mr. Brennan’s story

Although the Court decision does not say it, Mr. Brennan must have not obtained any legal advice before participating in the judgment debtor examination. Any lawyer hearing his story would have told him exactly what I tell every person who comes to my office to talk about an insolvency proceeding. Be honest and truthful.

Mr. Brennan did a really dumb thing. Part of the evidence that came out in Court is that he went to see the Trustee who did his bankruptcy filing six weeks prior to the July 10, 2018 judgment debtor examination to discuss his financial situation. He must have talked about the RRSP then.

If Mr. Brennan was honest and truthful at his judgment debtor examination, he could have filed for bankruptcy before the Sheriff managed to seize his RRSP. In that case, Mr. Brennan would have told the truth and his RRSP would have been exempt from seizure in his bankruptcy.

So instead of telling the truth and keeping his RRSP after bankruptcy, Mr. Brennan lied and therefore lost his RRSP, notwithstanding his bankruptcy.

That is the moral of Mr. Brennan’s story. By telling the truth and then becoming the honest but unfortunate debtor, the Canadian bankruptcy system will protect you.

Canada Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act summary

Are you an honest but unfortunate person in financial trouble? Have you run your company in an honest fashion but through various circumstances, the company’s debts are greater than its assets. Is there just not enough cash to pay all the bills?

If so, you need to call me today. As a licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called trustee in bankruptcy) we are the only professionals licensed, recognized as well as supervised by the federal government to give insolvency assistance. We are also the only authorized party in Canada to apply remedies under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada). I can definitely help you to choose what is best for you to free you from your financial debt issues.

Call the Ira Smith Team today so we can get free you from the stress, anxiety, and discomfort that your cash issues have created. With the distinct roadmap, we establish simply for you, we will without delay return you right into a healthy and balanced problem-free life, Starting Over Starting Now.canada bankruptcy and insolvency actcanada bankruptcy and insolvency act

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

RESP CONTRIBUTION NOT PROTECTED IN BANKRUPTCY

resp contribution
resp contribution

If you would prefer to listen to the audio version of this RESP contribution not protected in bankruptcy Brandon’s Blog, please scroll down to the bottom and click on the podcast

Introduction

Many parents contribute to a Registered Education Savings Plan (RESP) to save for their children’s post-secondary education. Unlike a Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP), an RESP contribution, or the total of all contributions made by the parent(s), is subject to seizure in the bankruptcy of the owner of the RESP.

In Brandon’s Blog, I discuss the history of why an RRSP is largely exempt from seizure in a bankruptcy, while a Registered Disability Savings Plan (RDSP) and an RESP are not. The rules governing whether an RRSP or Registered Retirement Income Fund (RRIF), RDSP or RESP are exempt from seizure or not is an interplay between both federal and provincial laws. As I practise in the province of Ontario, I will speak only about the Ontario situation.

resp contribution
resp contribution

RRSP or RRIF exemption

Before 2008, whether an RRSP was exempt from seizure or not relied solely upon provincial law. There was no federal law which outlined the treatment for an RRSP in bankruptcy. Effective July 2008, the assets contained in either an RRSP or a RRIF were codified in the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA) to be exempt from seizure, except for contributions made to an RRSP in the 12 months prior to the date of bankruptcy.

The only exception would be based on whether or not RRSPs and RRIFs were exempt from seizure under provincial law. So, in the case of Ontario, the 12-month clawback exists. The bankrupt has to pay the equivalent of the contributions made in the 12 months before the date of bankruptcy.

The reason for making this change to the BIA was because there was an inequality amongst RRSPs. If you held your RRSP at a financial institution, then it was not exempt from seizure in a bankruptcy. However, if you held your RRSP:

  • with an insurance company; AND
  • you had made an irrevocable designation that in the event of your death, the beneficiary of your plan was a spouse, child, parent or grandchild

then under the Ontario Insurance Act the entire RRSP or RRIF was exempt from seizure.

The amendment to the BIA was done for two main reasons:

  • to put all RRSPs and RRIFs on the same footing, regardless of what institution it was held with; and
  • in order to not be destitute in their fresh start that the bankruptcy system allows them to have, retired Canadians who had to go bankrupt should not lose what was probably their single largest source of retirement income as a result of their financial problems.

So before the July 2008 amendment, people who were going to file for bankruptcy and who had a sizeable RRSP held with a chartered bank, would transfer the RRSP to an insurance company and make the required beneficiary designation. Many cases were heard in bankruptcy Courts across Canada.

