Tag: personal guarantee

PERSONAL GUARANTEE: THE TREACHEROUS THREAT THAT COULD COST ONTARIO BUSINESS OWNERS EVERYTHING

Post author By Brandon Smith
Post date February 16, 2026

By Brandon Smith, Senior Vice-President, Licensed Insolvency Trustee at Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc.

Personal Guarantee Key Takeaways:

Limited Liability is Often an Illusion: If you signed a personal guarantee (PG), your personal assets are directly tied to your business debt.
P.G.s Are Strictly Enforced: Ontario courts uphold personal guarantees, even if you didn’t fully understand what you signed.
Your Home, Savings, and More Are at Risk: Defaulting on a personal guarantee can lead to the seizure of your personal property.
LITs Offer the Unique Solution: Only a Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT) like Brandon Smith at Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. can legally restructure both your corporate or personal debts under Canadian insolvency law.
Don’t Wait, Act Now: Proactive advice from an LIT is crucial to protect your financial future across the Greater Toronto Area.

Introduction: Navigating the Critical Crossroads of Business and Personal Liability

You started a business, likely as an Ontario numbered company, to protect your personal assets. You understood “limited liability” meant your personal finances were separate from your company’s. This is a fundamental reason why many entrepreneurs choose incorporation in cities from Toronto to Aurora and beyond. But then you signed it – that seemingly routine document called a personal guarantee. For many business owners across the Greater Toronto Area, from Toronto to Vaughan, Mississauga to Markham, this single signature shatters the illusion of limited liability, turning your separate corporate entity into a direct link to your personal wealth.

When your business faces financial distress, that personal guarantee transforms from a formality into a profound threat, putting your home, savings, and future on the line. It’s a critical crossroads where corporate responsibilities spill over into your personal life, often with devastating speed. Understanding this critical crossroads before crisis hits, or knowing your options when it does, is not just wise – it’s essential for your financial survival and peace of mind. Without proper guidance, the path from corporate debt to personal ruin can feel inescapable.

Understanding the Personal Guarantee: The Foundation of Individual Liability

A personal guarantee (PG) is a legally binding promise you, as an individual, make to personally repay a business debt if your company cannot. It bypasses the limited liability protection that an incorporated company usually offers.

Defining a Personal Guarantee: More Than Just a Signature

A personal guarantee is a contractual agreement that holds you, the business owner, personally responsible for your company’s debts. This means that if your business, say, a thriving retail store in Richmond Hill or a busy construction company in Woodbridge, defaults on its financial obligations, the lender or creditor can legally come after your personal assets to recover the money owed. It’s a direct commitment from you, the person, not just your company, and it’s taken very seriously by courts across Ontario. Many entrepreneurs sign these without fully grasping the long-term implications, viewing them as just another piece of paperwork to get the deal done.

The Mechanics: How Your Personal Assets Become Collateral

When a business defaults on a loan or lease that is backed by a personal guarantee, the lender or landlord doesn’t just stop at the company’s assets. Because of your signature on the PG, they gain the legal right to pursue your personal assets. This can include your personal bank accounts, investments, real estate (like your family home, cottage, or other properties), vehicles, and even future wages through garnishment. Essentially, your personal financial well-being becomes collateral for your business’s obligations. This is a crucial detail that distinguishes a guaranteed debt from a purely corporate one. It fundamentally shifts the risk from the corporate entity to the individual who signed the document, making it a very powerful tool for creditors.

Why Lenders and Landlords Demand Them

Lenders (like banks and credit unions) and landlords demand personal guarantees primarily to reduce their risk. Many small and medium-sized businesses, especially new or rapidly growing ones in areas like Richmond Hill or Newmarket, may not have enough established credit history or substantial assets to secure a loan on their own.

A personal guarantee provides an extra layer of security, giving creditors confidence that they will recover their funds even if the business itself falters. It shows the business owner’s personal commitment to the venture.

Without it, many businesses would struggle to get the financing or commercial leases they need to operate, effectively stifling entrepreneurial growth in communities across Ontario. It’s often the price of doing business for small enterprises that don’t yet have the balance sheet of a large corporation.

Deciphering the Types of Personal Guarantees

Not all personal guarantees are the same, and understanding the nuances of each type is crucial for any business owner in Ontario.

Unlimited Personal Guarantee: This is the most common and, frankly, the riskiest type of personal guarantee. It makes you fully responsible for the entire business debt, including the principal amount, accumulated interest, any legal fees incurred by the creditor, and any other associated costs, with absolutely no cap. If your business in Concord or Thornhill takes out a $500,000 loan, and you sign an unlimited personal guarantee, you are personally liable for that full $500,000 plus all additional charges, even if your personal assets only amount to $200,000. This type of guarantee truly exposes all your personal assets to the maximum extent.
Limited Personal Guarantee: This type restricts your liability to a specific, predetermined amount or a certain percentage of the debt. For example, you might only be responsible for a set dollar amount, say $100,000, regardless of the total business debt. Or, if there are multiple guarantors, you might be responsible for only 50% of the loan. This offers a significant advantage by capping your potential personal exposure, making it a more palatable option for many business owners. Negotiating for a limited guarantee is always a wise strategy if possible.
Joint and Several Personal Guarantee: This type is often found in businesses with multiple owners or partners, common in collaborative business environments like those found in Woodbridge or Concord. While two or more people guarantee the loan, “joint and several” means each individual guarantor is legally responsible for the full amount of the debt, not just their proportional share. If one guarantor cannot pay due to personal financial issues, the lender can pursue the other guarantor(s) for the entire outstanding balance. This is a critical point that many business partners overlook, often leading to severe financial and personal disputes when a business fails. It means your personal finances are not only tied to the business but also to the financial health of your co-guarantors.
Conditional vs. Unconditional Personal Guarantee:
- Conditional: A conditional personal guarantee is tied to specific conditions that must be met before the guarantee can be enforced. For instance, you might only be liable until the business reaches a certain sales target, if specific company assets are sold first, or if the primary borrower files for bankruptcy. These are less common, as lenders generally prefer the directness of an unconditional guarantee.
- Unconditional: Most personal guarantees are unconditional. This means the lender can demand payment from you directly upon the business’s default, without first pursuing the business or its assets. They don’t need to wait for any specific events or try to recover from the company first; they can go straight to you, the personal guarantor. This provides the quickest and most direct path to recovery for the creditor.

Common Scenarios Where Personal Guarantees Appear

Personal guarantees are woven into the fabric of many commercial dealings for small and medium-sized businesses in Ontario, often without the owner fully realizing their pervasive nature.

