quadriga Archives - Ira SmithTrustee & Receiver Inc.

If you would prefer to listen to the audio version of this Brandon’s Blog, please scroll to the bottom and click on the podcast.

The Ira Smith Team is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

Introduction

Quadriga CX (Quadriga, QuadrigaCX or Quadriga CX) was a subsidiary of Quadriga Fintech Solutions Corp. (Fintech). Fintech operated an online cryptocurrency exchange system where parties interested in acquiring, offering or trading numerous cryptocurrencies were able to complete such purchases on the QCX System.

In this Brandon’s Blog, I explain how the QuadrigaCX financial scandal can be used as an important lesson to aid in our financial literacy.

The Quadriga CX demise

Quadriga was experiencing a liquidity crisis as well as having been incapable to honour withdrawal requests from individuals. Furthermore, Quadriga had not been able to find a substantial amount of cryptocurrency upon the death of QuadrigaCX founder and CEO, Gerald William Cotten.

As a result of the liquidity situation combined with missing cash and cryptocurrency, Fintech and related companies made a decision to call a time out by filing for bankruptcy protection and hope for business restructuring on February 5, 2019, under the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act( Canada) (CCAA).

By April 11, 2019, it was obvious that there was no possibility of restructuring. On that date, the Court made a Termination and Bankruptcy Assignment Order was made by the court confirming the process through which the Quadriga CX CCAA procedure would terminate and shift to a corporate bankruptcy under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA).

QuadrigaCX 2020 update

The demise of the cryptocurrency trading system QuadrigaCX arises from a fraudulent scam by Gerald Cotten. Clients delegated their assets to Quadriga, which supplied fraudulent guarantees that those properties would be protected. In truth, Mr. Cotten invested, traded and made use of those properties as he pleased. Running with no proper system of oversight or interior controls, he had the ability to misuse those assets, uncontrolled and undiscovered, eventually bringing down the entire trading exchange.

On January 14, 2019, Quadriga CX announced that Mr. Cotten had passed away in India the previous month. With the Quadriga CX CEO death, he could not continue to manipulate the Quadriga CX platform and hide his fraud. The entire business operation imploded as described above.

It turns out that over 76,000 Quadriga CX customers were owed a combined $215 million. About 40 percent of the clients were from the province of Ontario. The bankruptcy trustee recovered $46 million in assets for distribution to unsecured creditors. The people that relied on QuadrigaCX collectively lost at least $169 million.

The Ontario Securities Commission investigation into the Quadriga CX demise

The staff of the Ontario Securities Commission (OSC) carried out an evaluation of the QuadrigaCX business operations to establish how the system was run, what created its collapse, and where the money went. Over a period of approximately ten months, a multi-disciplinary team of OSC Enforcement Branch staff analyzed trading and blockchain information, interviewed key witnesses and worked together with many regulatory bodies.

Most of the $169 million shortfall arose from Mr. Cotten’s fraudulent conduct. It has been widely guessed that the bulk of the losses arose from crypto properties ending up being lost or hard to reach as a result of Mr. Cotten’s death. The OSC found that most of the $169 million shortage arises from Mr. Cotten’s deceitful conduct.

The OSC report states that the bulk of the loss– about $115 million– occurred from Mr. Cotten’s illegal trading on the QuadrigaCX platform. He opened up Quadriga CX accounts under pen names and attributed himself with phony Quadriga cryptocurrency balances which he traded without knowledge by unwary Quadriga CX customers. He incurred losses when the price of the cryptocurrency would change, thus producing a deficiency in the assets needed to satisfy customer withdrawals. Mr. Cotten covered this deficiency with other customers’ deposits. This indicated that Quadriga CX, a state of the art new technology operated an old-time Ponzi scheme.

It is reported that Mr. Cotten lost an additional $28 million while trading customer deposits on three external cryptocurrency trading systems without permission from, or disclosure to, clients. He also misappropriated millions to fund his and his wife’s, Jennifer Robertson, way of living. In its final months, Quadriga CX had virtually no balances left and was running like a revolving door– brand-new customer deposits were quickly re-routed to money needed for Quadrigacx withdrawals.

In summary form, the OSC described the losses as:

$115 million trading losses sustained by Mr. Cotten on the Quadriga CX platform.
$46 million assets recovered or identified by the licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a bankruptcy trustee).
$28 million trading losses sustained on external platforms.
$23 million which could not be accounted for because of the poor state of the Quadriga CX books and records.
$2 million of client funds misappropriated for living and travel expenses.
$1 million estimated operating loss.