If the beneficiary in an insurance policy, including the RRSP or RRIF investments, was revocable, it was held that the licensed insolvency trustee (then called a bankruptcy trustee) could revoke the named beneficiary, replace it with designating the Estate as the beneficiary, and then collapsing the plan to obtain the funds.

If the beneficiary was irrevocable, then the Trustee could not collapse the investment. Rather, it would have to be 1 of the reasons why a Trustee would oppose the bankrupt’s discharge. The reason being is that the person, knowing themselves to be insolvent, transferred an asset out of the creditors’ reach for no value obtained. This was called a settlement.

The leading case which was subsequently followed by other Courts, including Ontario, was The Court of Appeal for Saskatchewan case Royal Bank of Canada v. North American Life Assurance Co., 1994 CanLII 4696 (SK CA) which became known as the Ramgotra case.

The reason is that Dr. Ramgotra was bankrupt. Royal Bank was a creditor and obtained Court approval to appeal, in lieu of the Trustee, a lower Court decision on what should happen to the RRSP, turned into an RRIF, funds. The Court of Appeal determined that since Mrs. Ramgotra obtained an irrevocable interest in the property, notwithstanding the RRSP transfer was a settlement, the Trustee could not obtain the money.

resp contribution
resp contribution

RDSP and Budget 2019

An RDSP is a financial savings strategy that is planned to assist moms and dads and others build up funds for the long-term financial safety of an individual who qualifies for the disability tax credit.

Unlike RRSPs, the balance kept in RDSPs are not excluded from seizure in a bankruptcy. The reason for this is because the settlor of the RDSP may do an RDSP withdrawal of funds at any time. The theory is that funds will be withdrawn for the welfare of the disabled person. However, it is the ability to withdraw funds at any time, that renders this vehicle to not be a true legal trust.

In Budget 2019, it is proposed that RDSPs be given the identical treatment to RRSPs. The societal aim is to make sure that the needs of a disabled person are not negatively affected due to the financial problems of the person who is looking out for and financially contributing to the welfare of the disabled person. More than likely the contributor is a parent.

Budget 2019 intends to exclude RDSPs from seizure in bankruptcy, except for payments made in the 12 months prior to the date of bankruptcy. This will put in on the same footing as RRSPs.

resp contribution
resp contribution

RESPs are not exempt

The reason that RESP contribution funds are not exempt from seizure in bankruptcy is fairly simple. The child does not obtain property interest in the RESP funds as the parent can collapse the plan any time before maturity. Therefore it is not a trust or any form of transfer of property to the child. Therefore, the Trustee of a bankrupt parent who owns an RESP can collapse it.

If the parent wishes the RESP to continue and not be collapsed, satisfactory arrangements have to be made with the Trustee for the equivalent amount of funds in the RESP as at the date of bankruptcy be paid to the Trustee for the benefit of the bankruptcy Estate and the bankrupt’s creditors.

As a result of perceived inequality, on June 3, 2019, Dan Albas, Conservative MP for Central Okanagan—Similkameen—Nicola (B.C.), introduced as a private member’s bill, Bill C-453, An Act to amend the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (property of bankrupt — registered education savings plan). This Bill intends to amend s. 67(1)‍(b.‍3) of the BIA, so that RESPs receive the same treatment as RRSPs and the treatment proposed in Budget 2019 for RDSPs.

The thrust is obviously to make sure that other than for contributions made in the 12 months before the date of bankruptcy, a parent should not lose the RESP benefits for their child’s post-secondary school education because of their bankruptcy.

As private member’s bills rarely become law, I am doubtful that this initiative, no matter how well-meaning, will pass. There may also be a societal distinction between a retiree whose income earning days are behind him or her, a disabled person who is reliant upon a trust set up for their care and benefit and an elementary or high school student’s future university or college tuition.

resp contribution
resp contribution

What about you?

Are you in financial distress? Are you worried about any RRSP, RDSP or RESP contribution? Do you not have adequate funds to pay your financial obligations as they come due? Are you worried about what will happen to you in retirement?

If so, call the Ira Smith Team today. We have decades and generations of experience assisting people looking for financial restructuring, a debt settlement plan and to AVOID bankruptcy.

As a licensed insolvency trustee, we are the only professionals accredited, acknowledged and supervised by the federal government to provide insolvency advice and to implement approaches to help you remain out of personal bankruptcy while eliminating your debts. A consumer proposal is a government approved debt settlement plan to do that. We will help you decide on what is best for you between a consumer proposal vs bankruptcy.