Business Loans and Lines of Credit: This is arguably the most frequent scenario. Banks and other financial institutions almost always require a personal guarantee from business owners when extending credit. This is particularly true for startups or businesses without substantial collateral. Whether you’re securing a loan for equipment for your manufacturing plant in Markham or a line of credit to manage cash flow for your Toronto-based tech startup, a personal guarantee will likely be a non-negotiable term. Lenders want to know that the individual behind the business is committed and has personal stakes.
Commercial Leases: When renting office, retail, or industrial space in busy areas like Mississauga or Thornhill, landlords frequently demand a personal guarantee, more commonly worded in the lease document as a personal indemnity, from business owners. This ensures rent payments even if the business goes under or defaults on the lease agreement. A landlord doesn’t want to be left with an empty space and unpaid rent, so your personal guarantee serves as their insurance policy hoping the rent continues to be paid, regardless of the business’s solvency. In reality, if the business becomes insolvent, the personal guarantor/iindemnifier has lost their source of income too and will be pursued by the landlord.
Franchise Agreements: Becoming a franchisee often involves a significant upfront investment, ongoing royalty payments, and adherence to various operational standards. Franchisors typically require personal guarantees from franchisees to secure these commitments. They are investing in you as much as you are investing in their brand, and your personal guarantee ensures your full commitment to the success and financial obligations of the franchise, whether it’s a restaurant in Vaughan or a service provider in Newmarket.
Supplier Agreements: For significant credit lines with suppliers, especially for goods that are critical to your operation, a personal guarantee might be requested to ensure payment for goods or services. This is more common if the business has limited credit history, is new, or if the value of the supplies is substantial. A supplier wants assurance that they will be paid, particularly if their product is a major cost component for your business.
Government-Backed Loans: Even loans partially guaranteed by government programs (like some through the Business Development Bank of Canada or Export Development Canada) often still require a personal guarantee from the business owner for the unguaranteed portion, or to ensure compliance with loan terms.

The Profound Personal Guarantee Impact: Benefits vs. Grave Risks to Personal Assets

Signing a personal guarantee is a double-edged sword for any Ontario business owner. It presents both potential benefits that facilitate business growth and grave risks that can jeopardize personal financial stability.

Benefits:

Access to Financing: For many new or small businesses, especially those just starting out in competitive markets like Toronto or Vaughan, a personal guarantee is the only way to secure necessary loans or credit lines. Without it, many promising ventures would be unable to obtain the capital needed to start, expand, or even operate day-to-day. It’s often the key that unlocks crucial funding, enabling growth and operational continuity.
Improved Loan Terms: The added security provided by a personal guarantee might lead to more favourable financial terms. Lenders may be willing to offer lower interest rates, extended repayment periods, or larger loan amounts when they have the assurance of a personal guarantee, recognizing the reduced risk. This can significantly impact the long-term financial health and viability of the business.
Increased Creditor Confidence: A personal guarantee signals your strong personal commitment to the business. It demonstrates to lenders and landlords that you are fully invested and confident in your venture’s success, building trust and potentially opening doors to future financial opportunities or partnerships.

Grave Risks to Personal Assets:

Loss of Personal Assets: This is the most significant and immediate danger. If your business defaults, creditors can legally seize your home, family cottage, car, personal bank accounts, savings, investments, and other valuable possessions to satisfy the debt. For many, their home represents their largest personal asset and their life savings, all of which can be put at risk.
Impact on Personal Credit: A business default, followed by a personal guarantee claim, could damage your personal credit score. This makes it incredibly difficult to secure future personal loans, mortgages, car loans, or even credit cards, potentially for many years. It could affect your ability to rent property or even get certain jobs.
Unlimited Liability: As discussed, many personal guarantees are unlimited, meaning you’re on the hook for the entire debt, including all associated costs, which can far exceed the initial loan amount. This can be financially ruinous, as the total debt can balloon rapidly with interest and legal fees.
Personal Bankruptcy: If your personal assets are insufficient to cover the guaranteed debt after your business fails, and you haven’t yet secured a new source of income that could help fund a viable consumer proposal to deal with your debt, you could be forced into personal bankruptcy. This is a formal legal process under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA) that leads to long-lasting financial consequences and can affect your personal and professional reputation.
Strain on Relationships: In joint and several guarantees, disagreements among business partners about repayment obligations when the business faces distress can lead to severe personal disputes, legal battles, and the breakdown of relationships, adding emotional turmoil to financial stress. This is particularly true in family businesses or partnerships where trust is paramount.

Before You Sign: Due Diligence & Negotiation Playbook

While personal guarantees are often unavoidable for small business owners in Ontario, you can take proactive steps to protect yourself before committing your signature. This due diligence can save you immense heartache and financial hardship down the line.

Read Every Word, No Exceptions: Never assume anything. It is absolutely critical to thoroughly read the entire personal guarantee agreement, no matter how long, complex, or full of legal jargon it appears. Many people skim these documents, missing crucial clauses that can severely impact their personal finances. If you don’t understand something, ask.
Seek Independent Legal Advice: This is not merely a suggestion; it is critical. Have a lawyer, who is independent of the lender or landlord, review the personal guarantee in detail. They can explain the full extent of your liability, identify any hidden clauses, and advise you on the specific risks involved. While some provinces, like Alberta, require independent legal advice by law for certain PGs, it is highly recommended in Ontario as best practice, even if not mandatory. This small investment can prevent a catastrophic loss.
Negotiate Clauses to Mitigate Risk: Many business owners believe personal guarantees are non-negotiable, but this isn’t always true. While the core requirement might remain, you can often negotiate key terms:
- Limit the Amount: Always try to cap your liability to a specific dollar amount or a percentage of the total debt. This sets a clear ceiling on your personal exposure, which is far better than an unlimited guarantee.
- Limit the Term: Can the guarantee expire after a certain number of years, or once a substantial portion of the loan (e.g., 50% or 75%) is repaid? A finite term reduces your long-term risk.
- Require Exhaustion of Company Assets First: Try to insist on a clause that states the lender must pursue all company assets and collateral before coming after your personal assets. This can delay or even avoid personal liability if the business has significant assets. (Note: This is often difficult to negotiate, as creditors prefer direct access.)
- Release Upon Sale of Ownership: If you plan to sell your ownership stake in the business, negotiate a clause that automatically releases you from the personal guarantee once the sale is complete and approved by the lender.
- Joint vs. Several Liability: If there are multiple owners, try to ensure liability is strictly “joint” (meaning each is only responsible for their specific, agreed-upon share), rather than “joint and several.” As discussed, “joint and several” means you could be on the hook for everyone’s portion.
Understand Recourse Agreements with Partners: If you’re guaranteeing a loan with business partners, have a clear, written agreement among yourselves about indemnification. This means if one partner is forced to pay on the PG, the others are legally obligated to reimburse them for their share.
Independent Witnessing: While not always legally required in Ontario, the lender or landlord requirimg an independent adult witness your signature adds evidentiary strength if the enforceability of the guarantee is ever challenged in court.

You may have no leverage in actually getting any terms of the personal guarantee amended, that does not mean you should not try.

When the Business Defaults: Navigating the Aftermath

The moment your business defaults on a loan or lease backed by a personal guarantee is a critical juncture. How you react can significantly impact your personal financial future.

The Default Process & Legal Recourse

When a business defaults on a loan or lease backed by a personal guarantee, the creditor will typically follow a structured legal process:

Issue a Demand Letter: The creditor will formally notify both the business and you, as the guarantor, of the default. This letter will demand immediate full payment of the outstanding debt, including any accrued interest and penalties. For the borrower, the landlord also issues the appropriate notice required under the BIA.
Initiate Legal Action: If the demand for payment isn’t met, the creditor can, and often will, sue you personally. Ontario courts enforce personal guarantees strictly, meaning your signature is often all they need to establish your liability. This lawsuit will seek a judgment against you for the full amount owed.
Obtain a Judgment: If successful in court (which is common if the PG is valid), the creditor will obtain a court judgment against you personally. This judgment confirms your legal obligation to pay the debt.
Enforce the Judgment: With a judgment in hand, the creditor has powerful legal tools to recover the money. This can lead to:
- Wage Garnishment: A court order can be issued to your employer, directing a portion of your employment income to be redirected directly to the creditor each pay period until the debt is satisfied.
- Bank Account Seizure: Funds in your personal bank accounts can be frozen and taken by the creditor to cover the debt.
- Asset Seizure: Your personal property, including real estate (like your family home), vehicles, and investments, can be seized and sold to satisfy the debt. This can be a devastating process, potentially forcing the sale of assets you rely on.
- Registration of a Writ: A writ of execution can be registered against your property (like your home), impacting your ability to sell or refinance it until the debt is paid.