What the Quadriga CX scandal can teach us for improving our financial literacy

In Canada, lots of crypto property trading systems are not registered. They have taken the view that they do not need to sign up with regulatory authorities. This is an essential message to users and possible users of these platforms. So we need to keep in mind that there may be no regulatory oversight at all on these cryptocurrency trading platforms.
Cryptocurrency trading and the trading platforms are risky. Trading in crypto assets carries threats. Many platforms preserve safekeeping and control of their clients’ crypto assets. Clients just have ordinary unsecured claims against the platform for their assets. Clients are relying upon the solvency and stability of the system operators. Crypto asset trading systems might not operate transparently. Clients might have restricted or no details regarding how the platform is protecting and managing their assets.
Cryptocurrency system clients ought to perform due diligence and look out for signs of fraud. Anyone considering delegating their assets to a crypto asset trading platform should take action to learn more about the platform’s operations and approach to control the risk of monitoring. I recognize that this may not be feasible with the present degree of disclosure supplied by some systems. Cryptocurrency trading platforms are a bit of a black box that ordinary people do not really understand.
If cryptocurrency trading platforms were required to sign up with the provincial regulatory authority, perhaps there would be some oversight and protection for consumers.
Platforms need to make sure that they have systems as well as controls in a position to take care of risks. Having an internal control system to take care of risks, including those pertaining to business protection, vital employees and compliance with regulations is an important step for consumer confidence. The trading platforms should be able to describe the systems used to protect client assets. That way the public at least has a chance of being able to properly evaluate between different systems.
Systems should reveal key details to customers. Supplying clients with exact details regarding crucial aspects of their operations – such as asset wardship and storage techniques, charges, reported volumes, system protection actions and internal controls will help with educated decisions by investors and also advertise capitalist confidence in the platform.

Summary

The Ira Smith Team family hopes that you and your family members are remaining secure, healthy and well-balanced. Our hearts go out to every person that has been affected either via misfortune or inconvenience.

I hope you have found this Quadriga CX scandal Brandon’s Blog helpful. Cryptocurrency trading is still in the realm of the Wild West. Further work must be done before crypt currency can be widely used as a cash replacement. There are many financial literacy lessons we can garner from the Quadriga CX story. Even if Mr. Cotten had lived, the Ponzi scheme could only have been kept afloat for a finite time period before it would implode.

We all must help each other to stop the spread of the coronavirus. Social distancing and self-quarantining are sacrifices that are not optional. Families are literally separated from each other. We look forward to the time when life can return to something near to typical and we can all be together once again.

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. has constantly used clean, safe and secure ways in our professional firm and we continue to do so.

Income, revenue and cash flow shortages are critical issues facing entrepreneurs, their companies and individual Canadians. This is especially true these days.

If anyone needs our assistance for debt relief Canada COVID, or you just need some answers for questions that are bothering you, feel confident that Ira or Brandon can still assist you. Telephone consultations and/or virtual conferences are readily available for anyone feeling the need to discuss their personal or company situation.

The Ira Smith Team is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

Trustees in bankruptcy Toronto Ontario introduction

On April 15, 2019, a group of companies operating as QuadrigaCX (Quadriga) became bankrupt. This followed their initial application under the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA) to get bankruptcy protection.

The purpose of this Brandon’s Blog is to describe the latest events in this ongoing saga. Especially something trustees in bankruptcy Toronto Ontario usually don’t dig this.

What was Quadriga

Quadriga operated a crypto money exchange permitting customers to save, get, and offer various cryptocurrencies (including Bitcoin, Bitcoin Cash Money, Bitcoin Cash SV, Litecoin and Ethereum) on the Quadriga platform.

The cryptocurrency industry is not regulated in Canada and there is no governing body giving oversight.

Canadian chartered banks generally do not supply financial services such as bank accounts to companies operating in the cryptocurrency sector. This held true at Quadriga who needed the solutions offered by Third-Party Payment Processors (TPPP) to provide Quadriga’s treasury functions.

TPPP’s utilize various banking facilities in many countries around the globe. It can be very difficult to trace the flow of funds. Especially if the TPPP purposely sets up an international flow of funds through various intermediaries. We found this when we administered the bankruptcy of Conquest Vacations Inc. (Conquest).

No Canadian or US TPPP would clear Conquest’s credit card transactions. So, Conquest entered into an arrangement with a UK TPPP who utilized, amongst other banks, a financial institution in Mauritius. Our ability to trace the flow of funds with a high level of accuracy was thwarted in that case.

Quadriga was started by Mr. Gerald Cotten. It is reported that he died at. the age of 30 from complications from Crohn’s disease. At the time of his reported death, he was travelling in India.

Apparently, Mr. Cotten was the only person who knew the passwords associated with all the wallet addresses holding cryptocurrency.

Various issues faced by Trustees in bankruptcy Toronto Ontario

The Trustee was unable to find any documentation or other information regarding passwords. The Trustee also was unable to locate conventional books and records. The Trustee was not able to locate basic company records or accounting records.

There were also no records found documenting the location of Quadriga’s cryptocurrency and money reserves between third party settlement processors, savings account, wallet addresses and other third-party exchanges.