Call the Ira Smith Team today so you can eliminate the stress, anxiety, and pain from your life that your financial problems have caused. With the one-of-a-kind roadmap, we develop just for you, we will immediately return you right into a healthy and balanced problem-free life.

You can have a no-cost analysis so we can help you fix your troubles. Call the Ira Smith Team today. This will allow you to go back to a new healthy and balanced life, Starting Over Starting Now.

resp contribution

 

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

BANKRUPTCY IN ONTARIO CANADA SECRETS REVEALED

Bankruptcy in Ontario Canada: Introduction

Most people are afraid of filing for bankruptcy in Ontario Canada and rightly so. It should be a last resort. There are many options available to people in financial trouble. All of them should be canvassed before deciding to declare bankruptcy.

In my professional practice, during the first free consultation appointment, we look at all options with the person to avoid bankruptcy. We naturally have a discussion about what it is and how it will affect the person. That way, the potential client is aware of all the options and can make an educated decision.

In this Brandon’s Blog, I discuss the questions that I am most often asked about the process. Hopefully, by the end of this blog, I will have demystified the process for you and helped in aiding your understanding.

The secrets we will show

Bankruptcy in Ontario Canada is definitely something nobody wants to talk about. So, therefore, it makes it seem very mysterious and secretive. It is also very scary. Therefore, from now on in this blog, so as not to scare you unnecessarily, I will try to refer to it only as “the B word”. I will only use the B word if the context requires it. This Brandon’s Blog will hopefully pull back the curtain in answering the most often asked questions thereby reducing the mystique and hopefully, your anxiety about this topic.

Where do I begin?

The first step is recognizing that you have financial problems and that bankruptcy in Ontario Canada might be your new reality. If you are having difficulty meeting all of your financial responsibilities or have actually quit paying all of your bills on time, you have a financial problem. As a licensed insolvency trustee (Trustee) we are the only professional licensed and supervised by the Federal government – Industry Canada (OSB).

If you are having financial problems, you must contact a Trustee as soon as possible, to have a free consultation to check your situation and to understand all the options available to you, including the B word. In that free appointment, you will learn that the B word may not be your only alternative to leave your debt behind. There are a number of choices that include, however, are not restricted to:

Should I declare the B word and what happens immediately if I do?

Declaring the B word is obviously a very serious step and a difficult personal choice. If the Trustee has properly explained all the realistic options available to you, it will make your choice much less scary. The first question is do you even qualify to file for the B word. You must be insolvent, owe more than $1,000 in unsecured debt to qualify for it in Canada.

As far as filing for the B word in Premier Doug Ford’s province, you must have:

  1. carried on business in the province during the year immediately preceding your B word; or
  2. lived in the province during the year before your B word; or
  3. where 1 or 2 above don’t apply, the majority of your property is in the province.

Note that the first test is that you are actually insolvent. Insolvent or insolvency is a financial condition. It means that you are:

  1. Unable to meet your obligations generally as they become due.
  2. You have ceased paying your current debts as they come due.
  3. The fair value of all of your assets is less than the total amount of your debts.

The B word is a legal state. Insolvency is a financial condition.

If I go for the B word, will I lose everything?

If you declare the B word, no, you will certainly not lose everything. There is a listing of things that are excluded from seizure in Ontario. The list is:

  • Necessary clothing for you and your dependants.
  • Home furnishings and appliances that are of a worth not more than $13,150.
  • Tools and various other personal effects not worth more than $11,300, made use to earn revenue from your business. If you are an Ontario farmer, this amount increases to $29,100 for everything, including your livestock.
  • One car or truck that is worth not more than $6,600.
  • The cash surrender value of life insurance if your beneficiary is what is called a “Designated Beneficiary”.
  • Your Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP), Registered Retirement Income Fund (RRIF) or Deferred Profit Sharing Plan (DPSP) other than for any amounts contributed in the 12 months immediately preceding your date of bankruptcy.
  • $10,000 of equity in your home but only if your share of the equity is less than $10,000 in total.

So if you go the way of the B word, based on this listing, you won’t lose everything. However, as you can see, if your share of the equity in your home is significant, the B word very likely is not for you. One of the other options is probably more suitable and you should pursue one of them.

What happens to the money I owe?

Once you go with the B word, all of your unsecured debts are frozen. Creditors cannot begin or continue any legal action against you. Any garnishee on either your wages or your bank account must come off. Normally if you owe money to Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) and have not kept up with a payment plan to them, they will garnishee your bank account which stops you from using it. The B word stops a CRA garnishee against your bank account or salary or wages also.