Protecting Assets Post-Default

Once a personal guarantee is called, options for protecting assets become significantly more limited. However, it’s vital to act quickly and strategically.

Do Not Transfer Assets Fraudulently: Attempting to hide, transfer, or sell off assets after default in an effort to avoid creditors can be considered fraudulent conveyance or fraudulent preference under Canadian law. This can lead to severe legal penalties, including criminal charges, and will almost certainly worsen your financial situation, as the court can reverse these transactions. The best time to always seek professional advice before making any significant financial moves is BEFORE providing the personal guarantee. Post-default is already too late.
Negotiate with the Creditor: Sometimes, a creditor may be willing to negotiate a payment plan, a reduced lump-sum settlement, or other terms if you demonstrate a genuine willingness to address the debt, even if you can’t pay it all immediately. This often requires professional assistance, as an experienced advisor can present your situation more effectively and explore options you might not know exist.
Understand Exempt Assets: In Ontario, certain assets are exempt from seizure in a bankruptcy or other legal action. These are designed to allow individuals a basic level of survival. Examples include a portion of your household goods, tools of your trade (up to a certain value), some equity in a primary vehicle, some equity in a personal residence,and most life insurance policies. A Licensed Insolvency Trustee can provide a precise list of these protections, which can be crucial in preserving some financial stability.

The Indispensable Role of Professional Advice

When your business is struggling, and you’re facing demands on your personal guarantee, you need expert advice. This is not a situation to navigate alone.

The Unique Power of a Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT)

When your business is struggling, and you’re facing demands on your personal guarantee, you need expert advice. While lawyers can defend you in court or try to negotiate with creditors, they cannot offer the comprehensive solutions required to truly resolve both corporate and personal debt issues under Canada’s insolvency laws. This is where a Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT), like Brandon Smith, Senior Vice-President at Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc., becomes your most critical ally.

LITs are the only federally regulated professionals legally authorized to administer all formal insolvency processes in Canada under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA). This unique mandate means we can address the “double bind” of corporate failure and personal guarantee exposure. We are not debt consultants or credit counsellors; we are officers of the court, licensed by the Canadian government, and uniquely positioned to provide legal pathways to debt relief. Whether your business is in Toronto, Vaughan, Markham, or any other community in Ontario, an LIT’s expertise is paramount.

Why Only an LIT Can Handle the “Double Bind”

Imagine your numbered company in Vaughan or Mississauga is in distress, and a lender is now pursuing you personally for a significant loan guaranteed by you. A lawyer can represent you in court, defend against the lawsuit, or try to negotiate with the creditor. While these services are valuable in certain contexts, a lawyer cannot provide the all-encompassing debt resolution solutions available under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act.

Here’s why only an LIT can effectively handle the complex interplay of corporate and personal insolvency, especially when personal guarantees are involved:

Stop Collection Calls and Legal Action Immediately: Only the filing of a formal insolvency process (like a Consumer Proposal or personal bankruptcy) by an LIT automatically triggers a “stay of proceedings” under the BIA. This is a powerful legal injunction that legally halts all unsecured creditor actions, including collection calls, lawsuits, wage garnishments, and even proceedings to seize assets. A lawyer can defend against these actions, but they cannot unilaterally stop them as an LIT can by filing under the BIA. This immediate relief from creditor pressure is often the first and most critical step towards regaining control.
Legally Reduce or Eliminate Debt: Lawyers can negotiate with creditors, but they don’t have the power to bind all creditors to a debt reduction agreement. An LIT, however, can administer a Consumer Proposal for individuals (which can include personal guarantee debt) or a Division I Proposal for corporations. These are formal, legally binding offers to creditors to pay back a portion of what’s owed, or extend the time to pay, typically resulting in a significant reduction of the overall debt. Once a Proposal is accepted by a majority of creditors (by dollar value), all included unsecured creditors are legally bound by its terms, even if they voted against it. This is a powerful, court-sanctioned tool no other professional can wield, allowing for a structured and manageable repayment plan or a full discharge of debt.
Administer Personal or Corporate Bankruptcy: If restructuring isn’t feasible or desirable, an LIT is the only professional who can administer personal bankruptcy (to discharge personal guarantee debt and other unsecured personal debts) or corporate bankruptcy (to formally liquidate the business in an orderly manner). These processes provide a complete fresh financial start for individuals or an orderly wind-down for corporations, a service that lawyers cannot provide. An LIT ensures that the bankruptcy process adheres to all legal requirements, protecting the rights of both the debtor and the creditors.
Holistic Approach to Interconnected Debt: The “double bind” of corporate failure and personal guarantee liability is precisely what LITs are designed to resolve. We understand how the corporate debt, the personal guarantee, and your personal finances are inextricably linked. We offer a holistic strategy that considers both the business’s situation and your personal financial health, finding the most efficient and legally sound solution for both. A lawyer’s approach often involves separate actions for corporate and personal legal issues.

Table: LIT vs. Lawyer in Resolving Personal Guarantee Debt

Feature	Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT)	Lawyer (Debt-Related Matters)
Legal Authority	Federally regulated under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA), an officer of the court.	Regulated by provincial law societies; represents clients in legal proceedings.
Debt Restructuring	Can legally reduce and consolidate unsecured debt via Consumer Proposals or Division I Proposals, binding all creditors to a formal plan.	Can negotiate with individual creditors, but cannot force them to accept a reduced settlement or legally bind all creditors to a collective plan.
Stopping Creditor Action	Filing a Proposal or Bankruptcy triggers an immediate, legal “stay of proceedings,” halting all collections, lawsuits, and garnishments.	Can defend lawsuits and send cease and desist letters, but cannot unilaterally stop legal actions without a specific court order for each.
Bankruptcy Administration	Only LITs can administer personal or corporate bankruptcies, leading to debt discharge or orderly liquidation.	Cannot administer bankruptcy; typically refers clients to an LIT when bankruptcy is the appropriate solution.
Holistic Approach	Addresses both corporate insolvency and personal liability from guarantees through BIA processes.	Primarily focuses on legal defense or specific debt negotiations; often separates corporate legal issues from personal liability.
Cost Structure	Fees for consumer insolvencies are federally regulated and often included in the proposal payment; initial consultation often free.	Hourly billing is common; costs can become very expensive, especially in litigation, with no guarantee of debt reduction.
Goal	To provide a legal path to debt relief and a fresh financial start for individuals and businesses, maximizing asset retention.	To represent clients’ legal interests, defend against claims, pursue legal action, or draft legal agreements.

When facing the complexity of a personal guarantee, especially in conjunction with business distress, you need the specialized expertise and legal authority that only an LIT provides. Their role is unique and indispensable for navigating Canada’s insolvency laws.

Brandon’s Personal Guarantee Take:

“As Senior Vice-President at Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc., I’ve seen countless Ontario business owners grapple with the crushing weight of a personal guarantee. The initial shock of realizing their personal assets are exposed is immense. Often, people feel isolated and overwhelmed, believing there’s no way out. My team and I are here to tell you: you are not alone, and you absolutely have options. We understand the fear, the stress, and the uncertainty that comes with such a significant financial threat.