There also appeared to be no segregation of assets between funds of Quadriga and its customers. This would make it extremely difficult in any bankruptcy administration for trustees in bankruptcy Toronto Ontario or anywhere else in Canada.

The Trustee found that a substantial volume of cryptocurrency from Quadriga’s platform was transferred to competitor exchanges, some of which were transferred into personal accounts controlled by Mr. Cotten.

Additionally, significant amounts of cryptocurrency were moved to wallet holders whose identification was impossible to identify.

trustees in bankruptcy Toronto Ontario

Gerald Cotten enrichment found by Trustees in bankruptcy Toronto Ontario

It turns out that the cryptocurrency of Quadriga’s customers was taken off the Quadriga system to other third party exchanges and traded on those exchanges.

In other situations, cryptocurrency and its resultant cash were utilized for a margin trading account established by Mr. Cotten. Trading losses sustained and also incremental fees charged by exchanges negatively affected Quadriga’s cryptocurrency books.

Mr. Cotten created particular accounts on the Quadriga system under pen names where it appears that make-believe cryptocurrency and cash funds were deposited and used to trade within the Quadriga platform.

This resulted in inflated revenue numbers and ultimately the withdrawal of customers’ cryptocurrency. Substantial funds were moved to Mr. Cotten directly and various other associated accounts. This resulted in a substantial amount of cash and cryptocurrency reserves that could not be located.

The Trustee’s examination revealed that Mr. Cotten occasionally moved substantial cryptocurrency as well as various other funds outside of Quadriga. In certain instances, these transfers were for considerable amounts of currency routed to Mr. Cotten directly. Funds were used to fund personal costs and also the purchase of various personal assets.

In various other cases, transfers were made straight to his wife, Jennnifer Robertson. Funds were also used to pay personal expenses and to purchase personal assets both in her name or the name of companies which she controlled.

**The trustees in bankruptcy Toronto Ontario settlement with Jennifer Robertson**

Ms. Robertson has offered the Trustee a settlement offer that involves returning the majority of her possessions, the assets of Mr. Cotten’s Estate and also the assets of entities owned by Ms. Robertson or the Estate to the Trustee.

Negotiations have led to a settlement agreement acceptable to the Trustee. The Trustee was of the view that a negotiated settlement was more effective than ongoing litigation.

The settlement arrangements were substantial and conducted at arm’s length. The Trustee sought and obtained the agreement of the Inspectors in the Quadriga bankruptcy administration.

The settlement to transfer almost all of the assets owned by Ms. Robertson, the various companies and the Estate was also approved by the Court. So everything seems to be going smoothly, right?

Trustees in bankruptcy Toronto Ontario usually don’t dig this!

Not quite. On Friday, December 13, 2019, the legal team representing individuals who were users of the platform in these bankruptcy proceedings and who have lost collectively millions of dollars, sent a letter.

The letter went to the Royal Canadian Mounted Police seeking an exhumation and also post-mortem autopsy be performed on the body. The reason is to confirm both its identity as well as the cause of death.

They say information revealed during the proceedings, even more, highlights the requirement for assurance around the concern of whether Mr. Cotten is in fact deceased.

I don’t know why these lawyers feel that proving Mr. Cotten is in fact dead is so important. Maybe they feel that anyone who would give up substantially all of her assets, the Estate’s assets and related companies’ assets, must have more money somewhere else hidden.

Maybe they think that Mr. Cotten faked his own death, has millions of dollars that still have not been found and the two will reunite once the heat is off. I don’t know why, but this certainly is an unusual turn of events in a bankruptcy administration.

It is certainly something that trustees in bankruptcy Toronto Ontario or anywhere else in Canada don’t dig!

We will have to see how this saga unfolds and if there will be any more surprises.

Summary

I hope you found this Brandon’s Blog, Trustees in bankruptcy Toronto Ontario usually don’t dig this interesting. Sometimes things are too far gone and more drastic and immediate triage action is required.

Do you have too much debt? Are you in need of financial restructuring? The financial restructuring process is complex. The Ira Smith Team understands how to do a complex restructuring.

However, more importantly, we understand the needs of the entrepreneur or the person who has too much personal debt. You are worried because you are facing significant financial challenges.

It is not your fault that you are in this situation. You have been only shown the old ways that do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team uses new modern ways to get you out of your debt troubles while avoiding bankruptcy. We can get you debt relief freedom.

The stress placed upon you is huge. We understand your pain points. We look at your entire situation and devise a strategy that is as unique as you and your problems; financial and emotional. The way we take the load off of your shoulders and devise a debt settlement plan, we know that we can help you.

We know that people facing financial problems need a realistic lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” approach with the Ira Smith Team. That is why we can develop a restructuring process as unique as the financial problems and pain you are facing.

If any of this sounds familiar to you and you are serious about finding a solution, contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. team today.

Call us now for a free consultation. We will get you or your company back on the road to healthy stress-free operations and recover from the pain points in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.