Similarly, a creditor who sues you and gets a judgement against you cannot continue any execution against your assets.

Once you are in the B word, the Trustee sends a notice to all of your creditors, along with a proof of claim form and instructions. With certain limited exceptions, the only remedy your unsecured creditors have is to file a proof of claim with the Trustee.

This does not apply to any of your debts owed to lenders who hold valid security against a specific asset. Examples would be a bank holding a mortgage against your home in return for the mortgage money or a lender who has security against your car for an auto loan.

What takes place to my salary or wages once I file?

Your income is not impacted by the B word process. You will continue to receive your normal salary or wages as you always have. You will need to complete Income and Expense Forms throughout detailing your and your spouse’s earnings and expenses. This is part of your budgeting procedure to meet one of the aims of the B word process; financial rehabilitation.

If your family income goes beyond specific requirements developed by the OSB, you will need to pay a part to the Trustee. This is called a surplus income payment requirement. In the first free consultation, I always tell potential clients whether they will have such a requirement. We also then look at that requirement, if any, to see if a consumer proposal would be more beneficial to the person than the B word.

Will the B word process get rid of my student loans?

If the B word date is within 7 years of when you stopped being a full-time or part-time student, your student loan debt will not be released by the B word process. Nevertheless, in particular situations, you might have the ability to make an application to the court for a discharge of your student loan financial obligations under the “hardship provision.” It is almost impossible to get that court-ordered discharge, but the slim possibility is there.

Will I still owe money after I file?

Only for a limited amount of debts. A discharge from the B word process does not cover:

  • secured loans – home mortgage or vehicle loan;
  • certain student loans (remember the 7-year rule I just mentioned?);
  • penalties or fines enforced by the court;
  • spousal support and alimony you have to make in your separation agreement or divorce proceedings; and
  • any debts from a fraud.

What length of time will I be in the B word system?

The length of time you will be in the B word system depends on whether this is an initial or 2nd time and whether you have surplus income. The minimum length of time is 9 months. That is if you don’t have any surplus income, none of your creditors oppose your discharge and it is your first time.

If it is your first time, none of your creditors oppose your discharge and you do have surplus income, then the 9 months increases to 21 months.

If it will not be your first time, the length of time before you can get a discharge will depend on many factors. We certainly discuss it during your first free consultation.

Who will find out that I have filed?

As soon as you declare the B word your Trustee will tell your creditors, the CRA, the credit bureaus and the OSB. The filing is public information and it will show up in your credit history.

Where your non-exempt assets given to the Trustee are worth more than $15,000, there must be a legal notice of your B word filing in the local paper.

Exactly how will it impact my credit score?

A person who files drops down to the least favourable credit rating (R9) immediately. After you declare the B word, you must start to work on improving your credit score. Once you are discharged, you will have more options to improve on your credit score and rebuild your credit.

Notice of the B word process will stay on your credit record for 7 years after you get your discharge.

How is my partner or spouse affected by my filing?

Your spouse or partner is not directly impacted by your filing. Your spouse or partner will have to show his or her income as part of your surplus income calculation. The partner or spouse will be liable to repay any loan they have co-signed or guaranteed for you. They will also have to repay any credit card balance on your account for which they have and used a supplementary card to make purchases.

Will my bankruptcy impact my ongoing divorce case?

In Canada, the B word rules do not conflict with most of the family law system and process. So the Trustee will not get involved in your family law proceedings, with two main exceptions.

There is an aspect of your divorce in Ontario that will be affected because Ontario is an equalization province. There are generally only 2 parts of your divorce proceedings your Trustee will certainly get involved in. One is when it pertains to the person who filed legal rights to entitlement to an equalization payment. Second is when the debtor owns property (either jointly with the spouse or alone) and such property has not already been dealt with in the family law proceedings.

How do I choose the right Trustee for me?

Sometimes people just say that “I want to go to the closest Trustee near me”. If travelling or time is an issue for you then that approach is quite legitimate.

The better way is making an appointment for a cost-free no commitment first consultation with a Trustee. If you can, it is best to get a referral from someone you trust. Otherwise, perform an online search and see which Trustee’s website resonates best with you. Ask any kind of questions you might have about your particular situation and the options you may have.