Our role is to provide clear, empathetic guidance through the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act. We’re licensed by the Canadian government specifically to help individuals and businesses like yours find relief from overwhelming debt, including those tied to personal guarantees. Don’t let pride or fear delay seeking help; early action can make all the difference in preserving your home, your savings, and your financial future. We serve clients across the GTA, from Aurora to Newmarket, and are ready to listen without judgment.”

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q: What is a personal guarantee and how does it work in Ontario?

A: A personal guarantee is a legally binding agreement where an individual (usually a business owner) promises to be personally responsible for a company’s debt if the company cannot pay it. In Ontario, if the business defaults, the lender can pursue your personal assets directly, bypassing the usual limited liability protection of your corporation. This means your personal wealth is on the line.

Q: Can a personal guarantee be discharged or eliminated if my business fails?

A: Yes, personal guarantee debt can often be discharged or significantly reduced through formal insolvency processes administered by a Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT). A Consumer Proposal or personal bankruptcy, for example, can include and eliminate personal guarantee obligations, providing you with a fresh financial start and relief from the debt.

Q: Why should I consult a Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT) if I’m facing personal guarantee debt?

A: An LIT is the only professional in Canada legally authorized to administer government-regulated insolvency proceedings like Consumer Proposals and bankruptcies under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act. This unique legal authority means an LIT can legally stop collection calls, lawsuits, and wage garnishments, and can structure a plan (a Proposal) that reduces or eliminates your personal guarantee debt, binding all creditors. Lawyers cannot offer these specific debt restructuring solutions that provide a legal fresh start.

Q: What is “joint and several” liability in a personal guarantee?

A: “Joint and several” liability means that if multiple people sign a personal guarantee, each person is individually responsible for the entire amount of the debt, not just a portion or their specific share. The creditor can choose to pursue any one of the guarantors for the full outstanding balance, making it a particularly risky type of guarantee for business partners.

Q: Will signing a personal guarantee affect my personal credit score?

A: Yes, a personal guarantee ties your personal credit to your business’s financial health. If your business defaults and you’re unable to meet the obligations of the personal guarantee, it will negatively impact your personal credit score. This can make it difficult to get personal loans, mortgages, or credit cards in the future.

Q: Are there any assets in Ontario that are protected from seizure if I default on a personal guarantee?

A: Yes, in Ontario, certain assets are considered “exempt” from seizure in insolvency proceedings, up to specific values. These can include a portion of your household goods, tools of your trade, some equity in a primary vehicle, most RRSPs and RRIFs (except for contributions made in the 12 months before filing for insolvency), and most life insurance policies. A Licensed Insolvency Trustee can provide you with the exact details of these exemptions.

Conclusion: Take Control of Your Financial Future – Contact Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc.

The personal guarantee is a powerful and often misunderstood legal document that can have devastating effects on Ontario business owners and their families. While it may seem like a simple step to secure vital business financing, it truly makes your personal assets the ultimate collateral, blurring the lines between your business and personal financial security.

If your numbered company in Toronto, Vaughan, Woodbridge, Concord, Mississauga, Thornhill, Richmond Hill, Markham, Aurora, or Newmarket is facing financial difficulties, and personal guarantees are a significant concern, you need to act quickly and decisively. Relying solely on general legal advice may not provide the comprehensive, legally binding debt restructuring solutions you truly need to protect your future.

As a Licensed Insolvency Trustee, Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc., led by Senior Vice-President Brandon Smith, possesses the unique legal authority and extensive expertise to help you navigate these complex challenges. We can explore all your options, from Consumer Proposals that reduce your debt and protect your assets, to guiding you through a corporate and personal bankruptcy process if necessary. Our approach is professional, empathetic, and always focused on achieving the best possible outcome for your specific situation. We are here to bring clarity and provide a pathway forward, no matter how dire things may seem.

Don’t let the silent threat of a personal guarantee lead to financial ruin. Contact Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. today for a free, no-obligation consultation. We are here to help you understand your situation, explore your legal options under Canadian insolvency law, and create a clear path towards a debt-free future. You deserve a fresh start, and we are here to help you achieve it.

Take the first crucial step towards a brighter financial future for your business. Contact Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. today to schedule your free initial consultation. Your business’s pivot to sustainable success starts now.

Don’t let financial uncertainty dictate your future. If you or your business is struggling with debt, losing sleep, or facing the possibility of legal action, contact Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. today. We offer a free, confidential consultation to discuss your situation, explain your options in plain language, and help you develop a clear, actionable plan. Our team of Licensed Insolvency Trustees is dedicated to providing the compassionate, professional support you need to regain control and achieve a debt-free life. Take the first step towards a brighter financial future – call us now.

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. is licensed by the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy and is a member of the Canadian Association of Insolvency and Restructuring Professionals.

Phone: 905.738.4167
Toronto line: 647.799.3312
Website: https://irasmithinc.com/
Email: brandon@irasmithinc.com

——————————————————————————–

Disclaimer: This analysis is for educational purposes only and is based on the cited sources and my professional expertise as a licensed insolvency trustee. The information provided does not constitute legal or financial advice for your specific circumstances.

Every situation is unique and involves complex legal and factual considerations. The outcomes discussed in this article may not apply to your particular situation. Situations are fact-specific and depend on the particular circumstances of each case.

Please contact Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc.get in touch with Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc.

About the Author:

Brandon Smith is a Senior Vice-President at Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. and a licensed insolvency trustee serving clients across Ontario. With extensive experience in complex court-ordered receivership administration and corporate insolvency & restructuring proceedings, Brandon helps businesses, creditors, and professionals navigate challenging financial situations to achieve optimal outcomes.

Brandon stays current with landmark developments in Canadian insolvency law. He brings this cutting-edge knowledge to every client engagement, ensuring his clients benefit from the most current understanding of their rights and options.

Brandon Blog Post

DEMYSTIFYING COMPANY LIQUIDATION: MASSIVE INSIGHTS FROM ONTARIO’S LEGAL JOURNEY

Post author By Brandon Smith
Post date February 19, 2024

company liquidation

company liquidation

Company Liquidation: Introduction

Company liquidation involves navigating a myriad of legal and financial obligations, particularly when a company is deemed insolvent. This process requires a thorough understanding of the duties and responsibilities of company directors, legal obligations in insolvency proceedings, and the roles of licensed insolvency trustees and the Court. Identifying insolvent companies and differentiating between secured and unsecured creditors are also fundamental aspects of the liquidation process.

In the fast-paced and competitive world of business, trust and collaboration are often the key ingredients for success. The recent legal case of Srivastava v. DLT Global Inc. 2023 ONSC 7103 (CanLII) serves as a powerful reminder of just how crucial these elements are in maintaining a thriving business. By delving into the details of the case, I explore the consequences of a breakdown in trust and collaboration and highlight the lessons that can be learned from this real-life scenario.

Join in this Brandon’s Blog Post as I explore the decision-making process in company liquidation, from understanding the options to implementing the liquidation strategy. We will also discuss the personal and legal ramifications, covering topics such as personal liability for business owners and directors, voluntary versus compulsory liquidations, and the voluntary liquidation process.

Whether you’re a business owner facing insolvency or a professional seeking insights into company liquidation, this article will provide valuable information to navigate the complex landscape of liquidation proceedings in Ontario.

Company Liquidation: Understanding the Basics

Company liquidation is a critical process for closing a limited company that either can no longer meet its financial obligations or if solvent, cannot continue due to other reasons. When a business undergoes liquidation, its assets are sold off, and the proceeds are used to pay back outstanding creditors.

