DIVORCE DEBT: NOT ALL EQUALIZATION ISSUES OR RULES ARE EQUAL IN BANKRUPTCY

If you would prefer to listen to an audio version of this divorce debt Brandon’s Blog, please scroll to the bottom of this page and click on the podcast.

Thank you for reading our Brandon's Blog. Check out our AI insolvency bot on this page and don't forget to subscribe!

Divorce debt and bankruptcy introduction

The topic of divorce debt and bankruptcy is always a tricky topic. There are 6 indisputable facts when it comes to this topic:

1. The primary reason for marital failure and also separation is financial issues. Divorce.com
2. Research shows that one out of every seven people who made an insolvency filing in Canada detailed separation, marital breakdown and/or divorce debt as a contributing variable to their economic troubles.
3. One-third of all people facing bankruptcy issues are likewise experiencing a family breakdown and divorce.
4. Bankruptcy won’t end all separation responsibilities. e. g. It does not end spousal support or child support.
5. Personal bankruptcy of one of the spouses, where certain divorce debts are joint, the bankruptcy, notwithstanding the divorce, will negatively affect the non-bankrupt spouse.

With really only one exception, bankruptcy law in Canada has been purposely designed not to interfere with the administration of provincial family law proceedings.

The only exception to this in Ontario is that an equalization payment is an unsecured divorce debt from one spouse to the other. If the spouse who has to make the equalization payment goes bankrupt during or after the divorce proceedings, then that debt is a debt caught by the bankruptcy. The spouse entitled to receive the equalization payment will have a provable claim in the bankruptcy for at least that amount. This does not apply to support payments.

The purpose of this Brandon’s Blog is to review a recent Ontario court decision released on February 19, 2020, that determines the answer to the question: can a licensed insolvency trustee (formerly called a bankruptcy trustee) (Trustee) begin an equalization claim against the non-bankrupt spouse under the Ontario Family Law Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. F.3 (“FLA”).

Divorce debt: The facts

The facts of the case were not in dispute. They are:

1. The husband and wife purchased a house in Toronto where they resided.
2. The matrimonial home was bought solely in the wife’s name.
3. The spouses separated in February 2015.
4. He left the marital residence in October 2015 and has never returned.
5. There is no disagreement that there the issues facing the husband and wife are irreconcilable, that the separation will be permanent and that the parties wish a divorce.
6. Neither the husband nor the wife had commenced an application for an equalization of the net family property prior to the husband filing an assignment in bankruptcy. It was not a divorce debt claim that he made. The husband remains an undischarged bankrupt. His sworn statement of affairs shows liabilities totalling $282,700.
7. The wife deposed that she paid the deposit and all other amounts to buy the marital residence. She also stated that in addition, she paid the mortgage, taxes, and all other expenses associated with the home.
8. The separation and divorce proceedings began due to his gambling addiction and his financial infidelity and other forms of infidelity.
9. Her affidavit sets out that there was never any intention that the husband would have any interest in the matrimonial house.

If the trustee is successful in asserting an equalization claim then she and her kids aged 12 and 15 would be forced to leave the home as it would have to be put up for sale in order to raise the necessary funds to pay the equalization claim.

Equalization in Ontario, divorce debt and bankruptcy

Trustees have various rights under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (Canada) (BIA). One of those rights is to have the benefit of laws dealing with property in the BIA. There is no dispute that the marital home falls under the definition of property. There is also no dispute that if the husband had begun an equalization claim of divorce debt before his bankruptcy, the Trustee would have the right to continue that claim.

Under the FLA, where spouses are separated without any possibility of reconciliation, the FLA qualifies the partner with the lesser of the spouses’ two net family property to one-half of the difference between them. If the trustee is permitted to make a case for equalization and is successful, then his share of the marital residence assets (based on any applicable reductions or offsets) would be included as an asset in his bankruptcy estate.

There is no disagreement that equalization claim is a divorce debt chose in action that a Trustee inherits upon the bankruptcy of the spouse who started that action. The question is, can a Trustee, standing in the shoes of the bankrupt spouse who has not yet started that action, start it?

There are many cases dealing with valid scenarios in which an equalization claim had already been started. The applicant Trustee’s position is that the Trustee has the capability to begin a claim for equalization of the net family property where neither partner has made such a case. The Trustee is relying on the fact that an equalization claim is a chose in action which the Trustee inherits.

The Judge’s decision

The Judge disagreed with the Trustee’s position. The court held that while the decision to continue with the divorce debt equalization claim made by the spouse can be left to a stranger to the marriage, the decision itself to make the claim cannot. So the Trustee can continue the decision of the spouse to make a formerly begun equalization claim however the choice to make the claim may not be made by anyone other than the spouse. That decision continues to be personal as between the spouses.

The Judge dismissed the Trustee’s motion and ordered the Trustee to pay $20,000 in costs to the wife immediately.

Summary

I am not aware of that question ever having been asked and decided by the Court before. So for now, in Ontario, that is the answer to that kind of divorce debt question. Do you have too much debt because of marital breakdown or for some other reason? Does your company have excessive debt and in need of debt restructuring? Would it not be great if you could do a turn-around?

The Ira Smith team is available to help you at any time. We offer sound advice and a solid plan for Starting Over Starting Now so that you’ll be well on your way to a debt-free life in no time. For more information on a no-cost basis please call us.

The Ira Smith Team understands how to do a debt restructuring. More notably, we comprehend the requirements of the business owner or the person who has too much individual debt. Because you are dealing with these stressful financial issues, you are anxious.

It is not your fault you can’t fix this problem on your own. You have only been taught the old ways. The old ways do not work anymore. The Ira Smith Team makes use of new contemporary ways to get you out of your debt problems while avoiding bankruptcy. We can get you debt relief now.

We look at your whole circumstance and design a strategy that is as distinct as you are. We take the load off of your shoulders as part of the debt settlement strategy we will draft just for you.

We understand that people facing money problems require a lifeline. That is why we can establish a restructuring procedure for you and end the discomfort you feel.

Call us now for a no-cost consultation. We will get you or your business back on the roadway to healthy and balanced worry-free operations and end the pain points in your life, Starting Over, Starting Now.