If after that appointment you feel comfortable with the knowledge and demeanour of the Trustee, and you felt confident that you received proper answers to your questions, then great. If not, make an appointment for a free first consultation with a different Trustee. Use that experience to compare both to see who you would like to put your trust in. At the end of the day, you have to know who you will be dealing with and feel comfortable with them. You have to know that your Trustee gets you!

Do you have too much debt? Are you having a problem making your month-to-month bill payments? Is your company dealing with financial obstacles that you just can’t figure the way out of?

If so, call the Ira Smith Team today. We have years and generations of experience aiding individuals and businesses looking for financial restructuring or a debt settlement plan. As a licensed insolvency trustee, we are the only experts recognized, licensed and supervised by the Federal government (the OSB) to provide insolvency recommendations and solutions to help you prevent the B word.

Call the Ira Smith Team today so you can end the stress and anxiety financial problems create. With the special roadmap, we develop unique to you, we will promptly return you right into a healthy and balanced stress-free life.

You can have a no-cost consultation to aid you so we can repair your debt problems. Call the Ira Smith Team today. This will definitely enable you to make a fresh start, Starting Over Starting Now.

bankruptcy in ontario toronto

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN BANKRUPTCY AND INSOLVENCY CANADA

What is the difference between bankruptcy and insolvency Canada: Introduction

Encountering major money troubles is life-shattering, especially if you automatically think that bankruptcy is your only alternative. As a matter of fact, lots of people erroneously think that serious financial difficulties immediately suggest the only answer is bankruptcy. The most common question I am asked is, “what is the difference between bankruptcy and insolvency Canada”.

What is the difference between bankruptcy and insolvency Canada: Insolvency

If you are having problems meeting your financial obligations or have stopped meeting those financial obligations as they come due you are insolvent, not bankrupt. Insolvent is a cash flow problem; bankruptcy is a legal state. You can read a detailed discussion on the definition of being insolvent in my last week’s vlog INSOLVENT DEFINITION: A NEW FOCUS FOR TORONTO BANKRUPTCY TRUSTEE.

Bаnkruрtсу is a legal рrосеѕѕ under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (R.S.C., 1985, c. B-3) (BIA) that helps you to resolve уоur debts if they have become unmanageable. If you have relatively few assets and low іnсоmе and dесіdе to file for bаnkruрtсу, you will probably fіlе under the streamlined Summary Administration part of the BIA.

If you have realizable assets that will produce a value greater than $10,000, then your bankruptcy would be administered under the general administrative provisions. Don’t worry about these distinctions right now. For now, just know that the summary administration rules are shortened, and the cost of the bankruptcy administration is fixed by a tariff set by the Superintendent of Bankruptcy.

In either case, you will turn over to your Licensed Insolvency Trustee (“LIT”) (formerly known as a bankruptcy trustee) all уоur рrореrtу that is not exempt (protected) by law. The LIT will sell your property and the proceeds will be used to рау for the bankruptcy administration and then make a distribution to уоur сrеdіtоrѕ.

What is the difference between bankruptcy and insolvency Canada: Assets exempt in a bankruptcy in Ontario

In Ontario, where my practice is, the following assets are exempt from seizure in a personal bankruptcy:

  1. Your necessary clothing without any dollar restriction.
  2. Family furnishings and appliances up to a value of $13,150.
  3. Your tools and other personal property used to earn income from your occupation up to a value of $11,300.
  4. One vehicle with equity of no more than $6,600.
  5. Registered Retirement Savings Plan and Registered Retirement Income Fund savings, other than payments made within the 12 months immediately before the bankruptcy filing.
  6. The equity in your house if up to the amount of $10,000. Note that the current thinking is that if your equity is more than $10,000, then your exemption is zero.

If you have very little property, all of it may be рrоtесtеd so that you will not lose it.

What is the difference between bankruptcy and insolvency Canada: Surplus income

How much уоur сrеdіtоrѕ will get in this process dереndѕ on how much уоur unрrоtесtеd property can be ѕоld fоr and whether you will be required to pay “surplus income” to your LIT. For a detailed discussion on surplus income, read my May 28, 2013 blog CAN YOU REALLY HAVE SURPLUS INCOME IF YOU’RE BANKRUPT?

Among all the things that seem to perplex many people when it involves the bankruptcy procedure is surplus income. It’s tough to get your head around the concept of surplus income when you are heading towards bankruptcy. Can that really be true if you are insolvent?

What is the difference between bankruptcy and insolvency Canada: What is surplus income

Surplus income in a bankruptcy describes the amount the bankrupt must pay to the Trustee monthly. The Canadian bankruptcy system attempts to balance your right to end your debt and start over with the rights of creditors to be paid.