There are two predominant types of company liquidation: voluntary and compulsory. Voluntary liquidation, which may be initiated by the shareholders or a court order, is often chosen when a company is solvent but burdened by debts. Compulsory liquidations happen through a court order when a company can either no longer pay its debts or, management is dysfunctional and can no longer work together to properly wind up the corporation and its business.

Liquidation proceedings are typically overseen by a licensed insolvency trustee. Company directors must comply with legal obligations during this process to avoid personal liability, particularly if they have given a personal guarantee for business debts.

A common cause for company liquidation is a significant drop in business, such as the loss of a major contract. Although liquidation can entail substantial costs, options exist even for companies without assets. Business owners must seek expert advice to ensure a smooth transition during the liquidation process. Here’s a simplified overview of the liquidation process:

Decision to liquidate (voluntary or court-ordered)
Appointment of a licensed insolvency practitioner
Asset liquidation
Settlement of debts with creditors
Redemption of shares to the extent there is cash to do so
Dissolution of the company

company liquidation

Company Liquidation: Understanding Insolvency in Canada

In Canada, insolvency is a legal term indicating a company’s financial distress, where a business is unable to meet its obligations as they come due, or ceases to pay current liabilities during normal operations. This situation often leads to company liquidation or other forms of bankruptcy proceedings governed by various statutes, including the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA), the Winding-up and Restructuring Act, and the Companies Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA).

Conversely, insolvent companies are subject to the aforementioned insolvency laws, which set out the protective legal framework allowing for a fair and orderly process of winding up a company’s affairs and distributing its assets. Insolvency laws in Canada are designed not only to adjudicate the distribution of company assets but also to provide possible recovery pathways for financially distressed businesses.

Identifying Insolvent Companies

Insolvent companies are characterized by their inability to discharge their financial liabilities as they become due. A more comprehensive view of insolvency includes the scenario where the total liabilities of a company exceed the fair valuation of its assets, suggesting that even the sale of all its assets would not cover the outstanding debts.

It is therefore essential for business owners and company directors to recognize the early signs of insolvency and to understand the consequences it may have for the future of their ventures. Identifying an insolvent company promptly is critical as it enables directors to take necessary action to either revive the company or initiate an appropriate exit strategy.

Duties and Responsibilities of Company Directors in Insolvency

When a company is facing insolvency, directors hold increased responsibilities and must pivot their focus to prioritize the interests of their creditors. This can involve refraining from incurring additional debt, avoiding transactions that undervalue company assets, and ensuring that no further detriment is caused to the financial standing of the creditors. Failure to act responsibly in the face of insolvency can result in allegations of wrongful or even fraudulent trading, potentially leading to personal liability for the directors. Timely, responsible action by directors is essential for limiting potential damages and preserving the trust and rights of creditors involved.

Legal Obligations in Insolvency Proceedings

The liquidation process for insolvent companies in Canada involves stringent legal obligations and is closely monitored by the courts. Directors must comply with laws set forth by the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act or engage in processes like Company Creditors Arrangement Act proceedings, which offer an alternative to outright liquidation. In practice, the process is administered by a court-approved licensed insolvency practitioner (IP) who oversees the liquidation of assets, repayment of creditors, and an investigation into the reasons for the company’s failure, including examining the conduct of its directors.

Commencing company liquidation does not automatically cancel existing contracts; however, the entity in liquidation has statutory provisions under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act to terminate agreements that are no longer viable or beneficial.

Directors must understand their legal obligations and the procedural steps involved to ensure that they comply with the law and mitigate any risk of personal liability. The role of IP is pivotal in managing the process to achieve an equitable outcome for all parties and to facilitate a lawful and orderly conclusion to the company’s affairs.

Company Liquidation: The Role of Insolvency Practitioners

A Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT) are professionals licensed, authorized and supervised by the Federal Government to act concerning an insolvent individual, partnership, or company. These specialists take control of businesses that face financial difficulties to achieve the best possible outcome for shareholders, board of directors, employees, and – most significantly – creditors. Their expertise is essential in navigating the complex process of business liquidation including the sale of assets.

LITs meticulously itemize business expenses and assess the value of remaining assets when a business is ending. This is a vital step in determining how best to distribute assets among creditors. They are also responsible for conducting thorough investigations into why a company failed, examining the conduct of its directors, and sometimes reviewing the actions of third parties, like creditors.

The process they oversee – whether it’s a voluntary company liquidation or an involuntary liquidation – adheres to a strict legal hierarchy for repaying creditors. This ensures a clear and equitable distribution of assets, even though unsecured creditors may receive little to no return. The ultimate aim of an insolvent liquidation, guided by the LIT, is to provide a dividend to all classes of creditors to the extent that the company’s assets allow.

The Official Receiver and their Role in Liquidation Proceedings

The Official Receiver is a local public official within the Federal Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy. They play a pivotal role in managing the insolvency process in Canada. This includes setting standards, providing directives to LITs on how to proceed in certain situations and overall supervisory responsibility of LITs.

Secured Creditors vs Unsecured Creditors: What You Need to Know

In the hierarchy of repayments during a company liquidation, understanding the distinction between secured and unsecured creditors is crucial. Secured creditors are those with a legal claim on assets, often due to a lien or a security interest that guarantees their investment. Should a company dissolve, these creditors are prioritized to receive payment from the sale of the secured assets. Examples include lenders who financed company property or equipment.

On the other hand, unsecured creditors do not have this collateral backing. They include entities like credit card companies or suppliers with outstanding invoices. Once the secured creditors are paid, unsecured creditors fall next in line for any remaining funds, though often recovery rates are low or nonexistent.

Employees, as stakeholders, are also categorized as unsecured creditors, but may be prioritized differently depending on the jurisdiction and specific liquidation laws. In bankruptcy, secured creditors may take control of pledged assets to offset their losses, while unsecured creditors must wait to see if there are any funds left after the liquidation of unpledged assets.

Understanding these classifications is paramount for anyone involved in a company liquidation, as they dictate the order of payments and potential recovery. This knowledge can influence decisions made prior to and throughout the liquidation process, impacting all parties involved, from the business owner to the smallest creditor.

Creditor Type	Description	Recovery Source	Priority in Company Liquidation
Secured	Creditors with a legal claim on assets (e.g., banks have taken a security interest for their loan, property liens)	Sale of specific collateral	High
Unsecured	Creditors without a claim on assets (e.g., suppliers, credit card companies)	Remaining business assets after secured debts are paid	Lower

By managing secured and unsecured creditors efficiently, Insolvency Practitioners can ensure a fair and lawful distribution of a company’s remaining assets, while acknowledging the varying levels of risk each creditor assumed.

company liquidation

The Company Liquidation Process: From Decision-Making to Implementation

The journey of company liquidation begins with a crucial decision-making phase, a stage where the future of a business and its stakeholders hangs in the balance. Whether a company opts for voluntary liquidation as part of a strategic exit strategy or faces the harsh reality of insolvency, the liquidation process demands a careful, planned approach to implement.

A solvent company considering voluntary company liquidation might be doing so for reasons such as the directors’ retirement or a strategic decision that the business has run its course. On the contrary, a liquidation of the assets of an insolvent company is triggered when a company cannot meet its financial obligations and must cease operations. In both cases, engaging professional advisers, being a LIT and a lawyer early in the process, can offer guidance through each phase, from the planning stages to the final dissolution of the company.