To permit Canadians to keep a sensible right to make a living throughout the bankruptcy administration, the federal government has established limits or standards on revenue a person can keep (after tax obligations and certain limited deductions) throughout their bankruptcy. The Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy establishes the limit restriction every year tied into the cost of living.

How do you figure surplus income?

The Federal Government establishes the formula used to calculate surplus income payments. The same formula is used for all of Canada.

The limits for surplus income are based off across the country “poverty line”. Surplus income has absolutely nothing to do with what you have left over monthly. It is a federal government formula that considers your revenue, specific non-discretionary costs as well as your household size.

The calculation is to find if you will need to contribute from your earnings monthly to your Trustee, for the benefit of your creditors.

Bankruptcy discharge

The final step of your bankruptcy process will be to get your discharge. Your discharge from bankruptcy acts as the trigger to discharge you from all of your debts. This means that you will not have to рау them (with possibly certain exceptions depending on your circumstances).

Whether you get an absolute discharge from your bankruptcy will depend essentially on your conduct. Before your bankruptcy, did you treat all your creditors the same? Does anyone feel aggrieved by your actions? That will decide if any of your creditors will oppose your discharge.

For an in-depth discussion of the personal bankruptcy discharge process, check out our vlog BANKRUPTCY DISCHARGE: THE TOP 8 THINGS THE BANKRUPTCY COURT WILL CONSIDER ON ANYONE’S BANKRUPTCY DISCHARGE APPLICATION.

Is your debt keeping you up at night?

Do you have extreme debt and have no concept of how to handle it? Are your debt woes keeping you up at night and causing you stress, pain and maybe even depression? We understand that pain and can cut it from your life.

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. has helped many companies and people throughout the Greater Toronto Area (GTA) juggling too much debt in their lives that requires a blueprint for Starting Over, Starting Now. Do not delay. Help is 1 phone call away. You can fix your financial troubles while avoiding bankruptcy as long as you take swift action. Call the Ira Smith Team today for your free consultation.what is the difference between bankruptcy and insolvency canada

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

6 CANADIAN PERSONAL FINANCE MOVES EVERY NEW GRAD SHOULD MAKE

canadian personal financeCanadian personal finance: Introduction

Congratulations Graduates! You’ve done it! And now, at long last, you’re working. Have you been out shopping for a new car? Maybe having a look at the condo market? My advice to you is to slow down. That is why I am providing my 6 Canadian personal finance moves every new grad should make.

As tempting as it is to be making some real money for the first time, finding ways to spend it isn’t as important as finding ways to save it.

Canadian personal finance: Finances 101 for recent grads in a first job

  1. Pay down debt first. This is one of the most important messages that we deliver, especially for high-interest rate debt. So, hold off on the spending sprees and pay off your debts.
  2. Establish a budget. “It is important to set a new budget based on your new income and stick to it”, says Jennifer Auld, a District Vice-President of TD, who suggests using one of the many financial apps available to help track your spending. “You can plug in all of your fixed costs and determine what’s left at the end, for you to spend”. “It’s a critical first step in terms of establishing how much you’re able to save each month and what your discretionary earnings look like.”
  3. Save! Save a portion of each paycheque, even if it isn’t a lot of money. It all adds up. You will establish a pattern of saving which will be a big help down the road.
  4. Take advantage of group RRSP plans with matching contributions at work. It’s free money and will help you save more money, faster.
  5. A tax-free savings account is a great option for someone making less than $50,000 a year. Especially people coming right out of school, according to Michael Allen, senior portfolio manager at Wealthsimple.
  6. Don’t make any drastic changes in lifestyle. Jennifer Auld of TD Canada Trust suggests continuing to live on a student budget for a couple of months while you make a plan, including establishing your short and long-term goals. “What that allows you to do is get comfortable with your new reality before you go out and start changing your lifestyle and changing the way you live day-to-day,” said Auld.

Canadian personal finance: What to do if you are deep in debt

If you’re a recent grad, or a not so recent grad, with a high debt load and getting deeper into debt, reach out to the Ira Smith Team. We help people deal with debt on a daily basis and there is a way out. You need a plan for Starting Over, Starting Now. Give us a call today and get on a path of debt free living.