When the voluntary liquidation process is chosen, a company can prepare in advance, making for a more orderly and manageable closure. This method is less intrusive compared to a court-imposed compulsory liquidation following a creditor’s application. Throughout the process, the appointed insolvency practitioner works to sell off assets and settle debts, culminating in the formal winding up of the company.

In the event of an involuntary company liquidation, the proceedings begin following a winding-up petition from creditors. Legal mandates spell out the steps to be taken, from appointment of a liquidator to notifying and paying out creditors. The process may differ slightly from province to province where specific local laws affect the liquidation process.

In either scenario, the overarching goal is to handle assets and debts in conformity with legal and ethical obligations, and ultimately, to provide clarity and closure to all parties involved.

Making the Decision to Liquidate: Understanding the Options

When the decision looms to liquidate a company, it’s paramount for business owners to understand their options. A company’s status—solvent or insolvent—plays a pivotal role in determining the path taken in liquidation. Solvent companies generally have the luxury of choice, where directors may opt for a company liquidation as an exit strategy when the business has fulfilled its purpose or due to retirement.

Alternatively, for insolvent companies, the decision is less voluntary and often more urgent. Directors may initiate a liquidation to preempt spiralling debts and legal actions by creditors, or they may find themselves in the throes of a bankruptcy protection filing, where a court determines what will happen with the business.

The voluntary initiation of a company liquidation before reaching a crisis point can be less traumatic for a company and its personnel, allowing the liquidator to manage a planned and orderly process.

Company Assets and Outstanding Debts: Navigating the Financial Obligations

Once a company enters the liquidation phase, addressing the financial aspects follows swiftly. This involves a comprehensive accounting of company assets and a thorough evaluation of outstanding debts. The liquidator’s role here is integral. They’re tasked with the identification and valuation of all company assets, assessing business assets like inventory, property, and machinery. Following the liquidation sale, they oversee the distribution of proceeds to creditors, prioritizing secured over unsecured creditors, with any excess then directed to shareholders or the owner.

The focus shifts to the company’s debts, with secured creditors receiving payment first due to their collateral backing. Unsecured creditors, such as trade creditors, are then considered. Insolvency practitioners navigate these waters, ensuring a fair and legal conclusion is reached, even as unsecured creditors may recover only a fraction of what is owed if anything at all.

The Sale of Business Assets and the Exit Strategy

The culmination of a liquidation process lies in the sale of business assets—an exercise aimed at converting the company’s holdings into liquid capital to settle its liabilities. Whether the liquidation is voluntary or a compulsory measure, the end goal remains the same: to conclude the business’s affairs in an orderly and effective manner. For company stakeholders, this can often mean selling off all components of a business—stock, fixtures, equipment, and even intellectual property.

Business owners may mark the liquidation of assets as a significant part of their exit strategy. Especially in a voluntary company liquidation, it allows them to retire, recalibrate, or move on from the company in a structured and anticipated way. Conversely, in an insolvency scenario, liquidation acts as a critical means to mitigate the impact on creditors, shareholders, and the business reputation.

By converting assets into cash, liquidation can fulfill outstanding financial obligations and, in some fortunate cases, result in a surplus for the company’s shareholders. Regardless of the circumstances, the conclusive act of selling off assets and settling the company’s affairs offers a clear yet often bittersweet period of transition for those involved. Whether it will be a long or shorter period of transition depends on the complexities of the business in company liquidation.

company liquidation

The Personal and Legal Ramifications of Company Liquidation

Company liquidation, whether voluntary or involuntary carries significant personal and legal ramifications that extend beyond the immediate dissolution of business operations. Directors and business owners need to be cognizant of the implications of liquidating their company, as the consequences of failing to adhere to legal requirements can be severe.

Understanding Personal Liability: The Impact on Business Owners and Directors

In the event of a company’s insolvency and subsequent liquidation, the directors’ conduct leading up to this point comes under scrutiny. Directors of insolvent companies must adhere to high standards of corporate governance, and failing to do so may result in personal liability. This scrutiny is aimed at uncovering any wrongful or fraudulent trading activities. If discovered, directors can be compelled to contribute to the company’s outstanding debts, significantly impacting their finances.

Moreover, if directors have provided personal guarantees for company borrowing, they can also be held accountable for these debts. This risk heightens the importance of seeking professional legal advice before initiating any company liquidation proceedings. A proactive approach, including ensuring that all debts and obligations are satisfied, protects business owners from the pitfalls of personal liability.

Finally, directors are liable for any unpaid salary or wages and any statutory withholdings not remitted to the government.

Voluntary vs Compulsory Liquidations: Factors to Consider

Understanding the difference between voluntary and compulsory liquidation is paramount for any business owner or director contemplating the end of their company’s operations. In voluntary liquidation, which requires a special resolution and the consent of shareholders, the business can be wound down in an orderly fashion, assets sold off, and creditors paid in an agreed-upon order. This option puts the business in control of its exit strategy.

Compulsory company liquidation, on the other hand, is not within the company’s control and occurs when economic conditions, company regulations, and financial distress lead to a court order forcing liquidation. Such unfavourable circumstances often stem from insolvency and more often than not, failure to fulfill legal obligations. Compulsory liquidation subjects the company to a court-appointed liquidator’s oversight, who will distribute assets to satisfy creditors without the company’s input in the order of repayment.

Navigating the Voluntary Liquidation Process: From Special Resolution to Finalization

The voluntary liquidation process is initiated by a company’s shareholders via a special resolution and is a methodical path toward winding down company affairs. It begins with a formal decision to cease operations, involves reaching out to a licensed insolvency practitioner, and requires calculated steps to manage the cessation of business affairs.

After shareholders’ approval, company assets are assessed and sold to pay debts. Secured creditors are prioritized, followed by unsecured creditors. Any remaining funds are then distributed among stakeholders or redirected towards the business owner’s subsequent ventures. Once all financial obligations have been met, the company is formally dissolved, marking the completion of the company liquidation process and providing a clear endpoint to the company’s existence.

company liquidation

Company Liquidation: The Importance of Trust and Collaboration in Business – Lessons from the Srivastava v. DLT Global Inc. Case

I won’t go into all the details of the case, but rather, provide an overview of the important points to be taken away from this legal battle. You can read the entire judge’s decision by clicking on this link. The case revolves around Neeraj Srivastava, a co-founder and former director of DLT Global Inc., and his application to wind up the company. The court ultimately dismissed the application, but the underlying issues uncovered shed light on the critical role of trust and collaboration in business relationships.

Background

Mr. Srivastava’s application was based on the argument that DLT Global could not continue its business due to significant liabilities. He claimed that they faced financial difficulties, had an unsustainable burn rate, and engaged in extensive litigation. These issues, according to Mr. Srivastava, justified the winding up of the company.

Trust and Collaboration

A breakdown in trust and collaboration between Mr. Srivastava and his co-founder, Loudon Owen, emerged as a central issue in the case. Mr. Srivastava alleged that his reasonable expectations as a co-founder and shareholder were not met and that he was unfairly treated by DLT Global. On the other hand, DLT Global argued that Mr. Srivastava engaged in misconduct and threatened to harm the business.

Lessons Learned

1. Clear Communication and Expectations: The Srivastava v. DLT Global Inc. case underscores the importance of clear communication and setting realistic expectations from the outset of a business venture. It is crucial for all parties involved to have a shared understanding of their roles, responsibilities, and the direction of the company.