Categories
Brandon Blog Post

PONZI SCHEME CRIMINALS: CANADIAN PONZI SCHEME GUY WHO RUINED LIVES SENTENCED TO 7 YEARS FOR MASSIVE PONZI SCHEME

2

Ponzi scheme criminals: Introduction

We now have a Canadian to add to the long list of Ponzi scheme criminals. A Ponzi scheme is a fraud perpetrated on unsuspecting parties in which belief in the success of a non-existent enterprise through the payment of quick returns to the first investors from money invested by later investors.

Ponzi scheme criminals: What is a Ponzi scheme?

The name comes from the swindling ways of an Italian born con man in the late 1890’s and early 1900’s – Carlo Pietro Giovanni Guglielmo Tebaldo Ponzi – known in North America as Charles Ponzi. The most famous of the modern-day Ponzi scheme criminals is Bernard (Bernie) Madoff, who is serving 150 years in prison for his multi-billion dollar Ponzi scheme.

Ponzi scheme criminals: Canadian Wade Robert Closson, Ponzi scheme criminal

Canadian Wade Robert Closson, a 48-year-old Sturgeon County, Alberta resident was recently sentenced to seven years in jail for executing a Ponzi scheme. He was originally charged in over 80 counts of fraud. Mr. Closson plead guilty to 53 counts. Most of the fraudulent activities encompassed more than one victim, typically a husband and wife pair. Several of them were present in Court and read their victim impact statements. Others were read on behalf of the victims.

Ponzi scheme criminals: His swindle has caused financial devastation

Many of the victims were discussing feelings of shame. They have experienced overall financial devastation. Some are now still working at the ages of 83, not being able to retire. As a result of the fraud perpetrated upon them by Mr. Closson, they cannot afford to take a vacation or go out for a dinner.

Ponzi scheme criminals: With friends like Mr. Closson……….

Mr. Closson was actually friends and even related to many of the victims. Most of them are talking about the loss of trust in their friend, in humanity and their ability now to relate to other human beings.

He preyed on his friends and relatives, who recruited from their social circles to invest with Closson. A number who lost money in the scam lost more than $100,000 with one suffering a loss of over $600,000. This included cash from a credit line and their RRSP. Closson took $80,000 of that amount out of the couple’s accounts without their authorization.

Ponzi scheme criminals: Essentially, it was a mortgage scam

The overall size of the fraud itself was $11 million dollars that ran through the Ponzi scheme. The Crown was able to prove losses of about $6 million dollars. That is what was in the agreed statement of facts.

The Court heard how Mr. Closson ran the Ponzi between 2006 and 2013. He operated two firms, Optam Holdings Inc. (Optam) and Infinivest Mortgage Investment Corporation (Infinivest), which both entered into bankruptcy in 2013. Closson would take the cash invested in Infinivest to pay off the investors in Optam.

When Optam applied for bankruptcy it detailed about $10 million in liabilities spread out among 69 creditors. The biggest one was Infinivest, which Optam owed $4 million.

ISI 4
ponzi scheme criminals

Ponzi scheme criminals: He recruited friends and family to be on his sales team

Closson made use of the cash to pay himself around $1.185 million throughout the period of the fraud. He used an unspecified amount of money for at least one vehicle, credit cards and golf club. Mortgage payments for his mother-in-law and father-in-law too.

He incentivized people to bring in others into his scheme by paying a commission to his buddies and family members. He invested in various other companies, including a financial investment in a firm that operated a lumber mill in Nicaragua. This investment did not work out well either.

Ponzi scheme criminals: The sentencing

In Court, Closson apologized for his activities and requested the forgiveness of the 20 victims who attended Court for the sentencing!

Justice Belzil ordered Closson to pay restitution of $5.8 million he lost in the Ponzi plan together with a fine of $10,600. He is banned for life from trading in securities.

The Ponzi plan spurred an examination by the Alberta Securities Commission which fined Closson $1 million and banned him from trading in the Province of Alberta in 2015. Up until now Closson has made no payments.

“It is one thing to be taken advantage of by a stranger but this was a trusted friend,” Justice Paul Belzil said when sentencing Mr. Closson.

Ponzi scheme criminals: Wade Closson, the undischarged bankrupt

Closson and his spouse have both filed for bankruptcy on March 27, 2013. He remains an undischarged bankrupt with a hearing set for his discharge from bankruptcy. No doubt that hearing was adjourned until the outcome of the criminal trial was known. Even if Mr. Closson does one day receive a discharge from bankruptcy, the Court fine and the restitution Order, because the restitution is a liability arising out of fraud, will follow him for the rest of his life.

How the bankruptcy discharge process works has been a topic of several of my blogs in the past, including, BANKRUPTCY DISCHARGE: THE TOP 8 THINGS THE BANKRUPTCY COURT WILL CONSIDER ON ANYONE’S BANKRUPTCY DISCHARGE APPLICATION.

Ponzi scheme criminals: Do you have too much debt?

Have you taken on debt that you cannot repay as a result of being swindled from a Ponzi scheme? Have you been swindled and now don’t have enough cash to meet all your debts? Are you facing financial problems for any other reason? The Ira Smith Team can develop a restructuring plan for you.

Debt problems are stressful and confusing. The Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. Team understands the pain you are going through trying to stay alive and trying to support yourself and your family. We understand the pain and stress you are feeling thinking that you may just soon hit the wall.

Our debt settlement plan process can ease this stress. The Ira Smith Team has a great deal of experience in helping people avoid bankruptcy while resolving their debt problems. We understand your pain points. Call the Ira Smith Team today for your free consultation. We can end your pain and put you back on a healthy profitable path, Starting Over, Starting Now.

ponzi scheme criminals 0
Ponzi scheme criminals
Categories
Brandon Blog Post

BANKRUPTCY ALTERNATIVE, REALLY? EMBARRASSED TO ADMIT YOU HATE YOUR RRSP?

bankruptcy alternative, RRSP, RRSPs, retirement, retirement income, bankruptcy, bankruptcy alternatives, credit counselling, debt consolidation, consumer proposals, trusteeRaiding your RRSP is the worst bankruptcy alternative and in this blog you will see why. The federal government introduced the Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP) in 1957 to encourage Canadians to save for retirement. For many Canadians, RRSPs will be their only source of retirement income, in addition to Old Age Security (OAS) and Canada Pension Plan. However, according to a recent BMO survey Canadians are raiding their RRSPs to make ends meet and this is not advisable survival plan or bankruptcy alternative.

What is an RRSP?

A RRSP is a personal savings plan registered with the Canadian federal government allowing you to save for the future on a tax-sheltered basis. It can contain a variety of investments including RRSP savings deposits, treasury bills, guaranteed investment certificates (GICs), mutual funds, exchange-traded funds (ETFs), bonds and equities. Your contributions are tax deductible and your investments inside the RRSP grow inside tax free. However, when you take money out of your RRSP, it’s taxed as if it was income earned that year.

Are Canadians really using their RRSPs as a bankruptcy alternative?

According to a new BMO survey:

  • 21% of Canadians have taken money out of their RRSP to cover living expenses or pay off debt
  • 15% took money out to cover costs after an emergency
  • 25% say they will likely never pay it back

So the results of the BMO survey show that rather than dealing with all of their debts once and for all using a proper bankruptcy alternative, they are creating a new, significant income tax debt by raiding their RRSPs to pay off some debt! Not a very sound strategy.

Why is taking money out of an RRSP not advisable?

  • There is a withholding tax of 10% – 30% depending on the amount withdrawn
  • The money taken out has to be declared as income, and taxed again (unless you’re making withdrawals to buy a first home under the Home Buyers Plan or covering education costs under the Life Long Learning Plan)
  • If the funds, net of income tax, does not solve your debt problems, then it really isn’t a bankruptcy alternative

In a valid bankruptcy alternative, such as a consumer proposal, and in bankruptcy itself, other than for any contributions to your RRSP made in the 12 months prior to filing, you cannot lose the balance of your RRSP. You will actually have more RRSP at the end of a successfully performed consumer proposal, than if you raid your RRSP to avoid a valid bankruptcy alternative!!!

What should I do so I don’t have to raid my RRSP?

If you’re in “survival mode” when it comes to your finances, instead of raiding your RRSPs, we’ve got much better options for you. Although many people believe that bankruptcy is the only way of out serious debt, that’s not always the case. Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. can discuss other bankruptcy alternatives with you which include credit counselling, debt consolidation and consumer proposals.

If we get to see you early enough, at the first sign of trouble, you can utilize and implement one of the bankruptcy alternatives, to free you from the burden of your company’s financial challenges to go on to be a productive, profitable employer allowing management to focus on business growth and not be plagued by debt problems.

People consider us bankruptcy experts because we wrote the eBook which is sold on Amazon.com, explaining the Canadian personal insolvency and bankruptcy system, specifically directed to the person stressed out with too much debt. Come in for a no obligation, no fee consultation and let us help you get back on track to living a debt free life Starting Over, Starting Now. Give us a call today.

Call a Trustee Now!