2. Building and Maintaining Trust: Trust is the foundation of any successful business relationship. It requires open and honest communication, transparency, and a mutual understanding of values and objectives. Without trust, collaboration becomes challenging, and the business may suffer as a result.

3. Resolving Conflicts Effectively: Conflicts are inevitable in any business relationship. However, it is how these conflicts are resolved that can make or break a partnership. By adopting a collaborative and problem-solving approach, parties can find mutually beneficial solutions and prevent the escalation of disputes.

4. Seeking Alternative Remedies: The Srivastava v. DLT Global Inc. case highlights the importance of exploring alternative remedies before considering the drastic step of winding up a company. Parties should consider mediation, negotiation, or other dispute resolution mechanisms to address their grievances and protect their interests.

Company Liquidation: Closing Thoughts

The Srivastava v. DLT Global Inc. case serves as a cautionary tale for businesses about the criticality of trust and collaboration. It emphasizes the need for clear communication, building and maintaining trust, effective conflict resolution, and exploring alternative remedies before resorting to extreme measures. By prioritizing these aspects, businesses can foster a healthy and productive environment that enables growth and success.

In conclusion, the lessons learned from this case remind us that trust and collaboration are not just buzzwords but essential components of any thriving business. By embracing these values, entrepreneurs and business leaders can create a solid foundation for long-term success, even in the face of challenges. Let us take these lessons to heart and build businesses that prioritize trust, collaboration, and mutual respect.

I hope you enjoyed this company liquidation Brandon’s Blog. If you or your company are struggling with managing overwhelming debt in this high-interest environment, don’t worry – there are some things you can do to take control of the situation.

Individuals and business owners must take proactive measures to address financial difficulties, consumer debt and company debt and promptly seek assistance when necessary. It is crucial to recognize that financial stress is a prevalent concern and seeking help is a demonstration of fortitude, rather than vulnerability. Should you encounter challenges in managing your finances and find yourself burdened by stress, do not delay in pursuing aid.

Revenue and cash flow shortages are critical issues facing people, entrepreneurs and their companies and businesses with debt problems that are in financial distress. Are you now worried about just how you or your business are going to survive? Are you worried about what your fiduciary obligations are and not sure if the decisions you are about to make are the correct ones to avoid personal liability? Those concerns and more associated with your company debt are obviously on your mind.

The Ira Smith Team understands these financial health concerns. More significantly, we know the requirements of the business owner or the individual who has way too much financial debt. You are trying to manage these difficult financial problems and you are understandably anxious.

It is not your fault you can’t fix this problem on your own and it does not mean that you are a bad person. The pandemic has thrown everyone a curveball. We have not been trained to deal with this. You have only been taught the old ways. The old ways do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team uses innovative and cutting-edge methodologies, to adeptly navigate you through the intricacies of your financial challenges, ensuring a resolution to your debt-related predicaments without resorting to the rigours of the bankruptcy process. We can get you debt relief now!

We have helped many entrepreneurs and their insolvent companies who thought that consulting with a Trustee and receiver meant their company would go bankrupt. On the contrary. We helped turn their companies around through financial restructuring.

We look at your whole circumstance and design a strategy that is as distinct as you are. We take the load off of your shoulders as part of the debt settlement strategy we will draft just for you.

The Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. team understands that people facing money problems require a lifeline. That is why we can establish a restructuring procedure for you and end the discomfort you feel.

Call us now for a no-cost consultation. We will listen to the unique issues facing you and provide you with practical and actionable ideas you can implement right away to end the pain points in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.

company liquidation

Brandon Blog Post

WHAT DOES RECEIVERSHIP MEAN FOR 1 BETTER GUARANTOR BANKRUPTCY DISCHARGE

Post author By Brandon Smith
Post date August 18, 2021

We hope that you and your family are safe, healthy and secure during this COVID-19 pandemic.

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

what does receivership mean

What does receivership mean: Receivership is for secured claims

What does receivership mean? A receivership is an enforcement proceeding that helps secured creditors recover secured debts on debtor defaults on loan payments from troubled companies. There are two types of receivers and receiverships: Privately-appointed receivers and court-appointed receivers.

As you can tell from the title of this Brandon Blog, I am not going to be writing about receiverships. You can take a look at my April 14, 2021, Brandon Blog titled “WHAT IS A RECEIVERSHIP? OUR COMPLETE GUIDE TO RECEIVERSHIP SOLUTIONS” to read all about what receiverships are.

What does receivership mean? It is a remedy for secured creditors.

I want to go through two more concepts quickly, and then I will get to what I really want to talk to you about today.

What does receivership mean: Bankruptcy vs. receivership

Despite the fact that receivership and bankruptcy sometimes get used interchangeably, they are not the same thing. A bankruptcy proceeding and a receivership proceeding are both legal actions conducted under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA) and governed by the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy (OSB). According to the BIA, either a receiver or a bankruptcy trustee in Canada needs to be a licensed insolvency trustee, whose license is granted and whose actions are supervised by the federal government’s OSB.

Here is where the similarities end. In a receivership, a secured creditor would either hire a receiver privately or ask a court to place a company into receivership and appoint one to liquidate the collateral they have against the debtor. According to the Canadian bankruptcy process, either the person or company voluntary files for bankruptcy with a licensed insolvency practitioner, or one or more unsecured creditors apply to the Court for the appointment of an insolvency trustee to administer the bankruptcy Estate.

Licensed insolvency trustees are needed in both cases. The receivership procedure is a secured creditor’s remedy and bankruptcy is an unsecured creditor‘s remedy. To read up more on the bankruptcy process, look at my September 30, 2020, Brandon Blog “DECLARE BANKRUPTCY: A COMPLETE GUIDE ON WHAT IS IT LIKE TO DECLARE BANKRUPTCY“.

What does receivership mean? Not the same as bankruptcy.

Employee Rights in Bankruptcy Protection and Bankruptcy⁄Receivership

Bankruptcy protection can be gained to try to make a troubled company stable and then return the company to profitability by filing pursuant to either the BIA or the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA), employees retain their right to unpaid wages, vacation pay, and severance or termination pay. There is no difference between filing and not filing. They are unsecured creditors of a troubled company, and the company directors are personally responsible for amounts owed to employees.

For the company in receivership or bankruptcy, the employees do have greater rights. The receiver of a company in receivership must register with Service Canada under the Wage Earner Protection Program Act (WEPPA) for the Wage Earner Protection Program. This program provides some compensation to eligible employees who are owed money by a bankrupt or receivership company.

To read more about WEPPA, take a look at my February 10, 2020 Brandon Blog, “SEVERANCE PAY ONTARIO & BANKRUPTCY-BARRYMORE FURNITURE UNPAID WORKERS ANGRY“.

So what does receivership mean to an employee with unpaid wages? It means they can claim a priority and get paid by Service Canada.

***What does receivership mean: Receivership – a typical appointment***

Now I will get to what this Brandon Blog is actually about. In Canada, it is the norm for secured creditors advancing loans secured against company assets, to also take a personal guarantee on the same debt from the principals of the company. In all entrepreneurial companies in Canada, that is at least the president running company affairs. If the lender-secured creditor suffers a shortfall from the liquidation of the company assets, the lender then looks to the guarantor(s) of the company debt to make good on the lender’s loss. Many times the company president/guarantor has no choice but to file consumer bankruptcy.

I was involved in a bankruptcy discharge hearing for one of our personal bankrupts in April 2021. He caused his company, being its sole Director, to file for bankruptcy with another Trustee. That same Trustee was also appointed as the company’s private receiver by the secured creditor. The company president provided the secured creditor with a personal guarantee.

Realizing that they would suffer a shortfall from the company situation, rather than suing on their personal guarantee, they approached us to consent to act as the Trustee in a Bankruptcy Application against the company president. We consented and the company president ultimately consented to a Bankruptcy Order being made to put him into bankruptcy with my Firm as the Trustee.

What does receivership mean: The bankruptcy of the guarantor

We administered the consumer bankruptcy. There were some assets to realize upon which we did. One realization required court approval as we were selling seat licenses and the right to purchase tickets for the Toronto Maple Leafs to a related party. The bankrupt person’s largest single consumer creditor was Canada Revenue Agency for unpaid income tax. The company in receivership was also a creditor as the president owed the company money. The secured creditor of the company was also an unsecured creditor of his in his personal bankruptcy for the personal guarantee on the shortfall.

The known creditors each filed their respective proof of claim in his bankruptcy, including the company by its privately-appointed receiver. We believed that the company by its receiver was a creditor for the amount of the shareholder loan owing to the company. The proof of claim they filed was for a much larger amount. As Trustee, we neither admitted nor disallowed any proofs of claim filed in this bankruptcy estate. The Trustee would have to take a cold hard look at the receiver’s proof of claim at some future date it is determined that a dividend will be paid to the creditors in this bankruptcy estate, which is highly unlikely.

What does receivership mean: The receiver opposes a bankruptcy discharge

Only one unsecured creditor opposed the bankrupt’s discharge. That was the receiver, or more correctly, the company in receivership by its privately-appointed receiver. The Trustee had not opposed. The lender, as an unsecured creditor, did not oppose either along with the other consumer creditors.

As I mentioned, in April 2021, the discharge hearing was held before the Master sitting as Registrar in Bankruptcy Court. The court raised a novel issue. Does the receiver have the standing to oppose the bankrupt’s discharge? The court allowed the hearing to be completed and allowed the parties to file further submissions, subsequent to the hearing, on this issue. Submissions were received from us, the
Trustee and from the Receiver in mid-May, 2021. The bankrupt took no position on the issue.

Does the Receiver have standing to oppose the bankrupt’s discharge?

Here is what I wrote to the court.

The security documents under which a privately-appointed receiver is appointed will determine if an unsecured amount owing by a bankrupt debtor is an asset secured by security held by a creditor over the assets of another party. If so, then the privately-appointed receiver has the right to file a proof of claim in the debtor’s bankruptcy as part of attempting to realize upon that asset forming part of the secured creditor’s collateral.

In doing so, the privately-appointed receiver is acting as Agent for the secured creditor. If the privately-appointed receiver files a proof of claim in the bankruptcy that is not disallowed by the licensed insolvency trustee administering the bankruptcy estate, then, in order to oppose the discharge of the bankrupt, the privately-appointed receiver must also be able to be the Agent for the debtor in receivership.

If the security under which the privately-appointed receiver is appointed allows for that receiver to operate the business of the debtor in receivership, then that receiver has the ability to be an Agent of the debtor in receivership and bring a claim in the name of that debtor.

In this matter, of the various pieces of security held by the secured creditor, only the General Security Agreement (the “GSA”), allows a receiver appointed in writing under it to operate the business of the debtor company. Under the GSA, the privately-appointed receiver has the ability to act as both Agent of the secured creditor and Agent of the company. The appointment letter appointing the receiver confirms that the appointment is under all security held, including the GSA.

Therefore, my opinion was that although we have concerns about the amount being claimed, the receiver has the ability to both file a proof of claim in this bankruptcy and oppose the discharge of the bankrupt as an Agent of the company. I believed it aided the administration of this bankruptcy to allow the receiver to oppose because it is able to draw the attention of the court to conduct of the bankrupt of which the court otherwise might not be aware of.

Finally, I advised the court that if there still was concern that it is formal defect or irregularity section 187(9) of the BIA, the court can determine that such formal defect or irregularity will not invalidate the opposition to the discharge of the bankrupt.

What the bankruptcy court decided

The court accepted our submission and agreed with it. The court continued to be skeptical of the amount of the company’s proof of claim filed by the receiver. The court noted that as Trustee, I reported that the bankrupt has fulfilled all statutory duties. Income and expense statements were provided and there was no surplus income payable.

On a general perusal of the Trustee’s s. 170 report, the Trustee does not report any significant misconduct or concerns but reserved its rights as to its position on the discharge pending the hearing and matters disclosed therein. In the court’s view, the Trustee’s non-opposition to discharge is a factor favouring the bankrupt’s discharge. After considering all facts, the court gave the bankrupt an absolute discharge from bankruptcy.

What does receivership mean summary

I hope that you found this what does receivership mean Brandon Blog helpful in describing the role of a privately appointed receiver especially in opposing the discharge of the bankrupt guarantor of the company’s secured debt. Problems will arise when you are cash-starved and in debt. There are several insolvency processes available to a person or company with too much debt. You may not need to file for bankruptcy.

If you are concerned because you or your business are dealing with substantial debt challenges, you need debt help and you assume bankruptcy is your only option, call me.

It is not your fault that you remain in this way. You have actually been only shown the old ways to try to deal with financial issues. These old ways do not work anymore.

The Ira Smith Team utilizes new modern-day ways to get you out of your debt difficulties with debt relief options as an alternative to bankruptcy. We can get you the relief you need and so deserve. Our professional advice will create for you a personalized debt-free plan for you or your company during our no-cost initial consultation.

The tension put upon you is big. We know your discomfort factors. We will check out your entire situation and design a new approach that is as unique as you and your problems; financial and emotional. We will take the weight off of your shoulders and blow away the dark cloud hanging over you. We will design a debt settlement strategy for you. We know that we can help you now.

We understand that people with credit cards maxed out and businesses facing financial issues need a realistic lifeline. There is no “one solution fits all” method with the Ira Smith Team. Not everyone has to file bankruptcy in Canada. The majority of our clients never do as we know the alternatives to bankruptcy. We help many people and companies stay clear of filing an assignment in bankruptcy.

That is why we can establish a new restructuring procedure for paying down debt that will be built just for you. It will be as one-of-a-kind as the economic issues and discomfort you are encountering. If any one of these seems familiar to you and you are serious about getting the solution you need to become debt-free, contact the Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. group today.

Call us now for a no-cost consultation.

We hope that you and your family are safe, healthy and secure during this COVID-19 pandemic.

Ira Smith Trustee & Receiver Inc. is absolutely operational and Ira, in addition to Brandon Smith, is readily available for a telephone consultation or video meeting.

Tags Bankruptcy, bankruptcy and insolvency act canada, bankruptcy proceeding, bankruptcy protection, Bankruptcy vs. receivership, BIA, Canada Revenue Agency, Canadian bankruptcy process, CCAA, Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act, company directors, company into receivership, company voluntary files for bankruptcy, Court-appointed receivership, debtor, defaults on loan payments, Employee Rights in Bankruptcy Protection and Bankruptcy⁄Receivership, licensed insovency trustee, Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy, OSB, personal guarantee, Privately-appointed receivers, receivership, Receivership - a typical appointment, Receivership is for secured claims, receivership proceeding, secured creditor, secured debts, troubled company, troubled company stable, trustee, unpaid income tax, unsecured creditors, Wage Earner Protection Program, Wage Earner Protection Program Act, WEPPA, What does receivership mean